Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I understand why they are so set on destroying Hamas

632 replies

FebruaryOnMyMind · 12/10/2023 14:10

Having seen the stories of the women and girls raped at the festival (reportedly over their dead friends bodies) and the people taken off as hostage; I understand why Israel want to destroy Hamas. They have said that Hamas militants are dead men. They have said that they will go after them. The worst killing of Jewish people since the Holocaust and their 9/11 with death toll of over 1300 people.

The story of the women at the Music and Peace festival is here -

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12623023/Israeli-girls-raped-friends-bodies-Hamas-terrorists-carried-second-Holocaust-British-relatives-reveal-condemn-celebrated-atrocities-Gaza-Iran-London.html

Yet some people celebrated when the killings of Jewish people (they were from many different countries) at the festival was announced.

I feel sadness for everything going on in the middle east and for all the people who are innocent are are dying. Terrorists need to be stopped.

Hamas 'carried out a second Holocaust' in Israel British relatives say

Two British nationals, Noam Sagi and Sharon Lifschitz (pictured), spoke of how their elderly parents were torn from their beds and forcibly deported to Gaza by Hamas along with children

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12623023/Israeli-girls-raped-friends-bodies-Hamas-terrorists-carried-second-Holocaust-British-relatives-reveal-condemn-celebrated-atrocities-Gaza-Iran-London.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
45
Lastchancechica · 12/10/2023 21:19

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 20:59

Israel has the backing of the US so their neighbours can't succede in their aim of wiping them out. If my drunken, foul mouthed husband kept beating me up and raping me, am I privileged to have the backing of a women's aid centre and the police.

I think it’s okay to acknowledge the superior military resources Israel have whilst understanding the need for that protection, and appreciating this makes Israel safer and less at risk from those choosing to harm them.

EasterIssland · 12/10/2023 21:10

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 20:59

Israel has the backing of the US so their neighbours can't succede in their aim of wiping them out. If my drunken, foul mouthed husband kept beating me up and raping me, am I privileged to have the backing of a women's aid centre and the police.

In your scenario you’re powerless. But if the police had lend you a Kalashnikov then maybe … you would be more strong when your drunk husband was beating you. Israel has got the power to destroy Gaza, Gaza doesn’t have the power to destroy Israel or wipe out all the Jewish people

EasterIssland · 12/10/2023 21:07

Baaaaaa · 12/10/2023 20:55

I'm off the fence I'm afraid. No one is squeaky clean, but you must be able to understand the difference between civilians (human shields) getting caught in the cross fire in attempts to combat guerilla warfare, and targeting civillians deliberately, repeatedly and viciously.

The Israelis are between a rock and a hard place. Where are they supposed to go. Hammas are nutters.

They withdrew from Gazza at one point. Dismantled settlement, forcibly removed their own citizens. Didn't work

Unfortunately not all those killed by Israel were caught in the cross fire. Many of them were directly targeted and killed.

JustJess90 · 12/10/2023 21:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 21:01

Baaaaaa · 12/10/2023 20:55

I'm off the fence I'm afraid. No one is squeaky clean, but you must be able to understand the difference between civilians (human shields) getting caught in the cross fire in attempts to combat guerilla warfare, and targeting civillians deliberately, repeatedly and viciously.

The Israelis are between a rock and a hard place. Where are they supposed to go. Hammas are nutters.

They withdrew from Gazza at one point. Dismantled settlement, forcibly removed their own citizens. Didn't work

Yes, I was on the fence too, but withdrawing from Gaza hasn't worked. I'm guessing their plan is to retake it and strengthen their position in the region.

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 20:59

Lastchancechica · 12/10/2023 20:54

I think it’s being pointed out that Israel have the backing of the worlds biggest super power backing them. They have access to warfare and resources.

Israel has the backing of the US so their neighbours can't succede in their aim of wiping them out. If my drunken, foul mouthed husband kept beating me up and raping me, am I privileged to have the backing of a women's aid centre and the police.

Baaaaaa · 12/10/2023 20:55

DottieMoon · 12/10/2023 15:09

You're very one sided, ridiculous and ignorant. Hamas and Israel government are both guilty of murdering innocent civilians, both murdering women and children. Israel have actually murdered more innocent Palestinian civilians than Hamas. Hamas are terrorists but although no UK media is not saying it, Israel actions should also be ladled as terrorism not defence. Of course there would be retaliation to the horrific actions of Hamas, but what Israel are doing is just as horrific. I feel for all the victims as a result of these two awful powers.

Edited

I'm off the fence I'm afraid. No one is squeaky clean, but you must be able to understand the difference between civilians (human shields) getting caught in the cross fire in attempts to combat guerilla warfare, and targeting civillians deliberately, repeatedly and viciously.

The Israelis are between a rock and a hard place. Where are they supposed to go. Hammas are nutters.

They withdrew from Gazza at one point. Dismantled settlement, forcibly removed their own citizens. Didn't work

Lastchancechica · 12/10/2023 20:54

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 20:36

I can't believe what I'm reading. That's not 'privilege', That's competent government in the face of a continuing threat to it's security and the lives of it's citizens.

I think it’s being pointed out that Israel have the backing of the worlds biggest super power backing them. They have access to warfare and resources.

StowOnTheWold · 12/10/2023 20:53

Weddingpuzzle · 12/10/2023 20:33

How can people not see that such reactive and devastating retaliation is creating a whole cohort of Gaza's population who will be potentially radicalised? What are the demographics of the crowds who are digging people out of bombed buildings in Gaza? Mostly young men. Hundreds of thousands of young men feeling powerless and watching the beginning of a genocide. Hamas aren't organised - this is not Ukraine who have a defence plan and boots on the ground. If Isreal aren't careful they will drive these people to organise and bite back. Where is the de-escalation and international dialogue? All I can see is a misplaced 'Isreal have a right to defend herself' rhetoric that's helping nobody.

75% of Gaza's population are refugees - they will look at Israel who displaced them, they will look at Isreal who are occupying them and bombing the shit out of them and they will radicalise. Israel's action is potentially creating a whole new cohort of terrorists. What is the end game here?

You are very naive to say:

All I can see is a misplaced 'Isreal have a right to defend herself' rhetoric that's helping nobody.

You clearly have no idea of the history of Jews. People always have a right to defend themselves. Particularly when there have been several diaspora of Jews over two thousand years. Romans, Visigoths, Ottomans, etc, etc. But you will at least have heard about Nazi Socialism?

And even today in the 21st Century there is State that wants to destroy Israel. It is the Iranian regime. More than 75 years after Hitler's death here we are again. Mass genocide against Jews.

Israel is not going to sit down with terrorists and paedophiles and discuss living together. That would be very misplaced.

1dayatatime · 12/10/2023 20:52

@crumpet

NotSuchASmugMarried
But Gaza has a border with Egypt. They could use that.

Egypt has closed the border

+++

Egypt has reopened the border - see my post below.

Lastchancechica · 12/10/2023 20:51

Stompythedinosaur · 12/10/2023 20:21

The conflict was started by the UK in 1917 by the Balfour Declaration.

This is totally inaccurate. Palestine was originally part of the Ottoman Empire before it became a colony of the British empire. It became the state of Israel in 1948 after millions of displaced traumatised Jewish families that Germany tried to exterminate were resettled in Israel. The rest of Palestine was shared by Egypt and Jordan at the time. The U.K. most certainly did not start a conflict.

Dolphin1111111111111111111111111 · 12/10/2023 20:51

Ofcourse they won't @Glitterdavies they call Palestinians animals, what about those in the car and filming. They are insult to human kind. My heart goes out to palestine

crumpet · 12/10/2023 20:47

NotSuchASmugMarried · 12/10/2023 15:29

But Gaza has a border with Egypt. They could use that.

Egypt has closed the border

1dayatatime · 12/10/2023 20:46

Mustardseed86 · 12/10/2023 20:10

Is there no way they can get the women and children out of Gaza? Not that women can't be terrorists but it's surely much less likely?

The border crossing at Rafah is now open.

www.reuters.com/world/egypt-facilitating-deliveries-aid-sinai-gaza-2023-10-12/#:~:text=The%20Rafah%20crossing%20between%20Sinai,that%20prevented%20normal%20operations%20there.

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 20:45

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 12/10/2023 20:39

I vote for negotiations
You vote for genocide

See you at the museum

You're really twisting yourself into contorsions here. Of course I'm not in favour of genocide, I just don't see how peace negotiations are possible with Hamas in charge. Should Israel pull on it's 'big girl pants' before or after the neighbouring government recognises their right to exist?

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 12/10/2023 20:39

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 20:36

I can't believe what I'm reading. That's not 'privilege', That's competent government in the face of a continuing threat to it's security and the lives of it's citizens.

I vote for negotiations
You vote for genocide

See you at the museum

Itllbefine6 · 12/10/2023 20:36

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 12/10/2023 19:47

Israel's army is very good
Israel's GDP is very good
Israel's intelligence service are supreme with star spangles
Gaza is inadequate in every sense

If negotiations are to work, Israel needs to pull up it's big person pants and start talking and check it's privileges.

Or do you prefer genocide?

I can't believe what I'm reading. That's not 'privilege', That's competent government in the face of a continuing threat to it's security and the lives of it's citizens.

Weddingpuzzle · 12/10/2023 20:33

How can people not see that such reactive and devastating retaliation is creating a whole cohort of Gaza's population who will be potentially radicalised? What are the demographics of the crowds who are digging people out of bombed buildings in Gaza? Mostly young men. Hundreds of thousands of young men feeling powerless and watching the beginning of a genocide. Hamas aren't organised - this is not Ukraine who have a defence plan and boots on the ground. If Isreal aren't careful they will drive these people to organise and bite back. Where is the de-escalation and international dialogue? All I can see is a misplaced 'Isreal have a right to defend herself' rhetoric that's helping nobody.

75% of Gaza's population are refugees - they will look at Israel who displaced them, they will look at Isreal who are occupying them and bombing the shit out of them and they will radicalise. Israel's action is potentially creating a whole new cohort of terrorists. What is the end game here?

Glitterdavies · 12/10/2023 20:31

I wonder if the main stream media will report this. Cutting limbs off a body and running it over.
https://www.instagram.com/p/CySNsvPOPiW/?igshid=MmU2YjMzNjRlOQ==

Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/p/CySNsvPOPiW?igshid=MmU2YjMzNjRlOQ%3D%3D

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 12/10/2023 20:28

Netanyahu won 27% of the vote at the last election.
Please do not think he represents the average Jewish Israeli.

IveHadItUpToHere · 12/10/2023 20:23

Annalouisa · 12/10/2023 20:17

How are the Israeli's supposed to react, if not with siege tactics?

In reality, Israel will cease to exist if it's perceived to be weak in its response. As the saying goes - if Hamas puts down its weapons, there will be peace. If Israelis put down their weapons, there will be no Israel.

Co-existence is not on the Hamas manifesto:“There is no solution to the Palestine problem except through Jihad (holy war).”

Is winning the war worth fighting back? Are Israeli lives worth protecting? The Israelis think yes.

Don't confuse Netanyahu's foreign policy with the will of ordinary Israelis. They are not the same.

HeidiInTheBigCity · 12/10/2023 20:21

Alexandra2001 · 12/10/2023 20:08

No, if Hamas hadn't decided to behead children, rape girls, then kill them and burn alive others, then Israel wouldn't need to bomb Gaza to destroy Hamas, killing civilians in the process.

Whatever the rights and wrongs of this on going and long term conflict, what Hamas did is pure evil.

You are an apologist for Hamas that is what's disgusting.

"Need to"??? Seriously?!

One of the major guiding principles of international law - especially the Geneva Conventions (which, for the uninitiated, essentially boil down to "rules for when shit has already hit the fan and you do find yourself at war - for the non-psychopaths among us") is that violations by one party do not justify the same by another!

In other words: no, Israel does not NEED TO bomb civilians in Gaza any more than Hamas NEEDED TO kill entire families in Kfar Azza!

That is just utter bullshit! Nobody bloody NEEDS TO massacre civilians!

For the record: I think I probably, on deeply personal grounds, despiseHamas more than you do! I am not excusing them! At all! I might be an atheist - but if I were not, I would want their leadership in hell!

But also: yes, I DO hold Israel to a somewhat higher standard! Absolutely, I do! That will be because the state of Israel claims to be a liberal democracy. I actually happen to believe in the ideals of liberal democracy (whereas I would not be seen dead subscribing to those of Hamas). So, you BET I expect leaders that claim to be in my camp to suck less than ones I would not be seen dead with!

IveHadItUpToHere · 12/10/2023 20:21

I'm not a massive fan of Humza Yousaf but he has been very eloquent on the reasons people can't just leave Gaza. His ILs and other Scottish citizens are trapped there. Even with the might of the British FO, they can't guarantee safe passage.
Tbh I'm surprised the UK Government and Keir Starmer are being quite so cavalier and vocal in their support of the flouting of international law when that flouting is directly threatening the lives of innocent, UK citizens.

EllebellyBeeblebrox · 12/10/2023 20:21

At what cost? The innocent on both sides are the ones who will suffer the most. The whole thing is fucking heartbreaking, the lives of Israel’s children and Palestine’s should have equal value.

Stompythedinosaur · 12/10/2023 20:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The conflict was started by the UK in 1917 by the Balfour Declaration.