Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ABIU about in law's wanting two Santa's?

160 replies

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 18:16

It's our turn to have Christmas at my families house.. but I have just learned that we have to go to my in laws first... Because 'santa' also visits my husband's aunt?

My husband's's aunt puts out presents from Santa on Christmas day for her great nephews (3 and 8).

So the kids wake up in their own homes and open their presents from Santa 1 and then go to their great aunt to open presents from Santa 2.

It's our first baby and he will be 11 months old this Christmas.. not old enough to understand but we will be putting out our own presents.

I feel like the second Santa crosses a boundary line? The kids great aunt has no kids and has never been married so I feel like I can't say this.

  1. We have a budget for 'santa' - we could afford more but I don't agree with spending too much money on toys for kids - rather buy a few things they want and some things they need.. ie books/clothes
  1. I don't want my kids bragging to others about having 'two santas'.. and other kids maybe not getting many toys at all
  1. I want my kids to appreciate presents and toys as some other children don't get any
  1. It wouldn't take kids long to wonder why they get two Santa's? Why he do X in one house and not in another etc.
  1. I feel like it diminishes 'our santa' ? And makes it a little less special for us. Particularly when our son gets older as he will be opening presents in one house wondering what he has got at the other

AIBU to say that I am not comfortable with this? I feel like saying it for the first Christmas would be better rather than letting it happen

OP posts:
Rosebud21 · 12/10/2023 08:36

YANBU, it's a lovely idea but a 2 hour journey, on Christmas day, every Christmas day, is a PITA 🎄. Perhaps it's time to negotiate another day over the holiday period for this, or to stop it altogether

LittleMonks11 · 12/10/2023 08:29

Regards the two hour round trip on Christmas morning to your husband's aunty when it's the year you are with your family - that's a flat out no from me. Lay it down now.

Regards all the other angst about Santa that you are giving headspace to when you have an 11 month old - just get on and enjoy it for heavens sake. Plenty of time yet to worry about your Santa narrative if that's the kind of thing you get anxious about.

Just switch on the news to get some perspective on all this.

maryberryslayers · 12/10/2023 08:28

I get what you mean. Santa is for parents to decide. We do one reasonably priced present from Santa, usually what they've 'written' about in their letter, and we buy the rest of their presents and say they are from us. I wrap Santa's in gaudy wrapping paper!
We are fortunate so I don't want them telling others about what Santa brought as it might be more than Santa buys their friends which would be confusing and upsetting. I also like them to know that our hard earned money and careful consideration went in to their gifts.

I don't agree that you should have to go to your in-laws on your family's year though, especially as it's your first with baby. Just say you'll pop by on Boxing Day etc as you're going to stick to alternate years to keep it fair and not spend your babies Christmas in the car rushing around. You can always blame babies routine if you need to.
You may also want to consider letting them know you'll be staying at home some years as older kids like to stay where their presents are.

Sugarfree23 · 12/10/2023 08:19

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 12/10/2023 08:00

I actually think it’s ok and so the great aunt can enjoy seeing the kids open presents however maybe do it another time like the evening or Boxing Day if it’s interfering with your day?

My kids great grandma started doing this. She bought kids a gift but refused to give them it until she saw them in person on Xmas evening. We go to her house for a Xmas evening buffet. It’s actually turned out not too bad now as the kids cousins all go too so they all turn up and have a new present to open and play with whilst the adults have a nice evening. It does work well.

Thats actually dictating what everyone does at Christmas.
She's a great gran one of potentially 4 great grans. Those children probably have other Grans to, do they not get to see their grandchildren ever on Christmas night?

I know sometimes it suits to have a set routine but other times it can cause friction that one side always takes precedent.

ChubbyMorticia · 12/10/2023 08:04

There’s a zero percent chance I’d be willing to add an extra two hours of travel to Christmas Day. You see them every other year for the holiday, that’s enough. Betting they’d be upset if you cut their visit short to spend a couple of hours with your family on their’ year.

Plus, I sincerely doubt you’ll be able to pop in and out. My bet is you’re going to be far more delayed than you bargain for

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 12/10/2023 08:00

I actually think it’s ok and so the great aunt can enjoy seeing the kids open presents however maybe do it another time like the evening or Boxing Day if it’s interfering with your day?

My kids great grandma started doing this. She bought kids a gift but refused to give them it until she saw them in person on Xmas evening. We go to her house for a Xmas evening buffet. It’s actually turned out not too bad now as the kids cousins all go too so they all turn up and have a new present to open and play with whilst the adults have a nice evening. It does work well.

2chocolateoranges · 12/10/2023 07:52

My mil used to try his when the kids were younger, oh wait and see what Santa has left for you here, I just told he kids granny was being silly and Santa only goes to our house. She soon stopped. End of story.

like you I didn’t want the children thinking Santa brought an an endless amount of gifts and I wanted them to be able to thank the relative who spent their time and money buying a gift.

i personally wouldn’t be going along with it, especially if it adds on extra travel time for Christmas Day.

Zebedee55 · 12/10/2023 07:52

When my kids were little, we always spent Xmas day with my parents. They used to like seeing the kids open the presents from them, so I just told my children that Santa and Rudolph needed a rest before they came to us,so they dropped some presents off at Nanny and Grandads.

Everyone was happy with that.🙂

DiaryLouise · 12/10/2023 07:49

Kids have a remarkable ability just to roll with whatever Santa related oddness is going on- he’s here, he’s there, he’s left the presents at granny’s house, he’s leaving presents at multiple houses or in your hotel or whatever, possibly because deep down they know it’s all nonsense. So I wouldn’t worry at all and certainly not about a baby.

I wouldn’t be committing to go to her house every year though.

BeyondMyWits · 12/10/2023 07:44

@Aismixx
"she also definitely will not be lonely on Christmas day as my husband's entire side go to her house all day."

So this is the in-laws way to have part of every single xmas day... even when you are spending "the day" with your side of the family. They will also be there, at the Aunt's house.

If you do go. And I hope not. Remember to spend 3 hours with your parents next year (you thought it was such a good idea etc)... or don't actually, just spend the morning in your house.

cherrypeachparfait · 12/10/2023 07:36

aloris · 12/10/2023 00:59

My MIL does this and I put up with it for years but, to be honest, it had a negative impact on our Santa experience because the way she did Santa made it clear that Santa was her. So our kids worked out that Santa wasn't real and that bothered me as it wasn't what I wanted. Santa was a part of parenting I was really looking forward to and it bothered me that she couldn't just step back and let me enjoy an aspect of parenting without making it about her.

If I was able to do it again, I wouldn't let her get one single claw on Santa. Santa is a privilege of the parents. It's a piece of pure joy and fun that you can have, to balance out all the hard graft of parenting (handling tantrums, making them brush their teeth properly, worrying about them when they are sick, being up with them at night when they wake up scared, etc). And these years when kids enjoy Santa are so short. By the time they are 6 or 8 years old they see right through it. People who feel they have the right to appropriate a parent's Santa years are selfish.

I agree

Therealjudgejudy · 12/10/2023 01:18

No way should you agree to this. She can give them her presents on boxing day.

If she kicks off about it then she is totally selfish and childish

Cnidarian · 12/10/2023 01:10

We will see her and his family no matter what Xmas eve, boxing day and will be having new year's dinner with them.

The addition of this information makes all the difference and changes my vote to YANBU. That's more than enough, you really don't have to go Christmas morning as well this year is your family's turn.

aloris · 12/10/2023 00:59

My MIL does this and I put up with it for years but, to be honest, it had a negative impact on our Santa experience because the way she did Santa made it clear that Santa was her. So our kids worked out that Santa wasn't real and that bothered me as it wasn't what I wanted. Santa was a part of parenting I was really looking forward to and it bothered me that she couldn't just step back and let me enjoy an aspect of parenting without making it about her.

If I was able to do it again, I wouldn't let her get one single claw on Santa. Santa is a privilege of the parents. It's a piece of pure joy and fun that you can have, to balance out all the hard graft of parenting (handling tantrums, making them brush their teeth properly, worrying about them when they are sick, being up with them at night when they wake up scared, etc). And these years when kids enjoy Santa are so short. By the time they are 6 or 8 years old they see right through it. People who feel they have the right to appropriate a parent's Santa years are selfish.

mathanxiety · 12/10/2023 00:55

This is batshit.

Nip it in the bud and do not play along.

Do not spend Christmas Day schlepping a baby from post to pillar to massage the feelings of people who should grow up.

Sugarfree23 · 12/10/2023 00:38

Nope definitely not leaving the house at 9am, that's a ridiculous suggestion.

Stop think how you want traditions to move forward.
Christmas Day with one family,
Boxing Day to chill sober up.
27th to see the other.

In a year or so would you consider hosting to avoid taking LO out the house? But hosting isn't the easy option either.

LittleMousewithcloggson · 12/10/2023 00:08

We used to take turns visiting parents until my eldest was crawling
Then we decided Christmas Day would always be at home for the kids sakes
Best decision ever
no one expects us to “pop in” on the way to anywhere else
We alternate Boxing Day with our parents and they are welcome to come to us for Christmas Day if they like (my parents do every other year) but our new tradition was Christmas at home!

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 23:49

@Gymnopedie

He's trying to please everyone but no way of doing so without everyone being put out in some way. We are a family now and I want to spend our first Christmas together.. took us a long long time to get our baby!

His first solution was 'so if we leave the house at 9am...' - immediate no from me lol.

Not sure what the plans will be! I don't wanna to voice my opinions on it too much as it's his family. Will stay silent until I have a plan of action. We will see her and his family no matter what Xmas eve, boxing day and will be having new year's dinner with them.

This auntie also is childless very much by choice.. she also definitely will not be lonely on Christmas day as my husband's entire side go to her house all day.

Feels like they had our full attention last year and will have it next year.. but we have to give up half our day when it's my sides 'turn'.

OP posts:
Lady1576 · 11/10/2023 23:47

So many cute suggestions on this thread for how to make it work, so that on old lady can have her little bit of joy. You couldn’t think of anything like that yourself, because you don’t really want to involve a random relative from your husband’s side. Maybe be honest about it. Santa came to my house on Christmas Eve and he never bought a stocking. I have never to this day wondered about that. As I type this it is the first time I’ve even thought about it. Tell dh you don’t want to drive over to his aunt because you can’t be bothered, or choose one of the many many very simple ways of making it work.

saraclara · 11/10/2023 23:39

TheShellBeach · 11/10/2023 23:28

But Santa goes to everyone's house, so what's the problem?

Exactly.

However, if it's a two hour drive, nope. The day is for OP's family. They don't get to lose a massive chunk of it for an auntie.

crumblycrust · 11/10/2023 23:37

Oh and he's old too, decrepit with creaking joints!

saraclara · 11/10/2023 23:37

I grew up with Santa visiting our house and my grandparents' house. My DGD also gets to see what he left at Grandma's house as well as what he lives at her house. I've never thought twice about it, and I didn't need to ask my DD for this. It felt natural to her too.

sandyhappypeople · 11/10/2023 23:36

You say it's your turn this year, so is it not every year that you'd be doing this?

Just let a kind family member get some enjoyment out of kids opening their presents! there's no second santa, normal santa has just left some presents there for them? I don't see the harm in it personally.

crumblycrust · 11/10/2023 23:34

Doesn't Santa zoom around on a sleigh at the speed of light? Plenty of time to spare. Kids don't generally question the logistics of how an obese man with an infinitely heavy sack of presents gets into at least a few billion tightly secured households in the span of one night, plus the vast amounts of espionage and admin needed to track down each recipient. So I think YABU.

TheShellBeach · 11/10/2023 23:28

But Santa goes to everyone's house, so what's the problem?