Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I understand why they are so set on destroying Hamas

632 replies

FebruaryOnMyMind · 12/10/2023 14:10

Having seen the stories of the women and girls raped at the festival (reportedly over their dead friends bodies) and the people taken off as hostage; I understand why Israel want to destroy Hamas. They have said that Hamas militants are dead men. They have said that they will go after them. The worst killing of Jewish people since the Holocaust and their 9/11 with death toll of over 1300 people.

The story of the women at the Music and Peace festival is here -

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12623023/Israeli-girls-raped-friends-bodies-Hamas-terrorists-carried-second-Holocaust-British-relatives-reveal-condemn-celebrated-atrocities-Gaza-Iran-London.html

Yet some people celebrated when the killings of Jewish people (they were from many different countries) at the festival was announced.

I feel sadness for everything going on in the middle east and for all the people who are innocent are are dying. Terrorists need to be stopped.

Hamas 'carried out a second Holocaust' in Israel British relatives say

Two British nationals, Noam Sagi and Sharon Lifschitz (pictured), spoke of how their elderly parents were torn from their beds and forcibly deported to Gaza by Hamas along with children

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12623023/Israeli-girls-raped-friends-bodies-Hamas-terrorists-carried-second-Holocaust-British-relatives-reveal-condemn-celebrated-atrocities-Gaza-Iran-London.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
45
SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 17:44

Thegreatprocrastinator001 · 14/10/2023 17:33

I understand that it's difficult to think about what it means when you justify targeting civilians for rape, abduction and murder. I understand that it's far more palatable to reach for disingenuous whataboutery designed to imply, incorrectly, that Israel has a routine and official tactic of raping Palestinian women. And to ignore the fact that Hamas could end this whole horror tomorrow if it wanted to (it doesn't want to).

But please try. Even if your frantic whataboutery were correct, you'd still be arguing that it's ok to use rape and sodomy of civilians as a war weapon if the other side does it too. In other words, you'd be saying there are times when rape is justified. There's absolutely no escaping that. If Israel were routinely using rape as a weapon, that would be inexcusable, and it would not become excusable if Hamas did it in turn.

If you just don't ever start justifying attacks and rapes that deliberately target civilians, you don't have to pretzel and twist yourself like this.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 17:18

Thegreatprocrastinator001 · 14/10/2023 17:10

No one is justifying any of it, but do you not think it's important to understand what motivates the violence in order to figure out a way forward? It's also important to remember that allegations of sexsexual assault and rape have been made by both sides
https://www.cair.com/cair_in_the_news/israeli-guards-rape-palestinian-women/

I can't stand it when people justify something and then immediately claim nobody is justifying it.

Unfortunately, this is the quagmire you enter once you start saying that targeting civilians is, on some level, ok (you do remember Hamas also employed rape and forced sodomy as weapons too?). If it's OK to target civilians because you haven't got the support to target the military, then it's got to be OK to target the military. Besides, another option has always been available to them: stop terrorising Israel and you'll have your own state. It's maddening that it could actually all be over tomorrow if they wanted it to be.

We all know Hamas' motives so there's really no reason to suggest that somehow muddies the waters. If targeting civilians is in some way justifiable, then targeting the military is always justifiable.

Think about it and just don't go there if you don't actually think that path is right.

Thegreatprocrastinator001 · 14/10/2023 17:10

No one is justifying any of it, but do you not think it's important to understand what motivates the violence in order to figure out a way forward? It's also important to remember that allegations of sexsexual assault and rape have been made by both sides
https://www.cair.com/cair_in_the_news/israeli-guards-rape-palestinian-women/

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 16:55

Thegreatprocrastinator001 · 14/10/2023 16:35

I think EasterIssland was being ironic, given the clip. Of course we can all see that killing is wrong on both sides. But I can't help wondering how I would feel as a civilian living in the Gaza Strip who had suffered years and years of devastating restrictions and blockades, in response to Hamas who I probably didn't vote for but whose cause I can understand. Kidnap and murder are somehow more emotive than bombardment and yet Hamas doesn't have the military capability to employ the same strategies as Israel so their options are kind of limited if they want to cause destruction. But Amnesty International is clear regarding the years of abuses and illegal treatment of those in the Gaza strip, which was alikened to an open prison, so the hatred that would have built up over the years just increases the likelihood of young men going to join Hamas. Any which way, none of this is Christian, Jewish or Muslim behaviour and it's horrific for anyone living through it.

Kidnap and murder are somehow more emotive than bombardment and yet Hamas doesn't have the military capability to employ the same strategies as Israel so their options are kind of limited if they want to cause destruction.

If you think the targeted kidnap, murder, violent rape and sodomy of women, children and civilians is acceptable if you haven't got the resources to attack military/strategic targets, then you must think it's ok to attack military/strategic targets even if this results in unintentional civilian deaths.

I'm not saying I think it's OK, but I'm not the one justifying Hamas.

aswarmofmidges · 14/10/2023 16:44

BBC also saying children killed after strike hits convoy on safe route

Thegreatprocrastinator001 · 14/10/2023 16:35

I think EasterIssland was being ironic, given the clip. Of course we can all see that killing is wrong on both sides. But I can't help wondering how I would feel as a civilian living in the Gaza Strip who had suffered years and years of devastating restrictions and blockades, in response to Hamas who I probably didn't vote for but whose cause I can understand. Kidnap and murder are somehow more emotive than bombardment and yet Hamas doesn't have the military capability to employ the same strategies as Israel so their options are kind of limited if they want to cause destruction. But Amnesty International is clear regarding the years of abuses and illegal treatment of those in the Gaza strip, which was alikened to an open prison, so the hatred that would have built up over the years just increases the likelihood of young men going to join Hamas. Any which way, none of this is Christian, Jewish or Muslim behaviour and it's horrific for anyone living through it.

DownNative · 14/10/2023 16:32

EasterIssland · 14/10/2023 15:15

I would simply say that YOU really need to read again instead of rushing to post what you THOUGHT Sky News said.

It's claim and counter-claim as we speak.

So, I ask....were you trying to mislead people on here with this? 🤔🙈

I understand why they are so set on destroying Hamas
Lastchancechica · 14/10/2023 16:25

TheChristianArab · 14/10/2023 15:46

Wow a whole 10 mins to get out and leave your whole life behind. Where are these people supposed to go?

Well according to everyone it is a hellhole anyway so what is being left behind exactly? No food security, a barbaric terrorist government, endless fighting and danger.

Hamas need to be removed for the sake of everyone on either side.

TheChristianArab · 14/10/2023 15:55

EasterIssland · 14/10/2023 14:49

Why aren’t Palestinians from the north moving to the south if they’ve got two safe corridors to escape!
oh wait

Trying to move approximately million people in a short time frame with only two routes is flipping impossible. Some are old, ill, have just lost family members etc. It's not just going to an airport to fly off to an all inclusive. Surely you can see that?

TheChristianArab · 14/10/2023 15:46

ticketstickets · 12/10/2023 14:36

Israel are not retaliating. They do not want to kill little children, but the Hamas terrorists don't really seem to care about protecting their children. Israel actually gives ten minutes warning before they bomb a building, Hamas tell civilians to ignore the warnings.

Wow a whole 10 mins to get out and leave your whole life behind. Where are these people supposed to go?

DownNative · 14/10/2023 15:10

EasterIssland · 14/10/2023 14:49

Why aren’t Palestinians from the north moving to the south if they’ve got two safe corridors to escape!
oh wait

I don't think someone's twitter account is a particularly reliable source for anything.....😐

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/10/2023 15:06

EasterIssland · 14/10/2023 13:54

Do you think this behaviour of someone of Israel is accidentally ?
https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/video-shows-settler-shooting-injuring-palestinian/

I wasn't claiming that no Israeli, Jew, or IDF soldier has ever intentionally killed a civilian. You won't find an army on earth without a soldier who has intentionally injured and killed civilians.

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/10/2023 14:54

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 13:57

No, I think the difficulty is for a different reason. And that poster has had posts deleted for expressing too honestly what that reason is.

Ah I haven't followed the whole thread. I suppose I was trying to be charitable.

AgentJohnson · 14/10/2023 14:53

Every other YouTube ad that I have seen in the last two days has been taken over by Israel's Foreign Affairs Ministry ads.
I’m guessing they have found another outlet to piss me off.

There are always going to be arseholes who support Hamas , just as there are people who think an hours warning is enough time for 1.2 million to leave on mass, taking as much as their lives as they can carry to who the fuck knows where is acceptable.

This incursion won’t make Israëli’s safer, in fact it will do the opposite. And before you say ‘what are they supposed to do?’, I DO NOT KNOW but I know this isn’t it.

EasterIssland · 14/10/2023 14:49

Why aren’t Palestinians from the north moving to the south if they’ve got two safe corridors to escape!
oh wait

I understand why they are so set on destroying Hamas
Pollyputhekettleon · 14/10/2023 14:45

andtheworldrollson · 14/10/2023 13:57

In normal life I would say dropping bombs in residential areas or pointing guns at someone was murder

In war, the Israeli actions apparently pass the criteria for war crimes (UN)

You'd be wrong. People have pointed guns at a friend, thinking it was unloaded, and killed them. They weren't held responsible. Others point a gun at someone to defend themselves, they're also not held responsible. And so on. I know you all understand this when it comes to individual moral responsibility.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 14:37

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 14/10/2023 14:35

The only Jew I have seen named and attacked is Netanyahu. Having less than 23% of the Israeli vote, he does not seem to be overtly popular with Israelis and probably even less so with those from other countries.

I'm glad that the overtly antisemitic posts of the last few days, that specifically attacked Jews and referred to them as such, were deleted before you saw them.

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 14/10/2023 14:35

The only Jew I have seen named and attacked is Netanyahu. Having less than 23% of the Israeli vote, he does not seem to be overtly popular with Israelis and probably even less so with those from other countries.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 14:26

It's incredible that you get banned faster for making up a story about a cheating husband than for posts that explicitly name and attack Jews.

andtheworldrollson · 14/10/2023 14:06

Stop killing people
Killing people is bad
Whatever their religion
Don't see why that is hard to understand
Don't see that it's subtle either , it's not nuanced
Surprised sone people think killing is ok

SurprisedWithAHorse · 14/10/2023 13:57

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/10/2023 13:52

In normal life you'd have no difficulty understanding the difference in moral culpability between someone who kills a child accidentally, carelessly, recklessly or deliberately. The difficulty people have with the distinctions in this context is purely politically motivated.

No, I think the difficulty is for a different reason. And that poster has had posts deleted for expressing too honestly what that reason is.

andtheworldrollson · 14/10/2023 13:57

In normal life I would say dropping bombs in residential areas or pointing guns at someone was murder

In war, the Israeli actions apparently pass the criteria for war crimes (UN)

EasterIssland · 14/10/2023 13:54

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/10/2023 13:52

In normal life you'd have no difficulty understanding the difference in moral culpability between someone who kills a child accidentally, carelessly, recklessly or deliberately. The difficulty people have with the distinctions in this context is purely politically motivated.

Do you think this behaviour of someone of Israel is accidentally ?
https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/video-shows-settler-shooting-injuring-palestinian/

Video shows settler shooting, injuring Palestinian

* * *

https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/video-shows-settler-shooting-injuring-palestinian/