Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ABIU about in law's wanting two Santa's?

160 replies

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 18:16

It's our turn to have Christmas at my families house.. but I have just learned that we have to go to my in laws first... Because 'santa' also visits my husband's aunt?

My husband's's aunt puts out presents from Santa on Christmas day for her great nephews (3 and 8).

So the kids wake up in their own homes and open their presents from Santa 1 and then go to their great aunt to open presents from Santa 2.

It's our first baby and he will be 11 months old this Christmas.. not old enough to understand but we will be putting out our own presents.

I feel like the second Santa crosses a boundary line? The kids great aunt has no kids and has never been married so I feel like I can't say this.

  1. We have a budget for 'santa' - we could afford more but I don't agree with spending too much money on toys for kids - rather buy a few things they want and some things they need.. ie books/clothes
  1. I don't want my kids bragging to others about having 'two santas'.. and other kids maybe not getting many toys at all
  1. I want my kids to appreciate presents and toys as some other children don't get any
  1. It wouldn't take kids long to wonder why they get two Santa's? Why he do X in one house and not in another etc.
  1. I feel like it diminishes 'our santa' ? And makes it a little less special for us. Particularly when our son gets older as he will be opening presents in one house wondering what he has got at the other

AIBU to say that I am not comfortable with this? I feel like saying it for the first Christmas would be better rather than letting it happen

OP posts:
WannabeMum22 · 11/10/2023 20:03

I'd say no to this. First of all I'm an adult and hate being dictated to - so for that reason alone I'd say no. Second of all when you alternate christmas it means just that - you alternate. You can see his aunt every other year but why should you cut your time short with your family? It's unfair. Surely she can save the gifts and give them to your children at another time if all it is about, is spreading love and christmas cheer. Say no and enjoy your time with your family this year.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 11/10/2023 20:01

"Sorry, it's a lovely idea but it doesn't work for us "

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 11/10/2023 20:00

What if ops parents want to do something?

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 11/10/2023 20:00

But why can't these other people pretending to give presents from FC just give them normally? From themselves?

Spinderellaseverywhere · 11/10/2023 19:57

I would definitely agree to do that as it sounds very sweet but not on the same day as your family when it’s their Xmas. Could you go to great Aunty’s house on another day? I wouldn’t commit to every Christmas because when your baby is older you they won’t want to be driving all over on Xmas day itself.

WillowCraft · 11/10/2023 19:56

I'd let her give some presents and say they're from Santa if that's what she wants to do. But I would decide on the day of the visit and it wouldn't be Christmas day unless that fitted in with other plans.

When children are young it feels like they get loads of presents and it's excessive. But you can remove some and regift. You don't need to give an 11 month old anything yourself as they won't care so that's one set fewer presents As they get older the novelty wears off and they get less from family and friends. On the other hand they start to enjoy the presents more. And it's their presents so it's a bit mean to try to stop people giving them.

ActDottie · 11/10/2023 19:52

Just go with it! I think you’re really overthinking this and as a kid I don’t even remember discussing Santa with my friends that much anyway.

cheddercherry · 11/10/2023 19:45

Oh god and I just saw the update about how much travel for such a short time is involved. Nah, nip it in the bud now and politely decline and send a card! Imagine the trip in the next few years with an overstimulated toddler stuck in a car for hours for 30 minutes of gifts with a random relative. Save your Christmas’ yet to come, or you’ll be trudging into Aunt’s house like Marley in chains for years to come.

Eminybob · 11/10/2023 19:45

Santa and stockings is the most stressful part of Christmas for me. If someone else was willing to take over I would happily hand over all Santa duties. Just one Santa, but it's at aunties house. Job done.

WhatAPalaverer · 11/10/2023 19:44

And if she wants to see you she can see you when you’re available!

WhatAPalaverer · 11/10/2023 19:43

Father Christmas only brings stockings. Everything else is from who it’s from. Stops all the “why didn’t I get a diamond tiara?” business plus means the actual givers get thanked. Auntie X can have gifts from her under her tree for your kids but they shouldn’t come from “Santa”.

cheddercherry · 11/10/2023 19:39

For me the issue is more that I’m expected to attend every year and that even on “my” family years I have to go. So tbh, I’d be making it clear that I wouldn’t be going every year if I already had plans with my family, and that it’s not set in stone. As you say, this year your baby won’t even realise they’re missing it.

I do think it’s probably a bit confusing being from a random Aunt. I get when people who have separated have to have to visits but why would santa go to aunties house and not say, grandma and grandads also? It opens a bit of a weird exception but hey, lots of families bend the stories!

It’s more the lack of fairness that you have to accommodate your in laws even on “your” year, but if your family had a morning tradition I assume they’d not be happy on their years for you to skip out to your family too.

RowenaEllis · 11/10/2023 19:32

It’s a hard pass on the 2 hour round trip every year just so the aunt can see the kids open her gifts - every other relative posts theirs, why can’t she? The second Santa is a non issue - just tell your kids that auntie likes to pretend. But the obligation to go every year is absurd.

FabFitFifties · 11/10/2023 19:31

My family used to do this, I stopped it for several reasons,but the most important being I wanted him to know who the presents were from and to thank them appropriately. My family didn't argue.

Sugargliderwombat · 11/10/2023 19:29

It's weird how many people are saying "oh bless her just play along". Imagine a MIL did this I think it would be a different story. Its a nice thing to do but just like anyone else you don't have to do it.

MimiSunshine · 11/10/2023 19:29

for My children, Father Christmas brings the stocking treats and little presents. this is for many reasons including…

  1. I don’t want them thinking they can ask him for anything and he’ll magically get it for them.
  2. I like them to thank the family member who got them something and that included me. and 3) as they get older they get pretty perceptive and in no way am I faffing about with specific ‘Santa wrapping paper’ so they don’t start asking why all of the presents wrapped up the same.

id just say no thank you very politely to the great aunt. If she wants to get your child a present, that’s lovely.You don’t have to do buy into the same tradition, especially not one that involves a 2hr+ trip on Christmas morning.

ColleenDonaghy · 11/10/2023 19:26

Santa used to occasionally forget a present at our house and drop it off at my grandparents on the way by. No big deal.

However, the two hour round trip is ridiculous and no way would I be agreeing to that, especially not with the expectation of it being repeated every year.

See the aunt another day and suck up the Santa thing as a compromise.

W0tnow · 11/10/2023 19:24

No. No.

As a kid I detested having to go from one place to the other on Christmas Day. Hated it. And as an adult, it is a monumental pain in the arse. If I could live my life again this is one hill to die on.

she can come to you if it’s that important.

itsmyp4rty · 11/10/2023 19:22

Personally if it is your families year this year then I wouldn't be going to the in laws just to indulge an aunts wish to play Father Christmas. Next year maybe, but not this year.

Soontobe60 · 11/10/2023 19:21

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 18:47

@Iwasafool

No one is saying this.
It's our brand new family and we have to work around others traditions to suit others.

Families grow and change.

My families traditions are being pushed aside for second Santa at someone else's.

Blimey, talk about over thinking something! How are you going to explain about santas at school / on TV / at Christmas parties etc? Come December, Santa’s are everywhere!
When my grandchildren first understood Christmas, when they came to my house on Boxing Day and saw presents under the tree for them, they knew Santa could come to anyone’s house!

CharlotteStreetW1 · 11/10/2023 19:20

HakunaMatiłda · 11/10/2023 18:55

So aunt wants one of the highlights of being a parent without doing any of the hard work?

Ouch!

Sunplant · 11/10/2023 19:16

Sorry I think you are being very unreasonable. Spreading out Christmas is a good idea. We always did this with our children and it happens now with the grandchildren. I think a lot of children have Christmas gifts on different days.
Does it matter that your great aunt likes to call it two Santa's? Let your great aunt enjoy it

Cherrysoup · 11/10/2023 19:10

As a pp said, I wouldn’t be allowing an aunt to stop you having your own traditions/going to see your parents. It just adds stress to an already stressful day. Having a second set of presents is a bit much. Just stay home!

Sugarfree23 · 11/10/2023 19:06

Op the 2hr round trip is what would make me say no or say you'll go round on Boxing Day or 27th when you have time for a proper visit, rather than a flying visit.

Santa dropping gifts in two places, meh, kids will swallow any excuse, he forgot to leave it, found it and knew you'd be visiting Auntie.

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 19:06

@Almostautumn2023

I think I like this idea.

Hate seeing people posting mountains of presents on social media on Christmas morning.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread