Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think having babies/parenting young kids can become an ‘addiction’

210 replies

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 13:07

I go to a lot of toddler groups on my days off and have met all types of families.

One family size that really intrigues me especially since becoming a mother is larger families (5+). Although rarer I have met a few mums who have 7+ children. I myself am 1 of 5 and my DP is 1 of 6!

Before having dc I would be very confused (judgy perhaps?) as to why on earth anyone needs/wants 5+ kids outside of religious reasons. Then being pregnant I was even more surprised women would choose to go through it so many times when it takes such a toll on our bodies.

However since having my DC and making mum friends I think I understand it, but maybe not?

Is it sort of an ‘addiction’ to the lifestyle?

Having a child, especially the baby/toddler years is so all encompassing that your identity can quite easily become being a ‘mum’ to young ones (or dad). Generally speaking of course, friendships become ‘mum friends’, weekdays become toddler groups, lunches and coffee mornings. Weekends and holidays are based around children activities. Conversations become child/pregnancy focused. It can easily become a ‘way of life’ rather than just a life stage.

I’ve observed you can also ‘opt out’ of other parts of life by being a parent to young dc. As in, not attend social things for childcare reasons. Not have a career, work full time or sometimes even at all very justifiably. You can really hide/escape a lot of things by having dependents and if you struggled with life before dc that you no longer have to deal with by having them, that must also keep the allure going to have more?

I have surprised myself by how much I love being a parent and am pregnant with my second dc. However after this there will be no more. Financially, mentally and practically it wouldn’t be ideal to have anymore. However if money and health wasn’t an obstacle then I can imagine how easy it would be to continue going.

My mum went through a depression when we all started leaving the home despite her saying she couldn’t wait for no more school runs and freedom etc. She now says being a mum was her ‘calling’ and her happiest years and would have had more of given the opportunity.
My MIL also said she would have had more kids if it wasn’t for FIL getting the snip. She already had 6 and wasn’t wealthy at all!

I can’t see people having so many kids because they are addicted to ‘babies’ because they don’t stay babies for long at all. So I can only conclude it’s the lifestyle of child rearing?

All the large families I’ve met are different in regards to class, jobs, money etc. so I don’t think it’s related to that in regards to why some are drawn to having more and more.

Anyone shed any lights or thoughts as to other reasons?

If you do have a big family, what are your reasons (especially if your a mum)

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 12/10/2023 17:36

Yes you are onto something with the opting out of work and adult life. I know two women (middle class and tall incidentally) who had four children each and never went back to work after the first was born.

ResearchMcResearchFace · 12/10/2023 17:30

I imagine a lot of it with the short, curvy women who have lots of kids in the USA are that they are more than likely Latinas! I am also one, we tend to have big families. If you are more indigenous than Spanish you're more likely to be shorter, possibly wider. Add racism into that and is it no wonder we're lower paid.
As a slightly related note, despite being a size 16, 5 foot nothing woman I had piss easy pregnancies. No sick days, no symptoms. If you breeze through pregnancy it's way easier to decide to have more kids

thecatsthecats · 12/10/2023 11:37

I think personality differences are massively under-accounted for in many walks of life.

I'm a confident and sociable introvert. I love and prefer time alone but have lots of friends and by no means shy or quiet in company.

MIL is very much an extrovert. If she could have all of her nearest and dearest living on the same street as her and have them all around for breakfast, lunch and dinner every day, she literally would.

Once, when her husband and sons were all at the football, I said "oh, I'm looking forward to the peace and solitude at home", she said without a hint of irony, "me and SIL are too, you could come and join us".

Something clicked in my brain when I was thinking about how many kids I wanted. Three children sounded fine to me. But then I realised that I would hate the variables of likely three sets of partners, three sets of grandchildren, three sets of other in laws, three sets of friends...

And I knew that three wasn't for me. I wouldn't be happy with that many "unchosen" people in my life.

HotApplePiePunch · 12/10/2023 11:00

My take on this (as a short curvy woman) is that it's a "low status" shape and probably, at a population level, has a correlation with low pay and fewer options.

I thought along similar lines Webex - (also curvy and before kids well paid ) though my view or cooperate USA may not be accurate but I did think them worse for judging on looks.

I just thought it odd the women's motivation wasn't considered at all.

Webex · 12/10/2023 10:50

I saw a documentary that looked at which women were having more kids in USA - shorter curvier women and it all focused on men picking these women and men's sexual preference and which affect that might have on population genetics - and completely ignored why the women were choosing to have more children

My take on this (as a short curvy woman) is that it's a "low status" shape and probably, at a population level, has a correlation with low pay and fewer options.

I'm a short fat woman with a fantastic job by the way before you jump on me, I know it doesn't apply to everyone but there is a big correlation between being attractive and being successful. And another correlation between low income and big families.

Daisies23 · 12/10/2023 10:48

I have 5 kids. My husband and I both always wanted 5. We love the chaos and generally love being around children. I've always worked and volunteered with kids in various settings and my has volunteered with various kids activities. We didn't have much money when our kids were small but now their older my husbands career has progressed and we manage fine. I work part time as a support worker which is a lot about equipping people for independent living and teaching them that they are capable of things they didn't think they were, which are also the parts of parenting I love.

My husband and I work well as a team and both really enjoy parenting. I have a social life and plenty of friends that I enjoy spending time with, as does my husband. We make an effort to spend time with the children 1:1 for at least 15mins per day and we try and do activities that they'd really enjoy 1:1 as well where we can. Obviously they do miss out on some things that we just can't do because there's so many of them, but I also think they gain something in the siblings they have. We also had our children very close in age so they have similar interests at the same time, so we're not trying to entertain a toddler and a teenager at the same time.

In my experience, although I love newborns, I also love every age we've hit so far,and are now approaching the teen years. Pregnancy was definitely not addictive, I did not enjoy that, and most of the large families I know found the same with pregnancy. And by the time I was on my 3rd there was a lot less excitement about pregnancy, and by the time I had my 5th I didn't want to tell anyone because I was so fed up of the judgement I got from others for having so many! And the youngest children didn't really experience the toddler/under 5 lifestyle as I was kind of out of it by yhen. To be honest once they hit 3 I think I found the lifestyle much more enjoyable, so I don't think it was an addiction to pregnancy/attention/lifestyle for me.

I think they PP who mentioned about being used to high pressure busy environments is most accurate. I thrive in those environments, especially where children are involved. I also just love parenting and all the different stages. It's obviously really hard work and there are plenty of times when I'm stressed out trying to juggle everything and I'm aware my kids are missing out on stuff, but I think that happens whatever type of family you have.

HotApplePiePunch · 12/10/2023 10:42

there's definitely a strong element of personality difference too
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/jul/26/personality-types-women-childbirth-study

I'm never sure how much personality categorising is pseudo science - but I suppose it does make sense personality is going to influence if you have children, when and how many - and reading that article how those choices are judged as I got a definite later and fewer better vibe from the article.

I saw a documentary that looked at which women were having more kids in USA - shorter curvier women and it all focused on men picking these women and men's sexual preference and which affect that might have on population genetics - and completely ignored why the women were choosing to have more children.

Personality types affect women's approach to childbirth - study

Institute of Social and Economic Research cross-referenced five personality traits with the ages of 16,000 mothers

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/jul/26/personality-types-women-childbirth-study

nanodyne · 12/10/2023 10:10

I'm one of 6 and when I finally started thinking about kids always assumed I'd have 3 or 4. After having 2, I honestly couldn't imagine putting myself through pregnancy and the newborn stage again! Mine are still very little, but so far they've just gotten better and better as they've grown - I even feel a little bit guilty about having #2 because #1 is such a pleasure and so bright and curious, but #2 obviously needs a bit more attention being younger.

That said, my sibling just had baby #4 and I could easily see them going for 5 or even 6 (biology allowing) - they love that whole baby/toddler/preschool phase, I think it gives them a sense of purpose and confidence that they haven't got in other areas of their life. They're much more of a free-range parent than I am too, so I can see that they wouldn't necessarily feel as overwhelmed by being outnumbered as I would. There's definitely a strong element of personality difference too - they really can't stand being alone and so I think the kids (especially little ones) help, whereas I really need my own space and time and quiet, so more kids (and little ones at that!) would be really hard for me to cope with.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 12/10/2023 07:25

I agree op but that is based on the few families l know with 5 + children - all started young (15 in on case (and seems to struggle now they are all a bit older) and it really is their whole lives.
I don't have a problem with it as such but it annoys me that l know they don't financially support themselves - they live off benefits - so they aren't funding it themselves.
Plus they don't seem to have the time for each child individually.
Wouldn't be for me - like you say, having children is a life stage rather than your whole existence revolving around raising kids. I look forward to DD growing up and seeing how she is as an adult.

TheaBrandt · 11/10/2023 23:27

Definitely think you are on to something. I left a very high pressure full on city job and was a sahm for 6 years. It is a seductive lifestyle you are free to do your own thing / pressures of the workplace gone / society appreciation. My two were pretty easy and well behaved and I met brilliant other mums in the same boat. It was a happy time in my life but definitely needed to get back into the real world when dd2 started school and we stopped at 2. The thought of remaining in that world didn’t feel healthy.

I now recoil from it - youngest 15 and can’t think of anything worse than sitting on the floor in a church hall and the daily drudgery <shudder>

BertieBotts · 11/10/2023 23:10

I only have three, but with a big gap between 1 and 2 so a similar total time span as if I'd had 5/6, and I do recognise myself in some of the posts Blush

I feel very much like a fraud who has never had a "real adult job" and I desperately want to get out and change that but do feel very daunted about it. I have been drawn to baby/toddler centred industries too probably because it's one of the only things that I feel competent in dealing with. The only thing that I would say is that I don't think addictive is quite the right word. I think many people enjoy the baby stage and want it to keep going but I don't know if it's the same as addiction.

I always wanted more children after the first but had such a large gap due to a relationship break up. When I was finally pregnant again I was so happy about it. The only way I can really describe it is you know when you wake up, snooze your alarm and then realise that you don't actually have to get up, you can just turn it off and go back to sleep? That sense of blissful relief. Well going back into baby land was just like that for me. The only thing I can compare it to.

My eldest is a teenager and I haven't lost interest in him. If anything I found the primary years a bit dull, very Pokémon and Minecraft. But once the teen years have hit they seem to find themselves a bit more.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 23:06

@Theantsgomarchingtwo that is incredibly sad. Have you ever had counselling?
I was watching an old documentary the other day about women having ten children, and it was very obvious that the women all had very unresolved issues from childhood. The way they spoke about having a child who unconditionally loves and needs you and really struggling when that came to an end (ie when they couldn't have any more) was just so sad. It really makes you question society when women are saying they want dc so that more people will talk to them! Do we only value the company of women who have children?

Lastdaysofsun · 11/10/2023 22:44

Such an interesting thread, thank you op 💜
I had infertility for years and had my Dd later, she’s now 5 and I can see what you’re saying. I loved being it that bubble, it was bloody hard work at times but it was opting out a little, I loved the play dates, coffee meet ups, the attention, all of it. I didn’t expect it, but those have been the happiest times of my life and I’m struggling to come to terms with it being over. I have two frozen embryos left but feel I’m too old possibly at 45. If I was younger I’d definitely try for more and if money was no object I’d have 4

Theantsgomarchingtwo · 11/10/2023 22:40

I find this a very interesting topic & often think about it time to time.

I grew up in 'boro lived on various council estates - never went anywhere, the highlight of my year was plaggy baggin if it snowed, somehow scrapped by enough to go to uni, I've got an okay job in hc nothing fancy or high paying, rent, holiday in the uk, suffer with poor mh most likely due to upbringing...you get the picture.

Life can be so very bleak and hamster wheel-esque. I found having babies was very exciting and easily "in reach" (baring the mc) whereas everything else in life - good grades, good careers, holidays abroad, nice clothes, nice homes in nice areas seemed unattainable for someone like me but a baby I could have and I could experience that euphoric high, that tiny human was mine to take home & love. As posters above mentioned folk talked to you more, the world felt more positive, your life suddenly has meaning, purpose and (at times!) joy. It opens up places & people you wouldn't normally be part of. So I can understand why some do go on and on and on to have more babies.

I have 3 unless my financial circumstances change we won't be having anymore but I have loved every moment of raising my children.

CarrotSoupwithCheese · 11/10/2023 22:30

What a fascinating thread. Can definitely relate OP, I only have 3 children but the third one was definitely a case of wanting prolong that preschool phase. I love toddler groups, drinking coffee and chatting with other mums, having the freedom to plan my day, enjoying the sunshine if the weather is good, etc.

I’ve come to terms with it coming to an end now (my youngest will start school next year) but I can see why some women would carry on.

Also there’s something very exciting about announcing a pregnancy (like announcing an engagement) and everyone being very happy for you, though I found that the excitement from others was less and less with each child.

10HailMarys · 11/10/2023 22:16

Pretty sure there is a recognised mental health condition where women are ‘addicted’ to having babies. I know someone who has deliberately had seven children with three men, mostly while lying to them that she was on the pill when she wasn’t. She dumped the father of four of her children when she got pregnant with her sixth child. As soon as the sixth child was approaching school
age she immediately became pregnant for the seventh time by a violent racist drug-user and animal abuser, whom all six of her other children despised.

She has very little money and until the older ones moved out the kids were sleeping three or four to a room. She split with her latest partner when it became apparent that she wasn’t likely to get pregnant by him.

She actually pays very little attention to her kids when they reach three or four. She definitely loves them but she isn’t actually very interested in them, if that makes sense. It’s all about babies for her.

She had a very tough childhood and has low self-esteem, and had her first baby at 17. It’s pretty clear to most people who know her that her own childhood and feelings of being unloved is a big factor - I think she only feels like she is worth something, or is loved, when she has a baby dependent on her. She has actively tried, with all seven children, to stop their fathers being hands-on dads when the kids are babies, eg refusing to ‘let’ their dads feed or bathe them etc.

boomtickhouse · 11/10/2023 21:42

Webex · 11/10/2023 14:59

I was unprepared for the level of attention and approval you get, and the year of maternity leave was a revelation

This resonates for me - I also found being visibly pregnant meant people were far nice to me than they every had been before. Just random people out and about were kinder and more friendly.

I see this with some friends. Leaving behind the baby/toddler years has raised some problems for them with work / marriage / other things. I think in the early years you can shelter yourself from dealing with other very real issues by immersing in toddler groups and being sheltered from the "real world" of work and societies expectations

boomtickhouse · 11/10/2023 21:38

JustAMinutePleass · 11/10/2023 13:53

One of the mums at DS’ private school is a 23 year old mum of 3 who has just had her 4th. She’s a lovely girl and when we chatted she told me she had no control over anything in her life except having kids - she was 18 when she married her DS (who was 25 at the time). She met him in Freshers Week (he was a guest of one of the societies). They fell in love and within a year she had dropped out of uni and was planning her wedding - as it often goes when Indian girls find a ‘well settled’ guy.

He’s lovely but he’s extremely wealthy, so much money and so many bills she wouldn’t know how to manage his money (he has a finance manager lol), and so she gets a hefty allowance for personal spends. He doesn’t really give her input or control over things other than household / child related stuff and has left the decision of how many kids to have with her. She wants 8 (like her grandmother did) and as they can clearly support them & adore the kids they have I don’t see why she shouldn’t have them.

Had I not had every fertility problem under the sun I would have liked to have 5/6 children. I adore my son but always wanted a large family and would never judge anyone for trying to make it happen.

This says controlling and grooming to me

Thepossibility · 11/10/2023 21:27

My SIL has a LOT of kids and I agree it's like an addiction.
She has said she loves the feeling of having a new baby.
She largely ignores the older kids.
It's like those people who keep getting cute puppies and kittens and give them away when they're no longer cute.
There is an element of religion though. She believe God is blessing them with all those children.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 21:21

I watch a family on YouTube and she's expecting her 12th I think. It's car crash TV, from the second she's pregnant she's decorating the nursery, buying clothes etc, but then the novelty seems to wear off and she does nothing but complain about how hard life is with so many kids and they have no money to go anywhere or do anything. They only have a 5 seater car so can't even go for a drive. When they do a pregnancy reveal to the kids they are always very visibly annoyed. They've got 3 or 4 grandchildren now but have just revealed their "very last final baby".

Ontheperiphery79 · 11/10/2023 21:12

I've seen the really sad side of it where women in addiction, who've had children removed from them either to foster care or adoption.
One lady has 8 in total, all of whom have been adopted. Since having her 8th (born with Foetal Alcohol Syndrome), she has had 2 further pregnancies, both of which miscarried at earlier stages.
There's a dark side to 'addiction' to having children...and it's the children that pay the price.

mrlistersgelfbride · 11/10/2023 21:09

I must be strange then because I can't imagine being addicted to having kids in any way!
I have one and she's always been a handful. Love her to bits but have never gotten round to doing it again and couldn't wait to go back to my job to get some adult time! I prefer things now she's older. I suppose it depends how well you took to being a mum- some of us really struggle and I found it really hard.

Most people I know are 2 and done, but occasionally I've seen families of 3 or 4 have 'one more'. Seems like very hard work.

uuughhhshsh · 11/10/2023 21:01

I vaguely know someone with 8 children and it 100% is an addiction to the baby phase. As soon as one is walking and talking, she is pregnant with another. Their family isn’t particularly wealthy either.

I personally think it’s batshit, and feel sorry for the older children who are expected to pitch in with childcare.

derley · 11/10/2023 20:56

I live in a very affluent part of London so my experiences of larger families is a bit different. They are mostly British, or other white Western families, well-educated and very wealthy (all dcs in private school from nursery, nannies, multiple homes). The mums aren't spending all their time at toddler groups and running around after kids - they share it with the nanny and other staff, and the schools also cover lots of extracurriculars so they aren't ferrying dc around to clubs. They usually work part-time, in a family business or some kind of self-employment, which allows a lot of flexibility, and it means they have an identity outside of the family. I think part of their reasons for having larger families is that they have enough money and resources so that there's almost no need to limit their family size, having enough dc to take on roles in the family business and financial legacy, and probably a bit of status - the dc all go to very nice schools and have good achievements and it looks good for them to have bragging rights for that. And to be fair to them they do tend to turn out perfectly nicely brought up dc.

MrsMiddleMother · 11/10/2023 20:54

I'm one of 6, my eldest sister has 9 kids and I know a few other 5+ families. Addiction to being pregnant and small babies, the attention, the 'perks' i.e free dental care, avoiding the work place. My sister is now a single mother on benefits, with no money and the children are often neglected. Growing up my dad worked hard, my mother didn't work at all yet we didn't have much money and were often neglected.

I have two children and would never have any more, for many reasons for mainly because I couldn't adequately care for more and I want my children to have the best chance in life but not every mother thinks that. From personal experience, I completely judge larger families even if they have lots of money and the kids appear well looked after. There's something about growing up 'one of 5' 'one of 6' that affects how you view lots of things and it's wrong.