Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think having babies/parenting young kids can become an ‘addiction’

210 replies

Sugarcoatedcandycane · 11/10/2023 13:07

I go to a lot of toddler groups on my days off and have met all types of families.

One family size that really intrigues me especially since becoming a mother is larger families (5+). Although rarer I have met a few mums who have 7+ children. I myself am 1 of 5 and my DP is 1 of 6!

Before having dc I would be very confused (judgy perhaps?) as to why on earth anyone needs/wants 5+ kids outside of religious reasons. Then being pregnant I was even more surprised women would choose to go through it so many times when it takes such a toll on our bodies.

However since having my DC and making mum friends I think I understand it, but maybe not?

Is it sort of an ‘addiction’ to the lifestyle?

Having a child, especially the baby/toddler years is so all encompassing that your identity can quite easily become being a ‘mum’ to young ones (or dad). Generally speaking of course, friendships become ‘mum friends’, weekdays become toddler groups, lunches and coffee mornings. Weekends and holidays are based around children activities. Conversations become child/pregnancy focused. It can easily become a ‘way of life’ rather than just a life stage.

I’ve observed you can also ‘opt out’ of other parts of life by being a parent to young dc. As in, not attend social things for childcare reasons. Not have a career, work full time or sometimes even at all very justifiably. You can really hide/escape a lot of things by having dependents and if you struggled with life before dc that you no longer have to deal with by having them, that must also keep the allure going to have more?

I have surprised myself by how much I love being a parent and am pregnant with my second dc. However after this there will be no more. Financially, mentally and practically it wouldn’t be ideal to have anymore. However if money and health wasn’t an obstacle then I can imagine how easy it would be to continue going.

My mum went through a depression when we all started leaving the home despite her saying she couldn’t wait for no more school runs and freedom etc. She now says being a mum was her ‘calling’ and her happiest years and would have had more of given the opportunity.
My MIL also said she would have had more kids if it wasn’t for FIL getting the snip. She already had 6 and wasn’t wealthy at all!

I can’t see people having so many kids because they are addicted to ‘babies’ because they don’t stay babies for long at all. So I can only conclude it’s the lifestyle of child rearing?

All the large families I’ve met are different in regards to class, jobs, money etc. so I don’t think it’s related to that in regards to why some are drawn to having more and more.

Anyone shed any lights or thoughts as to other reasons?

If you do have a big family, what are your reasons (especially if your a mum)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
daliesque · 18/10/2023 18:00

Women who can’t or have not had the opportunity to have children must clearly be inferior then in your eyes, even if they are doctors or nurses or human rights lawyers or teachers or emergency service workers.

I have yet to meet a patient who cared about my reproductive status! Some of my colleagues, however, do tend to think that having had children makes them more understanding of what cancer patients go through....rather than the actual cancer survivor 🤷‍♀️

Webex · 18/10/2023 12:15

And yet it wouldn’t be possible for you to do it without a partner that’s prepared to be dishonourable by having a career serving a boss. Oddly enough, I doubt you say this to them.

No, oddly this sort of thing never applies to men. See also "why have children if someone else is going to raise them" or "caring more about fancy cars and holidays than spending time with their children".

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/10/2023 12:02

Looking after your family is a far more noble endeavour than any career.

And yet it wouldn’t be possible for you to do it without a partner that’s prepared to be dishonourable by having a career serving a boss. Oddly enough, I doubt you say this to them.

110APiccadilly · 18/10/2023 09:49

I grew up round quite a few large families and I really liked the dynamics of them, though I'm aware I was seeing that from outside (I'm one of three, which I wouldn't say is "large", and there's a big age gap in my family as well, which affects the dynamics). So for me, a desire to have a big family stems from that really. (Though I doubt we'll actually have more than three as both of mine so far have been awkward pregnancies ending in sections - common sense has to come into play here and DH and I are unsure even about having another one at the moment.)

I think you've got the dynamic of more children/ not working the wrong way round to be honest. I know plenty of people who'd like another one but can't afford childcare. If you've already got a SAHP then that's not an issue, and even a PT working parent makes a big difference.

EatYourVegetables · 18/10/2023 09:08

I can’t think of anything worse than doing the baby stage over and over.

My kids are now 5 and 7. We have conversations! They like books which are not mind bogglingly repetitive! We can do activities together that we all enjoy! They can entertain themselves! They can wipe their own bums!

KimberleyClark · 18/10/2023 09:08

Siameasy · 14/10/2023 08:37

I’m not convinced we are built for it, no. A man can do all of those jobs but the one thing that solely a woman can do, you denigrate “popping out babies”

Modern feminism is actually a misogynistic movement and is anti-family.

I’m proud to be a wife and mother. Looking after your family is a far more noble endeavour than any career. If you would rather serve your boss that’s up to you.

Women who can’t or have not had the opportunity to have children must clearly be inferior then in your eyes, even if they are doctors or nurses or human rights lawyers or teachers or emergency service workers.

chaosmaker · 18/10/2023 08:57

What is noble about increasing the population? - To the pp that thinks it is for some reason.

ResearchMcResearchFace · 15/10/2023 20:24

@Siameasy I'm not choosing to serve my boss over my family. I'm choosing to serve my patients and people who need help in a mental health crisis. Imagine if all mothers felt more 'noble' being SAHM's. Who would work as nurses, teachers, social care workers, scientists, professors, medics and all the other jobs in the world. Who would help you in hospital should you pop out another kid? Who would teach your children in school? Who would come to take a statement from you if you were burgled?

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2023 08:25

When I was in my ante-natal classes at the grand old age of 32 (elderly prima gravida!!) there was a young expectant mum - she was 18, I think. She stood out amongst the crowd as weirdly matronly, but not in a good way. She wasn't like any 18 year old I'd ever met. The poor midwife had to constantly interrupt her because she had a hoard of awful, gruesome stories about the perils of pregnancy and motherhood, terrible labours, internal damage during delivery, etc etc incontinence and rupture.

I encountered her over and over again over a period of about 10 years and she was always pregnant - I think she had 6 the last time I met her. Yet motherhood seemed to bring out her 'We're all doomed!' attitude - there was just no joy in it for her, it seemed. I've never forgotten her and she puzzles me. Why keep getting pregnant if that's your attitude? I guess the only explanation is that she came from a background where women just get pregnant as soon as it's legal and keep on going until the menopause hits - that was the only life/future/role she had ever seen.

Sandia1 · 15/10/2023 00:35

A really interesting thread, OP and I totally agree with you. I very nearly had a third (I loved the lifestyle, found being a mum came very naturally, had lots of really good mum friends who were also not working, I hated my job and didn't want to go back F/T). I resisted the urge to have a third but childminded a relative for a bit instead and that helped. I now work full time in a different job and I love it. My children are now lovely teenagers.

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 15/10/2023 00:12

@YokoOnosBigHat but how does that explain larger age gaps?

YokoOnosBigHat · 14/10/2023 23:12

Definitely. I got very into the idea of a third and would have done it if I hadn't become unexpectedly ill when our second was about a year old and we intended to try again. By the time I was better about 18m later there was no urge and I realised that I'd only wanted a third because of the bubble my life had been. Once the bubble burst- even though it was burst by a crap thing and being in and out of hospital- I just wasn't interested anymore.

mathanxiety · 14/10/2023 21:36

What you're talking about isn't "secure middle class" its upper class.

I'm in the US so class boundaries are probably not the same as those in the UK. Middle class here is a huge category. 'Secure middle class' means a high income that is pretty much guaranteed for several decades, and there are a lot of secure middle class people in the are where I live.

mathanxiety · 14/10/2023 21:32

It’s a strangely sexist discussion. My husband also has a large number of children, he also wasn’t “addicted” to it. Not even discussed though is it? It’s 2023 not 1950.

Hear hear!

Siameasy · 14/10/2023 08:37

JudyGemstone · 13/10/2023 00:39

You don’t think women are ‘built for careers in a high stress workplace’?!

what are we built for then? Cooking and cleaning and popping out babies?

bit insulting isn’t it. I guess the women doctors, lawyers, engineers, police officers, hedge fund managers etc are barely coping in their jobs and miserable.

I’m not convinced we are built for it, no. A man can do all of those jobs but the one thing that solely a woman can do, you denigrate “popping out babies”

Modern feminism is actually a misogynistic movement and is anti-family.

I’m proud to be a wife and mother. Looking after your family is a far more noble endeavour than any career. If you would rather serve your boss that’s up to you.

Siameasy · 14/10/2023 08:31

Webex · 13/10/2023 09:48

Upon reflection I would like to have married and had kids younger because I would’ve been able to have more. My experience of “pursuing a career”, something heavily pushed at school in the 90s, is that it was hugely overrated and stressful and often comes at a cost. I do wonder whether women in general are built for “careers” in a high-stress workplace? Finding a husband after 30 wasn’t easy either. I wonder if future generations of women will do things differently?

It's weird to decide women just aren't cut out for careers because you didn't like it. I had PND after I had my son that was so bad I had suicidal ideation and my husband couldn't work for 6 weeks as I couldn't be left alone with the baby. I'd have to be pretty stupid to take from that that women are not built for looking after babies.

As a rule, most women will want children and unlike men we have a limited window in which to do this. So aggressively pursuing a career may not be in our best interests in the long term because we release our best eggs first so we may be better off having kids young.
Men and women are not the same - our bodies react differently to stress for one thing. I question whether a stressful career is really beneficial for a female.
I had PND as well 🤷🏻‍♀️

MBeat · 13/10/2023 12:11

Also as a mum of 5, yes I have a job. Part time professional now but full time until 35 in a professional job.

I just wanted to. We are happy. Middling income but make it work

MBeat · 13/10/2023 12:07

Coffeerum · 11/10/2023 13:16

I can't say I've ever come across a family in the UK with 5 or more children which didn't stem from religious or cultural reasons, along with a lot of sexism, lack of access to contraception etc.
My own parents are each one of seven and I'm going to go out on a limb based on what I know from their lives and assume my grandmothers would both have limited their reproduction at the time if they could.

First reply. I have 5, no religion, friend has 9. I know quite a few more with 5, or with 11 as a friend of a friend. All made a clear choice.

I think we just start to socialise with each other as it’s easier!

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 11:53

Yes @Webex I understood that.

Webex · 13/10/2023 11:08

no weirder really than deciding large families are bad because you prioritise your career

I make exactly that point in the post you are quoting from - weird to extrapolate from oneself not liking something that women as a whole are not cut out for it.

Zzizzisnotzeproblem · 13/10/2023 10:50

It's weird to decide women just aren't cut out for careers because you didn't like it. no weirder really than deciding large families are bad because you prioritise your career. The joy of living now is that many people just choose what they want to do. It’s a strangely sexist discussion. My husband also has a large number of children, he also wasn’t “addicted” to it. Not even discussed though is it? It’s 2023 not 1950.

elliejjtiny · 13/10/2023 09:57

I have 5. I always wanted 4 because growing up I knew lots of families who had 4 children and they always seemed to have lots of fun together. Also 4 is a good number for make believe games. Dc5 was a contraception failure while dh was on the waiting list to have the snip.

Webex · 13/10/2023 09:48

Upon reflection I would like to have married and had kids younger because I would’ve been able to have more. My experience of “pursuing a career”, something heavily pushed at school in the 90s, is that it was hugely overrated and stressful and often comes at a cost. I do wonder whether women in general are built for “careers” in a high-stress workplace? Finding a husband after 30 wasn’t easy either. I wonder if future generations of women will do things differently?

It's weird to decide women just aren't cut out for careers because you didn't like it. I had PND after I had my son that was so bad I had suicidal ideation and my husband couldn't work for 6 weeks as I couldn't be left alone with the baby. I'd have to be pretty stupid to take from that that women are not built for looking after babies.

BabyFireflyx · 13/10/2023 00:44

For my DSIS it's a get out of work free card. She hates her job but won't put any effort into getting another, plus her partner won't marry her and she won't let it go. She'll skip work for any reason she can think of, always has. I’m not sure how she's still got the job.
She's on baby number 3 now. Her partner is up at 5am every day, working two jobs. He was happy with the first child but didn’t want any more. Thought she was on contraception, then baby number two. Back to work after maternity leave, "contraception fail" again, now on early maternity leave with baby number 3 due in a month. She struggles with the two she has. His mother takes care of them a huge amount of the time. I wish he'd get the snip. Give it a year and baby number 4 will be coming along. Funny thing is, she hates being pregnant.
The mind boggles.

JudyGemstone · 13/10/2023 00:39

Siameasy · 11/10/2023 14:30

Upon reflection I would like to have married and had kids younger because I would’ve been able to have more. My experience of “pursuing a career”, something heavily pushed at school in the 90s, is that it was hugely overrated and stressful and often comes at a cost. I do wonder whether women in general are built for “careers” in a high-stress workplace? Finding a husband after 30 wasn’t easy either. I wonder if future generations of women will do things differently?

You don’t think women are ‘built for careers in a high stress workplace’?!

what are we built for then? Cooking and cleaning and popping out babies?

bit insulting isn’t it. I guess the women doctors, lawyers, engineers, police officers, hedge fund managers etc are barely coping in their jobs and miserable.