Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think its not okay to great gazans as israel has been

746 replies

LethargicButAwesome · 11/10/2023 21:46

Gaza has no food, no electricity and no water. On top of that they are being bombarded constantly
Israel has bombed the only escape route for refugees via Egypt, there is no way out
israel continues the blockage by air, land and sea - no aid can get in, no one can get out.
israel has said they will obliterate Gaza.

this is unprecedented, no matter what happens with governments or wars, you have refugee camps…safe havens…(often difficult) access to water - how are we even debating that this is acceptable? Am i the only person thinking this is the human race at its absolute worst? Its heartbreaking to watch, literally noone is doing anything - we are observing a genocide.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
68
ChickHenLittle · 14/10/2023 11:31

Is Netanyahu really not capable of coming up with an alternative solution? Even after seeing that attacks from both sides over the decades simply result in more deaths?
We aren't politicians, but you'd think someone running a country could come up with something other than "destroy an entire city and most/all of its trapped civilians".
He must know that even if they kill a lot of Hamas fighters (who unfortunately will probably be the most likely people to be able to escape Gaza), more civilians will die. Many government members have made it clear they don't care, one very publicly called for collective punishment (the siege) on ALL Gazans. I'm not sure they want an alternative at the moment.

I know that if the UK suffered a similar attack, I wouldn't want Sunak to order an attack on their country of origin, I didn't support the Iraq or Afghanistan wars (and look at the resulting destabilisation and mess left behind from those). Politicians have been elected to power to come up with better than "war". Governments should be able to come together to intervene and help and support the Israeli government instead of voicing support for further killing and doing little, if anything, else.

TreadLight · 14/10/2023 11:22

Why is it always someone else's fault that Israel breaks international law?

"He made me do it" doesn't work on the playground and it doesn't work in the Haig.

Yes, some countries are funding Hamas. It doesn't take much digging to discover the USA is funding the Israeli military machine.

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 11:08

Well something that doesn't involve committing crimes against humanity would be good

Can you be more specific?
For instance if financial backing for Hamas were removed that would resolve the situation without the need for military conflict, unfortunately I dont see said backers making any announcements to that effect.

Far from it, the normalisation of relations between Saudi and Israel is now scuppered so they will have achieved the desired effect, and it only cost the lives of a few thousand innocent civilians.

Reallifelurker · 14/10/2023 10:43

What would you suggest would be the correct Israeli response to the attacks

Anything that will actually remove Hammas from power. If they do that then maybe they’ve achieved something. Just bombing Gaza into oblivion didn’t work ten years ago and probably won’t now.

SnowflakeCity · 14/10/2023 10:40

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 10:30

The response is to commit crimes against humanity against international law. We should all condemn this. There are no excuses.

What would you suggest would be the correct Israeli response to the attacks?

Well something that doesn't involve committing crimes against humanity would be good Confused

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 10:30

The response is to commit crimes against humanity against international law. We should all condemn this. There are no excuses.

What would you suggest would be the correct Israeli response to the attacks?

SnowflakeCity · 14/10/2023 10:29

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 10:18

@TreadLight unfortunately that terrorist organisation rule and are based in Gaza, hence the incursion. And I don't think it's remotely a fair comparison to categorise the actions as similar - the first was a deliberate and particularly brutal series of terrorist attacks, the response is a military operation and while there are certainly civilian casualties, that is not the main intent.

The response is to commit crimes against humanity against international law. We should all condemn this. There are no excuses.

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 10:28

Ie you should not be attacking areas where high civilian casualties would be expected.

The whole of Gaza pretty much is densely populated so how does Israel then go after Hamas?

andtheworldrollson · 14/10/2023 10:26

The semantics there are ridiculous!

The first was a brutal and unjustified attack but it didn't come out of nowhere - Israel have occupied Palestine for decades and each year Israeli forces kill about ten times more Palestinians than the other way around - they see it as war not terrorism

Israel might see themselves as behaving legally and honourably but the UN doesn't

Whilst the main intent may not be civilians casualties the standard for the rest of the world is somewhat higher and rests on what actually happens rather than stated intent - actions not words define the impact on civilians. Ie you should not be attacking areas where high civilian casualties would be expected.

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 10:18

@TreadLight unfortunately that terrorist organisation rule and are based in Gaza, hence the incursion. And I don't think it's remotely a fair comparison to categorise the actions as similar - the first was a deliberate and particularly brutal series of terrorist attacks, the response is a military operation and while there are certainly civilian casualties, that is not the main intent.

TreadLight · 14/10/2023 10:12

@SomeCatFromJapan , that report is terrible. These acts were carried out by a terrorist organisation. But when a democratic nation state carries out similar acts (the number killed by Israel now exceeds these killed by Hamas) they become a terrorist nation.

Paintballmaker · 14/10/2023 10:06

DownNative · 14/10/2023 09:45

And none of them have a viable alternative solution to the problem....

Unlike your Ratko Maldic style solution

andtheworldrollson · 14/10/2023 10:04

I do believe that terrorist organisations will indoctrinate children and will use them in war

I still however do not see that as a reason to kill children

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 09:53

@DownNative have you seen this CNN report?

https://twitter.com/CNN/status/1713043391745851814

https://twitter.com/CNN/status/1713043391745851814

TreadLight · 14/10/2023 09:50

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 09:40

There are a great many Neville Chamberlain's on these threads.

Is that in respect of those suggesting appeasement of Hamas atrocities on the Israelis, or those suggesting appeasement of Israeli atrocities on Gazans?

DownNative · 14/10/2023 09:45

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 09:40

There are a great many Neville Chamberlain's on these threads.

And none of them have a viable alternative solution to the problem....

TreadLight · 14/10/2023 09:43

Hamas has been built on the aggressive militaristic stance of the Israeli state towards the Palestinian people over the decades. Every bomb that is dropped and every bullet fired by Israel is creating the next generation of terrorists. Israel has the power to change the direction of this conflict. There is no doubt it will be a long, hard path, but it doesn't have to be littered with the dead bodies of innocent Palestinians and Israelis.

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/10/2023 09:40

There are a great many Neville Chamberlain's on these threads.

Brumbies · 14/10/2023 09:37

Really?

Oliotya · 14/10/2023 09:26

Brumbies · 14/10/2023 09:17

Israel is the world’s only Jewish state, occupying a tiny percentage of the land mass of the Middle East And is surrounded by well-funded, hostile, state-sponsored terrorist groups which, as we have seen, are willing to replicate Nazi-era atrocities. Therefore this is no time to be calling for Israeli restraint. Israeli self-defence requires the total removal of Hamas from Gaza.

There is never any justification for war crimes. Israel is as responsible for it's own conduct as any other nation or organisation. One atrocity does not condone another.

Brumbies · 14/10/2023 09:17

Israel is the world’s only Jewish state, occupying a tiny percentage of the land mass of the Middle East And is surrounded by well-funded, hostile, state-sponsored terrorist groups which, as we have seen, are willing to replicate Nazi-era atrocities. Therefore this is no time to be calling for Israeli restraint. Israeli self-defence requires the total removal of Hamas from Gaza.

Paintballmaker · 14/10/2023 05:12

LethargicButAwesome · 14/10/2023 00:28

@Paintballmaker wow your literally quoting and recering to instances little boys whose fathers have been murdered throwing rocks as terrorists and trained fighters.

wow

i think its so ingrained in your mind that israel can never be wring, you dont even realise what your saying. Your whole post shows you think you palestinians as less than human. Just wow.

@LethargicButAwesome I think your reply was maybe aimed at @DownNative. I was just replying to them too and definitely don’t agree with their pseudo knowledgeable chatGPT drivel.

DownNative · 14/10/2023 01:24

SnowflakeCity · 14/10/2023 01:15

Is there any chance you could be a bit more concise? The epic length of your posts make them really annoying to scroll past.

It depends on the length of what I'm responding to and the detail required, so no. 🤷‍♂️

SnowflakeCity · 14/10/2023 01:15

DownNative · 13/10/2023 21:09

Are you seriously denying Hamas indoctrinate Palestinian children to admire and emulate Islamic Jihad terrorists?

Despite the United Nations confirming* *they do?

Despite NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence report confirming they do?

You haven't undermined my argument. Familiarise yourself with the attached images of Hamas abusing Palestinian children with Jihad ideology.

@ChickHenLittle said: "Or is it only okay to make such statements about Palestinians?"

Strange logic!

And no, I've never only made child soldier statements about Hamas. I take it you had no idea Provisional IRA also used children as soldiers too?

Former & fully repentant PIRA member, Sean Paul O'Doherty lifted the lid on that here:

https://irishpeaceprocess.blog/2018/01/10/ira-war-crimes-enlisting-children/

The attached image of a PIRA memorial to volunteers lists 12 year old Cathy McGartland as having been a PIRA member.

Unlike you, I've been dealing with terrorist groups and their ideologies for a long time now. I know how they operate and what they do to children.

I'm telling you the reality, but I understand you don't want to believe terrorists do this to children. It's tragic that they do.

Is there any chance you could be a bit more concise? The epic length of your posts make them really annoying to scroll past.

LethargicButAwesome · 14/10/2023 00:28

@Paintballmaker wow your literally quoting and recering to instances little boys whose fathers have been murdered throwing rocks as terrorists and trained fighters.

wow

i think its so ingrained in your mind that israel can never be wring, you dont even realise what your saying. Your whole post shows you think you palestinians as less than human. Just wow.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread