Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Tandora · 12/10/2023 18:11

CoughingMajoress · 11/10/2023 13:24

If you aren't Jewish just shut up. It's not appropriate for people who aren't minorities to lecture to minorities about what is and isn't racism.

Society is generally very poorly educated and bad about recognising antisemitism because a lot of antisemitism is insidious and uses propaganda and stereotypes, in ways society doesn't always recognise as damaging. For example, one of the most dangerous stereotypes about Jews is that we're money grubbing and I've had a lot of people not understand why that's a bad thing, because "surely being good with money is a good thing?" But to understand why this trope exists and why it's so dangerous, requires understanding literally centuries of Jewish history. This stereotype IS very very dangerous and it's literally been used to justify multiple genocides. After the Treaty of Versailles, the German government weaponised this stereotype via massive propaganda campaigns to blame Germany's poverty on Jews hoarding the money, rather than acknowledge their own responsibility for the huge financial penalties forced upon Germany after WWI; that propaganda campaign (which would not have existed if not for centuries of Jews being cast as money grubbing, a stereotype that goes back to the era when Jews were forced into jobs as money lenders, then penalised by Medieval Christians for the jobs they'd forced Jews into) very directly led to the Holocaust.

And I bet anything someone will come along in a minute and accuse me of being yet another Jew who won't stop blathering about the Holocaust.

There's a huge amount of antisemitism wrapped up in antizionism, and a lot of people frankly don't give a fuck about Palestine and are just using it to have a pop at Jews.

Every Jewish person is expected to have an opinion on Israel, is held responsible for Israel, there's been a big wave of antisemitic attacks in the UK over the past few days, in a way that would never happen in any similar situation. The Chinese government literally have concentration camps were religious minorities are tortured and mass murdered (including being killed to order for the illegal organ trade) and it gets almost zero media attention and no Chinese person in the UK would be judged or asked their opinion about the actions of their government, yet Jews - many of whom have no connection to Israel - don't get the same grace.

That's why so much antizionism is antisemitic.

And yet you can't talk about Israel without understanding the history of how Israel was created, and how it's been used as a weapon by geopolitical forces (eg the way the US and USSR used the Middle East as a staging ground for proxy war during the Cold War, or how the USA is using Israel to prevent the Middle East from becoming one big Islamic fundamentalist superstate, or how the US is using Israel as a tactical intelligence centre in the Middle East and how this relates to oil wealth, or how the US religious right extremists support Israel because of Biblical Literalism which is not exactly Jewish-friendly) and how much Jews have been abused and exploited in that process. Israel was created because Europe wanted to get rid of all the Jews after WWII, and not give back all the land and wealth that was stolen from European Jews during the war. I mean Israel was nearly in Uganda for God's sake, no one cared about Jewish people, only getting rid of them.

And people don't understand just how minuscule a minority we are. Jews make up just 0.2% of the world's population. Muslims make up 24% of the world's population, and Christians make up 31%. That is an INSANE disparity.

Plus, Jews only have one single miniscule country to call our own where we can be safe (after centuries of non-stop persecution and multiple genocides). There are nearly FIFTY Muslim countries, and many of those countries are extremely wealthy and could protect and home the entire population of Palestine if they wanted to. The rest of the Arab world has either turned its back on Palestine, or is (in the case of Iran) actively bombing infrastructure in Gaza and funding terrorism that will actively harm Palestinians because Iran wants to kill all Jews, and doesn't care how many Palestinians are hurt or killed in the process.

I'm not defending the actions of the Israeli government, no one I know agrees with the violent oppression and apartheid of the current government. Everyone I know has serious concerns about Israel's swing to the far right and the growing power the ultra-religious have in Israeli politics. And this systemic violent oppression is not just of the Palestinians, but of minority groups within Israel, such as Israeli Bedouin. Systemic violent oppression of Israeli Bedouin by the Israeli government is just as bad, yet somehow the world media don't give the tiniest shit. Most people outside Israel have never even heard of this! And that raises the question, why is the plight of some oppressed people (like Palestinians) a massive worldwide issue, while the plight of other equally oppressed people (like Bedouin, or Muslim Uyghurs in China) goes totally ignored? What political agenda is being served by this cherry picking?

This post is brilliant and should be read by all. It’s exactly this.

The only bit I don’t really agree with is the idea that the Palestinians could have another home in another Muslim state.

Otherwise this post is so important to be said. Heard and understood,

YABU OP

quiteoldad · 12/10/2023 18:04

@ Lemony
Yes, but bear in mind that Jews living under Dhimmi in Muslim lands were not having to do so because they were Jewish, it was because they were not Muslims. They were not being singled out*

Why does this make a difference?

A lot of the narrative on here has suggested that Jews were being
singled out under Dhimmi because they were Jews. Patently untrue in this
instance.

I can't even respond to the rest of your post. It just sounds like one long
"it wasn't that bad"

Indeed, as I said in my post, persecution in the Arab lands was not as bad as it was in Eastern Europe.

What is the point of it?
Comparison, context, that there was more accord between Jew and
Muslim the middle east than there was between Jew and Christian and many other points...which if you are unable to see on first read, then maybe read again.

What point are you actually trying to make?

That we should have just lived with it?
Where did I ever say that? That is just nonsense to even suggest I implied that.

I really am not sure at all what point you are trying to make (That's the third time you've said that) but for three days now everything you post seems to have the aim of undermining Jews or Israel and minimising anything they suffered. If that's what you want to see in my posts, then you are entitled to do so. Obviously you haven't seen all of them. You must have missed where I wrote;

Rather than shout in anger about baby killers and murderers and retribution, funnel your energy into thinking about what might be a possible solution to the conflict.

Please stop listing the atrocities carried out by your "opponent" thinking that if their abominations are worse than yours then it puts you on the higher moral ground. It doesn't.

Neither Hamas nor the state of Israel have anything to be proud of, they are both in the gutter. Think about working towards a resolution to the conflict.

The dead are now dead, that cannot be changed, try to make some suggestions, so that there isn't further, senseless killing.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:59

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 17:12

On the 'is this racist?' vein - I was reading something recently about children in nursery. They were asked to pick colouring pens and one child said black was the worst colour (it didn't state but I assume this child was white). A child present was mixed race and told their (Black) mother, who felt this was a racist incident. The nursery investigated, felt it wasn't racially motivated but the mother wasn't happy. How do we prove that this was racism? Do we brand this child (and no doubt it's parents) racist because the mother felt it was?

Very easily.

Here is the Jerusalem Declaration:
https://jerusalemdeclaration.org/

Here is the IHRA definition:
https://www.holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definitions-charters/working-definition-antisemitism

They are very short, one page each, but include things like

"Applying double standards by requiring of it a behavior not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation"

Such as .....Palestine! Which is why I spend time pointing out the double standards people are applying - which is text book antisemitism.

If it isn't on those two pages, it is not antisemitism.

Also, children choosing coloured pencils isn't mandated on the definition of afrophobia. But good job trying to imply our objections were ridiculous :)

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 17:56

because you had literally just said your immediate response to a Jew saying something was antisemitic was to assume they were lying to stop israel being criticised!

I never meant to imply anyone was lying. It’s just it’s a bit difficult to believe that anyone would really think I want a nation totalled and a people rounded up and killed. So it seems like rhetoric to me.

I mean if you actually read my posts I am not calling for the destruction of Israel, or victory for Hammas, or persecution of the Jews, or claiming that Israel are attempting genocide or that Israel shouldn’t defend itself or that Hammas aren’t terrorists.

Ive said that the partition was a mistake, the Arab Palestinians who lived there at the time did have a claim to the land (irrespective of whether Palestine was a “real” country) because, well, they lived there, the land grabs are wrong and Ariel Sharon was not broken hearted when the
Second Intifada started.

And you responded by saying I’m a child sitting on her hands trying not to be racist. This disprove that if you criticise Isreal you get accused of antisemitism in what way?

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:54

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 17:00

@LemonyTicket you cannot make any response without whataboutery. When someone asks you about how the Israeli policy treats Palestinians you start talking about Hamas and Jews under Arab rule. It is possible to seperate the issues. It very much comes across as you think the inhumane treatment is justified. I'm not saying that in a goady way BTW.

This entire post is nonsense. You have come to a thread which is about ANTISEMITISM. And used it to bash Israel for about 14 pages now.

This isn't about how bad Israel is.

It is about where the line of criticising Israel ends and becomes antisemitic.

When you drone on for 14 pages about how oppressive Israel is and completely ignore the fact that Palestine has one of the worst human rights records on the globe, where Amnesty describes eye watering abuses of it's own people, who are not being given even the right to VOTE then you are evidently "holding Israel to standards to which you do not hold any other nation" (which is the definition of antisemitism.

If oppression bothers you: oppression by BOTH needs to bother you

If killing bothers you: killing by BOTH needs to bother you.

If someone pointing out this prejudice to you is "whataboutery" in your eyes, then that's troubling. If you really wanted to consider antisemitism, which is implied by your presence on this thread - then a more beneficial response might be "hmm, I guess I do hold one to a higher standard than the other"

Instead you imply I am biased for pointing out your bias.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:40

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 16:13

Ah, the ol' "being called racist is just as bad as actually being the victim of racism

Lets wait for her to answer the question please

This was the exchange between us:

YOU: when Jews tell me I am being antisemitic I generally think they are just saying so to stifle criticism of Israel

ME: Why? Isn't that implying Jews are dishonest, sneaky, up to something?

YOU: Well it's not very nice being called a racist either

So basically a Jew can't say to you that you are being antisemitic because a) you don't like being called a racist and b) they are probably lying anyway because Jews do that and you think you are the hard done by one in this conversation?

Oh my goodness

I've lived 46 years without anyone accusing me of being antisemitic, so like I said if it's regularly happening to you maybe you should do some thinking.

I don't think you have said anything antisemitic on this thread, but if I am honest, throughout it - you and one other person have seemed very much like they were needling.

My impression is that you are on this thread to prove something - ie: that Jews need to stop complaining about antisemitism or something along those lines

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 17:40

@LemonyTicket, why have you picked up on the two posts I wrote that was a matter of opinion which you challenged (although repeating the sam thing in regards to oppression) which is fin but won't lead to anything productive yet ignored the one message when I asked questions to help better understand what is happening, which frankly is much more interesting.

I'll ask again. Can you, or of course anyone else, explain better the CURRENT situation in the West Bank. Precisely, How different or not is it for Jews and Palestinians living in area A, B or C? For example, do both Jews and Palestinians work as teachers in all 3 areas, and are the schools opened to both children? How about hospitals?

We know more or less what life is like in Gazza. I am interested in understanding what it's like in the West Bank.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:35

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 16:00

So you want us to let you be racist so you don't feel insulted????

I asked you if I’d said anything antisemitic and you said no. So why were you insinuating I was a racist?

Edited

because you had literally just said your immediate response to a Jew saying something was antisemitic was to assume they were lying to stop israel being criticised!

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:33

quiteoldad · 12/10/2023 17:25

Yes, but bear in mind that Jews living under Dhimmi in Muslim lands were not having to do so because they were Jewish, it was because they were not Muslims. They were not being singled out. Dhimmi applied to the Christians, Hindus sikhs Zoroastrians etc equally. Whilst certainly not being an ideal state of affairs for Jews in these land it was certainly preferable, during the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries, to being in Europe, especially Eastern Europe. Zionism sprung up late 19C from the oppression of Eastern European Jews. It was a European led movement. It suited the British because it would stop the waves of poor Jews who were coming over from Poland and Russia in the late 19C, early 20C. They were filling up the East End of London and parts of Manchester, Leeds and other centres. If they could have somewhere else to go, that would be great. And so Balfour, just before WW1, in which the declaration made no mention at all of Palestinians, despite the fact that they made up over 90% of the people living on the land under discussion. Then WW1, then all the shit with Sykes, Pico and the promises made to the Arabs and the Jews, not all of which could be kept.

Meanwhile, over in the middle east, Jews lived under Dhimmi were not really thinking about Zionism. They had integrated in the Arab countries and although not having equal status, their lives were not so miserable that they felt the need to move out, like those of Europe did. Relatively few Arab Jews came to the UK. Only when the troubles started in what was Palestine in the 1930 did things get nastier for Jews in Arab lands and they felt the need to leave.
That is my understanding, please feel free to correct.

Yes, but bear in mind that Jews living under Dhimmi in Muslim lands were not having to do so because they were Jewish, it was because they were not Muslims. They were not being singled out*

Why does this make a difference?

I can't even respond to the rest of your post. It just sounds like one long "it wasn't that bad"

What is the point of it?

What point are you actually trying to make?

That we should have just lived with it?

I really am not sure at all what point you are trying to make but for three days now everything you post seems to have the aim of undermining Jews or Israel and minimising anything they suffered

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:27

INeedAnotherName · 12/10/2023 14:52

Before this thread gets any weirder I would like to thank the more informative posters as I have learnt some things.

I particularly would like to thank @CoughingMajoress for the paragraph below. I never understood why it was so bad, but you have truely provided a lightbulb moment.

For example, one of the most dangerous stereotypes about Jews is that we're money grubbing and I've had a lot of people not understand why that's a bad thing, because "surely being good with money is a good thing?" But to understand why this trope exists and why it's so dangerous, requires understanding literally centuries of Jewish history. This stereotype IS very very dangerous and it's literally been used to justify multiple genocides. After the Treaty of Versailles, the German government weaponised this stereotype via massive propaganda campaigns to blame Germany's poverty on Jews hoarding the money, rather than acknowledge their own responsibility for the huge financial penalties forced upon Germany after WWI; that propaganda campaign (which would not have existed if not for centuries of Jews being cast as money grubbing, a stereotype that goes back to the era when Jews were forced into jobs as money lenders, then penalised by Medieval Christians for the jobs they'd forced Jews into) very directly led to the Holocaust.

The overriding theme of things is that Jews were forced, due to prejudice, into certain jobs. Then later, they were blamed for it.

There is so much rhetoric about Jews having empires, being rich, being at the top of business and so on, but they weren't allowed to work at lawfirms, so the made their own. They weren't allowed to work at hospitals so they built their own. They weren't allowed to work in theatres and no one would put on shows in their language so they built a movie industry too. In the 20s and 30s when they were arriving in American they had every door slammed in their face so they had to build their own power structures as they were shut out of existing ones.

So this is why they are often disproportionately present in some professions - they had to build their own empire because no one wanted them in theirs!

quiteoldad · 12/10/2023 17:25

Yes, but bear in mind that Jews living under Dhimmi in Muslim lands were not having to do so because they were Jewish, it was because they were not Muslims. They were not being singled out. Dhimmi applied to the Christians, Hindus sikhs Zoroastrians etc equally. Whilst certainly not being an ideal state of affairs for Jews in these land it was certainly preferable, during the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries, to being in Europe, especially Eastern Europe. Zionism sprung up late 19C from the oppression of Eastern European Jews. It was a European led movement. It suited the British because it would stop the waves of poor Jews who were coming over from Poland and Russia in the late 19C, early 20C. They were filling up the East End of London and parts of Manchester, Leeds and other centres. If they could have somewhere else to go, that would be great. And so Balfour, just before WW1, in which the declaration made no mention at all of Palestinians, despite the fact that they made up over 90% of the people living on the land under discussion. Then WW1, then all the shit with Sykes, Pico and the promises made to the Arabs and the Jews, not all of which could be kept.

Meanwhile, over in the middle east, Jews lived under Dhimmi were not really thinking about Zionism. They had integrated in the Arab countries and although not having equal status, their lives were not so miserable that they felt the need to move out, like those of Europe did. Relatively few Arab Jews came to the UK. Only when the troubles started in what was Palestine in the 1930 did things get nastier for Jews in Arab lands and they felt the need to leave.
That is my understanding, please feel free to correct.

Brightlyshining · 12/10/2023 17:21

I don't usually comment on these sorts of threads, but there seem to be several people here who do actually want to learn, so I'm commenting here.

Every time something happens in Israel, antisemitic incidents increase in many parts of the world, including the UK. This week there's been a huge increase in reported incidents. All these people saying that being anti-Israel isn't the same thing as antisemitism, yet it's clearly all interlinked because otherwise we wouldn't get this increase in hate crimes that correlate with the situation in the Middle East.

Not only do a lot of people not know the difference between anti-Zionism and antisemitism, there are actually a shocking number of people out there who don't even know the difference between Israeli citizens, and Jewish people around the world of various nationalities. I've met several people who thought that all Jewish people were Israeli. Yes, really. I'm a British citizen. As someone mentioned much earlier in the thread, there is antisemitism in the way people demand that all Jewish people around the world must explain their views on Israel, or apologise every time something happens etc. I've also met people who said that Israel is the very reason for antisemitism and no wonder people hate Jews after all that's happened - all while conveniently ignoring the fact that antisemitism has existed for thousands of years, and they never seem to find an explanation for that.

In terms of criticising Israel and its government, a lot of antisemitism comes from context and oh-so-convenient timing. So, while "Free Palestine" might not sound antisemitic in isolation, when it's deliberately painted on a bridge in the middle of Golders Green (this actually happened a few days ago), then yes it's antisemitic because it's done deliberately to antagonise.

I've been in a situation where a random bloke has walked up to me in a public place, out of nowhere, and started saying how awful it was that children were dying in Gaza. I hadn't even said anything, I was just sitting there waiting for a friend, and yet this guy had walked up to an obviously Jewish person and started talking about Gaza. This is absolutely antisemitism. I wasn't even doing anything at the time.

I've been in a situation where I walked into a room where two non-Jewish people were reading the papers, and as soon as I walked in, the woman immediately started saying to her husband how shocked she was by everything happening in Palestine that week, again apropos of nothing. They weren't even talking, but as soon as a Jewish person walked into the room, they conveniently started having a conversation about Israel. This is really not okay.

And online, a frequent occurence is that there'll be a thread about antisemitism in the UK, or an incident that happened etc, and a random person will come along and comment with "Freedom for Palestine!" when we weren't even talking about the Middle East. Again, this is antisemitic because it wasn't even the topic of conversation and you're doing the online equivalent of the things I've mentioned above.

This stuff happens all. the. time. And you know what's really sad is that I've experienced way more of this from left wing people compared to right wing. I've met a few right wing extremists and they've actually told me straight out that they don't like Jews, and much as that bothers me, at least they're more honest about it. Left wing people are far more dishonest, dressing up their antisemitism with academic rhetoric, or Palestine solidarity etc, when there's clearly antisemitism behind it because it's phrased in the most antagonistic way. As has been mentioned several times throughout this thread, a lot of antisemitic people jump on board the Free Palestine movement because it gives them an excuse to say antisemitic stuff.

Oh, and I don't usually go around correcting people's spelling online, but I've lost count of the number of people who claim to be experts in these things yet can't even spell Israel. Is-ra-el. A before E. At least get the basics right.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:16

SnowflakeCity · 12/10/2023 14:30

I feel like there is a certain amount of gaslighting involved in this way of thinking tbh.
Isreal: We deserve to exist(in your homes and on your land).
Palestinian: But that's my home you can't just take it.
Israel: Calm down, why are you always so angry, jeez, we just want to exist.
Palestinian: But those are illegal settlements, you can't just take what you want.
Israel: Ffs, it's no wonder we lock you up, you are so unreasonable. Look what we have to live with when we just want the right to exist 🙄

This is a narrative you have formed. What is more realistic is the reality that both groups of people lived on this land, one a minority who had been there longer, and the other a majority who had - for hundreds of years - held the minority in dhimmitude in an effective apartheid scenario

When that "empire" was over, both those groups wanted to rule the land. A careful and detailed investigation into what was right and fair was done, and it was decided two states would be created.

The Arab League didn't war against Israel because it wanted Arab Palestinians to have their homes - actually it happily watches as they have done and does nothing. They went to war against Israel so the Jewish Dhimmi did not dare to have power over territory they felt - after hundreds of years of Ottoman dominance over JEWISH land - they they owned the entire place.

That is all.

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 17:12

On the 'is this racist?' vein - I was reading something recently about children in nursery. They were asked to pick colouring pens and one child said black was the worst colour (it didn't state but I assume this child was white). A child present was mixed race and told their (Black) mother, who felt this was a racist incident. The nursery investigated, felt it wasn't racially motivated but the mother wasn't happy. How do we prove that this was racism? Do we brand this child (and no doubt it's parents) racist because the mother felt it was?

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 17:10

You have spent the whole thread throwing out energy of a child sitting on it's hands trying not to take a biscuit it really want to take

No I haven’t

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:09

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 14:04

There's also a big difference between disagreeing with the creation of Israel, and thinking it should be destroyed now.

Yes, it’s done now and Israel exists. Due to the way it came about and the conditions in the Palestinian Territories is also inflicted with terrorism. Obviously they are going to fight the terrorists.
What irks me is attitudes like that of a pp who seem to feel their enemies are “evil” and they are, and always will be, the victims. It’s not a very nuanced view is it?

Edited

This is because you don't like the idea of Jews as the victim. You have spent the whole thread throwing out energy of a child sitting on it's hands trying not to take a biscuit it really want to take

The Nazis who wanted to exterminate Jews were evil

The broader leadership of the middle east who shared Nazi antisemitic ideology and conspired with them, were also evil

The remaining people (like Hamas) who STILL share Nazi ideology of wanting to exterminate Jews are and always will be evil

And Jews will always be the victim of that.

Perhaps we make better victims when we go quietly into showers, but the way you are trying to shame this woman is shameful

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 17:05

Just to be clear, the MacPherson principle did not state that if a complainant believes something to be racist that it is racist. It said it should be investigated as such. There is a difference.

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 17:00

@LemonyTicket you cannot make any response without whataboutery. When someone asks you about how the Israeli policy treats Palestinians you start talking about Hamas and Jews under Arab rule. It is possible to seperate the issues. It very much comes across as you think the inhumane treatment is justified. I'm not saying that in a goady way BTW.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 17:00

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 13:27

Lots of racists are comfortable with their own views, and don't listen when others tell them they are racist
I really struggle with this concept.

It so reminds me when I took the decision to move to sleep in another room. My husband kept going on about how it meant I didn't love him anymore (analogy for being told I'm racist). I explained that I did love him but his snoring really affected my sleep so I had to move. He insisted that loving people sleep in the same bed, so moving meant I stopped loving him. The more I tried to explain, theore I was told I was showing all the signs I'd stopped loving him.

Should I have just accepted that if he felt unloved, it meant that it was and it was all down to me?

This weird analogy is just more or the same avoidance.

Racism is so simple.

If the victim says it's racist, and the textbooks say it's racist, and lots of others are saying "hey that's racist"

Just don't say it.

The MacPherson principle states: "In the report, Macpherson offered as a principle that all complaints about incidents of racism should be recorded and investigated as such, when they are perceived by the complainant or someone else as acts of racism"

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 16:51

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 13:10

Similarly, oppression. I don't object to the use of the word (whilst genocide felt like serious hyperbole). They do oppress Palestinians. But my question is why do you feel this is unique to them? Hamas oppress their own citizens with worse human rights abuses by a considerable measure. Jews are again, oppressed similarly by almost every Arab state. Historically, Jews lived for 600 years as Dhimmi to Muslims, which is my definition - "oppression" and "Apartheid" in it's worst forms
Oppression happens in all aspect of life at higher and lower levels. If a man oppresses his wife, can she says that she can oppress his children from a first marriage because her husband does it to her? Or that their own mother dies it to them at their residence home so why is the finger pointed at the SM? Pointing that other generations have done harm so it justifies doing the same to the next to next generation isn't ok.

I agree to so many things you say but the above comes across as shifting responsibility. It might not be the most important matter, it might not be the worse, but it remains something that has a negative impact.

This is an account of the dhimmitude under which Jews lived in their homeland of the middle east under Muslim rule. It is - quite literally - apartheid

https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-treatment-of-jews-in-arab-islamic-countries

Here is Amnesty's 2022 report on Hamas' oppression of it's own people

https://www.amnesty.org/en/location/middle-east-and-north-africa/palestine-state-of/report-palestine-state-of/

They are one of the most oppressive governments on earth. Hence calling Israel "oppressive" seems to be a very distorted way to see it.

The Treatment of Jews in Arab/Islamic Countries

Encyclopedia of Jewish and Israeli history, politics and culture, with biographies, statistics, articles and documents on topics from anti-Semitism to Zionism.

https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-treatment-of-jews-in-arab-islamic-countries

Angrycat2768 · 12/10/2023 16:43

"we will ensure that every Palestinian child will go to a school that is as good as the schools Jewish children will go to, that hospitals will be as good and as well resourced in the Palestinian areas as in the Jewish areas, that the laws will be imposed equally regardless of ethnicity or faith, that displaced people will be supported to set up a new life, that investment and development will be equal in both areas, that we will work together to run Israel/Palestine fir the benefit of all"

But if there was a 2 state solution, why would it be up to Israel to do these things? Palestine would be its own self-governing country, as it is now under Hamas and the Palestinian authority in the West Bank. It would be up to their government to provide all of those things. Unfortunately, their government is not interested in that. They are interested in terrorism, destroying Israel, and using their resources for warmongering and the people they are supposed to be providing for. Afghanistan is self-governing now and was before 9/11. They did not provide schools and hospitals. They beheaded people threw them off buildings and stopped girls from going to school. They are not all poor innocents corrupted by British colonialism to the point that 80 years later, they can not think for themselves. They are power-hungry Islamists who don't care for anything or anyone apart from themselves and use something some other warlord 1000 years ago said to justify what they want, cheered on by British Leftists living comfortably in London dreaming about overthrowing Capitalism while they benefit from it.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 16:43

CRITICISING THE ISRAELI GOVERNMENT
is NOT antisemitic
You can even attack them aggressively for their specific actions

SAYING ISRAEL HAS NO RIGHT TO EXIST (and claiming zionism is "genocide")
IS antisemitic
Because it is denying the right of Jews to self determination and flourishing in their own state

Yeah I’m the former not the latter. One take away I have from this thread is that anti-Zionism is taken to mean the destruction of Israel rather than just disapproval of its governments right wing tendencies. As I said before in that case I am not anti Zionist.

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 16:43

usernamealreadytaken · 12/10/2023 14:24

Thanks, that really interesting context. My point was not concerning Orthodox groups, it was specifically that if you were speaking to a (any) Jewish person currently, and they personally took your views as being anti-Semitic, would you still be entirely comfortable, both from the point that you aren't Jewish, and a Jewish person considers those views anti-Semitic? It has parallels with people who have opinions on black/Asian/Muslim issues, but cannot see those issues from the side of the affected person.

Obviously it isn't pleasant, but if a Jewish person wants to call me antisemitic I believe in free speech, I wouldn't be offended. Whilst I have no doubt that some antisemitics attack the notion of zionism as a method of attacking Jews, I do believe there are people who are anti Zionist without being antisemitic. It's interesting that Jews are allowed to be anti Zionist without being labelled antisemitic (the reasons of their anti Zionist sentiment are irrelevant). I very much do feel that within the context of Israel/Palestine it is a tool to silence any form of dissent towards Israel.
It's very hard to judge tone on the Internet, so I want to make it very clear that my posts are not angry/shout/aggressive etc, in person I've had many a good discussion with friends in Israel who have a range of opinions on this matter. We didn't always agree, but we agreed to disagree and are friends. And I have no 'skin' here, I went to Israel very open minded to do an internship with an Israeli NGO. What I saw over time though completely changed my mind and still haunts me years later.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 16:43

@andtheworldrollson

It's not love - and it helps to keep the hatred and fear going for generations- is that the future you want for your children?

Was it love that motivated the Germans during the nazi years ? No it was fear and self preservation and it led to great evil

In am sorry, but I just cannot let this slide.

The Germans did not become complicit in the Holocaust because they were "scared". They were motivated by antisemitism. They were motivated by the same ideas that led to our previous genocides, pogrums and massacres that Jews were uniquely terrible, and therefore them being treated badly was probably okay.

German people were not "scared" when they voted voluntarily for Hitler. He had been one of the most famous speakers in Germany for over 10 years. He had literally written Mein Kampf. They knew what he was and a number of them agreed.

They themselves may not have been evil, but they allowed evil to flourish because their antisemitism blinded them to right and wrong.

Likewise, the Palestinian people knew who Hamas was. They knew they were depraved terrorists who wanted Jews dead.

Antisemitism has existed since human being learned what hate meant, and no prejudice is more sophisticated in the ways it's evolved to keep itself going long after society realised prejudice is wrong.

Please don't patronise this woman by telling her what motivates her or comparing her to the German's who were probably complicit in killing her ancestors.

She understands what they didn't - that Jews - like you and everyone else, are entitled to live free from persecution and they are most certainly free to do it in the land from where they came.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 16:26

This is a really key point as people continue to show up saying "criticising Israel isn't antisemitic" - ignoring the fact this is not the question which has been asked.

Antisemitism and Islamophobia are fairly well designed concepts.

CRITICING HAMMAS (currently government of Gaza)
is NOT Islamophobic.
You can even attack them aggressively for their specific actions

SAYING PALESTINE HAS NO RIGHT TO EXIST (or claiming it's a terrorist endeavor as a concept)
IS Islamophobic
Because it is denying the right of Muslims to self determination and flourishing in their own state.

CRITICISING THE ISRAELI GOVERNMENT
is NOT antisemitic
You can even attack them aggressively for their specific actions

SAYING ISRAEL HAS NO RIGHT TO EXIST (and claiming zionism is "genocide")
IS antisemitic
Because it is denying the right of Jews to self determination and flourishing in their own state.

The idea that you can't do those things without being antisemitic or Islamophobic is nonsense, and if you are saying that you CAN'T do it and feel stifled then you have to go away and seriously have a word with yourself.

I am able to criticise Hamas for days. Write long essays on their specific actions. Condemn them in the strongest possible terms WITHOUT CALLING FOR PALESTINE TO NO LONGER EXIST.

There is absolutely no need to do that!