Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FloorWipes · 12/10/2023 07:09

Fruitandclottedcream · 12/10/2023 00:08

At the risk of being rude.
1.You're wrong. I don't have an agenda to push, I don't particularly want to present myself in a certain way. If I did, I would write a long LONG post with my thoughts and feelings on the entire topic of the Israel/Palestine conflict. A large chunk of my thoughts and feelings right now, are based around the fact that someone I know just lost 19 extended family members in 48 hours due to bombing on the Gaza strip. And how my dad has lost Israeli friends this week and how people everywhere are losing loved ones because of this.
And that whatever is going on in Gaza, is going on in Israeli territories, and vice versa, and how my heart breaks that thousands of civilians are killed and are just seen as "collateral damage" by terrorists on both sides. And how families can't even keep their babies and children safe from attack when these children have done nothing. They hold no opinions, they don't understand. And yet their lives are on the line, every single day.
I didn't post to "push a particular agenda" I just wanted to see if anybody shared my particular opinion, because I've been accused of being anti Semitic for saying I oppose modern Zionist ideology, even though I hold no hostility or prejudice towards Judaism or Jewish people. And actually, I've read everyone's views and learnt lots. But sure, I'm pushing an ugly agenda because I didn't really want to write a long post about how my heart breaks for everyone when it wasn't relevant.
2. "How learned and educated you are on all these matters, according to you" - I never said I'm "learned and educated on all these matters" . I said as somebody who strives to be anti racist, that includes learning about anti semitism and Jewish culture, heritage and history. And that I sought Jewish voices and resources to learn. I don't see an issue with that. At least I'm trying to educate myself before forming opinions. Which judging by your comments is something you're clearly not bothering to do.

  1. It was jumping out at me so I felt like saying it
Theres this little thought bubble in your head, it's where you're supposed to push all the goady and unconstructive thoughts that jump out at you. I suggest you find yours and utilise it.
Edited

I am not trying to goad you - I am trying to show you that you come across as extremely lacking in humility through all this, at best.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 06:56

To us, even thinking this implies you feel Jews are sneaky, surreptitious, scheming, deceptive, in a plot to protect Israel...... that makes me really uncomfortable to be honest!

And being accused of being racist is meant to make me feel just fab is it?

nappiesandcontracts · 12/10/2023 06:49

CoughingMajoress · 11/10/2023 13:24

If you aren't Jewish just shut up. It's not appropriate for people who aren't minorities to lecture to minorities about what is and isn't racism.

Society is generally very poorly educated and bad about recognising antisemitism because a lot of antisemitism is insidious and uses propaganda and stereotypes, in ways society doesn't always recognise as damaging. For example, one of the most dangerous stereotypes about Jews is that we're money grubbing and I've had a lot of people not understand why that's a bad thing, because "surely being good with money is a good thing?" But to understand why this trope exists and why it's so dangerous, requires understanding literally centuries of Jewish history. This stereotype IS very very dangerous and it's literally been used to justify multiple genocides. After the Treaty of Versailles, the German government weaponised this stereotype via massive propaganda campaigns to blame Germany's poverty on Jews hoarding the money, rather than acknowledge their own responsibility for the huge financial penalties forced upon Germany after WWI; that propaganda campaign (which would not have existed if not for centuries of Jews being cast as money grubbing, a stereotype that goes back to the era when Jews were forced into jobs as money lenders, then penalised by Medieval Christians for the jobs they'd forced Jews into) very directly led to the Holocaust.

And I bet anything someone will come along in a minute and accuse me of being yet another Jew who won't stop blathering about the Holocaust.

There's a huge amount of antisemitism wrapped up in antizionism, and a lot of people frankly don't give a fuck about Palestine and are just using it to have a pop at Jews.

Every Jewish person is expected to have an opinion on Israel, is held responsible for Israel, there's been a big wave of antisemitic attacks in the UK over the past few days, in a way that would never happen in any similar situation. The Chinese government literally have concentration camps were religious minorities are tortured and mass murdered (including being killed to order for the illegal organ trade) and it gets almost zero media attention and no Chinese person in the UK would be judged or asked their opinion about the actions of their government, yet Jews - many of whom have no connection to Israel - don't get the same grace.

That's why so much antizionism is antisemitic.

And yet you can't talk about Israel without understanding the history of how Israel was created, and how it's been used as a weapon by geopolitical forces (eg the way the US and USSR used the Middle East as a staging ground for proxy war during the Cold War, or how the USA is using Israel to prevent the Middle East from becoming one big Islamic fundamentalist superstate, or how the US is using Israel as a tactical intelligence centre in the Middle East and how this relates to oil wealth, or how the US religious right extremists support Israel because of Biblical Literalism which is not exactly Jewish-friendly) and how much Jews have been abused and exploited in that process. Israel was created because Europe wanted to get rid of all the Jews after WWII, and not give back all the land and wealth that was stolen from European Jews during the war. I mean Israel was nearly in Uganda for God's sake, no one cared about Jewish people, only getting rid of them.

And people don't understand just how minuscule a minority we are. Jews make up just 0.2% of the world's population. Muslims make up 24% of the world's population, and Christians make up 31%. That is an INSANE disparity.

Plus, Jews only have one single miniscule country to call our own where we can be safe (after centuries of non-stop persecution and multiple genocides). There are nearly FIFTY Muslim countries, and many of those countries are extremely wealthy and could protect and home the entire population of Palestine if they wanted to. The rest of the Arab world has either turned its back on Palestine, or is (in the case of Iran) actively bombing infrastructure in Gaza and funding terrorism that will actively harm Palestinians because Iran wants to kill all Jews, and doesn't care how many Palestinians are hurt or killed in the process.

I'm not defending the actions of the Israeli government, no one I know agrees with the violent oppression and apartheid of the current government. Everyone I know has serious concerns about Israel's swing to the far right and the growing power the ultra-religious have in Israeli politics. And this systemic violent oppression is not just of the Palestinians, but of minority groups within Israel, such as Israeli Bedouin. Systemic violent oppression of Israeli Bedouin by the Israeli government is just as bad, yet somehow the world media don't give the tiniest shit. Most people outside Israel have never even heard of this! And that raises the question, why is the plight of some oppressed people (like Palestinians) a massive worldwide issue, while the plight of other equally oppressed people (like Bedouin, or Muslim Uyghurs in China) goes totally ignored? What political agenda is being served by this cherry picking?

Great, very interesting post- I've learnt a lot. Thank you

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 12/10/2023 03:30

Lemony you have written incredible things in this thread. I hope people learn from them.

CoughingMajoress · 12/10/2023 03:23

LemonyTicket · 11/10/2023 23:54

I vehemently disagree.

When you are angry with Spains goverment, you criticise the specific policy and discuss that. You don't develop "anti Spainism".

When you are angry at China's government, you criticise the specific policy and discuss that. You don't develop "anti China ism"

You don't need new special words for the only Jewish state.

If you are angry at settlements in the west bank - criticise those.

If you are angry at delayed permits for medical care being arranged - criticise that

You will not find many Jews who don't vehemently agree with you.

But when you start using these words "anti zionism", you are telling us our country should not exist. Then can you understand this is treating us differently?

Exactly, and thank you for your posts, Lemony.

CoughingMajoress · 12/10/2023 03:21

Also, I am ONE person. And my dad is white English and Christian. My dad's family have lived in England for 900 years ffs.

I'm also a woman, a feminist, a lesbian, am GC, and am a very longterm Mumsnetter who has known and chatted and been friends with some of you for many years.

The point is that I am a person and a rounded human being and an individual, just like anyone else here.

Yet you're not capable of seeing me as anything other than "a Jew".

And making blanket statements, just because one single Mumsnetter who happens to be Jewish said something in a tone that was very slightly more brusque or less politely worded than you feel "Jews" should be to you.

For fuck's sake, this is Mumsnet. And this is AIBU. If you can't handle someone not being soft and gentle and nicey nice, get the fuck of AIBU. This thread is practically warm and cuddly compared to the average parking or cycling AIBU..

Yet it's only because a regular Mumsnetter happens to be Jewish that you take a lack of politeness as being indicative of how awful Jews are, what with our infamous "rudeness" and all.

Some people just don't see Jewish people as human beings.

Jeezypeepers · 12/10/2023 03:17

@LemonyTicket I just wanted to jump onto a thread on this that hasn’t filled up yet and thank you for your brilliant (and endlessly patient, despite lots of provocation from a selection of absolute fannies) explanations of the formation of today’s Israel and Palestine.

To the other poster who’s name I can’t remember Blush (French ethnic Jew lady) I’m in a similar position to you in that I’m an atheist, but ethnically Jewish woman living in a small Scottish town (from a big city originally) with zero Jewish population. I’ve also been quizzing my kids today on who knows they’re Jewish Sad. I actually wear a Magen David, as it was my mums, and we have a mezuzah on our door; and I’ve been really swaying about whether I should be removing them both at the moment. I’ve never felt this before in Scotland ever ever. Never unsafe. Now I’m unsure and just so uneasy. And like you we wouldn’t manage in Israel…my kids and I speak zero Hebrew and are just so culturally Scottish. It’s a really unsettling time for us all isn’t it; solidarity to all of us who feel removed from observant judiasm but are still Jewish enough for the antisemites Flowers.

CoughingMajoress · 12/10/2023 03:14

If any other minority said "it's not for you to dictate to actual minorities what is and isn't bigotry against my minority group" it wouldn't generate this much hatred.

People literally posting that they HATE Jewish posters just for saying, don't dictate to Jews what is and isn't antisemitic.

If a woman was to post "Men stop telling women what is and isn't misogynistic" would you be screaming about how much you hate her, and how it's so typical of all women to shut down debate by telling poor mens that as men they can't possibly know what misogyny is, and that women should be the voices being listened to?

If a lesbian poster was to start a thread in Feminist Chat about homophobia, would you find it acceptable for lots of straight posters to lecture her that she's wrong and that they're the authority on what is and isn't homophobic? Of course not.

I didn't scream "shut up", I asked posters who are not members of a specific minority group to let actual minorities speak, because only minorities are qualified to gauge what is and isn't bigotry towards themselves.

Because the fact is, antisemitism is very complex and coded, and requires a lot of historical education to be able to recognise and understand. Most non-Jews genuinely don't understand why the trope of Jews being good with money is considered very harmful and dangerous, while the trope of Jews being argumentative is considered far less so. (There's a very specific cultural reason why that trope exists and why it's perceived as being less harmful, which I'd be happy to delineate if you could stop screaming about how much you "DETEST" Jews who say non-Jews aren't qualified to recognise antisemitism for two minutes.)

And I gave a substantial amount of time to writing a very informative post containing a large amount of detail that most people outside the ME have never even heard of, much less consider themselves well-educated about. Clearly most posters here are not experts on Middle Eastern geopolitical history, so why do you refuse to listen to thoughtful and lengthy factual posts from people who are?

Posters actively turn down actual minorities taking the time to help them to educate themselves, by just screaming "I HATE PEOPLE LIKE YOU" - do you really genuinely think that saying you "detest" people is the way to open and fair discourse?

Remember, I did not say I hated anyone. I merely suggested that non-minorities shouldn't lecture minorities as to their own minority group. If your response to a minority being asked to be respected as the authority on their own minority group is to display this level of rage and hatred, you might want to consider why.

Would you react by saying "I detest you" if Mumsnetter posted "men shut up lecturing women what is and isn't misogyny"?

Lonesomefetter · 12/10/2023 02:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Same. I don't hate Jewish people, I don't particularly hate anyone (I dislike some people, but not for ideological reasons). I imagine for most of the UK Jewish people are not even on their radar, I had never met a Jewish person until I lived down south. Yet any criticism of Israel is met with the same thought terminating slogans.

I don't think there's any point talking about anything online anymore. It's sad.

etmoietmoietmoi · 12/10/2023 02:10

@LemonyTicket 100%.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 02:07

etmoietmoietmoi · 12/10/2023 01:35

You don't come across as antisemitic to me at all, but I would say you have a blind spot. The very online Corbyn diehards spewed it out at every opportunity. It was soul destroying to watch decent Jewish people repeatedly shouted down with horrific goading and insults. Even the most innocuous tweets from Jewish people, that had literally nothing to do with antisemitism or Israel, were met with replies of Free Palestine, demands to denounce Israel or pictures of injured or dead Gazans. Very blatant expressions of antisemitism were repeatedly downplayed (unless of course it came from the right, and in which case you were suddenly happy to call it out. Quelle surprise non).

Sorry if it feels raw for you, but I can assure you it feels even rawer for many Jews that were on the receiving end of repeated bigotry. It felt devastating.

I would agree with this. @quiteoldad I voted for Jeremy Corbyn. Campaigned for him actually. And initially I felt like the whole thing was a storm in a teacup.

It wasn't though.

I am a huge socialist, but I would not vote for a socialist party again unless the problem with antisemitism is dealt with. My son, who was an avid member of his university socialist club left for the same reasons.

I wouldn't feel safe to go and campaign and knock on doors again with socialists. Which sounds terrible, because my whole life they were "my tribe" - but this entire "down with the zionists and free palestine" feels like it became a cult that had very little to do with helping anyone Palestinian and a lot more to do with creating a figure of ultimate evil and hate in the "zionist".

To me, this personally started to feel like I was experiencing what my grandparents would have dealt with in the 1930s. It might sound OTT to you, but that was how it felt. The narrative, the use of language, targeted specifically towards Zionists (AKA, almost every Jew) reminded me of those posters depicting the Jude and the sneaky, deceptive, evil puppet master.

It was uncomfortable beyond words.

As @etmoietmoietmoi is saying, if you were ever on the receiving end of a very die-Hard Corbyn supporter shouting you down with very blatant expressions of antisemitism and then denying they were doing it and accusing you of being in on the "zionist plot" then I assure you it was bloody horrible. I had to completely disengage from it.

etmoietmoietmoi · 12/10/2023 02:05

@quiteoldad I also agree this has been a more respectful thread compared to the others.

etmoietmoietmoi · 12/10/2023 02:03

@quiteoldad Thank you. Yes, I'd say the majority of it was online, but I know there were serious issues at some CLP meetings with Jewish members being shouted at to denounce Israel or told to leave if they wouldn't.

I think for a of British Jews what really hurt the most was that so many of us are lefties!

quiteoldad · 12/10/2023 01:57

Etmoietmoietmoi wrote
"The very online Corbyn diehards spewed it out at every opportunity. It was soul destroying to watch decent Jewish people repeatedly shouted down with horrific goading and insults. Even the most innocuous tweets from Jewish people, that had literally nothing to do with antisemitism or Israel, were met with replies of Free Palestine, demands to denounce Israel or pictures of injured or dead Gazans. Very blatant expressions of antisemitism were repeatedly downplayed (unless of course it came from the right, and in which case you were suddenly happy to call it out. Quelle surprise non)."

I'm sorry you had to endure that, I was fortunate enough not to encounter such bile or vitriol. Were these at meetings and rallys? If so, then it's very likely these were genuine bigots.
If it were online, well I'd be a little more suspicious. As one who has done online dating, I'm fully aware that not everybody is who they might appear to be.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 01:55

Reading your comment I think the issue is there are multiple different "branches" of Zionism that are all recognised as valid. Jewish people are talking about one and Non Jewish people are talking about another

I think non Jewish people have hijacked the word and decided it means all sorts of ugly things. I think it's a very easy way to say things you couldn't say if you use the word "Jew".

Zionism refers to the movement to create a Jewish state in the Middle East, roughly corresponding to the historical land of Israel, and thus support for the modern state of Israel. Anti-Zionism opposes that.

So maybe back in 1912 being an "anti zionist" meant that you were someone who believed that was a bad idea. But as Israel has already existed already for 75 years and is home to 9 million people (including about 2 million Muslims) - so what down sit mean now when people say it?

What it now means is obviously that they think an established, existing country should no longer exist. Be destroyed. There really isn't any other interpretation surely?

Non Jewish people including myself tend to define Zionism by the Israeli governments current modern Zionist ideology, which has lead to the ongoing oppression and genocide of Palestinians

The definition I gave above is what it means, so maybe a better title for the thread should be "can I take words that hold deep meanings for Jews and the meaning of 3000 years of their experience and give those words new, and very unpleasant, definitions that associate their country with concepts of genocide and oppression"? To which the answer is hopefully "no" - particularly given that no people on earth have been greater victims of genocide and oppression than we have.

This is an important Jewish word. To us, what you're saying would be comparable to "non Muslims" deciding that the word "Mosque" now means "terrorist", based on "modern extremist Islamic ideology". Can you picture how offensive that would be? This is how offensive this feels for us.

There really isn't a "modern zionist ideology". There is just a set of policies by one government. The same as every other government. No need for special words to create a term which identifies Israel as uniquely evil and possessing of some unusual ideology.

You need to really deconstruct these words you are associating with Israel specifically over any other country. You use these two words "genocide and oppression". Do you really believe only Israel or "zionists" are deserving of these words? Why?

To break down these words, the UN has a definition of "Genocide" which is as follows:

"Any of the following acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, as such":

  • Killing members of the group
  • Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group
  • Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part
  • Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group
  • Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group

I would say one could argue Israel does the first three? But also, so does Hamas. So have almost every single Arab nation to Jews. So do many, many other countries actually.

When you read more on the expert definition it states:

"Genocide is a crime on a different scale to all other crimes against humanity and implies an intention to completely exterminate the chosen group. Genocide is therefore both the gravest and greatest of the crimes against humanity."

So I am going to ask you to answer in good faith: do you reasonably believe Israel has tried to "exterminate" Palestinians? They have the military capacity to do this overnight - and yet I think since Hamas took leadership in 2006 that the data says there have been under 3000 civilian deaths in total. 3000 over 18 years in an ongoing conflict? Genocide? Honestly?

Also, Hamas have stated - both in their original covenant and in many, many, many public statements that their intent is to "completely exterminate" Jews. So it is they actually who have stated intent of genocide - and it seems only their capacity / lack of weaponry power has prevented them from achieving it.

So my question really is why would you associate Israel with genocide, when it is their opponent who has spent almost forty years declaring their actual intent is genocide? Why would you associate Israel with "genocide" when UN experts say in the last century only two genocides have occurred (Holocaust and Rwanda) and for some reason you're now applying that definition to a conflict with very minimal loss of life?

It's something to think about.

Similarly, oppression. I don't object to the use of the word (whilst genocide felt like serious hyperbole). They do oppress Palestinians. But my question is why do you feel this is unique to them? Hamas oppress their own citizens with worse human rights abuses by a considerable measure. Jews are again, oppressed similarly by almost every Arab state. Historically, Jews lived for 600 years as Dhimmi to Muslims, which is my definition - "oppression" and "Apartheid" in it's worst forms.

Certainly elsewhere in the world FAR worse oppression happens. Try being gay in Iran for example. So I am just a bit confused why this very derogatory set of terms are applied to Israel and "Zionism" in this very targeted way? It feels odd to me, so I am just asking you to think about it and consider why the Jewish state is targeted in this way. Particularly given that we are people who have - for 3000 years - been similarly targeted for criticism in a unique and disproportionate way.

I have not and will not ever say your country should not exist. Because I don't believe that

Thank you - but as I said, when you say you are anti zionist - this is what you are saying :) Factually speaking those are the meaning of the words.

etmoietmoietmoi · 12/10/2023 01:35

quiteoldad · 12/10/2023 00:56

Having followed other, very shouty threads in which there was an awful lot of ignorance, noise and bigotry, I've gotta say that this has been a very reasoned thread.

I think the topic of what constitutes antisemitism is still a very raw subject for a lot of people. There are many, including myself who feel stronlgy that it was used as a weapon against Corbyn and so they rightly want to examine closely any accusation of antisemitism to discover its veracity. I'm not claiming that Labour was devoid of antisemitism, but that it was "found" in places where it never really existed. Simply by stating that I appreciate that I am now laying myself open to being accused of antisemitism.

You don't come across as antisemitic to me at all, but I would say you have a blind spot. The very online Corbyn diehards spewed it out at every opportunity. It was soul destroying to watch decent Jewish people repeatedly shouted down with horrific goading and insults. Even the most innocuous tweets from Jewish people, that had literally nothing to do with antisemitism or Israel, were met with replies of Free Palestine, demands to denounce Israel or pictures of injured or dead Gazans. Very blatant expressions of antisemitism were repeatedly downplayed (unless of course it came from the right, and in which case you were suddenly happy to call it out. Quelle surprise non).

Sorry if it feels raw for you, but I can assure you it feels even rawer for many Jews that were on the receiving end of repeated bigotry. It felt devastating.

Fruitandclottedcream · 12/10/2023 01:27

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 00:14

I mean the quote is correct. It's not a fact that she's anti Semitic because she's anti Zionist

I think she's antisemitic because on this thread she has:

  • implied Jewish people don't experience real racism because they are not generally brown
  • implied some kind of weird thing about Jews having power
  • put forward numerous statements which are completely inaccurate with a clear anti israel agenda
  • more or less outright said she denies israel's right to exist
  • applied completely different standards to israel as a nation
  • demonstrated as clear as day she has no idea what antisemitism is but that if Jews tell her, she isn't interested in listening

So, yeah, that rings every bell for me and based on what's she's written I wouldn't socialise with her or speak to her.

I don't think I have implied anything. And please don't gaslight me with this ⬇

From what I've seen You've basically spent the entire thread heavily implying that people who are anti Zionist are Anti Semitists for disagreeing with Israeli policy

The things listed in the bullets above are not "criticising israel's policy".

It is also not "criticising Israel's policy" to start a thread saying essentially "hey folks, don't you think Jews are wrong when they tell me I am antisemitic" and then making your first post one which states anti zionism doesn't mean what us Jews (or the dictionary) think it means - it means anti genocide, oppression and apartheid because you made that up and think we should just take on board this very important term relating to us as meaning all this terrible things.

If you were against those things, you would be anti HAMAS and anti ISLAMIC EXTEMISM and anti DHIMMI status for minorities. They are all those things!

I missed her posts, I apologise. I've just found them and yes. She is Anti-Semitic. Again I'm sorry I missed that. And I obviously disagree with her points.

OP posts:
Fruitandclottedcream · 12/10/2023 01:07

LemonyTicket · 11/10/2023 23:54

I vehemently disagree.

When you are angry with Spains goverment, you criticise the specific policy and discuss that. You don't develop "anti Spainism".

When you are angry at China's government, you criticise the specific policy and discuss that. You don't develop "anti China ism"

You don't need new special words for the only Jewish state.

If you are angry at settlements in the west bank - criticise those.

If you are angry at delayed permits for medical care being arranged - criticise that

You will not find many Jews who don't vehemently agree with you.

But when you start using these words "anti zionism", you are telling us our country should not exist. Then can you understand this is treating us differently?

Reading your comment I think the issue is there are multiple different "branches" of Zionism that are all recognised as valid. Jewish people are talking about one and Non Jewish people are talking about another.

From what I am reading in this thread Jewish people including yourself (I'm assuming you're Jewish based on your responses please correct me if I'm wrong), define Zionism by it's original pre 1948 definition of religious Zionism which is the ultimately Jewish Diasporas right to self determination and their right to return to Israel as it is their ancestral homeland.

Non Jewish people including myself tend to define Zionism by the Israeli governments current modern Zionist ideology, which has lead to the ongoing oppression and genocide of Palestinians.

I have not and will not ever say your country should not exist. Because I don't believe that. As I stated in a previous comment I don't hold any issue with Jewish people wanting to return to an ancestral homeland where they can be safe. If I had been persecuted for centuries I would want a country to call my own. My issue is that under modern Zionist ideology, this has been done at the cost of Palestinians, and it didn't need to be.

OP posts:
quiteoldad · 12/10/2023 00:56

Having followed other, very shouty threads in which there was an awful lot of ignorance, noise and bigotry, I've gotta say that this has been a very reasoned thread.

I think the topic of what constitutes antisemitism is still a very raw subject for a lot of people. There are many, including myself who feel stronlgy that it was used as a weapon against Corbyn and so they rightly want to examine closely any accusation of antisemitism to discover its veracity. I'm not claiming that Labour was devoid of antisemitism, but that it was "found" in places where it never really existed. Simply by stating that I appreciate that I am now laying myself open to being accused of antisemitism.

DevonDelight · 12/10/2023 00:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I think its fair to say that your user name raises questions about your integrity.

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 00:38

Defiantjazz · 11/10/2023 23:58

That they are lying, "playing the antisemitism card" in order to "silence your criticism of Israel".

I must admit this is what I tend to suspect (rightly or wrongly)

If you are "often" getting accused of it, maybe it would be a good idea to ask about it? Maybe ask someone trusted and Jewish and get some feedback? My experience is that when people are being racist they generally don't know it - but think this over

Are you Jewish? If so let me ask you.
Have I said anything on this thread that is antisemitic?

I must admit this is what I tend to suspect (rightly or wrongly)

Why?

Why would a Jewish person saying to you that they find something antisemitic automatically make you suspect they are trying to "silence criticism of israel"?

Would you think that if any other person said they felt you were being prejudiced?

To us, even thinking this implies you feel Jews are sneaky, surreptitious, scheming, deceptive, in a plot to protect Israel...... that makes me really uncomfortable to be honest!

I think these memes went around saying "we use antisemitism to silence criticism of Israel" and now people just use this to justify being antisemitic and trying to reverse blame for it onto the victim which makes me sad

Are you Jewish?

Yes

If so let me ask you
Have I said anything on this thread that is antisemitic?

No

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 00:27

@Fruitandclottedcream

However - Lots of comments on here imply or explicitly state, that because someone is non Jewish they cannot define what Anti Semitism is, because they simply can't understand it or know what it is if they're not Jewish themselves

Lots of people who are not Jewish have a deep and empathetic understanding of exactly what antisemitism is. Some absolutely do not. The point is that you don't get to define it for yourself - the world's leading scholars and experts have already done that. All you have to do is follow it and listen if Jewish people are trying to tell you.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 00:20

That they are lying, "playing the antisemitism card" in order to "silence your criticism of Israel".

I must admit this is what I tend to suspect (rightly or wrongly)

Seem to have lost edit function.
I should point out I’m talking about online discussions here. It’s probably harder to judge where someone is really coming from than in rl interactions. I am not saying it’s impossible that I’m wrong that’s just how it seems sometimes.

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 12/10/2023 00:18

Evermean · 11/10/2023 17:09

Right, so toy want the entire country if Israel to just up and move to...somewhere.

Well, that is exactly what the founders of the state of Israel imposed upon the Palestinians who were living in what is now Israel.

Are you agreeing that dispossessing those Palestinian families was a bad thing?

Its those same Palestinian families who now live in dreadful conditions in the West Bank and Gaza. Robbed of their land by people who at the time were described as terrorists by the British government (which ran Palestine at the time).

LemonyTicket · 12/10/2023 00:14

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 21:21

I mean the quote is correct. It's not a fact that she's anti Semitic because she's anti Zionist. I haven't read the thread so she could be both. But she could also simply be against the Israeli's illegal occupation and oppression of Palestine.

From what I've seen You've basically spent the entire thread heavily implying that people who are anti Zionist are Anti Semitists for disagreeing with Israeli policy because the person writing the policy is Jewish. That's not what anti semitism is. And that is a fact.

Edited

I mean the quote is correct. It's not a fact that she's anti Semitic because she's anti Zionist

I think she's antisemitic because on this thread she has:

  • implied Jewish people don't experience real racism because they are not generally brown
  • implied some kind of weird thing about Jews having power
  • put forward numerous statements which are completely inaccurate with a clear anti israel agenda
  • more or less outright said she denies israel's right to exist
  • applied completely different standards to israel as a nation
  • demonstrated as clear as day she has no idea what antisemitism is but that if Jews tell her, she isn't interested in listening

So, yeah, that rings every bell for me and based on what's she's written I wouldn't socialise with her or speak to her.

I don't think I have implied anything. And please don't gaslight me with this ⬇

From what I've seen You've basically spent the entire thread heavily implying that people who are anti Zionist are Anti Semitists for disagreeing with Israeli policy

The things listed in the bullets above are not "criticising israel's policy".

It is also not "criticising Israel's policy" to start a thread saying essentially "hey folks, don't you think Jews are wrong when they tell me I am antisemitic" and then making your first post one which states anti zionism doesn't mean what us Jews (or the dictionary) think it means - it means anti genocide, oppression and apartheid because you made that up and think we should just take on board this very important term relating to us as meaning all this terrible things.

If you were against those things, you would be anti HAMAS and anti ISLAMIC EXTEMISM and anti DHIMMI status for minorities. They are all those things!