Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:24

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 12:46

Disliking a country or political group or actions or attitudes is not racism. Thus, despite you very clearly disliking Israel and having admitted you're biased, I have told you that you have not said anything antisemitic.

True, but you seemed keen to have a pop at me anyway. Telling me I’m giving off weird vibes and I’m trolling. What that all about?
I’m sorry to keep banging on about it but I do feel you were just trying to push me off balance. Like that other poster who tried to tell me my posts were difficult to follow and “strange”. Pull the other one.

Sorry if you've felt like that. For me, it feels like this is a thread about understanding antisemitism and some people have been drawn to it, not to understand antisemitism, but to sort of sit in the background with an anti Israel agenda and just keep quoting posts to needle them in order to take out a sense of hostility they have.

You have probably no idea what it's like to deal with this for years on end online. Completely exhausting.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:18

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 12:32

That principle is far more important that "this is my land and you took it" - particularly as a Jew….To us the concept of arguing about it for 100 years is so alien. It is not important to fight over where your grandparents lived 75 years ago. This is not an important moral principle

That seems to fall right under 'Applying double standards by requiring of Muslims behaviours that are not expected or demanded of any other groups in society'.

How so?

My grandparents home and land was taken in 1941 (Iraq) and 1956 (Egypt). I do not hold claim to it or go to those places with weapons to fight for it back. How is it a double standards?

It's the same standard

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:14

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 11:57

@LemonyTicket sadly, some want to be able to say antisemitic things without the burden of being labelled antisemites. They just want to say what they think and if what they think happens to also be antisemitic, they don't want anyone to point that out. They also want to educate Jewish people on what antisemitism actually is and expect that Jews do not feel offended by any perceived antisemitism. This probably sums it up.

That sums it up!

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 13/10/2023 13:10

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 12:09

Well exactly. Not just some, but millions of people. The entire Freedom for Palestine and BDS movement is very, very attractive for antisemites as it somehow gives them a licence to say these things.

Spot. Fucking. On.

It’s the fixation with Israel, the only Jewish state, that reveals the antisemitism of so many, in my view.

Also the lack of any willingness to recognise - in fact consciously closing minds to - the facts of persecution and genocide of Jews, including in living memory, that makes Israel and Jews so rightly fierce about their homeland’s protection and survival.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 12:46

Disliking a country or political group or actions or attitudes is not racism. Thus, despite you very clearly disliking Israel and having admitted you're biased, I have told you that you have not said anything antisemitic.

True, but you seemed keen to have a pop at me anyway. Telling me I’m giving off weird vibes and I’m trolling. What that all about?
I’m sorry to keep banging on about it but I do feel you were just trying to push me off balance. Like that other poster who tried to tell me my posts were difficult to follow and “strange”. Pull the other one.

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 12:32

That principle is far more important that "this is my land and you took it" - particularly as a Jew….To us the concept of arguing about it for 100 years is so alien. It is not important to fight over where your grandparents lived 75 years ago. This is not an important moral principle

That seems to fall right under 'Applying double standards by requiring of Muslims behaviours that are not expected or demanded of any other groups in society'.

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 12:28

They are wind up merchants @25milesfromhome, using exaggerated and emotive language attacking individual posters and generally not coming across as smart or eloquent. Report all personal attacks and any posts that spread harmful misinformation.

The conflict has now spilled into many countries where Free Palestine supporters act in hostile and intimidating ways. It is understandable that there is a lot of emotion but much of it is unhelpful, propaganda or sheer encouragement of hostility towards Jewish people. These people really do not help deescalate things.

25milesfromhome · 13/10/2023 12:21

Gravityisreal · 13/10/2023 07:37

Ahh ok so because this happened to jews (which is horrendous!) then let’s do it to the Palestinians. Honestly, vile. Two wrongs don’t make a right! Have some humanity.

@Gravityisreal Your insinuation and accusation is disgusting. You don’t speak for me. Please show me where I said anything like that in my response to your your post. You said it would never be acceptable in any other part of the world, I pointed out that it was, and it did happen- over and over again. Honestly, the prejudice and supposition backed up by sheer ignorance on most of these threads is appalling and depressing.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 12:09

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 11:57

@LemonyTicket sadly, some want to be able to say antisemitic things without the burden of being labelled antisemites. They just want to say what they think and if what they think happens to also be antisemitic, they don't want anyone to point that out. They also want to educate Jewish people on what antisemitism actually is and expect that Jews do not feel offended by any perceived antisemitism. This probably sums it up.

Well exactly. Not just some, but millions of people. The entire Freedom for Palestine and BDS movement is very, very attractive for antisemites as it somehow gives them a licence to say these things.

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 11:57

@LemonyTicket sadly, some want to be able to say antisemitic things without the burden of being labelled antisemites. They just want to say what they think and if what they think happens to also be antisemitic, they don't want anyone to point that out. They also want to educate Jewish people on what antisemitism actually is and expect that Jews do not feel offended by any perceived antisemitism. This probably sums it up.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 11:50

You can criticise Israel all day long without being antisemitic as long as you don't:

Require or pressure Jewish people to condemn Israel in public

Blame Jewish people collectively

Apply antisemitic tropes to Israel or zionism

Hold Israel up to a different standard to Palestine or other countries

Deny Israel's right to exist

Other than that, you can criticise as much as you like, as angrily as you like, as robustly as you like.

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 11:44

Well, if you want to criticise Israel without being antisemtic, you want to know as much as possible about the context and history otherwise you will just sound ignorant, antisemitic, or even fanatic. Over and above the history, you should really look at the anti-Semitism that has been happening in whatever culture or community you are from. Passionate yet ignorant soundbites are cheap and unhelpful.

Anyway, who talked about excusing the current Israeli government? That's you. I don't support the current right wing government at all and neither do I support many things that are happening but I don't comment on them in an antisemitic way, which is what this thread is all about.

Feel free to comment without due introspection but the likelihood is that whatever community or culture you are from, your ancestors will have been part of a society where Jews were persecuted. This sort of anti-Semitism unfortunately remains a collective oversight.

SnowflakeCity · 13/10/2023 11:41

Anyone can criticise Israel without being antisemitic, provided they are not antisemitists, are well educated about the history of the Jewish people, the history of the middle east, the foundation of Israel and what happened since then; and provided they are completely aware of the inherent antisemitism in Europe and the collective blind spot to our antisemitic heritage.

I find it bizarre that you think to criticise Isreal without being antisemitic you need to be an historian. Surely you just need eyes and a heart to see that the collective punishment of Palestinians by the Israeli government is abhorrent? There are no excuses for that, not hidden in history, not hidden in religion, it is inexcusable end of.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 11:38

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 11:30

Well it is. I posted the definition of what Islamophobia is, as defined by Muslims themselves, and nothing I said was Islamophobic because it doesn't meet any of the criteria or even come anywhere close to it
So why are we not allowed to say we’re not antisemitic? Even when we’re not we’re being a PITA arguing back needling and just being nuisance

Edited

Where I have accused people of being antisemitic, I have quoted what they have said, along with the definition of antisemitism to show where they have breached it.

Disliking a country or political group or actions or attitudes is not racism. Thus, despite you very clearly disliking Israel and having admitted you're biased, I have told you that you have not said anything antisemitic.

Because you have not.

Racism isn't an abstract concept.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 11:36

Straw man

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 11:31

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 11:20

Anyone can criticise Israel without being antisemitic, provided they are not antisemitists, are well educated about the history of the Jewish people, the history of the middle east, the foundation of Israel and what happened since then; and provided they are completely aware of the inherent antisemitism in Europe and the collective blind spot to our antisemitic heritage.

Our European ancestors regarded their fellow Jewish citizens with mistrust, envy, hate and disgust. Jews were blamed for the black death, the killing of Jesus, there have been programs, abuse, humiliation and hundreds, well thousands of years of Jewish persecution all over the world have culminated in the Holocaust killing 6 million Jews. If you are aware and educated about all this, it's perfectly fine to comment on the Israeli /Palestinian situation without being antisemitic. Ideally you should also be aware that it is dodgy to love commenting on Israel but not on any other countries in the middle east, especially the ones who completely disregard any human rights.

Again you're not listening. This is very frustrating. It's like an abusing relationship

ANTISEMITE: I think zionists are scum of the earth
US: That's antisemitic
ANTISEMITE: I was just criticising Israel

ANTISEMITE: You look Jewish. I've never met you and this is a supermarket but I just wanted to say isn't stuff in Gaza awful
US: This is antisemitic
ANTISEMITE: I was just criticising Israel

ANTISEMITE: Welcome to our local council meeting. First order of the day, can we all vote to officially condemn Israel
US: That's antisemitic
ANTISEMITE: I was just criticising Israel

ANTISEMITE: The Israel Lobby has its tentacles running all through British government
US: That's antisemitic
ANTISEMITE: I was just criticising Israel

ANTISEMITE: You are just going full blown zionist
US: That's antisemitic
ANTISEMITE: I was just criticising Israel

These things aren't criticising Israel

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 11:30

Well it is. I posted the definition of what Islamophobia is, as defined by Muslims themselves, and nothing I said was Islamophobic because it doesn't meet any of the criteria or even come anywhere close to it
So why are we not allowed to say we’re not antisemitic? Even when we’re not we’re being a PITA arguing back needling and just being nuisance

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 11:24

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 11:14

There is nothing remotely Islamophobic in a single word you've quoted. Just as I expected there would not be!

Tempted to tell you that’s not for you to say but that really would be needling I suppose

Well it is. I posted the definition of what Islamophobia is, as defined by Muslims themselves, and nothing I said was Islamophobic because it doesn't meet any of the criteria or even come anywhere close to it.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 11:21

Would you go up to a random Muslim person in Sainsbury’s and demand that they must apologise for Hamas
No. I would not expect a random Muslim person to account for the actions of a bunch of people in another country.

Would you go and paint “Down with the Taliban” on the middle of a bridge in Finsbury Park?

Possibly. It’s not a sentiment I disagree with. That is not necessarily a personal attack.

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 11:20

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 11:06

I was going to say! Baffling! You wrote a long post describing lots of antisemitic incidents and they reply saying "oh but it's my civic duty to criticise Israel"

I think a lot of people categorise almost anything as criticising Israel when what it really is, is stuff like you've described

Anyone can criticise Israel without being antisemitic, provided they are not antisemitists, are well educated about the history of the Jewish people, the history of the middle east, the foundation of Israel and what happened since then; and provided they are completely aware of the inherent antisemitism in Europe and the collective blind spot to our antisemitic heritage.

Our European ancestors regarded their fellow Jewish citizens with mistrust, envy, hate and disgust. Jews were blamed for the black death, the killing of Jesus, there have been programs, abuse, humiliation and hundreds, well thousands of years of Jewish persecution all over the world have culminated in the Holocaust killing 6 million Jews. If you are aware and educated about all this, it's perfectly fine to comment on the Israeli /Palestinian situation without being antisemitic. Ideally you should also be aware that it is dodgy to love commenting on Israel but not on any other countries in the middle east, especially the ones who completely disregard any human rights.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 11:14

There is nothing remotely Islamophobic in a single word you've quoted. Just as I expected there would not be!

Tempted to tell you that’s not for you to say but that really would be needling I suppose

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 11:11

Tandora · 13/10/2023 04:18

“Islamic” dominance:

someone has dared to say "no" to Islamic dominance. And there is no justifiable reason why Islam has to dominate this entire region and insist on rule over every inch of it.

repeated use of “they” (and opposition to “us”)

It is not solely theirs. And they must accept that. And the international community must call on them to accept that

justifying of the illegal seizure of land and the regime inflicted on Palestinians:

That principle is far more important that "this is my land and you took it" - particularly as a Jew….To us the concept of arguing about it for 100 years is so alien. It is not important to fight over where your grandparents lived 75 years ago. This is not an important moral principle.

Also Repeated statements that Jews have the right to live in the place they came from.
Perhaps I should have the right to live in Africa on someone else’s land because apparently that’s where I came from 2 million years ago?

There is nothing remotely Islamophobic in a single word you've quoted. Just as I expected there would not be!

And as a Jew, I am more than entitled to refer to Jews as "us". Thank you very much!

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 11:07

It would be extremely odd behaviour to demand on opinion from a total stranger on any subject and even if you know them you would be careful with such a potentially loaded subject. These things happen online though. You know you’re interacting with a real person but you can’t see them so your disinhibitions are lowered

@Defiantjazz As per my original comment, these things happen in person too. Like I said, I’ve been in situations where people have walked up to me out of nowhere and literally just started talking about the awful situation in Gaza etc, apropos of nothing. They’ve literally walked up to a random Jewish person and basically said “Israel!!!” - it’s antisemitism through and through, and a lot of what happens online is just an online version of that. Would you go up to a random Muslim person in Sainsbury’s and demand that they must apologise for Hamas? Would you go and paint “Down with the Taliban” on the middle of a bridge in Finsbury Park?

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 11:06

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 10:05

@RedToothBrush You haven’t even read what I wrote. You can speak about Israel if you choose to, or when you feel it’s necessary, but it’s antisemitism when someone demands it of you, especially when a random stranger walks up to you in a public place. It’s antisemitism when it’s done with convenient context and timing - which you would know if you read what I actually said. It’s absolutely not essential for anyone to criticise the Israeli government when they’re sitting in a pub waiting for a friend, or going to the supermarket or whatever, and it’s not okay for random people to demand it of anyone. Which you’d know if you actually read what I wrote. I feel like you’ve quoted the wrong person.

I was going to say! Baffling! You wrote a long post describing lots of antisemitic incidents and they reply saying "oh but it's my civic duty to criticise Israel"

I think a lot of people categorise almost anything as criticising Israel when what it really is, is stuff like you've described

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 10:47

. MYou can speak about Israel if you choose to, or when you feel it’s necessary, but it’s antisemitism when someone demands it of you, especially when a random stranger walks up to you in a public place. It’s antisemitism when it’s done with convenient context and timing - which you would know if you read what I actually said. It’s absolutely not essential for anyone to criticise the Israeli government when they’re sitting in a pub waiting for a friend, or going to the supermarket or whatever, and it’s not okay for random people to demand it of anyone.

It would be extremely odd behaviour to demand on opinion from a total stranger on any subject and even if you know them you would be careful with such a potentially loaded subject.
These things happen online though. You know you’re interacting with a real person but you can’t see them so your disinhibitions are lowered (a bit like your drunk lol) (I’m not drunk btw).
I think the opinions you get on threads like this are a bit..unfiltered shall we say. Buts it’s badmouthing Israel at the end of the day. You may think that’s a bad thing but it does not mean that person hates Jewish people or wants another holocaust. I can understand how that may be a very real fear though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread