Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think having babies/parenting young kids can become an ‘addiction’

210 replies

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 13:07

I go to a lot of toddler groups on my days off and have met all types of families.

One family size that really intrigues me especially since becoming a mother is larger families (5+). Although rarer I have met a few mums who have 7+ children. I myself am 1 of 5 and my DP is 1 of 6!

Before having dc I would be very confused (judgy perhaps?) as to why on earth anyone needs/wants 5+ kids outside of religious reasons. Then being pregnant I was even more surprised women would choose to go through it so many times when it takes such a toll on our bodies.

However since having my DC and making mum friends I think I understand it, but maybe not?

Is it sort of an ‘addiction’ to the lifestyle?

Having a child, especially the baby/toddler years is so all encompassing that your identity can quite easily become being a ‘mum’ to young ones (or dad). Generally speaking of course, friendships become ‘mum friends’, weekdays become toddler groups, lunches and coffee mornings. Weekends and holidays are based around children activities. Conversations become child/pregnancy focused. It can easily become a ‘way of life’ rather than just a life stage.

I’ve observed you can also ‘opt out’ of other parts of life by being a parent to young dc. As in, not attend social things for childcare reasons. Not have a career, work full time or sometimes even at all very justifiably. You can really hide/escape a lot of things by having dependents and if you struggled with life before dc that you no longer have to deal with by having them, that must also keep the allure going to have more?

I have surprised myself by how much I love being a parent and am pregnant with my second dc. However after this there will be no more. Financially, mentally and practically it wouldn’t be ideal to have anymore. However if money and health wasn’t an obstacle then I can imagine how easy it would be to continue going.

My mum went through a depression when we all started leaving the home despite her saying she couldn’t wait for no more school runs and freedom etc. She now says being a mum was her ‘calling’ and her happiest years and would have had more of given the opportunity.
My MIL also said she would have had more kids if it wasn’t for FIL getting the snip. She already had 6 and wasn’t wealthy at all!

I can’t see people having so many kids because they are addicted to ‘babies’ because they don’t stay babies for long at all. So I can only conclude it’s the lifestyle of child rearing?

All the large families I’ve met are different in regards to class, jobs, money etc. so I don’t think it’s related to that in regards to why some are drawn to having more and more.

Anyone shed any lights or thoughts as to other reasons?

If you do have a big family, what are your reasons (especially if your a mum)

OP posts:
Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 00:16

Unless you have huge gaps you really aren’t stuck in the baby stage necessarily and even if there’s ten years between top and bottom you are still parenting the older ones like anyone else. Like a pp I like my children at all the stages which is normal I think?

Ladyj84 · 13/10/2023 00:02

Some mums may be but don't judge all. We adore our kids ranging from 2-13 and support financiallly,emotionally etc etc. I would never have had them if I didn't have a super hubby and was able to take care of all needs. I adore our big family and would never judge anyone who has similar or none.

Cloudburstings · 12/10/2023 23:42

MissHoney85 · 11/10/2023 13:42

I know what you mean. It's a bit like being part of a club, and kind of gives you a special status in society. I know I'll really miss these years when they're gone, and feel a strange kind of nostalgia about it even though I'm still experiencing it. I could easily keep having babies if time and money (and sleep!) weren't factors. I'm also aware that babies will turn into bigger kids / teenagers, and I might not enjoy that bit so much!

Agree with this.

And if you didn’t have much in your life before / find work daunting / have low self esteem it’s a great way to avoid a lot of adult life while also getting a certain status and validation.

and it’s self fulfilling- the more kids you have the harder it is to get back to work.

i also think it’s intrinsically fulfilling. Like other posters I would have had more than two if time and resources had allowed.

we didn’t as we felt we couldn’t meet more kids long term needs well.

I agree some that have big families seem selfish - doing it because they like it when it’s clear to an outsider they’re not going to be able to parent all the kids well or meet their needs

Oopsadaisysgranny · 12/10/2023 23:36

I’m a mum of 5 . Kids now late 20s early 30s. I love being a mum and would have had more of not for my health .I enjoy them just as much now as I did when they were little . We live in a small community and I love it when people say oh are you so and so mum . My children don’t seem to feel the same though as we have 1 grandchild and no signs of anymore . So now I’m looking after dgc

Pacificisolated · 12/10/2023 23:33

This must be why I don’t want a big family! I hated the uni and maternity leave ‘lifestyle’. Would much rather be at work or spending time with an older toddler/preschool child who can talk, use the toilet and enjoy a day out.
Some of the attention you get as a pregnant and postpartum woman is nice (and some is stifling) but it doesn’t even touch 1% of the misery of sleep deprivation 🤣

TheaBrandt · 12/10/2023 23:22

Yes agree it’s similar, it’s getting “stuck” in a life stage that should be transient. See also the gap year extenders. They panic when they realise they are 28 and still working in a beach bar in Bali with £50 in the bank and their peers are all qualified solicitors and teachers with mortgages.

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 12/10/2023 23:22

So the only way of being an adult is to follow your path through life?

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 12/10/2023 22:19

Funnily enough @TheaBrandt ibwas thinking of ‘eternal students’ when writing my OP.

Not that anything about having kids is like being a student. But there is parallels in terms of it being a ‘lifestyle’ and not ‘life stage’.

My good friend from uni is still in university now, well over a decade from graduating the first time. She’s just began another degree this September. All the subjects are different so it’s not subject progression.

She’s been able to work part time the entire time around her endless degrees.

I’m not judging as her life seems nice enough, she gets good grades and she seems relatively happy. But I do wonder what will happen if her parents ever say enough is enough and stop funding her fees.

But it does have the parallel of ‘opting out’ but in a different way. No pressure to buy a house, achieve financial independence or maintain a career. A different kind of ‘opt out’ but avoiding the crapness of your everyday adulting nonetheless. Can’t say I blame her.

I loved the uni lifestyle just like I love mother of little ones lifestyle. But it’s definitely a stage more so than a long term lifestyle. But I definitely get the allure.

OP posts:
Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 12/10/2023 21:01

Being brought up by abusive parents, negligent parents or in abject poverty will impact you regardless of how many children are in your family. It’s not the number of children driving that, though I’m sure it could make things worse.

TheaBrandt · 12/10/2023 20:38

It does blow your mind having a baby. I used to travel internationally with work and would whizz off to the far east with a few hours notice. After having my first a trip to the local supermarket seemed like a worrisome massive ordeal. Your world shrinks so much in some ways it’s lovely but agree it’s healthier if it’s a life stage not a way of life. Otherwise you end up like those students that can’t leave university and end up working there.

Greybluewhite · 12/10/2023 20:18

I can see how it can become addicting. I have 3 and won’t be having any more and I do feel sad about it. I loved pregnancy despite how ill I was, having special treatment at work and at home. I also loved giving birth and then how amazing it is having a newborn. I enjoyed watching how excited my whole family got when we welcomed a new baby. I also adore having children- they are hilarious! Oh and the added bonus of being able to work part time because they are young and it’s not worth paying for childcare, I pretend it’s a shame I can’t work full time but I’m secretly pleased!

I am one of those people who thrives on busy. I hate sitting around and always need something to do so tend to fill my life with responsibilities more than a normal person would. Maybe that’s it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/10/2023 20:03

I hated that we were bullied for being poor and despite what crap,people say about how children don't need much so don't worry about being able to afford more than the basics....well that's true, but those children have a shit childhood.

I find this rhetoric really irritating too. It's technically correct that children don't "need" days out/new clothes/occasional treats and other things and of course if the family can't afford them they can't afford them.

But the idea that having a "big/close/chaotic" family (as they're invariably described) compensates for living on the absolute breadline with multiple kids sharing rooms, no days out, no holidays, no decent food is delusional

Of course when circumstances force people into this they have to deal with it. But its not something anyone should be actively planning for.

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/10/2023 19:56

mathanxiety · 12/10/2023 18:17

I only have 5 so don’t fit the super large family stereotypes above. I only know a few larger families but they seem utterly unremarkable to me. There mums don’t seem particularly down trodden or to have low self esteem (actually rather the opposite, very very confident). It was a definite choice for us and for all the larger families I know.

Absolutely agree with your observations, @Zzizzisnotzeproblem

A larger family (by UK standards anyway) is actually a marker of very secure middle classness where I live.

A very large family (I'd say bigger than four) is the marker either of significant affluence or poverty. You have to be wealthy enough that money is no object or on benefits (although that's harder than it was). Unless you're obscenely wealthy it does also mean one parent can't work for at least 20 years. It's definitely out of reach for a lot of people.

What you're talking about isn't "secure middle class" its upper class.

daliesque · 12/10/2023 19:54

@NeverDropYourMooncup sounds like mine too. Except we were all NT and she went off us by the time we started junior school

daliesque · 12/10/2023 19:52

@bakewellbride we're the same with chips, especially from the chippie as that was dads payday treat for us all every Friday.

Other nights mother would fry them.

Neither my sister nor I, and probably the younger ones, don't eat them anymore.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/10/2023 19:44

My mother always maintained that babies were lovely, cuddly and they stayed where you put them.

Strangely, she never mentioned to anybody outside the household of five children that she disliked small children with minds of their own, intensely disliked preteens because they couldn't always be terrified into silence about abuse and actively despised anyone over the age of 11 - or two and a half if they committed the offences of being a) neurodiverse, b) not male or c) both a+b.

albalass · 12/10/2023 19:41

It can easily become a ‘way of life’ rather than just a life stage.

This is well put and sums up how I felt. Especially in the first 12 months - I felt like I had left 'normal life' behind (think my lack of sleep definitely contributed to the detached feeling). I did wonder if for mums who have several children over a number of years, that baby/toddler life just becomes normal life. I guess it does. For me, I enjoyed doing it with one child as there was a novelty factor. No desire to keep going to toddler groups/park visits/soft play for years to come so one child is perfect for me. I only know one family of 5 kids (all 14 and under) - they are very wealthy. Otherwise 3 is the max and the vast majority only have 1 or 2.

bakewellbride · 12/10/2023 19:31

@daliesque I'm sorry to hear of your experience. I know someone who was one of ten and he had a rough time too. He was one of the older ones so expected to pitch in a lot with looking after the younger ones. Tea was pasta every single night. As an adult now he absolutely hates pasta!

daliesque · 12/10/2023 18:32

This is really interesting reading for me as I'm one of 5 myself and that experience of childhood probably had an influence on my own choice not to have children.

I'm the second oldest and it often felt like there were two different families - my sister and I and then the younger ones. We didn't really have much in common with them because there's a 6 year age gap between me and the next child and 8 years between my sister and that child. The third child was a boy, our brother, think that might have made a difference. Then there was another boy and a youngest girl.

My abiding memory of my childhood after the youngest ones were born js noise and chaos. Our mother had more children because my father had asked her to go back to work when I started school as they struggled for money. She didn't want to, so got pregnant instead. Then again and again until she was, in her eyes, too old to work - she would have been around 40 at that point.

She didn't like children much. There were no hugs or attention after the age of about 7. She only liked her children when we were too young to answer back.

And we lived in such poverty. We had nothing. No holidays or days out and always clothes from the jumble sales that always smelled of someone else's sweat. Food was carb heavy and mostly something with chips as they had no money for anything more interesting.

I hated it. I hated that we were bullied for being poor and despite what crap,people say about how children don't need much so don't worry about being able to afford more than the basics....well that's true, but those children have a shit childhood.

mathanxiety · 12/10/2023 18:17

I only have 5 so don’t fit the super large family stereotypes above. I only know a few larger families but they seem utterly unremarkable to me. There mums don’t seem particularly down trodden or to have low self esteem (actually rather the opposite, very very confident). It was a definite choice for us and for all the larger families I know.

Absolutely agree with your observations, @Zzizzisnotzeproblem

A larger family (by UK standards anyway) is actually a marker of very secure middle classness where I live.

mathanxiety · 12/10/2023 18:07

Wrt certain ethnic groups tending to have larger families in the US - don't forget the impact of having extended family nearby to take care of children when parents are working. There isn't the 'living on benefits' option in the US in most cases, and there are no funded nursery/daycare hours, so if you want to have a larger family, you need to be careful about affordability and the sort of family support you will get (which makes it affordable but also allows you to have a little mental health break from time to time).

For many university educated women, paying off university loans, a mortgage, and /or professional school or grad school loans, with university costs looming too, means you have to factor in finances and the necessity of earning an income. Many middle class, university educated parents don't have the sort of family support nearby that would allow them to relax about childcare costs or the physical strain of a larger family. It isn't always feasible to up sticks and move back to the area where your parents live to tap into that kid of support.

pramhelpplease · 12/10/2023 18:00

I agree - I have just had my 3rd after a big age gap and before having him I would mourn the baby/toddler years, as I feel I am very good as parenting babies and small children and have found the current years (8 and pre-teen) very challenging and not that enjoyable to be honest. We definitely won’t have any more but every milestone my tiny baby hits is tinged with sadness I won’t get to do it again. If you enjoy babies it’s really “addictive” - all the bonding hormones etc etc. But some people can’t stand the baby stage, we’re all different!

I know someone from school who has six children, all about 2/3 years apart so whenever the youngest begins to get a bit bigger she gets pregnant! How she does it I will never know, she seems to be a fantastic Mum.

mathanxiety · 12/10/2023 17:52

It's a rather scathing judgement to call it 'opting out' of 'adult life'.
By definition, it is a choice reserved for adults. And by experience and observation, it is anything but 'opting out'.

mathanxiety · 12/10/2023 17:50

I have a friend who stopped at four because her fourth pregnancy was the first one where she had experienced morning sickness. They were all close together too, but she had au pairs.

EC22 · 12/10/2023 17:46

I have 5 children.
I loved being pregnant, loved having children. Calling it an addiction is mad. If it was an addiction I’d have 20+! I had as many children as I could comfortably house and afford.
I’m a midwife and Ive worked throughout their childhoods, going back when 2nd was 9 months old.
I suppose if you had difficult pregnancies or have little support or lack of finances it may be difficult to understand.