Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:40

You said “I haven’t goaded anyone on this thread of judged their views” because yourJewish person who has a lot of background education and cultural awareness of both topics

Aye that makes sense I’m sure

Teder · 13/10/2023 20:40

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:36

I mean.. I’m trying to get one over on you? But I have FAILED. Wtf?

And as for Lemony since you aren’t talking to me can I just take the opportunity to say I think I responded to your patronising supercilious posts with quite good grace.

You were the one who said you posted a sarcastic comment to my post!

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:36

I mean.. I’m trying to get one over on you? But I have FAILED. Wtf?

And as for Lemony since you aren’t talking to me can I just take the opportunity to say I think I responded to your patronising supercilious posts with quite good grace.

Teder · 13/10/2023 20:33

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:26

Well why did you say it then? Why is you point ? What are you on about?

I am talking about the topic of anti Zionism and antisemitism, particularly on MN over recent days. I have referenced other threads I’ve been on this forum and responses I have received from people.

I said it because I am a Jewish person who has a lot of background education and cultural awareness of both topics and I was sharing my personal views on a chat forum.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:26

Well why did you say it then? Why is you point ? What are you on about?

Teder · 13/10/2023 20:24

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:21

I haven’t goaded anyone on this thread, judged their views

Nor have I
You can bore off as well.

Did I say you have? Why would you think that? This isn’t your thread, there are lots of us.

You did respond to my post though as did someone else, feel free to ignore me.

I won’t bore off, this is an important topic so I will keep posting all the same.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:21

I haven’t goaded anyone on this thread, judged their views

Nor have I
You can bore off as well.

Teder · 13/10/2023 20:16

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:12

I am sure people like me (Jews who condemn the Israeli response) disconcert some people on here. It’s like some people are waiting for me (and those like me) to suddenly show another side

wtf are you talking about ?

I was jumped upon instantly for a statement I made. It was taken out of context. I haven’t goaded anyone on this thread nor judged their views.

It was like people are waiting for me to confirm “yes I think you’re all antisemitic” and I don’t think that at all. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:12

I am sure people like me (Jews who condemn the Israeli response) disconcert some people on here. It’s like some people are waiting for me (and those like me) to suddenly show another side

wtf are you talking about ?

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 20:10

contrary and trying to trip up or be silly or deliberately goady.

Oh bore off.

Teder · 13/10/2023 20:06

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 19:57

Did you read my post or knee jerk?

I was being sarcastic tbh.

Edited

Why? I don’t understand.

I don’t think people want nuanced debate. I think they want to place people in boxes and pretend they know the intricacies of being a Jewish person and how we all think.

I am sure people like me (Jews who condemn the Israeli response) disconcert some people on here. It’s like some people are waiting for me (and those like me) to suddenly show another side. There is no other side. I am sickened by the tragedy of loss of innocent life by greedy politics and the inner workings of a corrupt government.

I will continue to discuss antisemitism though. I won’t let it be pushed away and my words twisted by anyone.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 20:02

Teder · 13/10/2023 19:47

Did you read my post or knee jerk? Did you see my own criticism of the Israeli government? No, you just wanted to get one up on me. You have failed.

It is other people who start to link it to Jews around the world, not the Jews. Do you not get it?!! Since last Saturday, there has been a 3-4 fold increase in attacks on British Jews. Why the fuck should I be at risk because of the choices of a country where I do not live?

He's hung around for days doing nothing but be contrary and trying to trip up or be silly or deliberately goady. I am losing my patience with it and have just started completely ignoring

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 19:59

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 19:20

@LemonyTicket, there's only one last thing for me to say to you and it sums up in the saying 'practice what you preach'. You seem quite good at accusing others of your own actions.

As a jew, I have gone to finding your first posts interesting to finding them non credible because due your condescending attitude.

Why not just be honest with you. Here's what I see.

You arrived on the thread quite a long time ago and from the offset your first posts were along the lines of "oh but does Hamas being so terrible justify Israel being so terrible" or "oh but is racism always racism?" and then moved on to exactly what @Brightlyshining just talked about with the faux innocent posts. Example below:

"To those posters with extensive knowledge of the history, as a person more interested in understanding rather than debating on the terminology of words, could I ask you to educate me (others) on the Oslo accord and decision of divide the West Bank in 3 areas.

As an uneducated person, I just can't fathom the logic behind the division of areas in such small fragments. I assume it has to do with socio-geographical location of villages/town but it makes for such an odd arrangement. I'd love to also understand better what life in in area B. Does it mean Jews and Palestinians are managing to live in agreement in those regions?*

There seem so little explained about the West Bank as it stands now with all the focus- understandbly- being on Gaza.

Which has nothing to do with the thread and then just carried on asking similar questions. You can google in 5 seconds these questions. I think if someone knows enough to know know about the Oslo accord and Area B that you know quite a lot, and that your objective was to fill this thread with "ooohhh, aren't Israel terrible".

Then you pushed that and similar questions for quite a while to the point of getting very aggressive and rude to me "well fine I will go and find a REAL expert who actually wants to answer questions and isn't pushing an agenda"

This thread is about the difference between antisemitism and the difference between that and anti zionism. It is not about administrative facilities on the West Bank, and I think you know that, understand it perfectly and got very cross indeed when your intended 2x4 wasn't successful.

After I wouldn't bite and ignored you, you then re-appeared on page 19 or 20 and were suddenly Jewish, and were using that new miraculously developed identity to question my use of my first person plural pronouns. Despite them being completely standard English. On the preposterous supposition that you were *offended" "as a Jew" of being included in the sorry or our history or our experiences of antisemitism because they "don't happen to you.

So I am going to call red flag on all that to be honest. I think you're here to stir the pot and not much else.

ForFriends · 13/10/2023 19:59

They’ll come along and ask faux-innocent questions when they don’t really want an answer.

Mumsnet is full of faux innocent questions at the moment. A good one here
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/chat/4919111-worried-about-jewish-friend-reaction-to-israel-hamas-war?page=11&reply=129916815

😂😂😂The OP is American or international due to their spelling. Weird stuff.

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 19:57

Did you read my post or knee jerk?

I was being sarcastic tbh.

Teder · 13/10/2023 19:54

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 17:46

‘Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism.’

And there we have it. People honestly believe this shit and that we can criticise any government from any country apart from Israel. Because it’s apparently antisemitic.

I have been reading about the recent rise in antisemitic acts in London recently. Eg playing German military music outside synagogues etc. That’s appalling and antisemitic and I condemn it.

Condemning Hamas whilst feeling terrified for the Palestinian kids about to be wiped out by the Israeli army is not an act of antisemitism. However many Jewish/israeli people would like it to be seen thus.

For the hard of reading, I didn’t say being anti Zionist is antisemitic. I said it is intrinsically linked purely because so many people resort to antisemitism. So, if you’re upset you’re not getting a fair or balanced debate, have a chat to those who ARE being antisemitic. They’re the ones hindering the debate and shutting it down.

I can tell you didn’t even bother to read my post. I know you saw one line and decided you knew me and my views but I don’t know why? What are you getting out of it? It is possible to criticise Zionism without being antisemitic. Unfortunately, people haven’t learnt how to do that. For that, it’s their own prejudice and ignorance.

I clearly said I condemn the actions. I have said it throughout this thread. I have criticised the Israeli government.

Teder · 13/10/2023 19:47

Defiantjazz · 13/10/2023 17:34

Criticism of Israeli government policy and action is intrinsically linked to antisemitism

Is it? Should we just not criticise them then?

Did you read my post or knee jerk? Did you see my own criticism of the Israeli government? No, you just wanted to get one up on me. You have failed.

It is other people who start to link it to Jews around the world, not the Jews. Do you not get it?!! Since last Saturday, there has been a 3-4 fold increase in attacks on British Jews. Why the fuck should I be at risk because of the choices of a country where I do not live?

WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 13/10/2023 19:46

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 19:20

@LemonyTicket, there's only one last thing for me to say to you and it sums up in the saying 'practice what you preach'. You seem quite good at accusing others of your own actions.

As a jew, I have gone to finding your first posts interesting to finding them non credible because due your condescending attitude.

I’ll believe you. You’re Jewish.

So how do you manage to overlook the history of the Jews in respect of their willingness to defend Israel?

Other than Israel, that’s it for Jews and Judaism. As I imagine you’d understand.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 19:45

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 19:16

For anyone else reading this who is genuinely interested in learning about online antisemitism, and racism in general,@MeganSupervision ‘s questions and comments above are actually a common tactic used by racist people online. They’ll come along and ask faux-innocent questions when they don’t really want an answer. They just want to demand answers from Jewish people and deliberately get into an argument because they find it amusing. It’s subtle and nuanced, and you don’t necessarily see it at first, but unfortunately it’s a reason why a lot of us have given up commenting on these threads. This isn’t something that only happens to Jewish people. It happens to a lot of non-white people, just tiring people out and not genuinely wanting to have a civil discussion about it. It’s passive-aggressive behaviour.

Exactly, literally what the poster below your post is doing. Came to this thread yesterday and asked me to give her a detailed description of infrastructure, medical access and so on in the west bank (Something easy to google in seconds and nothing to do with this thread). Objective clearly being to start an argument. When I wouldn't give in to the demand, she started getting very aggressive and goady to a point I had to read the posts a few times to see if I'd missed something to explain the weird rage. Clearly just pissed off I wasn't taking the bait.

When that didn't work, came back to complain about me using the word "we" about Jews saying that she is a Jew (😯) and demanding I change my use of the word.

Just desperately goading, and we have it constantly. It's not about conversing, it's a spiteful kind of passive aggression.

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 19:20

@LemonyTicket, there's only one last thing for me to say to you and it sums up in the saying 'practice what you preach'. You seem quite good at accusing others of your own actions.

As a jew, I have gone to finding your first posts interesting to finding them non credible because due your condescending attitude.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 19:16

For anyone else reading this who is genuinely interested in learning about online antisemitism, and racism in general,@MeganSupervision ‘s questions and comments above are actually a common tactic used by racist people online. They’ll come along and ask faux-innocent questions when they don’t really want an answer. They just want to demand answers from Jewish people and deliberately get into an argument because they find it amusing. It’s subtle and nuanced, and you don’t necessarily see it at first, but unfortunately it’s a reason why a lot of us have given up commenting on these threads. This isn’t something that only happens to Jewish people. It happens to a lot of non-white people, just tiring people out and not genuinely wanting to have a civil discussion about it. It’s passive-aggressive behaviour.

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:55

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:50

You’re not seeing them because they don’t exist. Living in North London doesn’t mean everyone who lives there is your friend. I’ve had a couple of non-Jewish friends who said the same kind of rubbish as you, and I unfriended them because I don’t need to put up with antisemitism from my own friends.

Theoretically, if these alleged friends of yours saw the disingenuous stuff you’ve written in this thread, there’d be a huge argument coming. The only reason it’s not going to happen is because you don’t have these friends in the first place.

We’ve all heard variations of “Some of my best friends are black” a million times. Nobody believes you.

This is getting stupid. I am not seeing them this evening because they spend Friday night with their families.

I don’t have to defend my healthy and mutual friendships with internet nobodies.

If this is your only defence now, I shall no longer engage with your silliness and will leave you to have the last word you so desperately crave.

Brightlyshining · 13/10/2023 18:50

MeganSupervision · 13/10/2023 18:44

I am not seeing them this weekend but thanks. I am afraid having good Jewish friends is unavoidable if you live in N London ;-) They are great. And seem to quite like me. 🤷🏼‍♀️ I recommend you make some. For the bar/bat mitzvahs if nothing else!

You’re not seeing them because they don’t exist. Living in North London doesn’t mean everyone who lives there is your friend. I’ve had a couple of non-Jewish friends who said the same kind of rubbish as you, and I unfriended them because I don’t need to put up with antisemitism from my own friends.

Theoretically, if these alleged friends of yours saw the disingenuous stuff you’ve written in this thread, there’d be a huge argument coming. The only reason it’s not going to happen is because you don’t have these friends in the first place.

We’ve all heard variations of “Some of my best friends are black” a million times. Nobody believes you.

LemonyTicket · 13/10/2023 18:50

vivainsomnia · 13/10/2023 18:37

If you haven't - cool. WE still do. Even if YOU don't
If I and others haven't, it can't be WE. It might be some, or many, or a majority but not WE.

Easier to stick to accounting for personal experiences because otherwise, it is offensive to make assumptions on behalf of those who have nothing to do with what you describe.

Please stop trying to object to perfectly typical language and normal ways of speaking. I obviously can't write long things using "some, but not all Jews" every time instead of just saying "we".

I am Jewish, when I write about our history or anything like that, I can and will say "we". When I talk about our wider experiences as reported literally everywhere, I am totally entitled to say "we" as part of the group I indenitfy.

I would do the same if I was writing about anything. It's totally normal use of the English language. There is nothing offensive being implied about you. If I say "we experience antisemitism" and you haven't, you are not harmed.

You are just being contrary for the sake of it because I wouldn't answer your silly question yesterday and you had some silly tantrum over it where you went on for ages demanding I did what you said.

I can say "we" and will continue doing it. Stop trying to dictate to me what I can say and how I can say it. You do you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread