Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think having babies/parenting young kids can become an ‘addiction’

210 replies

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 13:07

I go to a lot of toddler groups on my days off and have met all types of families.

One family size that really intrigues me especially since becoming a mother is larger families (5+). Although rarer I have met a few mums who have 7+ children. I myself am 1 of 5 and my DP is 1 of 6!

Before having dc I would be very confused (judgy perhaps?) as to why on earth anyone needs/wants 5+ kids outside of religious reasons. Then being pregnant I was even more surprised women would choose to go through it so many times when it takes such a toll on our bodies.

However since having my DC and making mum friends I think I understand it, but maybe not?

Is it sort of an ‘addiction’ to the lifestyle?

Having a child, especially the baby/toddler years is so all encompassing that your identity can quite easily become being a ‘mum’ to young ones (or dad). Generally speaking of course, friendships become ‘mum friends’, weekdays become toddler groups, lunches and coffee mornings. Weekends and holidays are based around children activities. Conversations become child/pregnancy focused. It can easily become a ‘way of life’ rather than just a life stage.

I’ve observed you can also ‘opt out’ of other parts of life by being a parent to young dc. As in, not attend social things for childcare reasons. Not have a career, work full time or sometimes even at all very justifiably. You can really hide/escape a lot of things by having dependents and if you struggled with life before dc that you no longer have to deal with by having them, that must also keep the allure going to have more?

I have surprised myself by how much I love being a parent and am pregnant with my second dc. However after this there will be no more. Financially, mentally and practically it wouldn’t be ideal to have anymore. However if money and health wasn’t an obstacle then I can imagine how easy it would be to continue going.

My mum went through a depression when we all started leaving the home despite her saying she couldn’t wait for no more school runs and freedom etc. She now says being a mum was her ‘calling’ and her happiest years and would have had more of given the opportunity.
My MIL also said she would have had more kids if it wasn’t for FIL getting the snip. She already had 6 and wasn’t wealthy at all!

I can’t see people having so many kids because they are addicted to ‘babies’ because they don’t stay babies for long at all. So I can only conclude it’s the lifestyle of child rearing?

All the large families I’ve met are different in regards to class, jobs, money etc. so I don’t think it’s related to that in regards to why some are drawn to having more and more.

Anyone shed any lights or thoughts as to other reasons?

If you do have a big family, what are your reasons (especially if your a mum)

OP posts:
CharlotteBog · 11/10/2023 15:32

Coughingdodger · 11/10/2023 14:43

Why so?
The poster here with 7 children has just illustrated that very phenomenon.

No, what I mean is that if she based her findings on what she found through her work, she would not have come across the families with many children who were not known to social services.

Or maybe I have misunderstood what you're saying.

Leopardpj · 11/10/2023 15:31

OP this is an interesting essay on what you're talking about. Some of it a bit specifically American but a couple of points made me cringe with recognition about my own choice to have another baby! I think the psychology of these sorts of choices is fascinating, as is the way these choice shape the way we see ourselves and other women (as illustrated by this thread!)
Why Having a Third Baby Felt Like the Safe Choice - The New York Times (nytimes.com)

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 11/10/2023 15:28

I think you might just as well ponder if someone who only has a few children or none and spends all their focus on work, using it as the reason not to see people or do much is addicted to work. Why having over 5 children suddenly means you’re opting out of life is beyond me. It says rather more about your own attitudes to women/parenting than provides any clarity or insight into why people choose the paths they do.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/10/2023 15:28

@Sugarcoatedcandycane

I think you've nailed it. It's basically a get-out-of-jail-free card to opt out of being an adult. Not having to face any real adult responsibilities.

Trouble is there's only so long you can put that off. Menopause will knock that on the head.

I suppose historically many if not most women died before getting to menopause so it didn't really matter. Nowadays if you've spent the first 20 years of your adult life popping out kids the latter part of your life is going to hit you like a runaway train. Not a sensible idea at all.

Catza · 11/10/2023 15:24

Most of my friends stopped at one or two and when I speak to them, they all hated being stuck at home and their brains taken over by child stuff. They all love their kids but couldn't wait to get out to work again and have a bit more of a personal life, adult conversations and career growth. I expect that mothers of large families indeed have an entirely different wiring.

Leopardpj · 11/10/2023 15:20

Following with interest as I'm about to have my third child and I'm now wondering if I'm one of the women you're talking about! I do sometimes ask myself whether my decision to have another baby (when it means going back to the baby days even though two older DDs will be at school which many think is insane) is partly because I don't want to leave my identity as a mother of young children behind. Or don't know how to.
I do have a pretty successful career (although I only work part time while they're at school/ nursery on some days of the week) so it's not a displacement activity for me. But I do really value the social contact and camaraderie of having babies/ toddlers/ pre-schoolers. There is something quite comforting and addictive about the sugary dullness of it all, the shared humour, the freedom to shape your days as you please. I do also think there's something in the relief of being able to 'opt out' of the parts of your old life you secretly found stressful/ difficult. I definitely think you're onto something!

Nokoolaidherethanks · 11/10/2023 15:19

I know a lady who was definitely addicted to the baby years. She has 7 kids and doted on them as babies/preschoolers. Now her youngest two are 12 and 13 she seems to show very little interest in them (separated from dad and kids live with him) so I conclude she just liked babies and kept wanted a new one.

Bbq1 · 11/10/2023 15:16

I know a mum who has 8 children. Kids are aged between 3 and 18. For mum it really is a way of life as she started at 18. Tbh I'm surprised she's not pregnant again as youngest is 3. I do wonder what she will do as they all fly the nest. Mind you, prob be grandkids by then though.

thecatsthecats · 11/10/2023 15:16

Webex · 11/10/2023 14:59

I was unprepared for the level of attention and approval you get, and the year of maternity leave was a revelation

This resonates for me - I also found being visibly pregnant meant people were far nice to me than they every had been before. Just random people out and about were kinder and more friendly.

Interesting!

I have found it nice to have general friendliness from strangers like you describe, but have found some of the squickier, gooier reactions from family have frankly got on my tits.

I'm sarky, academic and cynical. So when MIL hears about me tidying my house, tilts her head to one side, beams and says to me and my sister in law, "Awwww, you know what that means? She's nesting." Followed by cooing from them both... ugh.

  1. my house was a shit tip, you didn't need a nesting instinct to see that.
  2. who is she, the cat's mother?
  3. have you both entirely forgotten who I am, or do you think that just because I'm gestating I've had a personality transplant?

To me the attention is quite oppressive and oddly disrespectful. But I can see how other, more normal people might thrive on it.

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 15:15

So many interesting replies. Thank you for indulging my curiosity!

To the PP asking why I think it’s ‘opt out’ (forgot your username). What I mean by that is exactly what @Persiana said in her post.

You can ’opt out’ of the working world very justifiably. You can ‘opt out’ of adult social occasions and/or cancel last minute citing childcare/sickness etc. You can ‘opt out’ of hobbies, friendships, dating (if you’re single) and to an extent financial independence. You can just throw yourself into the world babies and small kids very justifiably at the expense of everything else.

When me and my siblings grew up and left home my mum had a deep depression. She actually realised she couldn’t hold down a job. Despite having degree and being highly intelligent she struggled massively with it. She never realised this because she would always leave jobs for ‘childcare’ reasons not realising that childcare was masking the issue. She also struggles to make and maintain friendships. Again she was so busy with us kids that she didn’t think she had time/energy for friends outside kids groups/activities.

Basically when we left she realised that having kids every 5/7 years was masking a wide variety of issues. She had no excuses anymore to leave a job so had to face up to the fact she had work anxiety. She had no excuses to not make/see friends so had to face up to the fact she struggles with adult relationships. She couldn’t ‘opt out’ anymore.

She’s come out the other side now and has made a life for herself but she still says she would go back if she could!

I do wonder if there is this similar element on other larger families or if that’s just her own very individual case.

OP posts:
SaulHudsonDavidJones · 11/10/2023 15:13

I completely get what you're saying and agree, but for me it's the opposite. I find parenthood more difficult than work and although I love my children dearly I am more interested in having my family (as in, the family unit) than the baby/early years. I'd struggle to do it again from the beginning.

Sofarlatedo · 11/10/2023 15:11

@herewegoroundthebastardbush you’ve put into words perfectly how I felt/feel about having children - the love I felt was overwhelming. I stopped at 2 but could easily have had a 3rd if circumstances had been right - as it happened my spouse left when they were 7 and 4, a big part of this I think was feeling excluded as I felt so “complete” finally having my babies to love and care for.

Ohhmydays · 11/10/2023 15:10

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 11/10/2023 13:51

Also yes my body is wrecked. Don't know how women recover between pregnancies when they keep having more. My dental health alone after years of pregnancies and breastfeeding... and my joints oh god my joints. Couldn't really do pregnancy a third time, God knows how women manage 5 times!

It was number 3 that done me in(not planned conceived a few days after my period)Blew up like a balloon, pretty much lost all the enamel off my teeth now and the back and pelvic ache that started in early pregnancy has continued since. youngest us 1 1/2. I love my kids and kids in general but i also love my days at work. Been cooped up with young kids 24/7 is very mentally draining. I take my hat off to people with bigger families. I certainly couldn't do it. I know 1 woman who has 5 and still wouldn’t say no to another

Mudflaps · 11/10/2023 15:08

Sorry, I didn't mention it, they live in Ireland so Child Benefit for each child I think and the majority of the rent paid through assistance. There is also a fuel allowance towards heating but yes, I believe he must have an unofficial job to afford the life they have, they've a people carrier plus a van for days out but at least this means my friend gets to go with them, she went on the recent holiday and seemed to enjoy it. I know it shouldn't bug me but my dh and I couldn't afford a holiday despite him working (I'm retired because of ill health but have a relatively decent pension) due to mortgage increases, c.o.l. etc and yet they spent a few days in Disney and then on to the Alps to stay in a ski village (out of season I know but it looked lovely). The husband/father told me it was an educational tour not a holiday (previously they spent six months in a motor home touring Europe but only had four children then). I wonder will things change much for them as the children all become adults? I'd be concerned mainly for their mother, she has done nothing outside of the family since her late teens, she's quiet and shy and I think has a tendency to hide behind being a mother. I have one adult dc, would have loved to have another but couldn't, I do feel my dc misses out by not having a sibling but more so as an adult than as a child. I've a brother and while we might not see each other often due to distance we both know that we'd drop everything to help each other.

Ilovecakey · 11/10/2023 15:01

I have 5 children, had 3 then got pregnant accidently and last pregnancy was twins

Webex · 11/10/2023 14:59

I was unprepared for the level of attention and approval you get, and the year of maternity leave was a revelation

This resonates for me - I also found being visibly pregnant meant people were far nice to me than they every had been before. Just random people out and about were kinder and more friendly.

User37652 · 11/10/2023 14:54

I could see getting addicted to having a newborn - when I was pregnant I felt so special, at first it was having a secret that only DH and I knew about, then having everyone treat you well for it, getting excited about the birth, then the falling in love and newborn snuggles. But then comes all the rest of the hard work.

Persiana · 11/10/2023 14:52

I think you're spot on. Friends with larger families seem to take comfort from the chaos and theres a strong vibe of there's so much going on, if everyone is fed at the end of the day that's good enough. A kind of everything else is optional and I can opt out, be a bit flakey, be deserving of a large glass of wine at the end of the day etc. I'm genuinely not criticizing, but those are standard commonalities in those families and they definitely love love love the baby stage and dealing with little ones. It will be interesting to see if it carries on when they are teens etc!

IllBeHonesthere · 11/10/2023 14:52

My Dr did tell me though my HG may be in my mind and was probably my ASD causing sensory issues with regular morning sickness so that I was feeling worse but they diagnosed HG as I was dehydrated and lost weight (so not sure if it really was HG?) but he thought it was more my perception and sensory issues

IllBeHonesthere · 11/10/2023 14:50

I find the pregnancy stage awful as get HG, the baby stage is ok, the bit I find ‘addictive’ is as they get older and develop and grow and now I have 2 through to adulthood the sense of accomplishment and how the relationship develops and changes so I almost find the later stages of parenting the more addictive part ?

TheWayTheLightFalls · 11/10/2023 14:49

I sort of get it - I have three and I can parent to the age of my eldest with my eyes shut. I can’t bear the sleeplessness but other than that I like young children and I loved the camaraderie of mat leave. I’m too keen to get on with my career/have my own body back but if I didn’t then I can see how I’d consider another.

funinthesun19 · 11/10/2023 14:47

I have 4 children, and I have to say I loved the pregnancy and baby stage.

My youngest is 5 and life is moving on from all that now. Life is still exciting and full. I absolutely loved being pregnant and having babies though, and if I was a multi millionaire I would go and have another 4.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 11/10/2023 14:47

I can absolutely see why that baby stage is so appealing - I was unprepared for the level of attention and approval you get, and the year of maternity leave was a revelation. Having worked solidly for 15 years (to no particular acclaim) it was odd to get so much affirmation for strolling around Sainsbury's and then going to the park. If I had a low paid and unrewarding job, I wouldn't have hurried back.

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 11/10/2023 14:46

I’m not sure I’d describe it as an “addition”.
I do think some people enjoy or see value in the role of being a parent and choose to continue that role, I also think there are probably complex other reasons (cultural, religious, emotional) that people have high numbers of children.

It’s interesting you question why people have 4/5+. Why not questions why people have any or more than 1? Surely similar arguments could be used again having 2/3 kids too. Why have 3 when you could just have stopped at 1?

IllBeHonesthere · 11/10/2023 14:45

@foxblue I absolutely identify with that - especially the part about having something to talk about with others