Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
OhHelloTheres · 12/10/2023 16:23

I just wanted to point out that for anyone who still thinks Hamas and their supporters all over the world are anti-zionist, not anti-semitic that some Jewish schools in England are going to be closed tomorrow because of an increased threat. Hamas, the so-called "Freedom Fighters", have called upon their supporters to go out and find Jews to kill on Friday the 13th.

Maybe this can go some way to explain why a lot of us feel uncomfortable with anti-Israel rhetoric - we know what the enemy is actually after, and it's not land. It's death to all Jews, including my primary aged children in England.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 16:13

Ah, the ol' "being called racist is just as bad as actually being the victim of racism

Lets wait for her to answer the question please

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 16:12

@Pollyputhekettleon

I do think you're being optimistic, yes. At one point, around 1939, the British proposed that the Jews should just get 500 square miles I think it was. The Arabs still rejected it. Former dhimmis don't get sovereignty on Islamic lands. Lands conquered by Islam cannot be voluntarily handed over to former dhimmis at the request of other non-muslims

When left wing idealists accept this, they will begin to grasp the truth of the situation.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 16:07

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 09:43

I think that is interesting. My own feeling is that people who are happy, prosperous and see a good future for their children don't generally want to go to war. If I was in charge in 47/48 I'd have proposed to the Palestinians that we are here we are staying but we will split the land 50/50, we will ensure that every Palestinian child will go to a school that is as good as the schools Jewish children will go to, that hospitals will be as good and as well resourced in the Palestinian areas as in the Jewish areas, that the laws will be imposed equally regardless of ethnicity or faith, that displaced people will be supported to set up a new life, that investment and development will be equal in both areas, that we will work together to run Israel/Palestine for the benefit of all.

I reckon most Palestinians would be too busy leading their productive comfortable lives to want to have war now. There are always a few extremists so I imagine there would be some Palestinians who want their land back and some Israelis who want to land grab to expand Israel but I reckon the majority would be living together happily now and although it would have been a huge financial commitment for the Israelis in the long run it would have been cheaper than constantly being on war preparations, lives would have been saved and everyone would be happier.

Maybe I am naive but I think it would have been worth a try.

You are right of course. And interestingly Arab Israelis don't want to fight against Israel - they are happy and like their lives so as a rule aren't interested in rocking the boat, because what you say is right.

But it doesn't allow for the reality that, the Arab league weren't and aren't remotely keen on western ideas of democracy and equality being imposed on them. Actually some of our idea of equality are very offensive to them

crimsonfleet · 12/10/2023 16:03

Ah, the ol' "being called racist is just as bad as actually being the victim of racism".

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 16:00

So you want us to let you be racist so you don't feel insulted????

I asked you if I’d said anything antisemitic and you said no. So why were you insinuating I was a racist?

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 15:58

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 06:56

To us, even thinking this implies you feel Jews are sneaky, surreptitious, scheming, deceptive, in a plot to protect Israel...... that makes me really uncomfortable to be honest!

And being accused of being racist is meant to make me feel just fab is it?

So you want us to let you be racist so you don't feel insulted????

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 15:53

Rabin and Arafat came achingly close to a deal during the Clinton era. Arafat wanted sovereignty over Haram Al Sharif / Temple Mount. Rabin offered a 999 year lease. The talks broke up, and Arafat decided he'd try his luck with a terrorist campaign and see if he could get a better deal. The second Intifada started, thousands died, Israel reoccupied parts of Area C, and it has been dysfunctional since.

Ariel Sharon didn’t help matters much tbf

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 15:52

Jeezypeepers · 12/10/2023 03:17

@LemonyTicket I just wanted to jump onto a thread on this that hasn’t filled up yet and thank you for your brilliant (and endlessly patient, despite lots of provocation from a selection of absolute fannies) explanations of the formation of today’s Israel and Palestine.

To the other poster who’s name I can’t remember Blush (French ethnic Jew lady) I’m in a similar position to you in that I’m an atheist, but ethnically Jewish woman living in a small Scottish town (from a big city originally) with zero Jewish population. I’ve also been quizzing my kids today on who knows they’re Jewish Sad. I actually wear a Magen David, as it was my mums, and we have a mezuzah on our door; and I’ve been really swaying about whether I should be removing them both at the moment. I’ve never felt this before in Scotland ever ever. Never unsafe. Now I’m unsure and just so uneasy. And like you we wouldn’t manage in Israel…my kids and I speak zero Hebrew and are just so culturally Scottish. It’s a really unsettling time for us all isn’t it; solidarity to all of us who feel removed from observant judiasm but are still Jewish enough for the antisemites Flowers.

Thanks so much for this. I have literally taken three days off work at this point. But important to at least try and inform people of things if it's going to be a "hot topic".

Jewishness runs deep in Jewish people, because, us being so is really a testament to those who came before us through thousands of years and were brave in ways we can't understand. Generation after generation who refused to convert, refused to give up customs and ways of life in the face of much larger power.

I don't think our religion or nationality or even traditions define us, but we are and always will be a group :)

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 15:21

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 15:14

To those posters with extensive knowledge of the history, as a person more interested in understanding rather than debating on the terminology of words, could I ask you to educate me (others) on the Oslo accord and decision of divide the West Bank in 3 areas

The Oslo accord created the Palestinian National Authority who were meant to partially govern the West Bank and Gaza Strip (but don’t currently)
The settlements were mean to stop but Netanyahu carried on
It wasn’t a massive success.

Rabin and Arafat came achingly close to a deal during the Clinton era. Arafat wanted sovereignty over Haram Al Sharif / Temple Mount. Rabin offered a 999 year lease. The talks broke up, and Arafat decided he'd try his luck with a terrorist campaign and see if he could get a better deal. The second Intifada started, thousands died, Israel reoccupied parts of Area C, and it has been dysfunctional since.

Sharon got elected and decided to withdraw unilaterally from Gaza. It fell out of the control of the sclerotic Palestinian Authority within two years into the hands of the terrorists of Hamas.

No leadership on either side.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 15:14

To those posters with extensive knowledge of the history, as a person more interested in understanding rather than debating on the terminology of words, could I ask you to educate me (others) on the Oslo accord and decision of divide the West Bank in 3 areas

The Oslo accord created the Palestinian National Authority who were meant to partially govern the West Bank and Gaza Strip (but don’t currently)
The settlements were mean to stop but Netanyahu carried on
It wasn’t a massive success.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 15:13

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 14:48

No, but then burning people to death in the streets and cutting their heads off live on telegram with a spade wasn't very nuanced either. I don't think it's a situation which demands much nuance

Easy for me to say since I’m not involved, I know I’m being a bit of a keyboard warrior, but the violence is mutual isn’t it?
Also if the Palestinians are stonewalled at every turn (politically) then extremist loons are going to end up in charge.

No, the violence is not mutual.

There are serious wrongs committed in the West Bank, particularly by the settler extremists. Stones are thrown; olive trees are burned. A day ago there were 3 murders by masked gunmen. It's shameful, a bit like Kosovo or Cyprus or Northern Ireland levels of community hostility with state backing for one side.

The people of the Gaza border settlements are the most left wing, peace loving people in all of Israel, and they bore the brunt of the Islamic State style massacre.

It's not a competition. One does not excuse the other. I reject strongly any suggestion of a link of causation.

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 15:11

I think to move forward, the focus needs to be on the West Bank as it stands now. Not looking at history but how it is divided now.

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 15:07

So Islam will always grow, and Judaism will always shrink
I was surprised to read this in regards to the law of return in regards to the last group. That would make me eligible, something that has never ever even crossed my mind.

The law since 1970 applies to the following groups:Those born Jews according to the Orthodox interpretation; having a Jewish mother or maternal grandmother. Those with Jewish ancestry – having a Jewish father or grandfather

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 15:05

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 14:55

To those posters with extensive knowledge of the history, as a person more interested in understanding rather than debating on the terminology of words, could I ask you to educate me (others) on the Oslo accord and decision of divide the West Bank in 3 areas.

As an uneducated person, I just can't fathom the logic behind the division of areas in such small fragments. I assume it has to do with socio-geographical location of villages/town but it makes for such an odd arrangement. I'd love to also understand better what life in in area B. Does it mean Jews and Palestinians are managing to live in agreement in those regions? Why did that come about?

There seem so little explained about the West Bank as it stands now with all the focus- understandbly- being on Gaza.

At the moment Area B is in a shameful state of apartheid. Jewish settlements expand; Arab settlements are denied a permit and demolished. There are checkpoints. Jewish thugs roam around destroying agricultural produce with impunity and the law is not enforced. The right wing extremists are trying to drive out the Arabs from the West Bank, which is why they ignored Gaza.

There has been an unspoken confluence of interest between the Israeli far right and Hamas, which will be spoken about more after this war has concluded. For now it suffices that the forces of moderation have been invited into the emergency unity government.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 14:59

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 12/10/2023 14:18

I didn't mean to imply they were.

I was asking how you stop violence when one side refuses to do so?

If Israel adopted a passivist stance tomorrow, returned land, and recognised Palestine as a nation state would that stop the violence?

I don't think it would because elements of the other side see the entirity of that region as theirs alone and feel duty bound to wage war until every inch is under their control.

To me that element has to be removed before any hope of progress.

We've made peace with Jordan and Egypt, and please God we will make peace with the Palestinians.

We did not make peace by turning the other cheek and by pacifism. If we did that now they will rape and burn our girls in Tel Aviv.

We cannot make peace with the Islamic State of Hamas. Sometimes war is the right answer, and this is such a time. There will need to be a political settlement later, and I do hope the Palestinian Authority, Egypt and Qatar will engage productively after the war has achieved its aim.

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 14:55

To those posters with extensive knowledge of the history, as a person more interested in understanding rather than debating on the terminology of words, could I ask you to educate me (others) on the Oslo accord and decision of divide the West Bank in 3 areas.

As an uneducated person, I just can't fathom the logic behind the division of areas in such small fragments. I assume it has to do with socio-geographical location of villages/town but it makes for such an odd arrangement. I'd love to also understand better what life in in area B. Does it mean Jews and Palestinians are managing to live in agreement in those regions? Why did that come about?

There seem so little explained about the West Bank as it stands now with all the focus- understandbly- being on Gaza.

INeedAnotherName · 12/10/2023 14:52

Before this thread gets any weirder I would like to thank the more informative posters as I have learnt some things.

I particularly would like to thank @CoughingMajoress for the paragraph below. I never understood why it was so bad, but you have truely provided a lightbulb moment.

For example, one of the most dangerous stereotypes about Jews is that we're money grubbing and I've had a lot of people not understand why that's a bad thing, because "surely being good with money is a good thing?" But to understand why this trope exists and why it's so dangerous, requires understanding literally centuries of Jewish history. This stereotype IS very very dangerous and it's literally been used to justify multiple genocides. After the Treaty of Versailles, the German government weaponised this stereotype via massive propaganda campaigns to blame Germany's poverty on Jews hoarding the money, rather than acknowledge their own responsibility for the huge financial penalties forced upon Germany after WWI; that propaganda campaign (which would not have existed if not for centuries of Jews being cast as money grubbing, a stereotype that goes back to the era when Jews were forced into jobs as money lenders, then penalised by Medieval Christians for the jobs they'd forced Jews into) very directly led to the Holocaust.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 14:48

No, but then burning people to death in the streets and cutting their heads off live on telegram with a spade wasn't very nuanced either. I don't think it's a situation which demands much nuance

Easy for me to say since I’m not involved, I know I’m being a bit of a keyboard warrior, but the violence is mutual isn’t it?
Also if the Palestinians are stonewalled at every turn (politically) then extremist loons are going to end up in charge.

CoughingMajoress · 12/10/2023 14:42

A lot of Islamic extremists don't think Jews should be allowed to exist anywhere, though, not just in Israel.

If it was just about Israel then we wouldn't see regular attacks and high level security on synagogues and Jewish cultural centres in Britain, America, France, Germany, Sweden, etc. etc.

I think what's missing from the debate is that Islam and Judaism are fundamentally structurally very different religions. Islam is a religion of conquest and proselytization; they actively want the whole world to be Muslim. Jews actively discourage non-Jews from becoming Jewish, if you're not born Jewish then you can't become Jewish unless you're very very dedicated and willing to put in a ton of study and effort. So Islam will always grow, and Judaism will always shrink. Islam wants to grow, convert, colonise, because that's what the religion is based on: to spread and convert as much as possible. It's why Sharia Law enforcement exists, it's why Iran has military forces brutalising women to force them into observing Fundamentalist Islamic practices against their consent. That would never ever happen in Judaism, no non-Jew would ever be forced into being Jewish because that actively contradicts the basic tenet of Judaism, which is that it is a non-missionary religion.

That's why more than a quarter of the world's population is Muslim, while Jews make up just 0.2% of the world's population.

SnowflakeCity · 12/10/2023 14:30

Poudretteite · 12/10/2023 12:58

Exactly this.

Israel's position is 'we deserve to exist.' Hamas' position is 'no, you don't.'

We have not seen Pro-Israeli celebrations spreading graffiti in Muslim areas, chanting genocidal slogans, setting off fireworks, shouting 'gas the Muslims,' or cheering the death toll.

I feel like there is a certain amount of gaslighting involved in this way of thinking tbh.
Isreal: We deserve to exist(in your homes and on your land).
Palestinian: But that's my home you can't just take it.
Israel: Calm down, why are you always so angry, jeez, we just want to exist.
Palestinian: But those are illegal settlements, you can't just take what you want.
Israel: Ffs, it's no wonder we lock you up, you are so unreasonable. Look what we have to live with when we just want the right to exist 🙄

usernamealreadytaken · 12/10/2023 14:24

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:20

Yes I agree. But I genuinely don't believe I am antisemitic, as in against someone on the grounds that they are Jewish. I've interned/lived in Israel and I've had this conversation many a time with people (who I'm good friends with). There are many Jews who are anti Zionist, so by default they are antisemitic too. What about ultra orthodox groups such as Satmar, who are very observant Jews, but anti Zionist. How would one argue that they are antisemites?

Thanks, that really interesting context. My point was not concerning Orthodox groups, it was specifically that if you were speaking to a (any) Jewish person currently, and they personally took your views as being anti-Semitic, would you still be entirely comfortable, both from the point that you aren't Jewish, and a Jewish person considers those views anti-Semitic? It has parallels with people who have opinions on black/Asian/Muslim issues, but cannot see those issues from the side of the affected person.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 12/10/2023 14:18

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 14:06

I don't accept this cycle of violence rhetoric as it seems to deprive human beings of the choice not to respond to provocation with murder, rape, kidnap, execution by immolation, and torture.

The occupation of the West Bank is not justified by our caused by these atrocities.

These atrocities are not justified by or caused by the occupation.

I didn't mean to imply they were.

I was asking how you stop violence when one side refuses to do so?

If Israel adopted a passivist stance tomorrow, returned land, and recognised Palestine as a nation state would that stop the violence?

I don't think it would because elements of the other side see the entirity of that region as theirs alone and feel duty bound to wage war until every inch is under their control.

To me that element has to be removed before any hope of progress.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 14:15

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 14:06

There are a lot of obvious similarities between palestians now and Germany after ww1. Are you saying that Germans in the nazi era were uniquely evil? That is not true (although Hitler himself was an extreme case). The conditions that created Nazi Germany could happen in any country.

One major similarity is feeling oppressed and hard done by, giving the opportunity for leaders who promise nationalist glory.

Of course, since its creation Israel has been under threat from its neighbours on all sides which has also led to a strongly nationalist government there too.

Interference from the US and Iran is a complicating feature that didn't apply to Germany.

But humans are humans, underneath our skin we are all the same and given the same conditions will behave very similarly.

"but in every generation they stand up against us to wipe us out, and God saves us from their hands"

Passover Haggadah

ForFriends · 12/10/2023 14:14

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 14:06

There are a lot of obvious similarities between palestians now and Germany after ww1. Are you saying that Germans in the nazi era were uniquely evil? That is not true (although Hitler himself was an extreme case). The conditions that created Nazi Germany could happen in any country.

One major similarity is feeling oppressed and hard done by, giving the opportunity for leaders who promise nationalist glory.

Of course, since its creation Israel has been under threat from its neighbours on all sides which has also led to a strongly nationalist government there too.

Interference from the US and Iran is a complicating feature that didn't apply to Germany.

But humans are humans, underneath our skin we are all the same and given the same conditions will behave very similarly.

There are a lot of obvious similarities between palestians now and Germany after ww1.

Which similarities?