Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FeelingVeryUnwell · 11/10/2023 18:49

If for whatever reason Israel agreed with Hamas and handed over Gaza and Israel as a whole to the Palestinian people, what would happen to the Jewish population?

Evermean · 11/10/2023 18:47

The two state solution will never be agreed upon because the world knows it will never be fair and just.

@feralunderclass
So what's your solution? What do you think should happen to the Jewish homeland? (Or "homeland" as you called it?) Or will you just keep avoiding the question, just like you've avoided saying what you meant when you said Jews are the ones with the power.

andtheworldrollson · 11/10/2023 18:35

Do 1.6 million live as full Israel citizens with exactly the same rights as the Jewish population ?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2023 18:34

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 18:28

Kindly, you clearly have no idea what you are talking about. I was embarrassed reading your post.

Please, enlighten me then. You're brave enough to make snide comments, be brave enough to tell me your own opinions.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2023 18:31

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 18:23

Just lost my post and cba to type it out again. @LemonyTicket your attitude of legitimising the ongoing human rights violations against Palestinians because their population is increasing is absolutely disgusting. You cannot look at anything objectively, you keep making the Israelis to be the victims.
Regarding a "homeland", in 2020 alone 20,000 Olim (Jewish immigrants) from 70 countries were granted permission to live in Israel due to the Right to Return policy. They might never have even been in the country, or had any connection to it. The Palestinians who were forced to leave in 1948 and 67 don't have any right to return. They have lived there for possibly thousands of years. Where is the fairness? Each year the number of Olim increases, and where do you think the land to build settlements for them to live on comes from? It is taken (illegally, contravening international law) from Palestinians.
The two state solution will never be agreed upon because the world knows it will never be fair and just.

The two state solution will never be agreed upon because the world knows it will never be fair and just.

So what's your preferred outcome?

Perpetual war?

Israel to take full control of the region and potentially allow Palestinians to live there as Israel citizens (as 1.6m currently do)?

Palestine to take full control of the region and complete their stated aim of killing or driving every Jew out of the holy land?

andtheworldrollson · 11/10/2023 18:31

I think sone people are too close to accept that people can despise the actions of both sides equally

Both sides it seems would be happy to see the annihilation of the other

It does make me particularly sad though that the Isreal government can't see that it's actions and words against Palestine are so like the horrible actions and words used against jews for ever.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 18:28

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2023 18:24

Society is generally very poorly educated and bad about recognising antisemitism because a lot of antisemitism is insidious and uses propaganda and stereotypes, in ways society doesn't always recognise as damaging.

A really important point to drive home everytime it comes up.

We're seeing the rise of Jewish hate again, clear as day, in the narrative being pumped out over this latest flare up of the conflict. Just look at the countless threads on here and on other platforms.

Look at the OP, words like "genocide" and "apartheid" bandied about to describe Israels actions and not even an acknowledgement that Palestinian leaders are publicly and vocally committed to the obliteration of Israel and the extermination of the Jews. You dismiss this out of hand as "not relevant" when it's anything but.

The complexity and history of the situation distilled down into a black and white output of Israel bad, Palestine poor defenceless victims.

It's not the fault of Palestinians or their leaders that they're living in these horrible conditions, no. It's has nothing to do with the fact they've refused any and all attempts at peace, initiated (and lost) several wars, and carried out countless indiscriminate attacks.

No, its the fault of those pesky Jews! For coming to where they don't belong (or rather aren't wanted) and trying make a life for themselves on Muslim land!

And make no mistake it is the Jews who are the target, the state of Israel, not Israel Arabs, not secular Israelis, not just Israeli Jews but, all any and all Jews.

Just look at where's being vandalised and attacked in the UK during the protests, it's synagogues and known Jewish schools and business. No mosques or Muslim businesses were attacked despite around 18% of Israel being Muslim. Do they not bear any responsibility for their governments actions? Nope, just the Jews.

Isn't it strange that Palestinians are seen as a completely separate entity from their governments but Jews the world over are responsible for the actions of the Israeli government?

You're right OP people don't know the difference between antisemitism and antizionism including you.

Kindly, you clearly have no idea what you are talking about. I was embarrassed reading your post.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2023 18:24

Society is generally very poorly educated and bad about recognising antisemitism because a lot of antisemitism is insidious and uses propaganda and stereotypes, in ways society doesn't always recognise as damaging.

A really important point to drive home everytime it comes up.

We're seeing the rise of Jewish hate again, clear as day, in the narrative being pumped out over this latest flare up of the conflict. Just look at the countless threads on here and on other platforms.

Look at the OP, words like "genocide" and "apartheid" bandied about to describe Israels actions and not even an acknowledgement that Palestinian leaders are publicly and vocally committed to the obliteration of Israel and the extermination of the Jews. You dismiss this out of hand as "not relevant" when it's anything but.

The complexity and history of the situation distilled down into a black and white output of Israel bad, Palestine poor defenceless victims.

It's not the fault of Palestinians or their leaders that they're living in these horrible conditions, no. It's has nothing to do with the fact they've refused any and all attempts at peace, initiated (and lost) several wars, and carried out countless indiscriminate attacks.

No, its the fault of those pesky Jews! For coming to where they don't belong (or rather aren't wanted) and trying make a life for themselves on Muslim land!

And make no mistake it is the Jews who are the target, the state of Israel, not Israel Arabs, not secular Israelis, not just Israeli Jews but, all any and all Jews.

Just look at where's being vandalised and attacked in the UK during the protests, it's synagogues and known Jewish schools and business. No mosques or Muslim businesses were attacked despite around 18% of Israel being Muslim. Do they not bear any responsibility for their governments actions? Nope, just the Jews.

Isn't it strange that Palestinians are seen as a completely separate entity from their governments but Jews the world over are responsible for the actions of the Israeli government?

You're right OP people don't know the difference between antisemitism and antizionism including you.

Teder · 11/10/2023 18:24

AskNotForWhomTheBellCurves · 11/10/2023 18:18

Was the second paragraph in response to my post? If so then my spiteful dig was aimed the other way, at the people who quietly think those things about Jews but would never say as much in polite company. Sorry if I didn't make that clear.

Sorry no it wasn’t! It just reminded me that people often use it and it turns my stomach. I understand your post.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 18:23

Just lost my post and cba to type it out again. @LemonyTicket your attitude of legitimising the ongoing human rights violations against Palestinians because their population is increasing is absolutely disgusting. You cannot look at anything objectively, you keep making the Israelis to be the victims.
Regarding a "homeland", in 2020 alone 20,000 Olim (Jewish immigrants) from 70 countries were granted permission to live in Israel due to the Right to Return policy. They might never have even been in the country, or had any connection to it. The Palestinians who were forced to leave in 1948 and 67 don't have any right to return. They have lived there for possibly thousands of years. Where is the fairness? Each year the number of Olim increases, and where do you think the land to build settlements for them to live on comes from? It is taken (illegally, contravening international law) from Palestinians.
The two state solution will never be agreed upon because the world knows it will never be fair and just.

LemonyTicket · 11/10/2023 18:22

@andtheworldrollson

But lemony if Israel has stayed within the original land bounds and let Palestine have land too then just perhaps we would have less trouble?

It would be morally the correct thing to do, but in terms of evidence, nothing they have ever done or not done has affected anything.

hadaye · 11/10/2023 18:19

andtheworldrollson · 11/10/2023 18:06

But lemony if Israel has stayed within the original land bounds and let Palestine have land too then just perhaps we would have less trouble ?

But actually I am beginning to not care about the history - this is about the here and now and we need to stop history repeating itself by not allowing history to affect now so much , history being used to justify murder

If we go back far enough it's our families that are on both sides being killed today

Everyone needs to be able to live together

Groups like hamas and people like @feralunderclass don't want Israel to stay inside those borders, they don't want it to exist at all.

Defiantjazz · 11/10/2023 18:19

It’s breathtakingly ignorant for people to say “oh we cannot criticise Israel” when people have alreadybegun with their spiteful digs about jews having power, skin colour (no we weren’t all white!) and how we need to remember the holocaust was 70 + years ago etc.

I know it wasn’t you who said it but “If you’re not Jewish shut up” probably wasn’t the best opening gambit.

AskNotForWhomTheBellCurves · 11/10/2023 18:18

Teder · 11/10/2023 18:03

That’s because threads criticising Israeli government descend into making stereotypical and racist comments about the Jews.

It’s breathtakingly ignorant for people to say “oh we cannot criticise Israel” when people have already begun with their spiteful digs about jews having power, skin colour (no we weren’t all white!) and how we need to remember the holocaust was 70 + years ago etc.

Was the second paragraph in response to my post? If so then my spiteful dig was aimed the other way, at the people who quietly think those things about Jews but would never say as much in polite company. Sorry if I didn't make that clear.

Teder · 11/10/2023 18:14

“They weren't relevent to my point. My point isn't about terrorist acts. My point is that anti Semitism is not inherently the same thing as Anti Zionism...” @Fruitandclottedcream I don’t disagree with you but people very quickly descend into anti semitism on these threads. It never takes very long…

Teder · 11/10/2023 18:13

andtheworldrollson · 11/10/2023 18:06

But lemony if Israel has stayed within the original land bounds and let Palestine have land too then just perhaps we would have less trouble ?

But actually I am beginning to not care about the history - this is about the here and now and we need to stop history repeating itself by not allowing history to affect now so much , history being used to justify murder

If we go back far enough it's our families that are on both sides being killed today

Everyone needs to be able to live together

Hamas don’t want to stay within the so-call original bounds of land. They want to obliterate all the Jews and the state of Israel. They are not going to negotiate.

I cannot see how there will ever be peace. Lives are being ruined and it is horrific.

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 18:08

PurpleChrayne · 11/10/2023 17:11

But don't you see that failing to condemn Hamas when you rightfully condemn other terrorists IS anti-Semitic? It can be nothing else.

If you're responding to my original post I did condemn Hamas. On my actual post. I specifically said "Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point."

They weren't relevent to my point. My point isn't about terrorist acts. My point is that anti Semitism is not inherently the same thing as Anti Zionism...

OP posts:
Defiantjazz · 11/10/2023 18:06

It was indeed part of the Ottoman empire, and muslims, christians and jews lived there for centuries, sometimes fairly harmoniously and sometimes not. My point is that palestine wasn’t an established country that was just randomly colonised by european jews post-WW2, which is how it’s often portrayed - like most geopolitical history, the reality is way more complex.

Palestine did exist, to all intents and purposes, and the people who lived there were mucked about by the British Empires (probably well meaning) meddling. There’s the colonial element right there. European powers fucking things up.

andtheworldrollson · 11/10/2023 18:06

But lemony if Israel has stayed within the original land bounds and let Palestine have land too then just perhaps we would have less trouble ?

But actually I am beginning to not care about the history - this is about the here and now and we need to stop history repeating itself by not allowing history to affect now so much , history being used to justify murder

If we go back far enough it's our families that are on both sides being killed today

Everyone needs to be able to live together

Teder · 11/10/2023 18:03

Defiantjazz · 11/10/2023 17:44

It is a bit frustrating when you feel like you can’t criticize Zionism without being accused of anti-Semitism. That’s probably the reason some people want to separate the two notions.

Well, that and that fact that not believing Isreal is beyond reproach doesn’t actually mean you have it in for every Jewish person you know.

That’s because threads criticising Israeli government descend into making stereotypical and racist comments about the Jews.

It’s breathtakingly ignorant for people to say “oh we cannot criticise Israel” when people have already begun with their spiteful digs about jews having power, skin colour (no we weren’t all white!) and how we need to remember the holocaust was 70 + years ago etc.

LemonyTicket · 11/10/2023 17:59

Defiantjazz · 11/10/2023 17:44

It is a bit frustrating when you feel like you can’t criticize Zionism without being accused of anti-Semitism. That’s probably the reason some people want to separate the two notions.

Well, that and that fact that not believing Isreal is beyond reproach doesn’t actually mean you have it in for every Jewish person you know.

It is a bit frustrating when you feel like you can’t criticize Zionism without being accused of anti-Semitism

This is what criticizing zionism might sound like: "I understand Jews went through enormous struggle globally and needed to resolve the issue, but I feel trying to grow and build a larger base in the middle east might be destabilising. I think there are solutions for reintegrating a more multicultural approach again in the middle east if we can tackle extremism".

That is what legitimate, logic based, evidence based criticism of zionism as a concept might sound. The very minute you start deciding that "zionism" means genocide, apartheid and oppression then you are basically just using "zionism" as a code word to Jew bash.

Because frankly, zionism is not genocide, apartheid or oppression. It is a legitimate response to Jews experiencing all those things. Had Jews been allowed to live equally and fairly literally anywhere they would have been delighted.

Unfortunately they were not, particularly in their homeland of the middle east where they literally lived in apartheid for thousands of years. They literally were subordinate and did not have the same rights and had to live through all sorts of oppression, indignity and opression.

And moreover, actual genocide. We bandy about these words, but the facts are the Palestinian population in Israel has doubled. No one is suferring genocide. WE DID. We were quite literally almost exterminated as a group several times, and often by Arabs in our homelands.

We WERE quite literally oppressed. We had no country of our own, we had no protection in law, no rights to any land, we were not allowed to work in government, or socialise with Arabs, or live except in our designated areas. The yellow star the Nazis used was borrowed from the Arab world who also made us wear them.

So reframing the idea that we deserved our freedom and a place of our own as all the things we were escaping from is wrong. We would have happily lived peacefully for the last 75 years but we are unfortunately in a position where the people we were trying to live beside did not want us to have our own state.

Teder · 11/10/2023 17:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You ignored my point and continued to judge and lecture about a culture you clearly do not understand. I wasn’t calling you anti-Semitic. I was simply saying how non Jews should sit down and be quiet and let Jewish people speak. I wouldn’t speak over and speak for other ethnic minorities.

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 17:56

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 15:55

I am staunchly anti Zionist but not anti semitic at all. Many Arabs are semites, and many Christians are Zionists. I follow a lot of Jewish people on social media and I don't think a single one of them can accept the fact that someone might be against Israeli policy without them being a "jew hater". Someone on another thread questioned this anti zionist=antisemitic thing and a Jewish poster said that as the vast majority of Jews are Zionist by creed they feel extremely defensive and reflexively 'lash out' with the antisemitic accusation. It's an effective way to close down any discussion.

I've noticed this.
I've had a Jewish creator lash out at me, call me anti semitic and block me because she made a post and denied that the strikes in Gaza were happening because "Israel wouldn't hurt civilians". All I had actually said before she said that to me was that we need to acknowledge attacks are happening on both sides, and we need to condemn the fact that innocent civilians and children on both sides of this conflict are being murdered.

I do feel that a lot of Jewish creators I've seen on social media use anti semitism as a quick way to shut down the conversation and prevent people from challenging their world view. I suppose it boils down to cognitive dissonance in those cases. It's probably incredibly uncomfortable to acknowledge that Israel, the land that is meant to keep them safe, is actively causing others harm and isn't the safe haven they've grown up to believe it is.

OP posts:
KnitFastDieWarm · 11/10/2023 17:54

@Defiantjazz It was indeed part of the Ottoman empire, and muslims, christians and jews lived there for centuries, sometimes fairly harmoniously and sometimes not. My point is that palestine wasn’t an established country that was just randomly colonised by european jews post-WW2, which is how it’s often portrayed - like most geopolitical history, the reality is way more complex.

KnitFastDieWarm · 11/10/2023 17:49

Perhaps it’s better to say you’re critical of the current israeli government? ‘Anti-zionism’ is generally a massive dog whistle for anti-semitism because it has a history of being used to justify conspiracy theories about ‘jews running the world’ and other such nonsense.

Swipe left for the next trending thread