Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Those with high pressure jobs, what was worse, maternity leave or the job?

284 replies

Desupi · 11/10/2023 14:05

First time mum here due in March and very clueless! I work as an Executive Assistant to a high profile indivudual. Don't get me wrong I do like my job most of the time, but it can be highly stressful too.

I keep seeing all these posts on social media about how being a new mum is depressing, exhausting, you lose your identity etc, and it is making the whole thing quite daunting. However, I will have 9 months off work and think to myself how nice it will be to spend time with my baby and not have to think about work at all.

I appreciate that as I have never had children before I likely have no idea what is coming. But i guess what I am looking for is for some opinions on how you found maternity leave?

OP posts:
DepartmentOfMysteries · 15/10/2023 04:24

Maternity leave was so much easier and less stressful. It was such a gift to be able to take a full year. It felt like a holiday, and I had an exclusively breastfed non-sleeper for one of mine. However my husband was very supportive and appreciated the amount of work that goes into looking after the baby, which makes a big difference. I think after a stressful job, looking after a baby is tiring and frustrating, but it isn't stressful or difficult. Good luck!

DottyLottieLou · 15/10/2023 02:21

Maternity leave was so good, I did it for 10 years and they were the best years. Now about to retire and that will be even better.

Boredandbitter · 15/10/2023 00:53

Loved being at home, never been fond of my office job but Jesus, did I miss the company. All of a sudden, I was the entertainer and organiser of fun. I much prefer being entertained by others. I really missed adult company until I worked out Mother and Baby Groups. They kept me sane.

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 15/10/2023 00:38

Currently on mat leave with twins, taking a year off from a high pressured role, was nervous prior to going off as I like to keep stimulated and busy and haven’t previously had much interest in babies and related activities.

However, I’m loving it! I don’t think about work at all, enjoy every day with my babies (even the days we stay inside in our pj’s all day) and generally just feel happy.

I know this sadly isn’t the case for everyone, but don’t be put off by the negative stories you hear (usually much more often than the positive ones), it could be the best 9 months of your life so go into it open minded.

SouthLondonMum22 · 13/10/2023 14:39

Comedycook · 13/10/2023 08:43

I'm not talking about working. Lots of parents work...they have to. What I'm talking about is those who actively dislike being with their baby and prefer being at work. Just don't bother having one... surely that's easier?

Has anyone actually said that though? Not that I saw. They were talking about maternity leave which obviously means not working.

Some people just prefer the balance of working and being with their baby so may find maternity leave to be difficult because the balance isn't there.

SouthLondonMum22 · 13/10/2023 14:32

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 10:31

I can't even understand why the ONLY mental stimulation people can find is at work.

By all means, get a career you love, do a job you really thrive in. I loved working in a high pressure, very busy role, and frankly more than well paid. I can't personally imagine being in a boring role where you start looking at the clock at 9:05am and you have to invent something to do.

It's only a job however, it takes away any time you need for the other interesting and stimulating things you want to do. Job title mean nothing, they don't define you.

Some you can't do with a baby, but many you can, without mentioning that it's ok to enjoy spending some time with your baby

My career is absolutely a big part of my identity, I worked incredibly hard in a male dominated industry to get to where I am today.

I have hobbies and other things that I enjoy of course but nothing has ever come close to the mental stimulation that I get from work,

LemonPeonies · 13/10/2023 11:47

@Frontgarden I disagree with what you said too, though of course it's only your opinion. I'm a ward sister, busy heavy frailty ward overseeing care of 36 frail elderly unwell patients. I love my job, it's challenging but rewarding. I would call it a professional role and definitely not shit. I much more enjoyed taking a year off to cuddle, feed etc my baby. I took him out every day and found it easy and enjoyable, much easier than work 😆

SacAMain · 13/10/2023 10:31

I can't even understand why the ONLY mental stimulation people can find is at work.

By all means, get a career you love, do a job you really thrive in. I loved working in a high pressure, very busy role, and frankly more than well paid. I can't personally imagine being in a boring role where you start looking at the clock at 9:05am and you have to invent something to do.

It's only a job however, it takes away any time you need for the other interesting and stimulating things you want to do. Job title mean nothing, they don't define you.

Some you can't do with a baby, but many you can, without mentioning that it's ok to enjoy spending some time with your baby

Comedycook · 13/10/2023 08:43

HoppingPavlova · 13/10/2023 08:40

@Comedycook because you can do both? It’s not an either/or. You can both work and look after your children. I did, DH and I worked opposite days/shifts so I was either working or looking after kids, and so was he. No family support as no one near but we made it work as it was just possible for us to swing it that way with our jobs (albeit serious lack of sleep for several years while tag teaming in/out door🤣). What would it have mattered if you replaced one of us with nursery though, nothing. We only did it that way because we could and it was a real opportunity to get ahead $$ wise.

Your philosophy of having to pick your favourite out of work/kids and only do that is …… odd.

I'm not talking about working. Lots of parents work...they have to. What I'm talking about is those who actively dislike being with their baby and prefer being at work. Just don't bother having one... surely that's easier?

HoppingPavlova · 13/10/2023 08:40

@Comedycook because you can do both? It’s not an either/or. You can both work and look after your children. I did, DH and I worked opposite days/shifts so I was either working or looking after kids, and so was he. No family support as no one near but we made it work as it was just possible for us to swing it that way with our jobs (albeit serious lack of sleep for several years while tag teaming in/out door🤣). What would it have mattered if you replaced one of us with nursery though, nothing. We only did it that way because we could and it was a real opportunity to get ahead $$ wise.

Your philosophy of having to pick your favourite out of work/kids and only do that is …… odd.

Comedycook · 13/10/2023 08:24

I find it really perplexing that people can't find interesting things to do or be mentally challenged except in the context of work. If someone does prefer being at work to being with their baby then I'd ask genuinely why they bothered to have a child. It's not compulsory. There's loads of ways to stop getting pregnant. If your previous life was so much better then honestly why bother...just carry on doing the things you enjoy without the burden of being a parent. That's an absolutely valid choice

Flintwhistle · 13/10/2023 08:24

This thread has been so interesting and really shows how different people view life. But also I think, how older posters (me included) forget how different life is now than 35+ years ago.
I remember feeling lucky when I wasn't working and feeling that my then DH had the short straw having to work. I didn't work till mine were older and realised then how peaceful it was working with adults and having a coffee in peace.
And yet, so many of my pre baby friends had babies around the same time as me, and so we had friendship and support from people who we already knew, and had things in common with, not just babies. So it was better for our mental health.
In my case I had plenty of support from my mum too, though looking back I realise that I was one of not very many who had that.

It does seem more difficult now with people often further from their families, maternity leaves often not coinciding with those of friends etc so loneliness is a huge problem and really ramps up stress for women on maternity leave.

Finances obviously play a big part too. One baby, local family and friends, a car and a few quid to spare makes it easier to enjoy maternity leave than many other less affluent scenarios. And of course a partner who pulls their weight. And those are just things I'm thinking of off the top of my head.

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/10/2023 20:16

Gopred1 · 12/10/2023 17:23

@SouthLondonMum22

Theres a vast difference in saying you felt it was boring, monotonous etc which, at times is to be expected and I get that.
However, my comment was a reaction to people saying they hated being with their babies! To me that’s such an extreme thing to say. The emphasis on creating a bond and promoting development and healthy attachment in the early years is well documented, so those who state they hated being with their babies I’d be inclined to think they were missing the opportunity to do that which is a shame.

Most comments I saw were more about boredom and hating it due to that but it's possible I missed some.

Hate is a strong word and people do throw it about when I'm not so sure they actually mean more than dislike so I generally don't take it literally.

It also isn't about the baby or it wasn't for me anyway, it was about me and needing the mental stimulation I get from work with deadlines, pressure etc that makes me thrive. It's possible to have a bond with your baby, love your baby and enjoy spending time with your baby but just not 24/7.

Spinner001 · 12/10/2023 20:12

This completely.

I work for an investment bank in finance.

I also absolutely loved maternity leave.

I’m not sure these things should be mutually exclusive!

And whilst I love my work and am back full time, my family is my world and i find it puts into perspective how unimportant most of the shit at work actually is.

WorkSmarter · 12/10/2023 19:30

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/10/2023 14:19

It depends on so many variables;

Your baby, your personality, your job, how much support you have from your partner and family, what your community is like etc.

There are people who loathe looking after small kids and people who love it. Some people are just desperate to stop work, others find it's what gets them out of bed in the morning.

Having a new baby is relentless: much harder than it looks from the outside. You may thrive on it, you may not and its impossible to know before it happens.

Just keep your options open for now so you have a choice when the time comes.

Great advice!
Personally I found it very difficult but had been made redundant from my job of dealing with hundreds of people some days at events and lots of travel and variety.
I took a huge blow to my social life, intellectual challenge and status and would def have gone back to work if i could but took years to find another job. In the end I started my own business which turned out even better than imagined.
Being at home with no support from husband or family sucks and is never ending so get some friends in the same boat, make sure you get regular breaks and your partner does his share so he knows how hard it is.
Try to enjoy the time off as you can never get it back x

Didimum · 12/10/2023 17:31

Gopred1 · 12/10/2023 17:23

@SouthLondonMum22

Theres a vast difference in saying you felt it was boring, monotonous etc which, at times is to be expected and I get that.
However, my comment was a reaction to people saying they hated being with their babies! To me that’s such an extreme thing to say. The emphasis on creating a bond and promoting development and healthy attachment in the early years is well documented, so those who state they hated being with their babies I’d be inclined to think they were missing the opportunity to do that which is a shame.

Perhaps many of them were suffering from unchecked PPA or PPD, which is sadly common.

Gopred1 · 12/10/2023 17:23

@SouthLondonMum22

Theres a vast difference in saying you felt it was boring, monotonous etc which, at times is to be expected and I get that.
However, my comment was a reaction to people saying they hated being with their babies! To me that’s such an extreme thing to say. The emphasis on creating a bond and promoting development and healthy attachment in the early years is well documented, so those who state they hated being with their babies I’d be inclined to think they were missing the opportunity to do that which is a shame.

OneNameTwoNameThreeName · 12/10/2023 15:18

And we were out and about from day 3 despite emergency section. No house arrest…

OneNameTwoNameThreeName · 12/10/2023 15:16

My job 100%

Maternity leave has been nothing but amazing. Me and my little buddy spend our days however we want and I have never been so relaxed and happy in my whole life.

Boska23 · 12/10/2023 15:14

SacAMain · 12/10/2023 09:53

I still can't understand why some posters translate maternity leave with "being stuck at home all day with a baby" or sticking to baby groups if you hate them?

I agree about the first weeks of recovery, but maternity leave is what you make of it. Being miserable and playing mummy martyr is not benefiting your child in any way. That time is crucial to bond, but how is forcing yourself to be stuck indoors, doing nothing, be bored out of your mind helping you to bond?

No one is telling you to go clubbing in Ibiza all night when on maternity leave, but surely there's a middle ground.

It's so strange to see it as a punishment and being put on house arrest. It's only boring if you make it boring.

I'm one of those who couldn't wait to go back to work. I went through a tremendous infertility battle to become mother and I adore the ground my child walks on but I absolutely did not enjoy maternity leave and was bored out of my mind. However, I had a covid baby - by the time we were ready to go out and about - we went into the first lockdown. To be completely honest - I don't think I'd enjoy it even if it was a bog standard maternity leave without these complicating factors - but lockdown on top of sleep deprivation (that prevented me from enjoying activities I'd normally enjoy - reading etc.) made my maternity leave completely and utterly boring. My husband took shared leave when I got back to work and he found it way more pleasant so I am sure this is down to personalities as well.

I think that you can't know how you'll react to it. And I believe it is all down to personality and circumstances - I don't think women who enjoy maternity leave are not amazing professionals and I don't think women who did not are not fit to be mothers.

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/10/2023 14:53

SacAMain · 12/10/2023 09:53

I still can't understand why some posters translate maternity leave with "being stuck at home all day with a baby" or sticking to baby groups if you hate them?

I agree about the first weeks of recovery, but maternity leave is what you make of it. Being miserable and playing mummy martyr is not benefiting your child in any way. That time is crucial to bond, but how is forcing yourself to be stuck indoors, doing nothing, be bored out of your mind helping you to bond?

No one is telling you to go clubbing in Ibiza all night when on maternity leave, but surely there's a middle ground.

It's so strange to see it as a punishment and being put on house arrest. It's only boring if you make it boring.

Personally, I wasn't stuck at home all day and I avoided baby groups but I was still bored out of my mind and didn't enjoy it.

I just didn't find doing nothing but that fulfilling despite getting out and about, I needed the stimulation that I only get at work so I went back early although I had a feeling that I wouldn't want a long maternity leave even when I was pregnant.

Macaroni46 · 12/10/2023 13:29

Noticing a bit of a pattern here - lots of teachers saying they preferred Mat Leave, myself included. Maybe it depends on the pressure and pace of the job? For me, leaving my babies in order to look after other people's children really hurt, especially at morning drop off and home time when I saw my little class running out to their waiting mummies (I know I'm seeing this with rose tinted glasses but that's my abiding memory.) I was able to reduce my working days to 4 days which made a big difference.

SacAMain · 12/10/2023 09:53

I still can't understand why some posters translate maternity leave with "being stuck at home all day with a baby" or sticking to baby groups if you hate them?

I agree about the first weeks of recovery, but maternity leave is what you make of it. Being miserable and playing mummy martyr is not benefiting your child in any way. That time is crucial to bond, but how is forcing yourself to be stuck indoors, doing nothing, be bored out of your mind helping you to bond?

No one is telling you to go clubbing in Ibiza all night when on maternity leave, but surely there's a middle ground.

It's so strange to see it as a punishment and being put on house arrest. It's only boring if you make it boring.

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/10/2023 07:54

Gopred1 · 12/10/2023 07:35

@Stompythedinosaur no I did not have an easy time. Actually I was in a DV relationship and fled with my baby.
Obvious factors such MMH, breastfeeding problems, sleep deprivation etc contribute to mothers feeling stressed and overwhelmed during the first year and of course beyond. However, my point was aimed at those saying they hated being at home and couldn’t wait to return to work. I can’t relate. Everyone has their own journey with parenthood, and I was simply replying to the original question posed…

Saying you can't relate is very different to questioning why mothers who didn't enjoy a very short stage of their child's life had children at all, especially as it is impossible for anyone to know how they will feel or what kind of baby they will have.

Gopred1 · 12/10/2023 07:35

@Stompythedinosaur no I did not have an easy time. Actually I was in a DV relationship and fled with my baby.
Obvious factors such MMH, breastfeeding problems, sleep deprivation etc contribute to mothers feeling stressed and overwhelmed during the first year and of course beyond. However, my point was aimed at those saying they hated being at home and couldn’t wait to return to work. I can’t relate. Everyone has their own journey with parenthood, and I was simply replying to the original question posed…