Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spoiling child at Xmas, DP flounced off in a huff

254 replies

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 12:43

I have one DD aged 11. Was a single parent till she was 6, met DP when she was 7.

I. At Xmas my daughters total gift budget is $400(around 200 quid). I earn good money and she doesn’t often get bought much here and there, so I think this is fair.

this year I got her tickets to see Pink in the new year, they were about $600 in total, but paid for about six months ago. We live in regional Australia so flights+hotel will be another $1000 on top for the three of us, but it’s DPS birthday while we are there and it’s in the city that his family live in, which we would visit that time of year anyway so I have not considered that $1000 as part of the cost of DD ‘Xmas gift’ as we would usually spend nearly that visiting his fam anyway….

anywho, I told him tonight I was planning on getting her a few extra bits to actually open on Xmas day, like pyjamas a book, maybe some earrings, so she has some stuff to open on the day.

DP has got really wound up, that I’m spending a fortune and spoiling her- setting us up for the next year because we have to match it (I disagree I think she will understand it’s a one off time in a life type thing). He thinks she shouldnt have anything extra on top of the tickets and trip and I’ve already gone way overboard.

we had a bit of a Barney, I think that our usual gift budget is fairly frugal when I compare (thief of joy I know) what other people drop on their kids at Christmas… anyway am I being unreasonable with getting extra gifts to open when I’ve already nearly doubled the usual budget on tickets.

is he being unreasonable to view the hotel and flights as part of the gift expense on her behalf?

is $400 reasonable budget for a kid at Christmas anyway?

OP posts:
BetterWithPockets · 12/10/2023 15:41

Namerequired · 12/10/2023 15:08

No I agree with you here, he either has a father role or he doesn’t, you don’t pick and choose. If he acts like her father (and you’re happy with that), he’s raising her, paying for her etc he has a right to an opinion. I also think his opinion here is wrong though. The only part of the gift that is truly hers is $300 for her ticket. I don’t think you can pile the flights and hotel on unless it is literally just a trip for her, about her etc without other things thrown in. So about £150? Which is not a large budget for an 11yr old, and is certainly not going to spoil her. Not that there’s anything wrong with occasional spoiling. Has he seen what tech costs? I can see where he’s coming from when he groups all the costs together but he’s benefiting from those costs.

This! Especially this bit: I agree with you here, he either has a father role or he doesn’t, you don’t pick and choose. If he acts like her father (and you’re happy with that), he’s raising her, paying for her etc he has a right to an opinion. I also think his opinion here is wrong though.

If it’s very out of character for him though, have you tried to unpick why he reacted as he did, OP? Is he worried about money, for example? (I know you said you don’t have money worries, but there’s clearly something behind his reaction…)

Mari9999 · 12/10/2023 15:39

@PottedPlantsObsess
I think you work to provide for yourself and your child. You know what you can afford and what you would like to give your child for Xmas. You are not asking your partner to contribute to the gift, and his opinion can be considered but it should not be determinative.

I would imagine that you may voice an opinion about what he gives his son for Xmas but that you respect him enough not to expect your opinion to be controlling .

We gave our 16 year old a car last Xmas. Her gift this Xmas won't come remotely close in value and she won't be expecting it to be equal in value.

What is the purpose of hard work and some measure of success if you can't occasionally indulge your children? That is not something for which you should feel guilty or apologetic. I can't speak for you, but that is one of the motivators for working as long and hard as I work. Your daughter will only have this one childhood making it pleasurable for her when you have the means and opportunity to do so. is not spoiling her.

TomatoSandwiches · 12/10/2023 15:37

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 15:32

I think you misunderstand.
he has no issue with the trip at all. He thinks it’s a great Christmas gift.
however, he does think that this is enough in terms of a Christmas gift and it’s excessive to get extra things- particularly as the trip is costing more than we would normally spend for Christmas presents.

neither of us equate money or gifts with love, therefore I don’t think either opinion has any correlation with how much we love our child. It’s really just a question of whether you agree with him that it’s financially excessive, or agree with me that it’s a one off and it won’t do any harm.

Edited

But you would be spending a similar amount at a similar time anyway.
So he is wrongly attributing ALL of the trips cost on your DD.
He is wrong.
He has no justifiable reason to object to you buying some presents for her to open on Christmas day.
His behavioir ( flouncing and huffing ).is designed to modify YOUR behaviour so you capitulate and give in to his pov for whatever reason he truly has.
He is not being reasonable op.

Quitelikeit · 12/10/2023 15:34

But why are you so frugal?

Do you have thousand in savings?

What are you saving for?

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 15:32

billy1966 · 12/10/2023 15:20

Poor little mite.

It takes some misery guts to deny a child a rare treat of an outing when they live in the middle of nowhere.

He has shown you who he is.

Poor child.

I would get the ICK so quickly for a man who would feel so determined that my child not get such a rare treat.

Most loving mothers would too🤷🏻‍♀️

I think you misunderstand.
he has no issue with the trip at all. He thinks it’s a great Christmas gift.
however, he does think that this is enough in terms of a Christmas gift and it’s excessive to get extra things- particularly as the trip is costing more than we would normally spend for Christmas presents.

neither of us equate money or gifts with love, therefore I don’t think either opinion has any correlation with how much we love our child. It’s really just a question of whether you agree with him that it’s financially excessive, or agree with me that it’s a one off and it won’t do any harm.

OP posts:
JustWimpy · 12/10/2023 15:31

There's something very worrying about his determination that your child should have nothing to open at Christmas. There's a cruelty that would ring alarm bells for me. I can't see a future with him being bright if he wants to forbid you from spending a perfectly average amount on your child at Christmas. Only her ticket alone should count towards her present budget. I think you need to stand firm that you won't allow your child to suffer because of his meanness and consider his reaction very carefully.

oohsharon · 12/10/2023 15:28

"Wow 7
I think you’ve lost the ability to be objective and judge everyone by those 7 people"

Huh? 7? What the fuck are you on about? How would that even work 🤣

Fuck me. Make up whatever you like @rwalker but I'll tell you something. If some bloke had a temper tantrum because I wanted to get my kid some pjs and a book, and then told me he'll feel the same if I do it again next year, I'd tell him to fuck right off.

No way would I be earning the money and being told how to spend it when it came to my daughter. This kid sounds anything but spoilt and he's huffed and puffed and flounced out like the miserly prick he is.

If you think the OP should ignore that and marry him then fine, but I don't. And I wish my friends hadn't either.

purplecorkheart · 12/10/2023 15:27

Honestly he sounds joyless

cocksstrideintheevening · 12/10/2023 15:26

So the cost of your ticket shouldn't factor into it anyway imo. Apart from that you're the higher earner, can afford, get the kid some stuff to open.

Quitelikeit · 12/10/2023 15:26

The thing is you obviously live very frugally and so I guess that’s why I can’t relate to your approach

There are posts on here often about men who live like that and their long suffering wives and kids - ‘oh why does she need to go on that school trip’ ‘oh his trousers are fine’ ‘no he doesn’t need a haircut’ ‘can’t you buy that from the charity shop?’

People who live frugally usually do so due to their upbringing or to meet a savings goal

It is not healthy.

m May I ask what the purpose is of you living frugally?

Is it to buy a house, a particular goal in mind or just for the sake of it?

WhenRobinsAreNear · 12/10/2023 15:23

I don't think you're unreasonable to get her a little something to open at Christmas. If you haven't already I would make it clear that this year's present is an expensive one off as its a once in a lifetime thing.
I think you partner shouldn't have reacted how he did, maybe he's worried about wedding expenses etc? I'd just have a calm chat with him and see if you can get to the bottom of it.

PercytheParkKeepershedgehog · 12/10/2023 15:21

Amilliondollars · 12/10/2023 15:07

Or the latest Nike trainers or North Face coat?

I think you’d cook quicker than the turkey in a North Face parka in Perth at Christmas 😂

billy1966 · 12/10/2023 15:20

Poor little mite.

It takes some misery guts to deny a child a rare treat of an outing when they live in the middle of nowhere.

He has shown you who he is.

Poor child.

I would get the ICK so quickly for a man who would feel so determined that my child not get such a rare treat.

Most loving mothers would too🤷🏻‍♀️

Runnerinthenight · 12/10/2023 15:20

Surreyclaire · 12/10/2023 14:00

And people wonder why so many kids grow up to be entitled and ungrateful
incredible

Are you always a miserable killjoy?

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 15:19

Amilliondollars · 12/10/2023 15:06

What’s going to happen as she gets older and she wants more and more tech for example which costs hundreds. Is she going to be able to have a mobile and laptop and play station like her friends? Or will he think that’s indulging her?

it’s a hard one, luckily we have avoided the tech stuff till now and hopefully we can put it off for a few more years. not even sure how I feel about that….

OP posts:
Namerequired · 12/10/2023 15:19

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 15:12

Absolutely not, in front of her. He’s not a monster lol, just clearly a bit miserly!

we generally don’t do gifts for each other, it’s really not our thing.

Hmm so flights and hotels to his family don’t count as presents cause you ‘don’t do presents’. He has it well sussed lol 😝 Tell him to stop being tight. As pp said, they aren’t little for long. They also get more expensive so he may buckle up.

rwalker · 12/10/2023 15:18

oohsharon · 12/10/2023 15:10

"does everything in life have to be a red flag"

Nope. But I've watched several family members and friends ignore the warning signs then regret it once they were married. They look back and say, why didn't I see the signs 🤷🏽‍♀️.

Shame because apart from one, they had teenagers who have now had to live with shitty or cruel stepdads or watch their mums have a breakdown. Only one couple managed to split amicably. The things the OP has mentioned also happened to some of them so pointing it out can't hurt

Wow 7
I think you’ve lost the ability to be objective and judge everyone by those 7 people

ohdamnitjanet · 12/10/2023 15:17

I didn’t buy my ds shit during the year unless it was needed not wanted, which meant for birthday and Christmas I could spoil him, so it really was a special day. Practically thw only gifts he got were from me and I wanted him to have a pile of treats like children with families have. Lone parent, not much money, gave me pleasure and he didn’t take it for granted.
Does your dp want you to spend the money on him? What a killjoy.

TomatoSandwiches · 12/10/2023 15:15

You won't get many more years with her like this, she is on the cusp of being a teenager and her face won't light up in the same way at such a treat.
You've chosen a really stingy man to partner up with.
Perhaps he is prudent and has many other good qualities but he is potentially going to ruin any good or magical memories you design to have with her because of this attitude he has.

ohdamnitjanet · 12/10/2023 15:12

oohsharon · 12/10/2023 13:40

Oh he's going to suck all of the joy out of this for her.

Get fucking rid.

Yup!

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 15:12

Miss93 · 12/10/2023 14:48

So I suppose that means your DP doesn't get a Christmas present either.

He's being ridiculous,seeing Pink is not an everyday occurrence,so that's something your DD will cherish.
And your DP is ruining her experience.
Hopefully he didn't have his little tantrum with your DC there

Absolutely not, in front of her. He’s not a monster lol, just clearly a bit miserly!

we generally don’t do gifts for each other, it’s really not our thing.

OP posts:
mimiku · 12/10/2023 15:11

Oh man I have this argument every single birthday and Christmas with my kids. They don’t get spoilt throughout the year, they get little treats every now and then but rarely big things other than birthday and Christmas so I like to treat them as much as my budget allows. Every single time it ends in an argument with my other half (their dad) about how it’s not necessary blah blah blah. He seems to forget that whilst his mum is largely useless, she made a big effort for birthdays and Christmas for him and his brother growing up and is one of the few things she actually made a reasonable effort in and he has fond memories of this when he chooses to remember!

Annoys me enough that I get it in the neck, but he’s at least my kids dad so does have some say (even if I think he’s being unreasonable). Your partner isn’t and I’d tell him to keep his nose out personally because it’s nothing to do with him how much you buy your child for Christmas.

oohsharon · 12/10/2023 15:10

"does everything in life have to be a red flag"

Nope. But I've watched several family members and friends ignore the warning signs then regret it once they were married. They look back and say, why didn't I see the signs 🤷🏽‍♀️.

Shame because apart from one, they had teenagers who have now had to live with shitty or cruel stepdads or watch their mums have a breakdown. Only one couple managed to split amicably. The things the OP has mentioned also happened to some of them so pointing it out can't hurt

Namerequired · 12/10/2023 15:08

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 14:50

No we are not struggling financially.

i am the biggest earner.

We live remotely, so buying stuff doesn’t happen on a whim or particularly often

so she has three sets of grandparents that dote on her and often surprise her with bits and bobs, clothes, or Knick knacks. I don’t see the need for us to do that too…

I think it is his business if he’s taking responsibility in raising her. I definitely don’t agree with him, or his dummy-spit reaction but what kind of relationship do we have if I just disregard his opinion because he’s not biologically her dad?

No I agree with you here, he either has a father role or he doesn’t, you don’t pick and choose. If he acts like her father (and you’re happy with that), he’s raising her, paying for her etc he has a right to an opinion. I also think his opinion here is wrong though. The only part of the gift that is truly hers is $300 for her ticket. I don’t think you can pile the flights and hotel on unless it is literally just a trip for her, about her etc without other things thrown in. So about £150? Which is not a large budget for an 11yr old, and is certainly not going to spoil her. Not that there’s anything wrong with occasional spoiling. Has he seen what tech costs? I can see where he’s coming from when he groups all the costs together but he’s benefiting from those costs.

Amilliondollars · 12/10/2023 15:07

Or the latest Nike trainers or North Face coat?

Swipe left for the next trending thread