Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eating in a calorie deficit

37 replies

PinkMoscatoLover · 11/10/2023 17:42

Right guys, help me out.

I weigh nearly 22 stone (I wear a size 18-20). I’m only 24 years old so I’m massively overweight. I have binge eating disorder and two little ones with health conditions/disabilities so stressful periods make me binge more. I’m finally on the waiting list to get help for my eating disorder and should be starting this before the end of the year.

This is the first time I’ve felt in control with my life and with eating. I’ve recently joined Fitness First and the classes I go too are really good. I’ve been trying my best to eat three meals a day which seems to be working out quite well for me. Now I know to lose a substantial amount of weight, you’ll need to eat in a calorie deficit.

My question is, how do I go about doing this? How do I know how many calories my home cooked meals add up too? How/where do I track my calories and how much calories should I aim to eat in a day? If anyone has any articles that explain all of this clearly or if people would like to share their own experiences, that’d be really helpful.

I’ve posted on AIBU for traffic so I’ve got my hard hat on as no doubt a few posters may fat shame me🫣

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
divinededacende · 11/10/2023 23:23

I'm passing 8st weight loss at the moment and I definitely used to lean towards binge eating.

I started during the COVID madness and my main goal was to get a better sense of the calories in what I was eating. I wasn't interested on 'healthy' eating at first, I just wanted to know how to get the most bang for my buck calorie wise i.e. how much shite can I still eat without gaining more weight. Lockdown was miserable enough without being on a diet but I had already hit the "enough is enough" stage with my weight so I still felt motivated to take some baby steps.

MyFitnessPal was really useful for me because, once you start to get a sense of the calories in food, you start to see where you can make easy substitutions to lower the calories while keeping your eating habits mainly the same. It really helped me get some quick wins fairly early on without having to put in too much effort. The time spent scanning and tracking is an effort itself but worth it.

Over time I've gradually shifted my habits to integrate more balanced, healthy eating but I've used MyFitnessPal all the way through. My overall eating and fitness habits are fairly good now. Not perfect, but good for where I started.

My top tip is to be honest. It's a journey and you need to be comfortable that it might be 2 steps forward, 1 step back and that's fine. In the long term, it's still progress. Make sure you track your binges as much as you track your good days because its just as important to be able to see your patterns and maybe use the info to learn more about your triggers and weaknesses.

my approach might not work for everyone but I'm 2 years in and couldn't be happier with how it's turned out.

PinkMoscatoLover · 11/10/2023 21:15

Thank you guys:)

I just want to get in the habit of tracking my three meals a day which is quite important to me. I won’t be focusing on numbers and restricting food as eating three proper meals will already be me eating in a calorie deficit in comparison to how I usually eat🫣

I really would like to cut down on sugar and stuff but that would end up in me binging if I restrict certain foods. I’ll wait on the counselling to start before I try any of that by myself. It’s never ended well for me in the past

OP posts:
bakewellbride · 11/10/2023 21:08

I am a size 8 and very conscious of eating healthily and honestly have no idea how many calories I eat in a day or anything like that. Worrying about numbers etc is not sustainable/ lifelong and therefore a waste of time imo. If you eating 3 healthy meals a day, drinking plenty of water and not snacking then the weight will almost certainly come off. Try to focus on healthy eating for life and having a positive mindset so that it's something you want to do. That mindset is an absolute game changer. Good luck.

PaminaMozart · 11/10/2023 20:23

What @5128gap says!

And lay off sugar and UPF

5128gap · 11/10/2023 20:13

The advantage of being heavier at the start OP is that you can drop weight while still consuming a fair amount. Plus you're young which helps with metabolic rate.
So, if I were you I'd focus on eating loads of veg, up to ten portions a day, if you can, some whole grain carbs and lean protein in about half the amounts you'd normally have, and one treat a day. Don't drink any calories. If you can have a walk every day, even ten minutes then build up to longer, you'll drop weight without all the faffing and fad diets.

Mousespace · 11/10/2023 20:12

You see a lot of "do this calcuation and take 500 off" online but if you go too hard with the deficit you might be more likely to binge- this would happen to me.

What I did was just for a while track everything and not worry about the number. Just to get used to tracking it and weighing everything. Doing that for a while you find patterns- you see some things are way more calories than you expect, a serving size is smaller than you expect, that dinner is fewer calories than you'd expect, I could swap X for Y and it'd cut it by Z.

I worked on eating at "level" for a while. The amount to maintain weight. There are calculators for that. When that wasn't overwhelming I reduced by small amount of calories. 100 fewer to start with etc.

This is way slower than a lot of people online go but honestly doing it "fast" and the ways that are recommended just led to binging and putting anything I lost back on. I've lost just over 20kg this year since january, about 0.5kg a week, which is slow going but closer to the pace the NHS recommends.

Are you still having trouble with binges? I had to get my mental health up before I even started thinking about changing how I eat. Regular exercise has really helped me so I'd make it a priority you stick with that, not for weight loss just for the brain 😂

NotFastButFurious · 11/10/2023 19:59

It’s around a 3500 calorie deficit to burn a lb of fat so 500 calories a day less in compared to how many you’re burning to loose a lb per week. As you’re quite overweight and not eating well it should be fairly easy to loose more than that to start with if you stick to 3 healthy meals a day. Also, be careful of the MFP weight loss plan as it can go to very low
calories. You should be able to loose on 2000 calories a day to start off.

FusionChefGeoff · 11/10/2023 19:53

Hellinthekitchen · 11/10/2023 18:04

Do you think that tracking, weighing and measuring is sensible if you have binge eating disorder? I would be concerned that this would trigger you to binge more. And there is lots of research out there which suggests the same.

In your position, I would focus on eating three meals and no snacking.

Agree with this. I have had some form of eating disorder all my life and any kind of diet / tracking / restriction always ends in disaster for me.

PinkMoscatoLover · 11/10/2023 18:58

theduchessofspork · 11/10/2023 18:51

Only thing I would say is that calorie counting (or any similar system like WW points) tends to make binging worse. There is good research on this, which is why NHS treatments for disordered eating don’t use calorie counting

I wonder if you would be better focusing on 3 healthy meals a day, and paying attention to portion sizes, eating protein and fibre with every meal and dropping most refined carbs and sugar (white bread cake, biscuits etc). Once you’ve had some treatment for the binge disorder, they can advise on loosing weight safely. (It will probably be around portion sizes).

The other thing that might be useful is to eat regular meals, and perhaps keep a diary where you record your feelings when you binge or overeat.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/support/healthy-living/healthy-eating/healthy-eating-toolkit/food-portions

BEAT is the charity for eating disorders and they have online support.

You also might find Ranjan Chatterjees Loose Weight Feel Great useful, it’s not a diet book but a guide to healthy eating, which takes into account that it’s harder for some people - he includes ways to manage stress which I’m guessing you need with two little kids.

Thanks for your comment. I plan to do exactly as @Dutch1e when they said, ‘If it helps at all, for the first couple of months I didn't change my eating habits. I just tracked my normal diet purely for the sake of information/data.

Right now, all I want to do is try my best to eat three meals a day (which is something I’ve struggled with for years) and track what I’ve eaten. My long term goal is to eat in a calorie deficit in order to help lose weight. I didn’t go into all of that in my OP because I couldn’t be bothered!

I know how binge eating impacts me and I won’t be restricting anything! I’m trying my best to eat full meals in order to binge less. I just wanted a way to track everything. Thank you for all the comments:) you’ve all been so helpful

OP posts:
mynameiscalypso · 11/10/2023 18:55

I absolutely echo what @theduchessofspork says. Tracking your meals is fine and part of treatment for BED. Calorie counting / dieting in the most traditional sense is not recommended. It might be okay in the short term but ultimately you have to accept that when you have an eating disorder some of the 'normal' rules about dieting don't really apply to you at least until you are well into established recovery.

theduchessofspork · 11/10/2023 18:53

PinkMoscatoLover · 11/10/2023 18:37

Thank you guys! So many helpful comments. I’ll certainly look into MyFitnessPal, it’s good to hear that these apps can remember the calories of a meal so you don’t have to enter it over and over again.

So with measuring food, how does it work out how many calories is within the grams that you use? I don’t quite get that bit! Also, what scales do people use?

@Hellinthekitchen @mynameiscalypso I find keeping a track of what I’m eating encourages me to actually eat proper meals instead of binging. Thank you though!

It’s not keeping a track of your eating that’s usually problematic for binge eaters, it’s restriction systems.

theduchessofspork · 11/10/2023 18:51

Only thing I would say is that calorie counting (or any similar system like WW points) tends to make binging worse. There is good research on this, which is why NHS treatments for disordered eating don’t use calorie counting

I wonder if you would be better focusing on 3 healthy meals a day, and paying attention to portion sizes, eating protein and fibre with every meal and dropping most refined carbs and sugar (white bread cake, biscuits etc). Once you’ve had some treatment for the binge disorder, they can advise on loosing weight safely. (It will probably be around portion sizes).

The other thing that might be useful is to eat regular meals, and perhaps keep a diary where you record your feelings when you binge or overeat.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/support/healthy-living/healthy-eating/healthy-eating-toolkit/food-portions

BEAT is the charity for eating disorders and they have online support.

You also might find Ranjan Chatterjees Loose Weight Feel Great useful, it’s not a diet book but a guide to healthy eating, which takes into account that it’s harder for some people - he includes ways to manage stress which I’m guessing you need with two little kids.

Food portions

What is the healthy amount of fruit and veg you need to eat to keep a balanced diet? Our portion guides are available to view online or download as a PDF.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/support/healthy-living/healthy-eating/healthy-eating-toolkit/food-portions

PaminaMozart · 11/10/2023 18:48

Tracking your calories is all very well, but I feel you should be equally if not more focused on eating healthily. This will benefit your children as well! And you will be more likely to keep the weight off rather than getting into a spiral of yo-yo dieting.

There are many books and online resources, but basically it boils down to:

  • drastically reducing UPF, sugar and refined carbs.
  • instead eat LOTS of vegetables, a moderate amount of lean carbs, plus small amounts of complex carbs, healthy fats and dairy.
  • for weight loss, try intermittent fasting.

Sugar is the worst and it is in so many foods - so read the labels (or even better, don't buy packaged foods at all). If you can wean yourself off sugar, everything else will be easier.

Have a look at Dr Becky Gillaspy and the Glucose Goddess on YouTube.

Dutch1e · 11/10/2023 18:47

I use Cronometer and a kitchen scale to get a good sense of what a portion size actually is, and (most importantly for me) to see what nutritional gaps I have.

If it helps at all, for the first couple of months I didn't change my eating habits. I just tracked my normal diet purely for the sake of information/data.

Then I made one small change (I think it was adding leafy greens to 2 meals a day). No other changes at all for 2 weeks.

Bit by bit I created new habits... but I was adamant that I didn't want to feel hungrier than a normal pre-meal hunger. My goal was to change my life-long habits and VERY slowly use up my excess fat, not just lose muscle mass and feel virtuous for it.

Now I still track my daily intake, and probably will for another year or so, but I'm good at eyeballing portion sizes now and don't need to weigh my food.

Normalsizedsalad · 11/10/2023 18:41

So with measuring food, how does it work out how many calories is within the grams that you use? I don’t quite get that bit!

Download it and see. It's probably better than if someone tries to explain on here because it can end up confusing 😁

SecondStarOnTheRight · 11/10/2023 18:40

Another vote here for MyFitnessPal. I've used it a few times now (failed previously but my own doing, just lost focus and went back to eating badly).

I've been using it again now for 3 months, starting weight just a few pound less than you, and have lost 2.5 stone so far with minimal effort.

Just make sure to change your weight through the goals/settings on the app rather than just adding it to the diary as this will adjust the calorie goal as you lose.

Have a look through the weight loss support section on here too, I've found even just reading peoples journeys helps me along. Particularly one thread of '10st plus to lose', there's posts on there daily.

Good luck! 🩷

PinkMoscatoLover · 11/10/2023 18:37

Thank you guys! So many helpful comments. I’ll certainly look into MyFitnessPal, it’s good to hear that these apps can remember the calories of a meal so you don’t have to enter it over and over again.

So with measuring food, how does it work out how many calories is within the grams that you use? I don’t quite get that bit! Also, what scales do people use?

@Hellinthekitchen @mynameiscalypso I find keeping a track of what I’m eating encourages me to actually eat proper meals instead of binging. Thank you though!

OP posts:
mynameiscalypso · 11/10/2023 18:34

Honestly, I would wait until you're much further into your treatment for BED before you start counting calories. The link between restriction and binging is very strong and you risk setting back any progress you've made. In time, your treatment team can support you with healthy weight loss strategies.

ScottishBeth · 11/10/2023 18:30

I recommend this free programme. https://www.nobsweightloss.com/

I have found it relatively straightforward to lose weight without counting anything.

One other thing I do is when I'm hungry choose a healthy but high protein snack - Greek yoghurt with fruit or peanut butter on toast, for example. That fills me up and then the temptation to eat loads of junk is way less. I still do eat cake type things, but I plan it as a treat.

Home - No BS Weightloss

Home

https://www.nobsweightloss.com

Mrsttcno1 · 11/10/2023 18:25

I agree with other posters, My Fitness Pal is what I use to track my calories HOWEVER I would not recommend asking My Fitness Pal to calculate your recommended daily calories. It is notorious for low balling it, as an example I’m a size 8-10 and if I put my info in with a goal as weight loss it recommends 1200 cals a day- literally a toddlers calories!

Use My Fitness Pal to track your calories and weigh/scan everything you put in your mouth. To get your daily calories, search on google TDEE Calculator, it’s free to use, pop your info in. This will calculate your basal metabolic rate (basically how many calories you burn just to exist), and you can work out a deficit from there, then just pop that amount into your My Fitness Pal as your goal calories. You will probably find that even on a small deficit, at first you will lose a lot of weight quickly. As well as diet, try and just get 10k steps a day- if you can’t get outside to do this there’s loads of Youtube videos now to get your 10k steps in! X

Yocal · 11/10/2023 18:23

Another one who has used my fitness pal and like it.

If anyone fatshames you ignore them. Those people don't deserve your attention. You sound like you are ready to tackle your weight so that will be great for your health. Sorry to hear you have a binge eating disorder. I'm sure that is hard to live with and I hope you overcome it.

I also follow Sean Casey on Facebook. He has a healthy attitude to weightloss and is really good at pitching his advice so you don't go mental dieting! He lives in the real world and is quite funny as well.

GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 11/10/2023 18:22

I use Noom (the free version) it works well for me.

With regards to calorie counting home cooked meals, last night I made pumpkin soup, the ingredients were:

15g of butter
15g plain flour
1/3 of an onion (I didn’t weigh it but you could)
2 carrots (again not weighed)
1 1/2 medium size potatoes
1 small pumpkin approx. 200g
4 portions worth of veg stock

This made 3 portions so dividing each ingredient by 3 (if its a weird figure I round up as its better to slightly over calculate) this mean’t each portion was:

5g butter
5g plain flour
1/4 of an onion

3/4 of a carrot
1/2 a medium potato
67g of pumpkin
1 1/2 portions of veg stock

I then put this in my app and it calculates how many calories for each ingredient and then gives you a total amount of calories (289) you can then save that as a specific dish so next time you can just go into your dishes and add it as a meal. Obviously if you weigh each ingredient exactly it’ll be more accurate.

If you’re not sure on things read the bags, for example if the flour says its 125 calories per 100g and you want to use 60g, divided 125 by 10 to give you the number of calories in 10g then x by 6 to get the total calories in 60g then divide that by the number of portions made.

I also had crusty bread, the app said 3 slices of generic crusty bread was just under 500cal but I read the bread packet and it was 273cal per half a stick so I ate half and manually inputted the calories so its sometimes worth checking if unsure. Its not hard to do once you get the hang of it.

Normalsizedsalad · 11/10/2023 18:14

Hellinthekitchen · 11/10/2023 18:04

Do you think that tracking, weighing and measuring is sensible if you have binge eating disorder? I would be concerned that this would trigger you to binge more. And there is lots of research out there which suggests the same.

In your position, I would focus on eating three meals and no snacking.

Didn't think of that

Welshwonder92 · 11/10/2023 18:08

I recommend following Richie Howey and TeamRH on Facebook. They will work out calories for you and you won’t feel restricted either

Normalsizedsalad · 11/10/2023 18:06

Just always double check if the scan codes logs as what you scanned. Some codes were obviously used previously or something so my veg logged as meat😂