Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:40

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 17:34

Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism

Is it? Should we just not criticise them then?

You’re just being disingenuous now. People throughout this thread have explained multiple times, and in multiple ways, the details and nuances of how it’s linked.

Look, there are antisemitic ways of criticising Israel, and non-antisemitic ways of criticising Israel. There are antisemitic reasons for doing so, and there are non-antisemitic reasons for doing so. The issue is that vast amounts of people are doing it in an antisemitic way, and for antisemitic reasons. That doesn’t mean everyone is, but it does mean a lot of people are doing so but claiming they aren’t. That’s why it’s so heavily linked.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 17:34

Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism

Is it? Should we just not criticise them then?

Teder · 13/10/2023 17:20

Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism.
Since last weekend, reports of antisemitism in the U.K. have increased three fold. Now tell me British Jews are shutting down debate? Are we, or are we being made to feel responsible for the actions of another country’s government.

Minority groups are held to a higher standard. When terrorist attacks occur, people say <insert ethnic minority here> and their leaders should LOUDLY and CLEARLY condemn the actions. I have and I would but I do it because I want to and it is important to me. I am not the Israeli prime minister nor the IDF, so I hold zero responsibility. As a Jewish person, I have no more responsibility to say “I condemn the bombing of Gaza and the military attacks” than the average other person. I have seen on other threads that posters get themselves all worked up if one doesn’t open their post with “of course innocent victims in Gaza is despicable and I abhor their murder and condemn the actions of the Israeli government”.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 17:15

To say that it is completely disproportionate to be angry and upset at the thought of a genocide playing out before our very eyes is beyond belief. Why wouldnt people be concerned for the millions of civilians being starved, refused water, having all methods of communication taken away? It is disturbing and gross that you would ask the question 'why are people so obsessed with what Israel are doing'.

Israel is not attempting a genocide but it is oppressing the people in the Palestinian territories. In Gaza you are not even allowed to leave without Israel’s permission. The water supply etc can be cut off (as it is now I believe).
I genuinely don’t understand why some people think the only reason Israel is thought of negatively is because of hatred of the Jewish people as a whole.

Antisemitism may increase at times like this but that’s because some people are arseholes who just like to be haters. They were probably throwing rocks at mosques a few months ago.

Ididivfama · 13/10/2023 17:14

lookingforMolly · 11/10/2023 15:39

It's true though.. you wouldn't lecture a Black individual on what is & isn't racism so why would you tell a Jewish individual what is and isn't Anti Semitism... ?? Would you?

I guess the point is that Isreal is a country that a lot of people don’t agree with. A lot of people don’t like the Iranian government but don’t get called Islamophobic. To dislike the Israeli government makes your antisemetic, in some cases.
The complication comes partly I’m sure with Israel being the only Jewish country.

CoughingMajoress · 13/10/2023 17:06

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 16:11

Certainly no Chinese person living in the UK is ever held accountable for or interrogated as to their opinion about China's use of death camps
How do you know? I mean this is anecdotal evidence isn’t it? I’ve never been subjected to/knowingly witnessed antisemitism but then I’m not Jewish. Would you know if Chinese people are asked about death camps?

Russia had been committing atrocities and human rights violations for decades (Belarus, for example) and it took an outright invasion of another country to make the world notice or care.
You know about it though? But you think no-one else does?

You're just being goady.

Belarus has very obviously had a tiny, tiny percentage of the media coverage that the invasion of Ukraine has had, ditto all the other Russian human rights violations and atrocities over the years.

Ditto Chinese concentration camps.

Anyone trying to claim these things have had remotely similar levels of attention as Israel is just being goady, because that's so blatantly not true.

And I personally know because I work directly in this area. I have in the past worked with a Belarusian company who are in exile in the UK, and have spent time with the Belarusian woman who runs the company who has been arrested and tortured multiple times. So I know from actually working with and knowing Belarusian "dissidents" personally how little media attention and public attention there is. But clearly I am very unusual in that respect, very very few people in the UK are actually directly and personally working with Belarusian activists.

Right now I have a publishing deal from a small indie press and I am using part of the book to explore the Chinese concentration camps, the systemic oppress and genocide of Uyghur Muslims and Falon Gong members and how this links with the "red market", the state-run illegal human organ trafficking trade in China. Again, this is obviously very very unusual, since there are hardly lots of people in the UK landing publishing deals to write about the Chinese government

It's very obvious that there's a massive difference in cultural issues where Jews are expected to have an opinion on and be held responsible for Israel, and that simply doesn't exist with most similar cases. For example I used to work mostly in theatre, and you cannot put on a play about anything even slightly Jewish without protests and threats and disruption. Plays about China or with Chinese characters (for example the one going on right now at the Young Vic) do not receive any of this at all, ever.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 16:58

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 16:32

I'm Jewish and have had none of the experiences you've had. Nor has my sister, her husband and two children who practice more than me.

I don't understand why you are always using the word 'us' in your posts.

I am a woman too. Women have experienced sexual harassment as a broad generalisation. It would be perfectly normal for me to speak about sexual harassment and say "this is something we have to face".

If you haven't - cool. WE still do. Even if YOU don't.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 13/10/2023 16:51

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 16:32

I'm Jewish and have had none of the experiences you've had. Nor has my sister, her husband and two children who practice more than me.

I don't understand why you are always using the word 'us' in your posts.

Whose post(s) are you referring to?

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 16:43

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 16:32

I'm Jewish and have had none of the experiences you've had. Nor has my sister, her husband and two children who practice more than me.

I don't understand why you are always using the word 'us' in your posts.

I have a real issue with people who use ‘we’ to speak for hundreds and thousands of people without their consent.

It’s like when someone with ADHD says, we do this, we can’t do that, as if they represent every person with ADHD.

Some people here speak as if they are the spokesperson for every Jewish person or Israeli. That would really piss me off if I was from those groups.

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 16:32

I'm Jewish and have had none of the experiences you've had. Nor has my sister, her husband and two children who practice more than me.

I don't understand why you are always using the word 'us' in your posts.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 16:11

Certainly no Chinese person living in the UK is ever held accountable for or interrogated as to their opinion about China's use of death camps
How do you know? I mean this is anecdotal evidence isn’t it? I’ve never been subjected to/knowingly witnessed antisemitism but then I’m not Jewish. Would you know if Chinese people are asked about death camps?

Russia had been committing atrocities and human rights violations for decades (Belarus, for example) and it took an outright invasion of another country to make the world notice or care.
You know about it though? But you think no-one else does?

CoughingMajoress · 13/10/2023 16:02

SnowflakeCity · 13/10/2023 13:34

This is bizarre to me? Israel are breaching international humanitarian laws, they are enforcing collective punishments right now. They have given people 24hrs to do something impossible, real peoples lives hang in the balance and you are pretty much saying 'Ew, why are they so obsessed with us'.

Edited

There are countries with literal concentration camps, countries conducting genocide, and barely a word from the media or any awareness. Certainly no Chinese person living in the UK is ever held accountable for or interrogated as to their opinion about China's use of death camps.

Let's not pretend every country that commits human rights violations is subject to this, because Israel is unique. Even Russia is a bad example - Russia had been committing atrocities and human rights violations for decades (Belarus, for example) and it took an outright invasion of another country to make the world notice or care.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 15:16

Anyway, the anti-Israel lobby has been going at this for many, many years. And doing so as a political and social touchstone. Of course other tensions and conflicts in the world attract (some) attention. But nothing like the fixated, relentless, single-issue campaigning against Israel - which is the give-away of these campaigners’ antisemitism

Im talking about the views of the general public rather than lobby’s. Israel and the Palestinians are at the forefront at the moment because they are at war. They are not all everyone thinks about all the time.

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 13/10/2023 14:38

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 14:29

People have an obsession with Israel because they get to blame Jews for it. Look at most other issues in the world where there aren’t Jews to blame and see how much people really care about those

It’s not true that wrong doing by other country’s is ignored or that no other nations are viewed in a negative light. Take Russia for example, plenty of people bad mouthing it for what’s is doing to Ukraine.

“bad mouthing it”?

Interesting choice of words.

Anyway, the anti-Israel lobby has been going at this for many, many years. And doing so as a political and social touchstone. Of course other tensions and conflicts in the world attract (some) attention. But nothing like the fixated, relentless, single-issue campaigning against Israel - which is the give-away of these campaigners’ antisemitism.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 14:29

People have an obsession with Israel because they get to blame Jews for it. Look at most other issues in the world where there aren’t Jews to blame and see how much people really care about those

It’s not true that wrong doing by other country’s is ignored or that no other nations are viewed in a negative light. Take Russia for example, plenty of people bad mouthing it for what’s is doing to Ukraine.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 14:05

And now, you're suggesting I don't use Mumsnet to discuss antisemitism either.

Or, alternatively, people could stop being antisemitic so Jews could participate in life like everyone else without feeling uncomfortable

There doesn’t seem much point in discussing it with people you don’t feel are being genuine and are just trolling /venting ill feeling. If it were me I wouldn’t bother.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:55

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 13:53

Yes, because antisemitism only started a few days ago and had never existed before this week 🧐

I think you're being spectacularly gaslit right now!

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:54

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 13:48

You have probably no idea what it's like to deal with this for years on end online. Completely exhausting

Maybe just step away from it then. Few people are genuine online and most are somewhat badly behaved on sites where this is allowed to extent (such as this one) because you don’t have to deal with the reality of who you’re speaking to.

Yes. So far, due to antisemitism

I have left the Labour Party
My kids have left the Labour party
I have left Twitter and Facebook
My kids have had to step back from social media and unfollowed many accounts they were interested in
My son had to leave his university socialist society
I don't feel able to join a political party for fear I'd face the same (for example the local council)
My kids have had to stop contact with some of their friends

And now, you're suggesting I don't use Mumsnet to discuss antisemitism either.

Or, alternatively, people could stop being antisemitic so Jews could participate in life like everyone else without feeling uncomfortable?

Or, is letting y'all take out your fixation on the only Jewish state a larger priority?

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 13:53

SnowflakeCity · 13/10/2023 13:52

Because Israel are committing mass punishments against civilians. Right now. Right now they have given people the impossible of evacuating. Right now people are suffering horrifically at the hands of the Israeli government. To say that it is completely disproportionate to be angry and upset at the thought of a genocide playing out before our very eyes is beyond belief. Why wouldnt people be concerned for the millions of civilians being starved, refused water, having all methods of communication taken away? It is disturbing and gross that you would ask the question 'why are people so obsessed with what Israel are doing'.

You want the world to turn its back on Palestianians and thank fuck they are refusing to.

Yes, because antisemitism only started a few days ago and had never existed before this week 🧐

SnowflakeCity · 13/10/2023 13:52

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:41

I am not "pretty much" saying it. I am outright saying it.

Why are you so obsessed with us?!

There's a widely publicised conflict today, right now, but this obsession has gone on for years. It's completely disproportionate, it's directed entirely in one direction, and it seems to be to be an almost fixation for many people.

Genuine question.....why?

Because Israel are committing mass punishments against civilians. Right now. Right now they have given people the impossible of evacuating. Right now people are suffering horrifically at the hands of the Israeli government. To say that it is completely disproportionate to be angry and upset at the thought of a genocide playing out before our very eyes is beyond belief. Why wouldnt people be concerned for the millions of civilians being starved, refused water, having all methods of communication taken away? It is disturbing and gross that you would ask the question 'why are people so obsessed with what Israel are doing'.

You want the world to turn its back on Palestianians and thank fuck they are refusing to.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 13:48

You have probably no idea what it's like to deal with this for years on end online. Completely exhausting

Maybe just step away from it then. Few people are genuine online and most are somewhat badly behaved on sites where this is allowed to extent (such as this one) because you don’t have to deal with the reality of who you’re speaking to.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 13:42

SnowflakeCity · 13/10/2023 13:34

This is bizarre to me? Israel are breaching international humanitarian laws, they are enforcing collective punishments right now. They have given people 24hrs to do something impossible, real peoples lives hang in the balance and you are pretty much saying 'Ew, why are they so obsessed with us'.

Edited

This isn’t just about what’s been happening this week. This is about the long term issue that a lot of people out there only care about Palestine and nothing else. There are lots of hideous things going on in the world, including the treatment of Uighur Muslims in China but also countless other hideous things, and there is nowhere near the level of outrage going on. Yes, they’ll all claim they care about other stuff too but they really don’t. Israel and Palestine is the pet issue of millions of antisemites because it reinforces their world view that Jews are bad people. People have an obsession with Israel because they get to blame Jews for it. Look at most other issues in the world where there aren’t Jews to blame and see how much people really care about those.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:41

SnowflakeCity · 13/10/2023 13:34

This is bizarre to me? Israel are breaching international humanitarian laws, they are enforcing collective punishments right now. They have given people 24hrs to do something impossible, real peoples lives hang in the balance and you are pretty much saying 'Ew, why are they so obsessed with us'.

Edited

I am not "pretty much" saying it. I am outright saying it.

Why are you so obsessed with us?!

There's a widely publicised conflict today, right now, but this obsession has gone on for years. It's completely disproportionate, it's directed entirely in one direction, and it seems to be to be an almost fixation for many people.

Genuine question.....why?

SnowflakeCity · 13/10/2023 13:34

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:28

Thanks for saying this. There isn't an outright defined classification of "obsession with Israel" as antisemitism - but it certainly feels like a weird fixation on the only Jewish state as the sole bad guy on the face of earth.

It's made "online space" very hostile for Jews.

This is bizarre to me? Israel are breaching international humanitarian laws, they are enforcing collective punishments right now. They have given people 24hrs to do something impossible, real peoples lives hang in the balance and you are pretty much saying 'Ew, why are they so obsessed with us'.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 13:28

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 13/10/2023 13:10

Spot. Fucking. On.

It’s the fixation with Israel, the only Jewish state, that reveals the antisemitism of so many, in my view.

Also the lack of any willingness to recognise - in fact consciously closing minds to - the facts of persecution and genocide of Jews, including in living memory, that makes Israel and Jews so rightly fierce about their homeland’s protection and survival.

Thanks for saying this. There isn't an outright defined classification of "obsession with Israel" as antisemitism - but it certainly feels like a weird fixation on the only Jewish state as the sole bad guy on the face of earth.

It's made "online space" very hostile for Jews.