Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ABIU about in law's wanting two Santa's?

160 replies

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 18:16

It's our turn to have Christmas at my families house.. but I have just learned that we have to go to my in laws first... Because 'santa' also visits my husband's aunt?

My husband's's aunt puts out presents from Santa on Christmas day for her great nephews (3 and 8).

So the kids wake up in their own homes and open their presents from Santa 1 and then go to their great aunt to open presents from Santa 2.

It's our first baby and he will be 11 months old this Christmas.. not old enough to understand but we will be putting out our own presents.

I feel like the second Santa crosses a boundary line? The kids great aunt has no kids and has never been married so I feel like I can't say this.

  1. We have a budget for 'santa' - we could afford more but I don't agree with spending too much money on toys for kids - rather buy a few things they want and some things they need.. ie books/clothes
  1. I don't want my kids bragging to others about having 'two santas'.. and other kids maybe not getting many toys at all
  1. I want my kids to appreciate presents and toys as some other children don't get any
  1. It wouldn't take kids long to wonder why they get two Santa's? Why he do X in one house and not in another etc.
  1. I feel like it diminishes 'our santa' ? And makes it a little less special for us. Particularly when our son gets older as he will be opening presents in one house wondering what he has got at the other

AIBU to say that I am not comfortable with this? I feel like saying it for the first Christmas would be better rather than letting it happen

OP posts:
MeinKraft · 11/10/2023 23:23

Oh I want to change my answer too after seeing it's a 2 hour drive! I was thinking more like 2 minutes. Absolutely not.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 11/10/2023 23:13

The distance is too far, can it be done on a different day instead

PercyPigInAWig · 11/10/2023 23:05

Never mind the two Santas, I’d be knocking on the head right now that it’s your turn to go to anyone’s family, I wouldn’t get into alternating Christmases and people expecting you to spend it with them because you went to the other side last year. As DC we wanted Christmas at home, in our own house with our new toys. DH and I made a point of not getting into any Christmas rotas, we do what suits our family, still meet up with others but not schlepping DC off to visit different relatives and spending lots of time in the car.

Universalsnail · 11/10/2023 22:57

My Nan used to do this and we used to love it. I'd just go with it.

MrsAvocet · 11/10/2023 22:55

I can see that your DH's aunt probably means well and maybe she enjoys having the children in the extended family around on Christmas Day, but the bottom line is that you, your DH and your baby are a separate family now and it's up to you how you do things. You might want to combine your family's traditions and those of your DH's family but there is no reason why one "side" should get priority over the other, and you might of course want to develop your own, completely different way of doing Christmas. If you lived very close to this lady and it was a matter of popping round the corner for half an hour at some point during the day then that would be one thing, but clearly you don't so it's not practical to see her on Christmas Day. I'd arrange to visit on another day assuming you'll be visiting your ILs at some point over the festive period. When your baby gets older you'll probably appreciate spreading things out rather than having one full on day anyway.
The 2 santas thing isn't something I'd worry about really. Kids work things put for themselves son enough anyway. My MIL has always insisted that ALL Christmas presents come from Santa so she did the "oh look, Santa has left presents for you here too" thing when we visited but in my family we didn't do that so my parents would give my children presents labelled "love from Grandma and Grandad". That caused a bit of tension as obviously whilst my DC still believed it looked like one set of grandparents gave them gifts and the others didn't but I wasn't going to make my parents change what they've always done to make my MIL happy - they were just as entitled to stick to how they'd always done things as she was. By the time they were about 7 the children had figured out the truth anyway and were just humouring adults who talked about Santa!

Gymnopedie · 11/10/2023 22:30

OP I understand about the two Santas and two lots of presents. They could both be up for debate, there's no right or wrong. But I'd be buggered if I was going to take three or more hours out of every Christmas Day every year for it. It would be bad enough on the years you do Christmas with the inlaws, but to take that amount of time out of the year it's your parents no way.

You're lucky in that this year IS your parents. If it had been the inlaws and you'd had to go along with it they'd pressure you by saying the precedent had been set. As it is you can say no now.

The inevitable question - where's your DH in all this?

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/10/2023 22:23

Two Santas aside-

I'd say no. The deal is that you are at your parents this year. The aunts rules or traditions shouldn't over ride that. It isn't a reasonable request-unless you all live near each other and can quickly pop in.

caringcarer · 11/10/2023 21:52

When I was a kid I had 3 stockings every year. First one at home then second one at my childless Aunties then off to Grand for third stocking. When I was little I genuinely thought I got 3 stockings because I had been such a good girl through the year. Once I learned the truth I just played along for a few more years. My Aunty was like my second Mum all through my life. She couldn't have kids of her own but me and my sister's loved her to bits. When she was old and in a care home and I visited her often she told me several times how much she had enjoyed my childhood with me.

BomeleeBay · 11/10/2023 21:49

My lovely, sweet and kind MIL suggested another stocking from FC at her house, which I said was lovely but FC is doing a stocking of token toys at ours and because my children also had my parents why does FC not also deliver to them? I had older nieces and nephews so my Mum couldn't adopt this either.

I wanted my children to know who bought them presents, that meant stuff under the tree in their sacks were from us, their parents, the stocking at our house was from Father Christmas. They received presents from their relatives directly into their hands, some on Christmas day, some before which they could open there and then and some after and then their knew who to thank.

Children from other families will have,
everything brought by FC with no expense spared,
FC given a budget,
parents buy but they send it to FC and he delivers it back to their house parents buy everything with a budget,
or parents buy everything without a budget.

Dh and I came from families who did very different Christmas present buying and came up with stocking from FC and downstairs, no way was I sneaking a fully laden stocking into a room to be opened at 2am. Then a few presents from us under the tree. As we also have relatives buying for them it really starts to pile up so we keep it small.

Zola1 · 11/10/2023 21:33

It's wonderful that your child has more people who love him and want to get him gifts and make Christmas special for him.
It's not a bad thing. It's a good thing. My daughter is a teenager and my nan passed away when she was 7 but she still says remember how nan used to get me a stocking I loved that it was so kind

AndyPandyismyhero · 11/10/2023 21:31

One of my happiest and longest lasting memories is of visiting my grandparents on either Christmas Day or Boxing Day and being led upstairs by my nan to look for the stocking that Father Christmas always 'forgot' to leave at my house. It didn't spoil the stockings left at my parents at all. It is one of the happiest memories of my nan. She did a little stocking for my eldest DC for a year or two, but then became too unwell to continue.
However, I would absolutely not be doing an extra two hour journey for it on Christmas Day if i was not travelling there anyway.

WeWereInParis · 11/10/2023 21:15

Sunplant · 11/10/2023 19:16

Sorry I think you are being very unreasonable. Spreading out Christmas is a good idea. We always did this with our children and it happens now with the grandchildren. I think a lot of children have Christmas gifts on different days.
Does it matter that your great aunt likes to call it two Santa's? Let your great aunt enjoy it

I think a lot of children have Christmas gifts on different days.

But this isn't on a different day. The aunt is insisting on them doing a two hour round trip on Christmas morning. When they're spending Christmas with OP's family.

Codlingmoths · 11/10/2023 21:13

I wouldn’t be going anywhere else before lunch on my family Christmas day. We’d be waking up slowly, enjoying letting baby slowly discover presents, prepping food and gettign dressed up and heading off to lunch.

Lavender14 · 11/10/2023 21:11

If it worked logistically I would play along with it. My neice and nephew have 3 Santa's, their mums, their dad's and their nanas. They didn't really question it and given how many children now come from multiple households I would be surprised if there's not other kids your child will come into contact with who have multiple santa stops. Similarly, santa has always stopped at dh family home, but also with his grandparents at their house too. As they've got older his grandparents visit on xmas eve and exchange presents then. I don't think the number of gifts dictates your child's appreciation for getting presents- you teach and model that.

I do however understand your feeling that as its your first Christmas you want to feel like it's special and you're doing that first with your dc rather than sharing it with the great aunt. But I'd imagine this is her way of sharing that she cares and also having visitors and a bit of magic on Xmas day and actually getting to see your dc open their present on a day which might otherwise be a bit lonely. So I think personally that visiting her is in the spirit of things since the idea of santa is really just showing that we care for others.

If you need to travel to see family (we do every other year) you could visit her on Xmas eve instead? Or have her visit you? You could try starting a new tradition involving her that suits you all?

I'd also ask how important this tradition is to your partner? If I got to choose Xmas eve we'd see noone but I know its an important part of tradition for dh since he was a child so I respect that.

Sugarfree23 · 11/10/2023 21:01

Op Everybody does Santa differently, ours gives some things but delivers most things.
Mum didn't intend that to be the case but wanted to hoover before putting them under the tree.

Aunt got a lot of sympathy on her because she's childless and possibly not by choice. But I'd nip this in the bud, 2hrs driving for 30mins visit is stupid. However Christmas day can be manic, the thought of clock watching, right we need to leave to get to Aunties at 12.00 so we can be at Grannies at 3pm, and you know it's never going to be that easy, esp if you've been building toys at 3am! (I've got that t-shirt)

ohfook · 11/10/2023 20:46

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 18:45

In response to some of the questions.. yes this will happen every year.

And no she doesn't love nearby.. will be about a two hour round trip plus presents.

Ah ok this has made me change my answer! Ignore my previous post. No pissing way would my kids be spending two hours in the car on Christmas Day. I might be inclined to make it a nice Boxing Day treat though if I was feeling generous.

Holidaynovice · 11/10/2023 20:46

I thought you were unreasonable until I read about the 2 hour round trip and the expectation it would be every year. No way would I agree to that, we used to visit on Christmas day but actually the kids prefer to be in their own home on the day itself. I would say sorry that doesn't work for us, happy to visit (on a different day- if you are) or you're welcome to visit us on X day. I wouldn't worry about the 2 Santa's thing though, that's a bit of a non issue.

Brightredtulips · 11/10/2023 20:35

I think you're over thinking this. They are lucky children, just enjoy it all. We also had Santa visit with full costume on Boxing day, he came down the stairs ringing a bell carrying a sack, jingle bells sung by everyone. My old dad continues to do it even though the kids are in their 20s, my dad is 83. No one wondered why Santa was coming again(with presents from family who came on Boxing day) or why on Boxing day. The kids always said to my dad that he missed Santa's visit, they still say it. I'm hoping we will continue our tradition though probably one day there will be a daughter in law who won't approve.

TammyJones · 11/10/2023 20:35

2 hour round trip ?
Forget it.
It's your family's turn.
How can you be still expected at Aunty's?

TheCatterall · 11/10/2023 20:26

Regardless of Santa 2 - I’d decline as it’s a 2 hour round trip on Christmas Day that eats into existing plans. I can’t think of anything worse just for a quick visit then another long drive with young child to next stop etc.

And then use someone else’s suggestions for how to pave the way forward with an alternative suggestion.

lavagal · 11/10/2023 20:17

You are over thinking this
Santa visits each house on Xmas eve - he leaves presents on his visits

Our DD has Santa presents at home, MIL, my DM, my DD, my sisters and my SIL. She isn't spoilt- they would all gift her anyway, she just gets them there at their houses

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 20:11

@FabFitFifties

This is actually just that.
I am stealing this fosho! Thank you so much for posting.. no one gets offended! 🙌

OP posts:
StarlightLime · 11/10/2023 20:09

What on earth is the problem?? You're not "tied into" anything, you're visiting this house this year so Santa has left an extra delivery... If you don't visit next year, he won't 🤷🏻‍♀️
Get some Christmas spirit and let the poor woman join in the festivities.

MereDintofPandiculation · 11/10/2023 20:06

Aren’t they going to have 4 Santas? - including the one that turns up to nursery and the one you take him to see at a department store/on a steam train/in a cave etc? It really doesn’t matter.

BasiliskStare · 11/10/2023 20:04

2 hour round trip on the same day it is "your turn" for Christmas I think is too much. She could post presents and you can go another day.