Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think its not okay to great gazans as israel has been

746 replies

LethargicButAwesome · 11/10/2023 21:46

Gaza has no food, no electricity and no water. On top of that they are being bombarded constantly
Israel has bombed the only escape route for refugees via Egypt, there is no way out
israel continues the blockage by air, land and sea - no aid can get in, no one can get out.
israel has said they will obliterate Gaza.

this is unprecedented, no matter what happens with governments or wars, you have refugee camps…safe havens…(often difficult) access to water - how are we even debating that this is acceptable? Am i the only person thinking this is the human race at its absolute worst? Its heartbreaking to watch, literally noone is doing anything - we are observing a genocide.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
68
Paintballmaker · 13/10/2023 18:45

DownNative · 13/10/2023 18:02

Hamas must be destroyed and that includes their terrorist infrastructure such as underground tunnels.

Where did Hamas build their network of tunnels?

Right underneath the homes of Gazans and the entrance is also inside the homes.

See the Reuters and BBC News articles. Note the map showing the tunnel network courtesy of the BBC.

It is the tunnels network that's being attacked. Not homes. You can blame Hamas for this.

BTW, it's not 2m who need to evacuate north Gaza. It's 1.1m and they need to move to other parts of Gaza. See map.

Again this ‘they made me do it’ defence. How about Israel take some responsibility for their decision to displace these people making them homeless?

If this is the only solution to get rid of hamas why don’t they offer the civilians shelter and repayment for the loss of their homes? How would you feel if someone told you to leave your home by tomorrow taking only what you can carry, never to return? Where are these people supposed to go since no one is coming forward to help them?

This is a huge humanitarian crisis in the making.

DownNative · 13/10/2023 18:02

JSMill · 13/10/2023 17:46

They've given them warning and will then proceed to destroy their homes so they have nothing to return. How on earth are 2 million people supposed to evacuate and where will they shelter? How will they eat? You're talking about powerless civilians including children and old people. How can anyone be so heartless?

Hamas must be destroyed and that includes their terrorist infrastructure such as underground tunnels.

Where did Hamas build their network of tunnels?

Right underneath the homes of Gazans and the entrance is also inside the homes.

See the Reuters and BBC News articles. Note the map showing the tunnel network courtesy of the BBC.

It is the tunnels network that's being attacked. Not homes. You can blame Hamas for this.

BTW, it's not 2m who need to evacuate north Gaza. It's 1.1m and they need to move to other parts of Gaza. See map.

To think its not okay to great gazans as israel has been
To think its not okay to great gazans as israel has been
To think its not okay to great gazans as israel has been
To think its not okay to great gazans as israel has been
Coughingdodger · 13/10/2023 17:54

parakeet7 · 13/10/2023 17:46

"bumbling". Lazy writing and a completely anti semitic post.

Anti-Semitic again.
Anyone who objects to innocent people being bombed is anti-Semitic in the eyes of these fanatical posters.

parakeet7 · 13/10/2023 17:50

RosaKim · 13/10/2023 02:30

I can barely contain my anger watching news articles and “Israel has a right to defend itself” on fucking repeat

Does anyone actually understand what the Palestinian people have been going through for years? Nobody has given a shit

Edited

I think it's brilliant that most of the West's leaders including our royal family support Israel. They deserve the support for standing firm against terrorism.

JSMill · 13/10/2023 17:46

yeahokrightsure · 13/10/2023 13:07

What a load of racist propaganda

They are not bombing the shit out of innocents – they have already given a warning for civilians to leave. They always give a warning. They have to take out terrorists in one strong attempt because Hamas have had opportunities time and time again to change the situation and aid their people. They do not do this. They use the money and infrastructure to make weapons and attempt to kill off Israel. They use their own people as human shields to hide behind so the blame can lay at the door of Israel for terrorising the Gaza. None of this is true. And you are just feeding into it.

They've given them warning and will then proceed to destroy their homes so they have nothing to return. How on earth are 2 million people supposed to evacuate and where will they shelter? How will they eat? You're talking about powerless civilians including children and old people. How can anyone be so heartless?

parakeet7 · 13/10/2023 17:46

andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 13:11

They are bumbling the shit out of innocents

Babies and children are being killed - how are babies not innocent ?

How does the elderly or hospital bound person get up and leave ?

Where do they leave to exactly?

Why would you trust an army that has been killing peoples for decades, that has dehumanised you ( called Palestinians "human animals " ) and kept you in the "open air prison" of Gaza as described by the UN.

  • in any one year the Israel's soldiers seem to kill ten times as many Palestinians as Palestinians kill Israel people

It is not proportionate; it is not legal ; it is not self defence

"bumbling". Lazy writing and a completely anti semitic post.

Paintballmaker · 13/10/2023 15:57

yeahokrightsure · 13/10/2023 13:07

What a load of racist propaganda

They are not bombing the shit out of innocents – they have already given a warning for civilians to leave. They always give a warning. They have to take out terrorists in one strong attempt because Hamas have had opportunities time and time again to change the situation and aid their people. They do not do this. They use the money and infrastructure to make weapons and attempt to kill off Israel. They use their own people as human shields to hide behind so the blame can lay at the door of Israel for terrorising the Gaza. None of this is true. And you are just feeding into it.

They’ve given 24 hours notice for more than one million people to leave. Where are they all supposed to go exactly? What about the elderly and the disabled? Are they supposed to wait to be bombed into oblivion as they physically can’t leave?

DownNative · 13/10/2023 14:36

Glitterdavies · 13/10/2023 06:44

See this needs to be said on repeat over and over as its getting lost in the threads.

Does a post deleted presumably for Anti-semitism need reposting again and again, @Glitterdavies?

Really?!

andtheworldrollson · 13/10/2023 13:11

They are bumbling the shit out of innocents

Babies and children are being killed - how are babies not innocent ?

How does the elderly or hospital bound person get up and leave ?

Where do they leave to exactly?

Why would you trust an army that has been killing peoples for decades, that has dehumanised you ( called Palestinians "human animals " ) and kept you in the "open air prison" of Gaza as described by the UN.

  • in any one year the Israel's soldiers seem to kill ten times as many Palestinians as Palestinians kill Israel people

It is not proportionate; it is not legal ; it is not self defence

yeahokrightsure · 13/10/2023 13:07

What a load of racist propaganda

They are not bombing the shit out of innocents – they have already given a warning for civilians to leave. They always give a warning. They have to take out terrorists in one strong attempt because Hamas have had opportunities time and time again to change the situation and aid their people. They do not do this. They use the money and infrastructure to make weapons and attempt to kill off Israel. They use their own people as human shields to hide behind so the blame can lay at the door of Israel for terrorising the Gaza. None of this is true. And you are just feeding into it.

asterel · 13/10/2023 12:53

JSMill · 13/10/2023 12:45

I was told the Egyptians want to provide fuel and food but Israel have threatened them with missile strikes. I am struggling to believe that though. The US wouldn't stand for that.

The Egyptians have been reinforcing their border to keep Gazans out.

JSMill · 13/10/2023 12:45

I was told the Egyptians want to provide fuel and food but Israel have threatened them with missile strikes. I am struggling to believe that though. The US wouldn't stand for that.

Glitterdavies · 13/10/2023 06:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

See this needs to be said on repeat over and over as its getting lost in the threads.

emilysquest · 13/10/2023 06:43

@Willyoujustbequiet that is an interesting stat re the solar power, thanks. I started a thread a couple of days ago discussing, in good faith, the issue of solar power in Palestine and got a lot of very sarcastic and rude answers (among some incredibly helpful ones).

emilysquest · 13/10/2023 06:40

@DownNative I didn't say it was only the British. I was just replying to a PP who said the conflict had nothing to do with them that if they were British that was hardly the case. They answered in a way that suggested that they were not British, which was fair enough.

RosaKim · 13/10/2023 02:30

I can barely contain my anger watching news articles and “Israel has a right to defend itself” on fucking repeat

Does anyone actually understand what the Palestinian people have been going through for years? Nobody has given a shit

Oopsadaisysgranny · 13/10/2023 02:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

parakeet7 · 13/10/2023 01:39

DownNative · 12/10/2023 12:54

This member has had their 03:39am post deleted for an anti-semitic tirade that I personally reported. Seems they're being a bit more careful since.

Yes this poster is certainly anti-semitic.

Willyoujustbequiet · 13/10/2023 01:08

LethargicButAwesome · 11/10/2023 21:46

Gaza has no food, no electricity and no water. On top of that they are being bombarded constantly
Israel has bombed the only escape route for refugees via Egypt, there is no way out
israel continues the blockage by air, land and sea - no aid can get in, no one can get out.
israel has said they will obliterate Gaza.

this is unprecedented, no matter what happens with governments or wars, you have refugee camps…safe havens…(often difficult) access to water - how are we even debating that this is acceptable? Am i the only person thinking this is the human race at its absolute worst? Its heartbreaking to watch, literally noone is doing anything - we are observing a genocide.

It is estimated that between 30 -50% of their electricity is now provided via solar power so it is simply not true to say they have none. They are not wholly reliant on Israel for it.

DownNative · 13/10/2023 00:51

emilysquest · 12/10/2023 14:28

@Highandlows if you are British you can't look at the history of Israel/Palestine and say "this is nothing to do with us", surely?

Only the British? Really? Think you'll find quite a few countries are part of the history of Israel & Palestine.

The following excerpts have been taken from the United Nations website:

www.un.org/unispal/history/

"Palestine was among former Ottoman territories placed under UK administration by the League of Nations in 1922. "

You can see in this link which countries were members of the League Of Nations in 1922 when Palestine was placed under UK administration.

www.britannica.com/topic/League-of-Nations/Members-of-the-League-of-Nations

"UK considered various formulas to bring independence to a land ravaged by violence. In 1947, the UK turned the Palestine problem over to the UN."

Under British administration, Palestine was NOT partitioned, but you will often hear people talking as though it was!
So, we move on to the actual partition itself:

"After looking at alternatives, the UN proposed terminating the Mandate and partitioning Palestine into two independent States, one Palestinian Arab and the other Jewish, with Jerusalem internationalized (Resolution 181 (II) of 1947)."

As we can see, the partition of Palestine was not caused by the British Government alone.

The collective members of the United Nations made that decision.

"One of the two envisaged States proclaimed its independence as Israel and in the 1948 war involving neighbouring Arab States expanded to 77 percent of the territory of mandate Palestine, including the larger part of Jerusalem. "

The Office Of The Historian in the United States says the following:

"The Arab-Israeli War of 1948 broke out when five Arab nations invaded territory in the former Palestinian mandate immediately following the announcement of the independence of the state of Israel on May 14, 1948."

history.state.gov/milestones/1945-1952/arab-israeli-war

Whether you believe it was Israel or the five Arab nations who started the conflict, it is clear that the United Kingdom is not to blame for the partition as it didn't enact that plan.

Partition was a United Nations collective plan.

Personally, I would argue it was the FIVE Arab States who kickstarted the Arab-Israeli aka Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

DownNative · 13/10/2023 00:47

If we really want to talk about the treatment of Gazans, how about Palestinian child soldiers?

The UN states Hamas AND the Palestinian Authority use children as soldiers.

"Both the PA and Hamas routinely indoctrinate Palestinian children to aspire to martyrdom through armed confrontations with Israel. According to Palestinian Media Watch (PMW), “the PA operates a systematic and institutionalized policy and program to recruit child soldiers/terrorists.”

In its reports to the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) on this issue, PMW accused the PA of indoctrinating Palestinian children to admire and emulate terrorists and noted that “The PA openly admits, that the child terrorists are not acting in a vacuum, but rather they consider them to be the PA’s soldiers who the PA has sent to carry out a mission.”

The United Nations below:

"PA television (TV) broadcast quizzes children on songs with “value and meanings” which PA considers expression of Palestinian “national identity.” One of the songs depicts Israel as the “enemy” and encourages armed attacks: “I'm coming with my rifle… I'm coming towards you, my enemy… with cleavers and knives.” (January 2021).

• Official PA TV children’s program commemorated cartoonist Naji al-Ala, by sharing several cartoons encouraging violence among children, including one where Fatima (Palestinian woman cartoon character) presents an AK47 to Handala (the Palestinian refugee cartoon character) and one of her handing rocks to children. (August 2020).

• Fatah Facebook page promotes child soldiers by sharing video of Jordanian boy in military uniform holding slingshot and rifle. He wants to “shoot Jews” who killed terrorist Omar Abu Laila (killed Israeli soldier, stole his weapon and shot to death Israeli father of 12). (February 2020).

• Hamas TV children’s program interviews young children dressed in military fatigues. One child says he wants to be an engineer when he grows up “so that I can blow up the Jews.” The child host responds “Keep waging Jihad…when you grow up you will wage resistance against the Jews…” (September 4, 2015).

More from the United Nations:

"In addition, PA and Hamas educational programs routinely portray terrorists as role models and incite children to violence. For example, every year Hamas runs summer camps in which it trains children in military tactics and weapons use.

Likewise, summer camps run by Fatah and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) teach children to venerate famous Palestinian martyrs like Abu Jihad, who was responsible for terror attacks in which 125 Israelis were killed.

Therefore, it is no surprise that Palestinian children perpetrate violent attacks against Israelis and participate in violent confrontations with the goal of harming Israeli soldiers and civilians."

There is absolutely NO doubt that Palestinian children ARE taught to hate Israelis. Even worse, they're TRAINED to murder Israelis!

Remember, there is a lot of support for terrorist groups from Palestinians. Not all of them - unfortunately, a minority is not bigger than a majority.

ketchup07070 · 13/10/2023 00:15

I'm quite puzzled that Keir Starmer and Emily Thornberry have said they think it's fine to block water etc from civilians. They seem to state it's also following international law. But then Tory MP Alicia Kearns is saying Israel has a duty to switch water back on under international law. She also argues Britain should be pushing for a humanitarian corridor. Why is there such different views of both what is international law and of what is moral? I was vaguely thinking of voting Labour, but the sheer callous dismissal of a million children has completely put me off. I'm not arguing for the Tories by the way - still politically homeless.

nocoolnamesleft · 13/10/2023 00:10

BigBillyButterBollocks · 12/10/2023 23:04

Do posters like you have an orgasm every time time you manage to take a critic of Israel's actions and turn it into "it's a shame Hamas...". That is a bit sadistic and abusive.

"over 500 children died because of Israel bombing". Oh no, look what Hamas made Israel do

'5000 children died of dehydration after Israel cut their water supply". Oh no, look what Hamas made Israel do

"A little boy was burned alive and another shot in the head by an IDF soldier during an attack of a Palestinian town by Israeli extremists". Oh no, look what Hamas ma... Oh, wait...

What the fuck do you think was Hamas's aim with the attacks? They weren't going to occupy Israel. They weren't going to defeat Israel. Of course this is what they wanted. Hamas committed atrocities, in the hope that Israel would commit atrocities. Which they are. This was clearly the game plan. I deplore what Hamas did. I deplore what Israel is doing. But one of the reasons I deplore what Hamas did was because it was pretty much designed to trigger the Israeli government into actions that would kill Palestinians. Hamas deliberately wanted Palestinians to die for political gain. Killing innocent people you consider to be your enemy is incredibly wrong. But deliberately triggering the death of what you consider to be your own side? What do you call that? there are no good guys in this. But there are innocents on both sides being slaughtered.

SomeCatFromJapan · 12/10/2023 23:19

Do posters like you have an orgasm every time time you manage to take a critic of Israel's actions and turn it into "it's a shame Hamas...". That is a bit sadistic and abusive

What is currently happening in Gaza is a direct result of the atrocities carried out by Hamas on Saturday. I'm not saying this to minimise or absolve Israeli action but given that Israel have only just suffered one of the biggest terrorist attacks ever it's absolutely correct to mention it.

It's also really off under the circumstances to accuse a poster of being "sadistic and abusive" as a way to try and silence them from talking about genuinely sadistic, abusive events just because you are so anti the affected country that you can't bear to see its citizens get any acknowledgement for their suffering.

BigBillyButterBollocks · 12/10/2023 23:04

nocoolnamesleft · 12/10/2023 22:57

Probably true. That would appear to have been Hamas's plan. Commit some atrocities, really piss off the right wing Israeli government, and then use the retaliation to recruit the next generation, and inflame their international supporters. And, as always, it's the innocents (on both sides) who suffer. The only winners in this are holders of extreme militant views on either side.

Do posters like you have an orgasm every time time you manage to take a critic of Israel's actions and turn it into "it's a shame Hamas...". That is a bit sadistic and abusive.

"over 500 children died because of Israel bombing". Oh no, look what Hamas made Israel do

'5000 children died of dehydration after Israel cut their water supply". Oh no, look what Hamas made Israel do

"A little boy was burned alive and another shot in the head by an IDF soldier during an attack of a Palestinian town by Israeli extremists". Oh no, look what Hamas ma... Oh, wait...

Swipe left for the next trending thread