Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Defiantjazz · 11/10/2023 22:43

It does seem that way, doesn't it? Shame, I was interested to hear their answers

I don’t know why I bother sometimes.
can some people not read ?

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 22:42

I do think that concerns about the treatment of Palestinians is feeding antisemitism, as you say anti Israel and anti Zionism ends up just being anti Jew. I went to a very integrated grammar school in the 60s. In my city there was no Jewish senior school and very minimal provision for senior school places in Catholic schools so my school became the default school for Jewish and Catholic kids who passed the 11 plus, as time went on Muslim families also chose the school.

We had a Rabbi come in to do assembly for the Jewish girls every Friday, then the Imam came in for the Muslim girls. A Catholic teacher did assembly for us Catholic girls and every term the local priest came in an said mass in the school hall. I think it was very progressive and very good for good community relations
as we were all valued and our culture respected.

There is one thing I have never heard discussed and I don't know the answer but maybe someone on here does, did Israel pay compensation for seized houses/farms?

Saschka · 11/10/2023 22:37

quiteoldad · 11/10/2023 22:28

Teder wrote
"Please don’t pretend there hasn’t been a plethora of anti Jewish propaganda on here."

I've seen a lot of vehement anti-Israel propaganda on here.

I cannot be sure whether or not it comes from antisemites, .... neither I think, can you.

There have been LOADS of threads deleted this evening - I promise you, there has been overt anti-Semitism, not just criticism of the Israeli government’s actions.

I don’t think MNHQ would delete multiple threads just for being insufficiently pro-Likud, do you?

Evermean · 11/10/2023 22:36

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 22:29

When "the enriching diversity of immigration" means that those who live there already get their human rights violated, then of course it is wrong. Please read into the Israeli policy. It has never been about Jews simply wanting a homeland to coexist peacefully. The whole raison d'etre of the policy is to subjugate the Palestinian population. As has been said numerous times, they were already living together before the occupation.

So once again what do you want to happen to Israel and where do you think the Jewish homeland should be?

FloorWipes · 11/10/2023 22:35

What’s the point of this thread? I feel like OP you are making this about you when you and your opinions on this don’t matter in the slightest right now. Why are you doing that?

Evermean · 11/10/2023 22:33

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 22:16

The Jewish person holds the power

If this is in relation to what I said, then I did not make the above statement,you are twisting things to suit your narrative.

Yes you did, on page two of this thread.

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 22:30

Teder · 11/10/2023 21:35

@Fruitandclottedcream You seem very clear what anti semitism is and is not. What what qualifies you to make that statement? Your ethnic background - when clearly not Jewish - does not make you any more understanding of anti semitism, so I assume you have a detailed understanding of the history of Judaism.

I do actually have a detailed understanding of Jewish history. I've spent a lot of time learning over the past several years because I strive to be anti racist, and part of anti racism is understanding Anti-Semitism. Which means becoming educated about Jewish Culture, Heritage and History.

Just above this post There's an excerpt of a previous comment of mine, detailing some of the history I'm familiar with. There's more detail in a much longer comment. I think it's on page 4 of this thread.

OP posts:
feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 22:29

When "the enriching diversity of immigration" means that those who live there already get their human rights violated, then of course it is wrong. Please read into the Israeli policy. It has never been about Jews simply wanting a homeland to coexist peacefully. The whole raison d'etre of the policy is to subjugate the Palestinian population. As has been said numerous times, they were already living together before the occupation.

quiteoldad · 11/10/2023 22:28

Teder wrote
"Please don’t pretend there hasn’t been a plethora of anti Jewish propaganda on here."

I've seen a lot of vehement anti-Israel propaganda on here.

I cannot be sure whether or not it comes from antisemites, .... neither I think, can you.

Pollyputhekettleon · 11/10/2023 22:19

hadaye · 11/10/2023 19:37

No I don't think they can explain.

Many of them are genuinely unaware that Jews lived in Israel all along. They think they started emigrating there after WW2 from Europe. Some of them think they started emigrating there from Europe before then as part of the Zionist movement.

Others think they shouldn't have been given a state because it would have either required the Arabs on that territory to either move to the Arab section, or to live under majority Jewish rule. They think that would have been something like genocide. I presume they believe that the Jews who were in the area all along should have agreed to live as a minority in the Arab state, which was to cover the entire territory. And Jews from Europe presumably shouldn't have been allowed to migrate there. Apparently some people are allowed to not appreciate the enriching diversity of immigration.

JSMill · 11/10/2023 22:18

OneTC · 11/10/2023 10:31

Some people do use it as a diversion for sure but I think lots of people are also pretty willfully blind to the actual anti-Semitism that is dressed up as anti Zionism as well.

Hmm. Arabs come under the definition of Semite people. So if you criticise them aren't you being anti semetic?

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 22:16

The Jewish person holds the power

If this is in relation to what I said, then I did not make the above statement,you are twisting things to suit your narrative.

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 22:14

Barak Ravid AT BarakRavid
BREAKING: Biden: I have known Bibi for 40 years and we have frank conversations. I told him that with all the anger and frustration it is important that Israel operates in Gaza according to the rules of war

Read between the diplomatic lines on this: the US government ARE concerned about how Israel are responding / going to respond.

Thats not as 'fully supportive' as you might expect from the US. There is a definite tone of worry and its certainly not giving a ringing endorsement of the Israeli government.

This ISN'T typical of any US administration.

Teder · 11/10/2023 22:11

quiteoldad · 11/10/2023 21:38

Unless someone comes onto this board and says something such as “Jews are the cause of our troubles”, then you are going to have a devil of a job determining whether or not they are antisemitic.

Criticising the brutality of Israel or saying that the creation of the Jewish state was a bad idea, are not in themselves antisemitic, though of course such things could and probably would be said by an antisemite. Unfortunately, the accusation of antisemitism has been sprayed around on these chatboards willy-nilly, with very little evidence being presented for its actual existence.

You’ve had plenty of Jewish people on MN who have openly condemned the attacks on Gaza and who believe any harm caused to innocent, every day people is 100% abhorrent. I am one of those people. Please don’t pretend there hasn’t been a plethora of anti Jewish propaganda on here. It’s on this thread. Some is subtle, some is overt. Please listen to the people who say we see it on here and it’s not about zionism. I have given examples on this thread as have others.

Evermean · 11/10/2023 22:08

quiteoldad · 11/10/2023 21:38

Unless someone comes onto this board and says something such as “Jews are the cause of our troubles”, then you are going to have a devil of a job determining whether or not they are antisemitic.

Criticising the brutality of Israel or saying that the creation of the Jewish state was a bad idea, are not in themselves antisemitic, though of course such things could and probably would be said by an antisemite. Unfortunately, the accusation of antisemitism has been sprayed around on these chatboards willy-nilly, with very little evidence being presented for its actual existence.

What about" the Jewish person holds the power?" Or Jewish people should leave their homeland, which I'm guessing is what the poster is implying. Of course no one is going to come out and say "fuck the Jews", not without the post lasting more than five minutes. That's what dogwhistles are for.

OhHelloTheres · 11/10/2023 21:45

hadaye · 11/10/2023 19:37

No I don't think they can explain.

It does seem that way, doesn't it? Shame, I was interested to hear their answers

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 21:41

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2023 18:24

Society is generally very poorly educated and bad about recognising antisemitism because a lot of antisemitism is insidious and uses propaganda and stereotypes, in ways society doesn't always recognise as damaging.

A really important point to drive home everytime it comes up.

We're seeing the rise of Jewish hate again, clear as day, in the narrative being pumped out over this latest flare up of the conflict. Just look at the countless threads on here and on other platforms.

Look at the OP, words like "genocide" and "apartheid" bandied about to describe Israels actions and not even an acknowledgement that Palestinian leaders are publicly and vocally committed to the obliteration of Israel and the extermination of the Jews. You dismiss this out of hand as "not relevant" when it's anything but.

The complexity and history of the situation distilled down into a black and white output of Israel bad, Palestine poor defenceless victims.

It's not the fault of Palestinians or their leaders that they're living in these horrible conditions, no. It's has nothing to do with the fact they've refused any and all attempts at peace, initiated (and lost) several wars, and carried out countless indiscriminate attacks.

No, its the fault of those pesky Jews! For coming to where they don't belong (or rather aren't wanted) and trying make a life for themselves on Muslim land!

And make no mistake it is the Jews who are the target, the state of Israel, not Israel Arabs, not secular Israelis, not just Israeli Jews but, all any and all Jews.

Just look at where's being vandalised and attacked in the UK during the protests, it's synagogues and known Jewish schools and business. No mosques or Muslim businesses were attacked despite around 18% of Israel being Muslim. Do they not bear any responsibility for their governments actions? Nope, just the Jews.

Isn't it strange that Palestinians are seen as a completely separate entity from their governments but Jews the world over are responsible for the actions of the Israeli government?

You're right OP people don't know the difference between antisemitism and antizionism including you.

not even an acknowledgement that Palestinian leaders are publicly and vocally committed to the obliteration of Israel and the extermination of the Jews.

You clearly stopped reading my post as soon as I challenged your world view because I literally comdemned Hamas behaviour in the last part of my post. I would argue that even if I didn't specifically mention every single Palestinian leader... condemning the attacks against Israeli citizens is a really REALLY clear sign I strongly disagree with the fact that some Palestinian groups want to exterminate Jews. Forgive me for assuming a grown adult could infer that from a statement saying I condemn the actions of Hamas.

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 11/10/2023 21:40

Equally I don't think people understand the difference between Palestinians and Hamas in this current conflict:

quiteoldad · 11/10/2023 21:38

Unless someone comes onto this board and says something such as “Jews are the cause of our troubles”, then you are going to have a devil of a job determining whether or not they are antisemitic.

Criticising the brutality of Israel or saying that the creation of the Jewish state was a bad idea, are not in themselves antisemitic, though of course such things could and probably would be said by an antisemite. Unfortunately, the accusation of antisemitism has been sprayed around on these chatboards willy-nilly, with very little evidence being presented for its actual existence.

Teder · 11/10/2023 21:35

@Fruitandclottedcream You seem very clear what anti semitism is and is not. What what qualifies you to make that statement? Your ethnic background - when clearly not Jewish - does not make you any more understanding of anti semitism, so I assume you have a detailed understanding of the history of Judaism.

etmoietmoietmoi · 11/10/2023 21:34

However I'm familiar with the creation of Israel and the exodus of Jewish people after WW2 which is why I'm solely against the modern political Zionist ideology, including the oppression of Palestine. I take no issue with Zionism in the context of creating a homeland for Jewish people. I'd want a safe homeland after centuries of oppression too. I also understand the religious significance of being in Israel

Thank you for your posts @Fruitandclottedcream, FWIW I think they are generally very considered. While I strongly disagree with some of your comments though, I think you touched upon the biggest part of the problem here, which is the interpretation of 'Zionist'. Many Jewish people see Zionism as nothing more than the creation and existence of a homeland for Jews, a place where they can live a life safe from persecution. Ideologically-speaking it's very much wrapped up in the context of the immediate post-Holocaust period. That's how I interpret Zionism anyway. But I also see Israel as somewhere where Jews can go to today in order to escape current antisemitism. (Do I agree with aggressive Israeli expansion into Palestinian land? No, I don't). I'm ethnically Jewish and although from the UK I'm also half-French, and can tell you there has been a mass exodus of Jews from France to Israel over the last 10 years due to increased antisemitic hate crimes and violence. So for many, the Zionist state is just interpreted as nothing more than a place of safety should we need it.

On the other hand, many non-Jews use the term Zionism to mean what you've termed "the modern political Zionist ideology", which, with the current Israeli PM is supremacist and racist. FWIW I despise Netanyahu and so do all British Jews that I know, although I don't think we should have to keep declaring this. Anti-Zionist therefore means different things to different people. However that being said, "Zionist" for many others, particularly antisemites on the far left, use the word simply as code for "Jew". It is also wrapped up in anti-imperialism ideology and often anti-globalist conspiracy theories. These people on the far left are different from the more-explicit antisemites of the far right, and know how to disguise their prejudice towards Jews at best, visceral hatred at worst. This is quite easy to identify, particularly on social media timelines of people who display a fanatical, obsessive hatred of Israel - frequently Corbyn loyalists - who never have one word to say about Syria, China or Russia, etc. So obviously when someone proudly declares themselves a staunch anti-Zionist, we're going to be wary. Being on the left doesn't automatically give people anti-racism credentials (how many times do we need to hear "lifelong antiracist" from people who are anything but). This has been very hard for many of us, especially because historically, Jews have been a very socialist and left-leaning group of people. And I can tell you it is beyond galling to have non-Jews downplay experiences of antisemitism or tell you that you're just making it up, imagining it or using it as a "smear".

What particularly scares me though is that Jews are an incredibly tiny group in the UK, which makes us feel incredibly vulnerable. It's very hard to try and blot out the fact that increasingly people are becoming more brazen in displaying hostility towards us, and like nothing more than to bait us and hold us to account for the actions of a barbaric, right wing government in another country. Or for Labour losing an election. For the first time in my life this week I am scared that the situation for Jews in the UK (which has become more polarised and intolerant in general) is going to deteriorate to the extent that I might want to leave the country I grew up in. But where to go? Move my non-Jewish DH and family to France (which is only marginally better than the UK at the moment)? Or Israel, where I literally have zero connections or attachment, and which is anything but safe? I'm not religious nor am I culturally Jewish, so I can only imagine how much more frightened British people more active in the Jewish community feel.

Sorry for the long post.

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 21:26

INeedAnotherName · 11/10/2023 16:24

Well I've just learnt something. I thought both phrases meant the same.

So loosely speaking -
Anti semitic - hostile/hating Jewish people
Anti zionist - hostile/hating the creation and/or the state of Israel ?? ?

So what is the word for hostile/hate for the Israeli government's policy for the collective punishment of civilians (a war crime) that they have decided on? Because I think that is the position where most people have been posting from. Not the other two.

Edited

That would also fall under anti Zionism. Because Israeli governments current policy have been created in line with their modern Zionist ideology

OP posts:
Defiantjazz · 11/10/2023 21:26

Not to mention the chuptzpah really of the entire thread "people don't actually understand what antisemitism is". From a non Jew, and my "people" she presumably means the victims (Jews)

As I said earlier you do often get accused of antisemitism if you criticise Israel in any way and no you don’t have to be be going on about global conspiracy’s or brandying the word genocide about to goad. Just pointing out there’s violence/wrong doing from both sides seems to be enough.

A lot of people seem to think that means you’re secretly siding with Hammas and think Israel shouldn't exist.

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 21:21

LemonyTicket · 11/10/2023 21:06

@Defiantjazz

More or less yes. This is one post:

So no, just because a Jewish person tells me I'm antisemitic because I'm anti Zionist, then no, I don't feel I'm obliged to accept that as fact

That particular poster has made clear they wouldn't know antisemitism if it jumped her in the shower in an SS uniform to be fair.

Not to mention the chuptzpah really of the entire thread "people don't actually understand what antisemitism is". From a non Jew, and my "people" she presumably means the victims (Jews).

Mayeb she was hoping to teach us what it was so we will understand in future 🙄

I mean the quote is correct. It's not a fact that she's anti Semitic because she's anti Zionist. I haven't read the thread so she could be both. But she could also simply be against the Israeli's illegal occupation and oppression of Palestine.

From what I've seen You've basically spent the entire thread heavily implying that people who are anti Zionist are Anti Semitists for disagreeing with Israeli policy because the person writing the policy is Jewish. That's not what anti semitism is. And that is a fact.

OP posts:
LemonyTicket · 11/10/2023 21:06

@Defiantjazz

More or less yes. This is one post:

So no, just because a Jewish person tells me I'm antisemitic because I'm anti Zionist, then no, I don't feel I'm obliged to accept that as fact

That particular poster has made clear they wouldn't know antisemitism if it jumped her in the shower in an SS uniform to be fair.

Not to mention the chuptzpah really of the entire thread "people don't actually understand what antisemitism is". From a non Jew, and my "people" she presumably means the victims (Jews).

Mayeb she was hoping to teach us what it was so we will understand in future 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread