Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think having babies/parenting young kids can become an ‘addiction’

210 replies

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 13:07

I go to a lot of toddler groups on my days off and have met all types of families.

One family size that really intrigues me especially since becoming a mother is larger families (5+). Although rarer I have met a few mums who have 7+ children. I myself am 1 of 5 and my DP is 1 of 6!

Before having dc I would be very confused (judgy perhaps?) as to why on earth anyone needs/wants 5+ kids outside of religious reasons. Then being pregnant I was even more surprised women would choose to go through it so many times when it takes such a toll on our bodies.

However since having my DC and making mum friends I think I understand it, but maybe not?

Is it sort of an ‘addiction’ to the lifestyle?

Having a child, especially the baby/toddler years is so all encompassing that your identity can quite easily become being a ‘mum’ to young ones (or dad). Generally speaking of course, friendships become ‘mum friends’, weekdays become toddler groups, lunches and coffee mornings. Weekends and holidays are based around children activities. Conversations become child/pregnancy focused. It can easily become a ‘way of life’ rather than just a life stage.

I’ve observed you can also ‘opt out’ of other parts of life by being a parent to young dc. As in, not attend social things for childcare reasons. Not have a career, work full time or sometimes even at all very justifiably. You can really hide/escape a lot of things by having dependents and if you struggled with life before dc that you no longer have to deal with by having them, that must also keep the allure going to have more?

I have surprised myself by how much I love being a parent and am pregnant with my second dc. However after this there will be no more. Financially, mentally and practically it wouldn’t be ideal to have anymore. However if money and health wasn’t an obstacle then I can imagine how easy it would be to continue going.

My mum went through a depression when we all started leaving the home despite her saying she couldn’t wait for no more school runs and freedom etc. She now says being a mum was her ‘calling’ and her happiest years and would have had more of given the opportunity.
My MIL also said she would have had more kids if it wasn’t for FIL getting the snip. She already had 6 and wasn’t wealthy at all!

I can’t see people having so many kids because they are addicted to ‘babies’ because they don’t stay babies for long at all. So I can only conclude it’s the lifestyle of child rearing?

All the large families I’ve met are different in regards to class, jobs, money etc. so I don’t think it’s related to that in regards to why some are drawn to having more and more.

Anyone shed any lights or thoughts as to other reasons?

If you do have a big family, what are your reasons (especially if your a mum)

OP posts:
VikingLady · 11/10/2023 20:50

Oh, and most of us had careers pre kids. I owned and ran my own business and have postgraduate qualifications, others travelled for work, ran organisations etc. This just happens to be the lifestyle we discovered we liked best.

VikingLady · 11/10/2023 20:45

I stopped at two, but I wanted (and still want but can't afford) six. I home educate my two, my life is basically about my family, and I don't see why that is necessarily a bad thing. As long as I don't pressure the kids to provide emotionally for me, why shouldn't i be happy in my family? What's wrong with that?

I know several people with four or five children, only one for religious reasons. Most with the same spouse. And the vast majority are home educators, so most of their lives/identities are tied up in their families too. So? If everyone is happy, and the kids grow up functional and happy, what's so wrong with that? Most of them go into volunteer work as their kids get older, so empty nest syndrome is less of an issue for our bunch.

Not everyone is interested in a career. I get bored with jobs, any job, very quickly- but I don't get bored of my family.

Overloadimplode · 11/10/2023 20:38

I absolutely loved the baby and toddler years. I wanted to do it over and over again. I loved being with small kids, socialising with new people at baby and toddler groups, being off work, having time to myself to go outside, discover new places.
I did enjoy my identity as a mum to small kids. I loved feeling busy and purposeful with tasks that were easy to me, like housework.
In comparison, I hate going out to work every day, getting up early, answering to other people and having no time.
I understand it can be addictive.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 20:36

@Zzizzisnotzeproblem I think childcare would be the main career inhibiting factor! I don't think 6 dc is that large though, the "addicted" people usually have 8+.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 20:33

ClassicStripe · 11/10/2023 18:37

I love love love having a baby in the house. Love pushing a pram. Love all their firsts. Love the smell of them. Love baby clubs. I would have a million if I could. Just an endless cycle of first years.

What about when they aren't babies any more? Do you still love them then? I know one woman (who is lovely BTW, but I suspect has LD) who is in her late 50s now and still loves babies, but it seems once her dc got past about 2 she really couldn't relate to them at all.

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 11/10/2023 20:27

I don’t feel personally attacked because frankly none of the stereotypes particularly apply to me. There are tons of larger families on MN. There are tons in the world. You asked if people felt it was an addiction. I don’t think so and neither did the other mums of larger families. You seemed to be suggesting you could understand wanting to stay having coffee mornings and playgroups because you enjoy that stage. That wasn’t a driver for me and I’m not sure why you couldn’t have a less work focused lifestyle without babies?
Anyway, I sincerely doubt if the few families I know that that was the reason. I think they like having more children. I personally would have had another but it wasn’t sensible.

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 20:03

@Zzizzisnotzeproblem its a discussion about why people have larger families. There are loads of discussions about being ‘one and done’ and whether or not ‘to go for a third’.

You get people from both arguments on those threads too.

I get that you have 5 kids so may feel ‘attacked’ by this thread but you’re not. Other mums of multiples have commented with their reasonings and love of having a big family.

Like I said, I love being a mum, enjoy the lifestyle and if I was able too, that would be my reason for having many kids if I could.

OP posts:
Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 11/10/2023 19:59

The whole premise that you would only have a large family if you were “addicted” to either babies or “the lifestyle” is derogatory. The endless and frankly odd insistence that you must have some sort of deficit or psychological problem to want more than two children on this thread. Like a previous poster I am not particularly religious, am educated to degree level as is my dh, didn’t have my children “young”, aren’t only interested in babies, and I don’t neglect my children or any of the other tosh. Yes I would have more money if I had fewer dependents but presumably that’s the same for everyone.

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 19:50

@Sumtimesiamgreen huh? Where have I said anything derogatory? I’m actually saying I understand and that if I had enough money and health id probably do it too! I don’t get where you’re coming from?

OP posts:
Sumtimesiamgreen · 11/10/2023 19:37

And of course all the tax they earn to prop up the economy and pay for pensions.

Sumtimesiamgreen · 11/10/2023 19:35

You must have a wedgey from pulling up your judgey pants too high today.
I am not religious. I have 6 dc, a career, a dh, am educated and you are misinformed.

frenchfries111 · 11/10/2023 19:11

I’m one of seven children. My mother loved babies, children not so much.
We weren’t unusual though in a Catholic school in the 70s/80s. My mother did use contraception as well, it was by choice.
DHs parents were from massive families, not by choice though

I have a good childhood friend. She knew how crap things were for me growing up in a large family, the lack of privacy and money etc. compared to her being one of two. she’s gone on to have six children herself. She loves them but spends a huge amount of time complaining about the difficulties of having them. It shouldn’t be a surprise to her. I also think she was caught up in the ease and relative cheapness of babies and toddlers. It’s hard to be sympathetic.

ClassicStripe · 11/10/2023 18:37

I love love love having a baby in the house. Love pushing a pram. Love all their firsts. Love the smell of them. Love baby clubs. I would have a million if I could. Just an endless cycle of first years.

chaosmaker · 11/10/2023 18:36

Having large families does impact on everyone else though. Apart from environmentally, there is the impact on local services etc.

RosesAndGin · 11/10/2023 17:59

The only large families I know tend to have the kids in batches of two with each new 'father' figure moved into the home. It's like they think it's compulsory to have children with whichever man ìs flavour of the month at that moment.
They are from a low socio economic background, the mothers I know have never had a paid job and new babies seem to miraculously appear at times the job centre would expect them to be looking for work (usually once the youngest starts school another pregnancy is announced).
Obviously this is only my experience but the people I know that have large families have 100% used them as a reason not to work.

MyDogsPaws · 11/10/2023 17:38

I have 3 kids which feel like a lot to me, I personally can’t imagine having anymore and being able to cope. I also feel judged for having even 3 kids, especially as I work in the sustainability sector, so tend to be vague about the No of kids I have in work conversations 😬

There is a family local to me with 11 children. The children are pretty much feral and seem to look after themselves, spending a lot of time wandering the streets, the oldest kids seem to look after the younger kids. I put in a safeguarding concern to the school after one of the children came to my house and told me they were hungry because they don’t get anything to eat at home. A friend of mine said the same child expressed amazement at being given strawberries and told her she had never seen them before in real life, wherever any of it was true I don’t know but hopefully the concerns were investigated.

This mother is currently pregnant so the family continue to have children despite not seeing to be particularly concerned about the older children they already have, I guess they just like having babies and once you get to that number it definitely seems like an addiction. Like all addictions there will be an underlying cause and it’s probably not easy to just break out of it without help.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 11/10/2023 17:23

Coffeerum · 11/10/2023 13:16

I can't say I've ever come across a family in the UK with 5 or more children which didn't stem from religious or cultural reasons, along with a lot of sexism, lack of access to contraception etc.
My own parents are each one of seven and I'm going to go out on a limb based on what I know from their lives and assume my grandmothers would both have limited their reproduction at the time if they could.

The Radfords?

Sarah2891 · 11/10/2023 17:20

3 of my old school friends all had 5 kids. All pregnant as teens. None of them religious.
It wouldn't be for me but each to their own!

Hollybelle83 · 11/10/2023 17:14

Also not gushy about the baby-toddler stage. I have 2 amazing DCs and love them with everything, but huge chunks (but by no means all) of that early stage was more challenging than rewarding. I would actually be devastated if I accidentally got pregnant again. Very happy with what I have.

BananaPalm · 11/10/2023 17:06

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/10/2023 14:31

I may get shot down for this but I think for some women there's an element of self-infantilization about it tbh. Having babies is a way to avoid having to be a grown-up.

I think if you've started having kids very young and had loads (four plus) you will a) have spent most if not all of your adult life having, nursing or raising children and b) will almost certainly not be financially independent or capable of being financially independent. So coming to the end of that cycle of being pregnant, giving birth and having tiny kids to look after might seem an unwelcome and bleak wake-up call.

Suddenly there's no longer a justification for having your entire world limited by the boundaries of your home and a few baby groups/school. You have to encounter adults again and interact with them about things which are a bit more external than how much formula you have in the house. You might have to think about earning stuff. It must seem quite scary.

I'm always a bit dubious of people who say they are "desperate" to have a fourth/fifth/sixth baby and can't stop thinking about it. People will say it's a "biological drive" but I think a lot of the time its more a fear of actually having to be a proper adult.

This is one of the many reasons I'm not a huge fan of people having kids when they are very young. I think hard-wiring the idea that you're basically a baby machine as soon as you get to adulthood shores up problems for later life.

Totally agree!

newYear10 · 11/10/2023 17:04

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 16:28

I'm fascinated by large families and watched many on documentaries and YouTube. They all seem to have certain traits in common (these don't seem to apply to the religious or cultural ones):

  1. Woman started very young, usually in teens or very early 20s
  1. Both from lower socio economic group, no higher qualifications
  1. Claim to be "addicted to babies" but very much seem to enjoy the attention of pregnancy and material aspects of a newborn eg, buying cots/prams/personalised clothing for newborn. They never buy secondhand, always new and expensive stuff.
  1. Don't seem to be that bright. Claim their dc have the same time/attention/resources as families with 2dc, even when it is glaringly obvious that they live in very chaotic/overcrowded situations
  1. Their dc tend to start having dc very young too.
  1. When the dc grow up and they can't have any more children they start breeding dogs and/or cats. There definitely seems to be a 'safety in numbers' feeling.

I followed the families that were alongside the Morecambe family on the TV series, and nearly all of them split up after they stopped having dc, with most of the women saying there was DV and/or coercive control, and getting pregnant was part of that. The women then seem to go a bit wild and "it's me time!" and relinquish responsibility of the kids in order to go off and party/meet new men.

Sums it up!

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/10/2023 16:59

@thecatsthecats

To me the attention is quite oppressive and oddly disrespectful. But I can see how other, more normal people might thrive on it.

I totally agree with you. I find the attention paid to pregnant women and women with tiny babies faintly nauseating and I found it very oppressive when I was pregnant.

I love being a mother to my daughter but I honestly found the idea that people were congratulating me for having incubated, delivered and supported a small child a bit repulsive. There's no skill to it, literally anyone can do it. Why celebrate it? And I hated people commenting on my pregnancy bump etc. It's as if people are relieved to see women reduced to their most basic biological function and stripped of anything more active, authoritative or intellectual.

The whole culture of early motherhood creeps me out. It's bad enough feeling like a walking incubator/dairy without people actively celebrating it.

Boredatwork1234 · 11/10/2023 16:45

Dogon · 11/10/2023 13:26

I've thought this before. Not all large families, but certainly appears to be with some. I know a large family and the parents pay little attention to their kids once they reached a certain age. It's like they were only interested when they were babies and children (all adults now).

This was my family, now as adults we don’t have great relationships with our parents. One sister is no contact.

very much felt like babies got
more attention and as you older you were more of a disappointment. Completely shown in grandchildren too, obsessed with new babies and not so much older children

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 11/10/2023 16:34

I only have 5 so don’t fit the super large family stereotypes above. I only know a few larger families but they seem utterly unremarkable to me. There mums don’t seem particularly down trodden or to have low self esteem (actually rather the opposite, very very confident). It was a definite choice for us and for all the larger families I know.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 16:28

I'm fascinated by large families and watched many on documentaries and YouTube. They all seem to have certain traits in common (these don't seem to apply to the religious or cultural ones):

  1. Woman started very young, usually in teens or very early 20s
  1. Both from lower socio economic group, no higher qualifications
  1. Claim to be "addicted to babies" but very much seem to enjoy the attention of pregnancy and material aspects of a newborn eg, buying cots/prams/personalised clothing for newborn. They never buy secondhand, always new and expensive stuff.
  1. Don't seem to be that bright. Claim their dc have the same time/attention/resources as families with 2dc, even when it is glaringly obvious that they live in very chaotic/overcrowded situations
  1. Their dc tend to start having dc very young too.
  1. When the dc grow up and they can't have any more children they start breeding dogs and/or cats. There definitely seems to be a 'safety in numbers' feeling.

I followed the families that were alongside the Morecambe family on the TV series, and nearly all of them split up after they stopped having dc, with most of the women saying there was DV and/or coercive control, and getting pregnant was part of that. The women then seem to go a bit wild and "it's me time!" and relinquish responsibility of the kids in order to go off and party/meet new men.

Swipe left for the next trending thread