Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ABIU about in law's wanting two Santa's?

160 replies

Aismixx · 11/10/2023 18:16

It's our turn to have Christmas at my families house.. but I have just learned that we have to go to my in laws first... Because 'santa' also visits my husband's aunt?

My husband's's aunt puts out presents from Santa on Christmas day for her great nephews (3 and 8).

So the kids wake up in their own homes and open their presents from Santa 1 and then go to their great aunt to open presents from Santa 2.

It's our first baby and he will be 11 months old this Christmas.. not old enough to understand but we will be putting out our own presents.

I feel like the second Santa crosses a boundary line? The kids great aunt has no kids and has never been married so I feel like I can't say this.

  1. We have a budget for 'santa' - we could afford more but I don't agree with spending too much money on toys for kids - rather buy a few things they want and some things they need.. ie books/clothes
  1. I don't want my kids bragging to others about having 'two santas'.. and other kids maybe not getting many toys at all
  1. I want my kids to appreciate presents and toys as some other children don't get any
  1. It wouldn't take kids long to wonder why they get two Santa's? Why he do X in one house and not in another etc.
  1. I feel like it diminishes 'our santa' ? And makes it a little less special for us. Particularly when our son gets older as he will be opening presents in one house wondering what he has got at the other

AIBU to say that I am not comfortable with this? I feel like saying it for the first Christmas would be better rather than letting it happen

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sportismeantobefun · 13/10/2023 11:19

This 👆

we had very similar where my MIL likes to buy surprise ‘bits’ for the grand children. Little things, but obviously a lot of thought goes into them and it brings her lots of joy. However always labels them from ‘Santa’ in obviously her handwriting even if given on boxing day etc.

Used to really piss me off as I thought it was weird and confusing for the kids (as well as it always being Father Christmas not Santa in my family growing up). I felt she was trying to take over the ‘being Father Christmas’ joy from DH and me and she’d had her turn being 🎅 with DH. Also how could they say thank you if it was from Santa? However it only lasted a couple of years until my eldest asked me why MIL labels the ‘extra’ presents from her as from Santa. I said similar to the above and it’s never been mentioned since.

However…..just seen the update. I would not travel an hour on Xmas day to do this!

Dragonsandcats · 13/10/2023 11:04

I would absolutely not be doing a 2 hour drive for this when it was my turn with my family.

FortyFacedFuckers · 12/10/2023 20:11

PhantomUnicorn · 11/10/2023 18:18

just play along, and then later when they're old enough tell your kids that those presents are from Aunty, she just likes to pretend they're from Santa because she doesn't have children of her own or something.. make something up to excuse it.

What's the harm in humouring her? Its all make believe any way.

My inlaws done the same & I just handled it like this

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 12/10/2023 19:10

To me the 2 Santa's thing is a red herring..I've just read op's update that it a 2 hour round trip. Fuck that. Sorry, if she live 5 mins down the road I'd be like go for it but not on your nelly would I want to travel that far on top of everything else on Christmas Day with a 1 year old

Holly60 · 12/10/2023 18:25

It's not 'two Santa's' though is it? It's Santa dropping off some of the presents somewhere else, I think?

This is a very common set up- many people have Santa visit two places (co-parents for example springs to mind)

I think you'll be able to explain it just fine

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 12/10/2023 17:36

Insisting that you go on Christmas morning to 'another Santa' is ridiculous. Just nip it in the bud or she'll ruin every Christmas for you.

If she wants to do presents you can arrange to exchange them on a other day that's suitable for you and make sure they're from her not Santa.

SecondUsername4me · 12/10/2023 16:39

I'd just say "happy to do second santa on years we spend with you all, but on the years we go to my side we simply won't be able to join you"

mathanxiety · 12/10/2023 16:38

@saraclara has nailed it.

WhatAPalaverer · 12/10/2023 16:37

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 12/10/2023 13:30

Seems mean, so your mum doesn’t get to see the children open them. Couldn’t your presents have gone under the tree and other people get given to them. To be fair I think it should be up to the giver to choose how/when the gift is given(within the reasonable constraints of when your actually seeing them)

Agree completely- it’s really harsh to expect grandparents to buy gifts for their grandchildren but then not see them open the gifts and get no thanks for them as Santa gets all the credit! I wouldn’t bother buying anything if you were my daughter in law!

cartagenagina · 12/10/2023 15:05

YANBU there’s no way I would squeeze in an additional 2 hour trip on Christmas Day when it’s not their turn.

saraclara · 12/10/2023 14:58

The updates should have been in the OP. This isn't about two Santas at all. It's about his family nabbing you on the one day that's about your family. And your DH should absolutely have your back (and your family's) on this.

His are going to have you to themselves on Christmas Eve, Boxing Day and New Year? What on earth are they thinking, and what is HE thinking, in trying to steal part of your family's day?

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 14:53

Peridot1 · 12/10/2023 12:36

@Iwasafool - exactly! The stockings never had expensive things in them just some chocolates and a few little bits. But the presents definitely added up! And of course every child had to have a different stocking. And the all remembered which was which even without tags on. The funny thing was dad was never big into Christmas when we were children. But he loved it with the grandchildren.

It's funny isn't it. I started an advent tradition of a 50p piece every day so they had £12 on Christmas Eve and they would buy something for mum and dad wth "their" money. It was a reasonable amount 20 years ago but with one GC it was fine, a chocolate and 50p every day, when you get up to the 8 or 9 GC it is suddenly over £100 before you even think about stockings or presents and to add insult to injury the adult GC claims his old advent calendar is such an important part of Christmas that I can't stop!

Beware starting traditions.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 12/10/2023 13:30

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 12/10/2023 09:31

I see what you mean. It works for us as our kids have 2 great nans, 2 great grandads, 2 nans and 2 grandads. We see PILS side for Christmas lunch and then my side for Xmas evening buffet. So the kids see all their grandparents on the one day. At first I hated that my nan (kids great nan) was dictating this as she wasn’t like this growing up with us. My mum didn’t help either as she was fully on her mums side. My mum tried to do it too with the whole we’ll keep presents at ours until we see the kids. I said no, presents are delivered by Santa and go under the tree to be found Xmas morning.

Seems mean, so your mum doesn’t get to see the children open them. Couldn’t your presents have gone under the tree and other people get given to them. To be fair I think it should be up to the giver to choose how/when the gift is given(within the reasonable constraints of when your actually seeing them)

Peridot1 · 12/10/2023 12:36

@Iwasafool - exactly! The stockings never had expensive things in them just some chocolates and a few little bits. But the presents definitely added up! And of course every child had to have a different stocking. And the all remembered which was which even without tags on. The funny thing was dad was never big into Christmas when we were children. But he loved it with the grandchildren.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 12/10/2023 11:40

Also, my SIL declared that all presents opened in Xmas morning that were given in advance (no matter who they were from) were from santa, one year to the extent of re-wrapping everyone's gifts in the same santa paper. That was the last year I handed gifts over in advance, credit (and thanks) to the gift-giver thank you very much!

Loverofoxbowlakes · 12/10/2023 11:38

YABU.

We always had a bag full of (gratefully recieved) tat (same contents every year, became a family tradition into adulthood) from santa at my grandparent's house as well as at home.

Don't make a big thing of it.

You do know santa isn't real, yes?

MuggleMe · 12/10/2023 10:51

It's the summons rather than the second Santa that's the issue for me. Your DH has final say on 'his' years and you on yours.

Assume on his years you spend the day at the aunt's so not losing 3 hours to this 'tradition'.

We're also big on giving credit where it's due and not saying everyone's gifts were from Santa.

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 10:43

Peridot1 · 12/10/2023 09:59

I think the main thing I’d be refusing would be the travel on Christmas Day which is supposed to be your day with your side. So it would be a no from me.

With regard to the Santa thing - I get what you are saying but as you can see everyone seems to do it so differently I think children just accept different approaches. When I was a child my maternal grandmother spoiled us with presents from Santa as we were her only grandchildren. But we knew the presents were from her really. I think she used to say Santa left them and wink at us so we knew. My paternal grandmother had lots more grandchildren and ‘Santa’ would leave us something small there. Again we knew it was from her.

With our DS we used to stay with my parents a lot for Christmas and there were lots of cousins and my dad decided he’d do stockings even though I did one for DS. My sisters don’t do stockings so if I’d made a fuss none of the children would have had a stocking which I felt was unfair of me to dictate so I didn’t say anything. The children all knew it was all from Grandad. Other presents were all signed “from Grandad Santa”. Dad started doing the stockings when there were three grandchildren. He really regretted ever starting it once there were 11!

Sympathies to your dad. It is easy to start these things with the first GC, I'm not quite up to 11 yet but heading that way and what was lovely for one, nice for two can be a bit of a nightmare for 8, 9 or 10. Not to mention I was working with the older GC and now it's all done on a pension and it can easily run into hundreds. At the same time you can't do it for one and not do it for others.

A rod for our own backs springs to mind.

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 10:39

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 12/10/2023 09:31

I see what you mean. It works for us as our kids have 2 great nans, 2 great grandads, 2 nans and 2 grandads. We see PILS side for Christmas lunch and then my side for Xmas evening buffet. So the kids see all their grandparents on the one day. At first I hated that my nan (kids great nan) was dictating this as she wasn’t like this growing up with us. My mum didn’t help either as she was fully on her mums side. My mum tried to do it too with the whole we’ll keep presents at ours until we see the kids. I said no, presents are delivered by Santa and go under the tree to be found Xmas morning.

People do it in various ways. Santa never brought all the presents in my family, I liked my Santa presents but I also liked visiting or being visited by aunts/uncles/grandparents who would bring their presents.

We did the same with my children, I preferred the presents to not all come at once as that can be a bit overwhelming so getting some on Christmas evening or Boxing Day for example meant those presents didn't just get lost in amongst everything else.

I don't think there is a right way to do it, just the way that seems right to each family.

Peridot1 · 12/10/2023 09:59

I think the main thing I’d be refusing would be the travel on Christmas Day which is supposed to be your day with your side. So it would be a no from me.

With regard to the Santa thing - I get what you are saying but as you can see everyone seems to do it so differently I think children just accept different approaches. When I was a child my maternal grandmother spoiled us with presents from Santa as we were her only grandchildren. But we knew the presents were from her really. I think she used to say Santa left them and wink at us so we knew. My paternal grandmother had lots more grandchildren and ‘Santa’ would leave us something small there. Again we knew it was from her.

With our DS we used to stay with my parents a lot for Christmas and there were lots of cousins and my dad decided he’d do stockings even though I did one for DS. My sisters don’t do stockings so if I’d made a fuss none of the children would have had a stocking which I felt was unfair of me to dictate so I didn’t say anything. The children all knew it was all from Grandad. Other presents were all signed “from Grandad Santa”. Dad started doing the stockings when there were three grandchildren. He really regretted ever starting it once there were 11!

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 12/10/2023 09:31

Sugarfree23 · 12/10/2023 08:19

Thats actually dictating what everyone does at Christmas.
She's a great gran one of potentially 4 great grans. Those children probably have other Grans to, do they not get to see their grandchildren ever on Christmas night?

I know sometimes it suits to have a set routine but other times it can cause friction that one side always takes precedent.

I see what you mean. It works for us as our kids have 2 great nans, 2 great grandads, 2 nans and 2 grandads. We see PILS side for Christmas lunch and then my side for Xmas evening buffet. So the kids see all their grandparents on the one day. At first I hated that my nan (kids great nan) was dictating this as she wasn’t like this growing up with us. My mum didn’t help either as she was fully on her mums side. My mum tried to do it too with the whole we’ll keep presents at ours until we see the kids. I said no, presents are delivered by Santa and go under the tree to be found Xmas morning.

cheddercherry · 12/10/2023 09:20

If you’re spending Xmas Eve, Boxing Day and New Year’s Eve with his family no way would I be giving up my Xmas day morning with my family on their turn. For me it’s that simple, it’s so skewed his family’s way that it’s just nonsensical to give yet more time, do they not think your family would like proper time with their grandchild too?

GreenhouseGarden · 12/10/2023 08:58

I struggled with this kind of think when the kids were little. But with the benefit of hindsight- the more people that love your and want joy for your children the better.

ds1 found the concept of Santa disturbing. Strange man coming down the chimney - no fucking thank you. And has never really believed.

ds2 - never believed not a day in his life.

whilst I can understand wanting the day to go just as you expect it. I recommend just going with the flow. The only thing getting wound up is going todo is ruin the day for you.

BestZebbie · 12/10/2023 08:53

Could this be less of an overstep than you are thinking because of different family traditions around Santa?
In my birth family, Santa brought a stocking and a few token gifts from himself, to play with/eat on Christmas morning before the real gifts were exchanged between family members (having been put under the tree for display several weeks earlier). However in my DH' family, "Santa" delivers all the gifts from himself and between family members on Xmas Eve (via some kind of vague North Pole warehousing system), and they are all "from Santa" in this way.
When we had a baby, MIL therefore expected to bring lots of gifts "from Santa" to put under the tree, which would have hugely overshadowed the stocking Santa was bringing overnight - but she wasn't trying to "steal" Santa in the way that taking a baby for its first haircut etc is "stealing" something, it was literally just a different word being used for the family gift exchange.

LittleMonks11 · 12/10/2023 08:41

Rosebud21 · 12/10/2023 08:36

YANBU, it's a lovely idea but a 2 hour journey, on Christmas day, every Christmas day, is a PITA 🎄. Perhaps it's time to negotiate another day over the holiday period for this, or to stop it altogether

They will be spending Xmas eve, Boxing Day and New Year's Eve with aunty by the sounds of it! She's being a bit naughty to be honest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread