Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think its not okay to great gazans as israel has been

746 replies

LethargicButAwesome · 11/10/2023 21:46

Gaza has no food, no electricity and no water. On top of that they are being bombarded constantly
Israel has bombed the only escape route for refugees via Egypt, there is no way out
israel continues the blockage by air, land and sea - no aid can get in, no one can get out.
israel has said they will obliterate Gaza.

this is unprecedented, no matter what happens with governments or wars, you have refugee camps…safe havens…(often difficult) access to water - how are we even debating that this is acceptable? Am i the only person thinking this is the human race at its absolute worst? Its heartbreaking to watch, literally noone is doing anything - we are observing a genocide.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
68
thinkfast · 12/10/2023 09:43

LethargicButAwesome · 12/10/2023 09:30

Agree a two state solution. Set up borders like every other country in the world for entry and exit. Lift the blockade to allow them to trade as their own independent country.

Hamas won't accept a two state solution OP. Hamas are the government of Gaza, so if they won't accept it it won't happen. It's like you're entirely unaware of the long long history of negotiations to try to achieve peace in this region.

It's simply not true to say that all borders between all countries are open for people to cross! Try crossing the Lebanon/ Israel border. Lebanon does not allow it.

Israel has an absolute right to control its own borders and say who goes in or out.

Noicant · 12/10/2023 09:41

LethargicButAwesome · 12/10/2023 09:36

Your missing the point. Israel illegally occupies Palestine. Therefore it absolutely IS ISRAELS responsibility to provide options, if Palestine was an independent country, then your argument would make sense, but its not, its an occupied territory controlled completely by israel.

It doesn’t occupy Gaza they are self administered and what can anyone do if they spend all their money on weapons instead of food, medicine and education .

Unless you mean Jewish people in Israel full stop. I’m never sure anymore if by occupation posters mean Israelis should stick to their own borders or if they should be ejected completely. Becasue when Hamas say occupation they are talking about the existence of any Jews in Israel full stop.

SaySomethingMan · 12/10/2023 09:41

There is a lot of support for Jews all over the world at this horrendous time. To say “the world” is chanting something so horrific is just sensationalist and undermines the effort of the vast majority of people showing support, fighting and challenging anti- jewish sentiments

Noicant · 12/10/2023 09:38

LethargicButAwesome · 12/10/2023 09:30

Agree a two state solution. Set up borders like every other country in the world for entry and exit. Lift the blockade to allow them to trade as their own independent country.

They can’t negotiate with Hamas, it’s literally in Hamas founding statement. they are islamists who are absolutely clear that there should be no non-muslims in Palestine.

https://irp.fas.org/world/para/docs/880818a.htm

Hamas will not accept a 2 state solution, I’m not sure Netanyahu is bothered either tbh.

Israel has just suffered from a massive terrorist attack, I think most normal people would like to see a 2 state solution but thats not going to be on the horizon right now.

I’m still holding out hope for some sort of safe enclave for Palestinian women and children but the Egyptians have been clear they won’t be taking Palestinian refugees. The best option is safe zones near the Egyptian border for vulnerable populations.

THE COVENANT OF THE HAMAS - MAIN POINTS

https://irp.fas.org/world/para/docs/880818a.htm

Dalekjastninerels · 12/10/2023 09:37

This is a shithole Sad

Nothing exists out of the blue; that is the problem everyone needs to realise this and come up with a solution.

As far as war goes I am 100 percent neutral; I follow as far as I can the teachings of Our Lord Jesus.

I think founding the Zionist State of Israel was a huge mistake; Israel is Spiritual.

The ones trapped in the shithole are Israeli Civilians and the Palestinians Sad

CaroleSinger · 12/10/2023 09:37

OhHelloTheres · 11/10/2023 23:00

What would have been an acceptable response to the slaughter of over 1000 innocent civilians and kidnapping of over 100? Sit back and await round 2?

There's a whole difference between defence and retaliation though. Surely the bigger question is why it was allowed to happen in the first place? Why help took hours to arrive and one of the most sophisticated armies on the planet took hours to respond to the invasion. How could such a sophisticated military capability not have seen this coming? If I were cynical I might wonder if they let it happen as a means to an end to justify what we are now witnessing. Are we to believe a government with access to such sophisticated defences have such pitiful intelligence and such a poor ability to respond to an attack? This wasn't just about a failure of the Iron Dome. This was a failure of government. It just is not feasible that they did not know this was coming or that it should take hours for help to arrive if there was an invasion with this sort of military capability supplied by superpowers. If it is then god help us all.

LethargicButAwesome · 12/10/2023 09:36

Your missing the point. Israel illegally occupies Palestine. Therefore it absolutely IS ISRAELS responsibility to provide options, if Palestine was an independent country, then your argument would make sense, but its not, its an occupied territory controlled completely by israel.

OP posts:
DownNative · 12/10/2023 09:34

It's not possible to get everyone out of Gaza away from Hamas, so it's in the interests of all Palestinians and Israelis that Hamas is defeated. Remember, they use Palestinian civilians as human so Hamas absolutely do NOT want a fair fight or to allow civilians to leave.

Coughingdodger · 12/10/2023 09:32

Lesina · 11/10/2023 23:16

Egypt needs to open the border and allow Palestinians to leave. Set up camps and house fleeing refugees.
Hamas knew without doubt what Israel’s response would be. Hamas have inflicted this on the Palestinian people.
Everyone should go and visit Auschwitz and gain some insight to Israel’s stance of ‘never again’.
Let Egypt open her border.

We’ll all be visiting a museum in Gaza in future years, believe me.

coviduality · 12/10/2023 09:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

'THanKs To sOcIAl mEDia iN rEcENt yEaRS 🤪' tells you everything you need to know

LethargicButAwesome · 12/10/2023 09:30

Agree a two state solution. Set up borders like every other country in the world for entry and exit. Lift the blockade to allow them to trade as their own independent country.

OP posts:
Dulra · 12/10/2023 09:29

ArtyStripedSocks · 12/10/2023 09:23

@Dulra my point is that it is not up to Israel to provide the other options.

The whole situation is horrific and no doubt Israel's actions will be horrifying. However, the attacks by Hamas are not Israel's doing, and Israel will react to them, as Hamas knew full well when they committed these barbaric disgusting acts of terrorism against innocent Israeli citizens.

@ArtyStripedSocks Not up to them provide options? That's very cold. As I said Israel have a right to defend their borders but their response will go way beyond that and completely obliterate Gaza. They tell civilians to leave and then bomb their only border crossing. Israel have no intention of trying to protect the lives of innocent civilians and to me that is murder

skyllama · 12/10/2023 09:27

Netenyahu has openly admitting providing funding to Hamas and propping up Hamas to allow cause for Israel to further incur into Gaza.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/

Evidence coming out now that Israel was warned ahead of this incursion by Egyptian intelligence and that Israel chose to ignore it. Again allowing all this to blow up.

Egypt warned Israel days before Hamas struck, US committee chairman says

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-67082047

ArtyStripedSocks · 12/10/2023 09:23

@Dulra my point is that it is not up to Israel to provide the other options.

The whole situation is horrific and no doubt Israel's actions will be horrifying. However, the attacks by Hamas are not Israel's doing, and Israel will react to them, as Hamas knew full well when they committed these barbaric disgusting acts of terrorism against innocent Israeli citizens.

BlueYonder57 · 12/10/2023 09:23

anythinginapinch · 12/10/2023 08:39

It seems that Israel has chosen to learn absolutely fuck all about social and political hatred, killing, and contempt for "others". About each persons right to life.

Oh - and Hamas have?

"Whataboutery" is a pointless exercise in rhetoric that can only be enjoyed when sitting happily nowhere near the conflict. It is beyond tragic that innocent people are being killed and maimed in this war. It doesn't matter what "label" they wear. Every death in war is a testament to failure on everyone's part. But I don't think the UK (or many places) are sitting in a comfortable position when they set out to lecture others about "social and political hatred, killing, and contempt for "others"." We don't have the "excuse" of war - or at least not normally. But there is enough social and political hatred and contempt for others of MN, never mind in our society. And I would be interested, for example, if the UK will be opening its borders to Gazan refugees - or will it be sending anyone who arrives to Rwanda? I'm just recalling all those thread on MN alone about how we don't want all those "men from uneducated barbaric societies where women have no value on our lauded shores". Just because hatred and contempt is a spectrum does not mean that we have the corner on moral outrage - our "armed wing" did some bloodly questionable things in Afghanistan and Syria and not so long ago. We have done some bloody questionable things throughout history. As has just about everyone else. This is not a competition.

Trading "whataboutery" on MN is the "civilised" exchange of rockets. We aren't living it, so it is turned into entertainment, trading stories of horror and excuses on which ever side we are on. From our glass houses....

skyllama · 12/10/2023 09:23

AngeloMysterioso · 12/10/2023 00:50

YABU to start yet another thread on this.

YABU to dictate to people what they can and can't discuss on an open forum such as this.

maddening · 12/10/2023 09:22

OhHelloTheres · 11/10/2023 23:00

What would have been an acceptable response to the slaughter of over 1000 innocent civilians and kidnapping of over 100? Sit back and await round 2?

By a terrorist group - not the civilians of Gaza.

Dulra · 12/10/2023 09:19

Viviennemary · 12/10/2023 09:15

I am hardening my heart against this. Somebody is just on TV now going on about denying people electricity and food. People have been denied a lot worse. A mother of a new born baby her husband killed. The point is both sides have to obey the rules of war. It can't just be one sided.

You do know denying people electricity and power also means their hospitals where they are trying to treat their sick and dying? I was listening to Irish radio yesterday and they were interviewing a medicine sans frontier doctor in a hospital in Gaza and the situation is dire they are fast running out of supplies and power so people are dying, the desperation and fear in her voice was hard to listen to

Littlegoth · 12/10/2023 09:15

@ArtyStripedSocks I don’t think there are any options for the Gazans. I doubt Egypt will open the borders or set up refugee camps as they won’t risk it being exploited and infiltrated by Hamas. They are already struggling with the militant groups they already have. It’s not that long since the Arab Spring.

Viviennemary · 12/10/2023 09:15

I am hardening my heart against this. Somebody is just on TV now going on about denying people electricity and food. People have been denied a lot worse. A mother of a new born baby her husband killed. The point is both sides have to obey the rules of war. It can't just be one sided.

thinkfast · 12/10/2023 09:14

LethargicButAwesome · 12/10/2023 08:54

Perhaps they should lift the blockade and give them freedom? Then they would not be their responsibility.

Please clarify what you mean by this?

Are you suggesting that Israel should open the borders with terrorists and let Hamas flood into Israel? Leave innocent Israeli citizens to the kind of treatment that happened on Saturday? Cause that's what it sounds like.

If that's not what you mean can you please explain.

Dulra · 12/10/2023 09:13

ArtyStripedSocks · 12/10/2023 09:10

@Littlegoth my point is that Israel would be crazy to open their borders, and there are other options for the Gazans.
The situation is awful, but Israel must protect its borders if it wants to survive.

What are the other options for Gazans?

Israel has every right to defend its borders but it doesn't have the right to obliterate another nation which it is likely to do

Oliotya · 12/10/2023 09:12

asterel · 12/10/2023 00:46

punishing the entire population of Gaza because few odd people committed an act of terrorism

What’s happening in Israel and Gaza is terrible. But it’s not just “a few odd people”. Hamas is the Gazan government - they were voted in by the people. They are deeply corrupt thugs and extremists who deliberately harm the ordinary people - and of course they don’t want to give up power to have a normal democratic state, because of course they wouldn’t be in charge then. They orchestrate these attacks to keep the Gazans exactly where they are. It’s a huge mistake to think of them as a few isolated “odd people” or as freedom fighters for the oppressed.

Hamas cannot simultaneously be a terrorist organization and an elected government. The two are incompatible. Hamas were "elected" in 2006. Median age in Gaza is 18. Do the maths.

Hankunamatata · 12/10/2023 09:12

I don't think they will be able to get rid of hamas. Bombing the the crap out of gaza and starving them will turn civilians more militant and move them towards hamas.

I don't know the answer

FloweryDrawer · 12/10/2023 09:12

I think most people are in the middle and want an end to it all. But the loudest voices on social media are both extremes. It was the same during the pandemic. So hard to get moderate voices heard.

I don’t like the victim-blaming of ordinary Palestinians. People keep saying they voted for Hamas so it is up to them to get rid of them now. The ‘election’ of these corrupt murderers was years ago. My vote in a democratic western country can’t get rid of the Tories, so I am not sure what power the average Palestinian has. I feel panicky for these Palestinians right now. In a living hell trying to get water, food and medicine for their families. Imagine the trauma. I am more than ok with every disgusting member of Hamas losing their life. But at what cost to the Palestinian children?

And then I am also trying not to think of what many innocent Israeli families are going through right now. The ones whose relatives were taken hostage must be in hell. Each second of their day must be agony. That dad losing his wife and girls as hostages breaks my heart. I find myself having crazy thoughts like the families whose relatives were killed by Hamas are ‘luckier’ than the ones whose relatives might be suffering torture at the hands of the evil creatures of Hamas at this very moment; how f*ed up is that thought?? My Israeli friends are beside themselves with family members being called up and even volunteering to do so. What can I say to reassure them??

Someone needs to stop this bloodshed somehow. I have a horrid feeling that the people who can act don’t even want this war to stop. Because on both sides, their own egos, pride and hatred means more to them than their own innocent people. I truly believe that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread