Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:44

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:37

You asked: “So pray tell, what’s the ‘right’ way of saying you fear for the lives of Palestinian people at the moment? Useful to know.” But you don’t actually want to know.

You’ve literally asked me for some examples of right and wrong ways of going about it. I’ve replied that I’ve given a load of examples on page 15, and now you can’t be bothered to read them. Which makes me wonder why you asked in the first place. There are so, so many people who come along in these threads and play innocent, asking what they claim to be innocent questions, and yet they don’t even want to read the answers.

Enjoy your weekend with your imaginary close Jewish friends who don’t actually exist.

Edited

I am not seeing them this weekend but thanks. I am afraid having good Jewish friends is unavoidable if you live in N London ;-) They are great. And seem to quite like me. 🤷🏼‍♀️ I recommend you make some. For the bar/bat mitzvahs if nothing else!

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 18:42

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:46

‘Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism.’

And there we have it. People honestly believe this shit and that we can criticise any government from any country apart from Israel. Because it’s apparently antisemitic.

I have been reading about the recent rise in antisemitic acts in London recently. Eg playing German military music outside synagogues etc. That’s appalling and antisemitic and I condemn it.

Condemning Hamas whilst feeling terrified for the Palestinian kids about to be wiped out by the Israeli army is not an act of antisemitism. However many Jewish/israeli people would like it to be seen thus.

Please stop. You know perfectly well that she wasn't saying that. She described, as have I and countless others the glaring difference between regular criticism like every other country gets and this bizarre shit that goes on here.

No other country NONE has their students accused of being part of a secret cabal of a foreign state. NONE. No one else has their history repeated over and over again to them in ways that are utter garbage. No one else gets told they don't know what racism towards them actually is and gets sent links to explain to them that they're actually just smearing people for Israel.

It's bloody mad!

@Brightlyshining has actually described at length the antisemitism she's experienced (which was nothing like "criticising Israel") and instead of commenting on that or trying to actually think about how it might feel to put up with this shit, you sit there waiting to pounce so you can gaslight us yet again.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:37

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:32

Your reply is exactly what I predicted. Especially the last bit. I am not going to dignify it with a response.

Anyway these words are all pointless internet bluster. Posters could be anybody and all of us could be lying.

Israelis and Palestinians are dying right and it all feels hopeless. Have a good evening.

You asked: “So pray tell, what’s the ‘right’ way of saying you fear for the lives of Palestinian people at the moment? Useful to know.” But you don’t actually want to know.

You’ve literally asked me for some examples of right and wrong ways of going about it. I’ve replied that I’ve given a load of examples on page 15, and now you can’t be bothered to read them. Which makes me wonder why you asked in the first place. There are so, so many people who come along in these threads and play innocent, asking what they claim to be innocent questions, and yet they don’t even want to read the answers.

Enjoy your weekend with your imaginary close Jewish friends who don’t actually exist.

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 18:37

If you haven't - cool. WE still do. Even if YOU don't
If I and others haven't, it can't be WE. It might be some, or many, or a majority but not WE.

Easier to stick to accounting for personal experiences because otherwise, it is offensive to make assumptions on behalf of those who have nothing to do with what you describe.

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:32

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:26

The intransigence is coming from you.

And you know what’s worse is that you’re demanding explanations from me, and when I say there are explanations throughout this thread (I joined around page 15, but there’s lots of other useful stuff before that), you suddenly can’t be bothered to read it, and you say you’ll just carry on as before. Because you don’t actually want to read any examples.

As for your close Jewish friends of many years, sure. I’m sure some of your best friends are black, too 😉

Your reply is exactly what I predicted. Especially the last bit. I am not going to dignify it with a response.

Anyway these words are all pointless internet bluster. Posters could be anybody and all of us could be lying.

Israelis and Palestinians are dying right and it all feels hopeless. Have a good evening.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:26

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:18

It’s just impossible dealing with such intransigence.

I will just carry on as I have been this week. Supporting my close Jewish friends of many years, whilst being able to feel compassion for the Palestinian people about to be killed en masse. If my friends challenge me, I will be happy to discuss further. But I think for now, they just need my kindness and support.

The intransigence is coming from you.

And you know what’s worse is that you’re demanding explanations from me, and when I say there are explanations throughout this thread (I joined around page 15, but there’s lots of other useful stuff before that), you suddenly can’t be bothered to read it, and you say you’ll just carry on as before. Because you don’t actually want to read any examples.

As for your close Jewish friends of many years, sure. I’m sure some of your best friends are black, too 😉

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 18:24

@Defiantjazz I won’t be replying to you any more as you’re being deliberately antagonistic and playing dumb

My posts are hard to follow* *

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 18:23

Belarus has very obviously had a tiny, tiny percentage of the media coverage that the invasion of Ukraine has had, ditto all the other Russian human rights violations and atrocities over the years.
**
Ditto Chinese concentration camps.
**
Anyone trying to claim these things have had remotely similar levels of attention as Israel is just being goady, because that's so blatantly not true

Speaking in general I’m not sure that the China or Russia being guilty of human rights violations is going to come as a shock to many. Really. They have form.

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:18

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:15

People have explained it numerous times throughout this thread. Go back and read it.

It’s just impossible dealing with such intransigence.

I will just carry on as I have been this week. Supporting my close Jewish friends of many years, whilst being able to feel compassion for the Palestinian people about to be killed en masse. If my friends challenge me, I will be happy to discuss further. But I think for now, they just need my kindness and support.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:15

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:11

So pray tell, what’s the ‘right’ way of saying you fear for the lives of Palestinian people at the moment? Useful to know.

People have explained it numerous times throughout this thread. Go back and read it.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:13

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:01

But this is all an idiot issue.

I don’t agree with everything the Israeli government does. (Nor the UK government, or Indian government etc). According to you, that makes me antisemitic and potentially capable of attacking innocent Jewish people?

May I suggest that you go back and read some of the earlier bits of this thread?

What part of “there are antisemitic ways of saying it and non-antisemitic ways of saying it” do you not understand? The issue is that vast amounts of people are saying it in antisemitic ways, and with convenient timing.

There are millions of antisemitic people who deliberately latch on to the Palestinian movement because it’s a way for them to legitimise antisemitism.

There are also numerous people on this thread who have explained time and time again that it’s about context, and about people demanding explanations from Jewish people around the world.

And it’s not just an idiot issue, it’s an antisemitism and Islamophobia issue. Nobody thinks they’re an idiot and nobody wants to admit their motivations.

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:11

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:05

As I have already said above, there are antisemitic ways and reasons for saying it, and non-antisemitic ways. It’s all about context. There are too many antisemitic people who’ll just say they just care about innocent Palestinian children, when there’s a whole load of motivations behind that. And of course all of those people, presumably including you, will say you’re not one of the antisemitic ones and it’s only other people who get it wrong.

So pray tell, what’s the ‘right’ way of saying you fear for the lives of Palestinian people at the moment? Useful to know.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 18:08

The explanation to that is Islamophobia. Because there are millions of idiots out there who think all Muslims support terrorists. Every time something like that happens, there’s an associated increase in Islamophobic attacks in Western countries. And yet people will still insist there’s no link.

Exactly. And said idiots will hold anyone Jewish, never mind Israeli, responsible for the actions of Israel’s government. They care about neither side

Scare any population of Jewish people enough and they may flee to Israel. Israel will decide it needs more land because it will not turn anyone away. Problem for the Palestinians just gets worse. Do you think the haters have thought of that ? Do you think they’ve really though about it at all?

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:05

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:52

See my reply above.

Do you think feeling fear and compassion for innocent Palestinian children is antisemitic? I would be interested in your response.

As I have already said above, there are antisemitic ways and reasons for saying it, and non-antisemitic ways. It’s all about context. There are too many antisemitic people who’ll just say they just care about innocent Palestinian children, when there’s a whole load of motivations behind that. And of course all of those people, presumably including you, will say you’re not one of the antisemitic ones and it’s only other people who get it wrong.

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:01

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:58

The explanation to that is Islamophobia. Because there are millions of idiots out there who think all Muslims support terrorists. Every time something like that happens, there’s an associated increase in Islamophobic attacks in Western countries. And yet people will still insist there’s no link.

It’s not an exclusively Jewish issue. Lots of people will tell you that criticism of Isis isn’t Islamophobic and has no connection etc, even we all know that really, Islamophobic people will join any movement that allows them to say things about people and attack them.

But this is all an idiot issue.

I don’t agree with everything the Israeli government does. (Nor the UK government, or Indian government etc). According to you, that makes me antisemitic and potentially capable of attacking innocent Jewish people?

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:00

@Defiantjazz I won’t be replying to you any more as you’re being deliberately antagonistic and playing dumb.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:58

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:51

After 9/11 and 7/7 there was a huge increase in Islamophobia and attacks on innocent Muslims wearing headscarves etc. People scared to visit mosques. What is your explanation of that?

People are utter dicks everywhere and attack the wrong target and innocent people get caught up in the backlash. Surely you can see this is not exclusively a Jewish issue?

The explanation to that is Islamophobia. Because there are millions of idiots out there who think all Muslims support terrorists. Every time something like that happens, there’s an associated increase in Islamophobic attacks in Western countries. And yet people will still insist there’s no link.

It’s not an exclusively Jewish issue. Lots of people will tell you that criticism of Isis isn’t Islamophobic and has no connection etc, even we all know that really, Islamophobic people will join any movement that allows them to say things about people and attack them.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 17:54

Whats your point? Are you saying the Guardian has been stirring? Cos that wouldn’t invalidate my argument. It would back it up actually.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:52

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 17:51

If you’d like to come up with a better explanation of this increase in incidents then I’m all ears.

Ive already given my explanation - it may be complete tosh but it’s there.

Perhaps* *media is to blame? It’s quite good a whipping the average sun reader into a frenzy

Yeah cos that would never happen in the Guardian, would it 🧐

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:52

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:49

So you don’t think criticism of Israel is linked to antisemitism, yet you also acknowledge the huge increase in antisemitic incidents in the UK this week. What’s your explanation for why these incidents have happened?

See my reply above.

Do you think feeling fear and compassion for innocent Palestinian children is antisemitic? I would be interested in your response.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 17:51

If you’d like to come up with a better explanation of this increase in incidents then I’m all ears.

Ive already given my explanation - it may be complete tosh but it’s there.

Perhaps* *media is to blame? It’s quite good a whipping the average sun reader into a frenzy

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:51

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:43

And if you really think it’s not linked, then you’re going to have to come up with an explanation as to why there’s been a huge increase in antisemitic incidents in the UK this week. Not just this week, but every time something happens in Israel there is an extremely strong correlation with antisemitic incidents around the world. If you’d like to come up with a better explanation of this increase in incidents then I’m all ears.

After 9/11 and 7/7 there was a huge increase in Islamophobia and attacks on innocent Muslims wearing headscarves etc. People scared to visit mosques. What is your explanation of that?

People are utter dicks everywhere and attack the wrong target and innocent people get caught up in the backlash. Surely you can see this is not exclusively a Jewish issue?

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:49

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:46

‘Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism.’

And there we have it. People honestly believe this shit and that we can criticise any government from any country apart from Israel. Because it’s apparently antisemitic.

I have been reading about the recent rise in antisemitic acts in London recently. Eg playing German military music outside synagogues etc. That’s appalling and antisemitic and I condemn it.

Condemning Hamas whilst feeling terrified for the Palestinian kids about to be wiped out by the Israeli army is not an act of antisemitism. However many Jewish/israeli people would like it to be seen thus.

So you don’t think criticism of Israel is linked to antisemitism, yet you also acknowledge the huge increase in antisemitic incidents in the UK this week. What’s your explanation for why these incidents have happened?

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:46

Teder · 13/10/2023 17:20

Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism.
Since last weekend, reports of antisemitism in the U.K. have increased three fold. Now tell me British Jews are shutting down debate? Are we, or are we being made to feel responsible for the actions of another country’s government.

Minority groups are held to a higher standard. When terrorist attacks occur, people say <insert ethnic minority here> and their leaders should LOUDLY and CLEARLY condemn the actions. I have and I would but I do it because I want to and it is important to me. I am not the Israeli prime minister nor the IDF, so I hold zero responsibility. As a Jewish person, I have no more responsibility to say “I condemn the bombing of Gaza and the military attacks” than the average other person. I have seen on other threads that posters get themselves all worked up if one doesn’t open their post with “of course innocent victims in Gaza is despicable and I abhor their murder and condemn the actions of the Israeli government”.

‘Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism.’

And there we have it. People honestly believe this shit and that we can criticise any government from any country apart from Israel. Because it’s apparently antisemitic.

I have been reading about the recent rise in antisemitic acts in London recently. Eg playing German military music outside synagogues etc. That’s appalling and antisemitic and I condemn it.

Condemning Hamas whilst feeling terrified for the Palestinian kids about to be wiped out by the Israeli army is not an act of antisemitism. However many Jewish/israeli people would like it to be seen thus.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 17:43

And if you really think it’s not linked, then you’re going to have to come up with an explanation as to why there’s been a huge increase in antisemitic incidents in the UK this week. Not just this week, but every time something happens in Israel there is an extremely strong correlation with antisemitic incidents around the world. If you’d like to come up with a better explanation of this increase in incidents then I’m all ears.