Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:49

Syndulla · 12/10/2023 10:32

I agree OP. It has been frustrating to see many posters on here claiming that posters who are criticizing the Israeli actions in Palestine are antisemitic.

It has been used to shut down debate. We don't claim that individuals criticizing HAMAS are Islamophobic so why are people accused of antisemitism when they criticize Israel's actions?

Of course there are those who are antisemitic, and this should be called out and dealt with appropriately. But just saying that Israel should not be bulldozing Palestinian homes for settling in the West Bank, or should not be cutting off water supplies, flattening whole neighborhoods, or are potentially going to commit genocide through their actions in Gaza, is not antisemitic.

People absolutely do claim that criticizing Hamas is islamophobic. I've had countless debates with people who say criticizing jihadists in Europe is islamophobic. Why? Because they'll tell you that Islamism is simply a creation of white western imperialism, that it's the fault of western colonialism and intervention that desperate people become radicalized, that the west has done exactly the same things to people in other countries but isn't criticized for it. They'll tell you that the only permissible response from non-muslims is to stay in our lane. They'll also tell you that the only legitimate criticism of jihadist groups is to say they nothing to do with Islam but merely use the religion as a cloak. There's more.

In the case of Hamas specifically, they'll tell you that it has reformed, no longer seeks to genocide the Jews, and that the only possibly motive for disbelieving that is that you are Islamophobic. They'll tell you it's simply the understandable, if regrettable, lashing out of oppressed people and disagreeing with that is imposing unfair and hypocritical standards on the muslims of Gaza and is therefore islamophobic.

One of the problems with widespread censorship is that people are genuinely sheltered from reality.

Grassy82 · 12/10/2023 10:47

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:14

Either they didn't drive all of them out or some of them came back not too long afterwards (I'm not actually sure which it was but it doesn't matter). Certainly there were Jews living there at the time of the Muslim conquest. They continued to live there as dhimmis, second class citizens under Islamic rule, for centuries. Others lived in all of the surrounding area, which were not countries then but parts of the Ottoman empire etc. They were also dhimmis, also persecuted. So even those who did leave Judaea, as they called it, did not all go to Europe.

Please don’t have me wrong, I fully appreciate the very long history of these religious lands, the settlements and their significance. However for Jewish people who had settled in Europe over many centuries, they found themselves increasingly unsafe and this was played out horrifically for them. Instead of working to keep them safe in the places they were living in Europe, Europe has helped to resettle them in a place where they were already oppressed as well. Does this mean to be Jewish it always seems to be ‘someone else’s problem’ and not society’s problem as a whole

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/10/2023 10:46

I don’t understand the situation/politics at all so reading with interest.

CoughingMajoress · 12/10/2023 10:46

No one is being or has been called antisemitic for criticising the specific actions of the Israeli government.

Some of the harshest criticism of the Israeli government has come from Jewish posters.

I mean, I'm the only poster on this thread that has mentioned the Israeli government's violent systemic oppression of other minority groups such as Israeli Bedouin, which is something most people outside Israel have never even heard of because it gets no media attention (and got called a rude Jew, typical Jew trying to shut down debate of Israel, and had someone flat out say "I despise people like you" for my pains) - that's pretty obviously not someone trying to defend the Israeli government or smear those who do.

Teder · 12/10/2023 10:45

Poudretteite · 12/10/2023 10:42

We don't claim that individuals criticizing HAMAS are Islamophobic so why are people accused of antisemitism when they criticize Israel's actions?

Hamas is officially recognised as a terrorist group, firstly, and, secondly, people obsessively separate Hamas from Palestine to avoid precisely that Islamophobia. By contrast, no one has a problem referencing 'Jews' or 'Israel' being as one and the same as their government.

Just quoting this for effect.

Teder · 12/10/2023 10:44

Syndulla · 12/10/2023 10:32

I agree OP. It has been frustrating to see many posters on here claiming that posters who are criticizing the Israeli actions in Palestine are antisemitic.

It has been used to shut down debate. We don't claim that individuals criticizing HAMAS are Islamophobic so why are people accused of antisemitism when they criticize Israel's actions?

Of course there are those who are antisemitic, and this should be called out and dealt with appropriately. But just saying that Israel should not be bulldozing Palestinian homes for settling in the West Bank, or should not be cutting off water supplies, flattening whole neighborhoods, or are potentially going to commit genocide through their actions in Gaza, is not antisemitic.

I am deeply uncomfortable with the term “shut down debate”.

I only call out anti semitism when is it there. Essentially, people like me get accusing of shutting down debate and “playing the race card” when people make actually racist comments. Why should I sit down and shut up when I see something? I would call out any -ism.

If people want anti Zionist debate to not be derailed, then they need to not be anti semitic. It is possible to debate it, a lot of people seem to find it hard not to sneak in anti Jewish comments.

Poudretteite · 12/10/2023 10:42

We don't claim that individuals criticizing HAMAS are Islamophobic so why are people accused of antisemitism when they criticize Israel's actions?

Hamas is officially recognised as a terrorist group, firstly, and, secondly, people obsessively separate Hamas from Palestine to avoid precisely that Islamophobia. By contrast, no one has a problem referencing 'Jews' or 'Israel' being as one and the same as their government.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:37

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 10:21

You've been around these threads for quite a while. Are you still genuinely unaware that there had been Jews also living there all along? Or what exactly is going on here

Well I’ve been on this thread, not the others.
No I am not genuinely unaware there were Jews living there all along. What makes you think I am?

That's so strange. This is the exchange:

'The land of the Palestine Mandate was not the Arabs' land or the Jews' land. You understand that, right?

Not really. You could argue it belonged to the people who lived there not whoever the empire decided to give it to. I’m not saying Jewish people should have been prevented from settling there but the whole partitioning thing was a mistake.'

'The people who lived there' were both Jews and Muslims right? We're agreed on that. You seem to be arguing that it therefore (morally, I presume you mean) belonged to both the Jews and the Muslims. If I say 'It belonged to the Jews', that would therefore be false. If I said 'It belonged to the Muslims' that would also be false. Are you following?

Syndulla · 12/10/2023 10:32

I agree OP. It has been frustrating to see many posters on here claiming that posters who are criticizing the Israeli actions in Palestine are antisemitic.

It has been used to shut down debate. We don't claim that individuals criticizing HAMAS are Islamophobic so why are people accused of antisemitism when they criticize Israel's actions?

Of course there are those who are antisemitic, and this should be called out and dealt with appropriately. But just saying that Israel should not be bulldozing Palestinian homes for settling in the West Bank, or should not be cutting off water supplies, flattening whole neighborhoods, or are potentially going to commit genocide through their actions in Gaza, is not antisemitic.

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 10:27

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:01

@Iwasafool

The belief that war is caused by economic factors is simply, again, left wing dogma. Historically, most human conflict seems to have been about access to women actually. Interestingly, I rarely hear people argue that, say, the Crusaders were in no way motivated by religion. Or that if they had been happy and prosperous at home they'd never have gone.

Maybe most western people just don't meet many men who absolutely love war, who live for it. You'll find them on Telegram posting videos about blowing up tanks. They also don't meet many people who genuinely believe in their religion and believe their duty to their God is to go to war, that they'll go to hell if they don't and heaven if they do. There's an odd assumption that all humans are motivated by standard 20th century materialistic western values - happiness, material wealth, optimism.

I do think you're being optimistic, yes. At one point, around 1939, the British proposed that the Jews should just get 500 square miles I think it was. The Arabs still rejected it. Former dhimmis don't get sovereignty on Islamic lands. Lands conquered by Islam cannot be voluntarily handed over to former dhimmis at the request of other non-muslims.

I don't meet many men who love war and I think we have to think about why some men are like that. I'm not Jewish, I am Irish from a family where on one side they are Catholic and on the other they are protestants so I understand historical hatreds, religious hatreds and bitterness about land taken from you. You might have noticed that great progress was made with peace in Ireland during the 90s which coincidentally were good times economically. Certainly for the Catholics in my family living in Belfast with little access to jobs for much of the 20th century there was bitterness, from the Protestant side there was an attitude of not being interested in fair shares. There is some truth in the old saying of the devil makes work for idle hands.

I honestly don't think the Crusaders are terribly relevant to modern warfare and I don't think the issues in Israel/Palestine have much to do with access to women but if you have evidence of that do share it.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 10:21

You've been around these threads for quite a while. Are you still genuinely unaware that there had been Jews also living there all along? Or what exactly is going on here

Well I’ve been on this thread, not the others.
No I am not genuinely unaware there were Jews living there all along. What makes you think I am?

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:14

Grassy82 · 12/10/2023 10:08

@Pollyputhekettleon yes they had. And didn’t the romans drive them out? However instead of any country working to secure the safety of Jews who had settled in Europe, they ended up with no choice but to leave and find somewhere else to go to be safe. The modern movement of Zionism was borne out of fear and the need for protection. Yet they still aren’t safe.

Either they didn't drive all of them out or some of them came back not too long afterwards (I'm not actually sure which it was but it doesn't matter). Certainly there were Jews living there at the time of the Muslim conquest. They continued to live there as dhimmis, second class citizens under Islamic rule, for centuries. Others lived in all of the surrounding area, which were not countries then but parts of the Ottoman empire etc. They were also dhimmis, also persecuted. So even those who did leave Judaea, as they called it, did not all go to Europe.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:09

Grassy82 · 12/10/2023 09:59

@Defiantjazz As I get older I find it very hard to reconcile how I feel to be British, when I am so acutely aware of how much of the issues in the world have been caused and created by the empire and colonialism. I once went to a museum in Cambridge and there they had a huge totem pole in the middle of the room and from what I could see, someone decided it would be great for everyone else to see in the U.K. so took down a huge religious artefact and popped it onto a boat and sailed away with it. Everyone was in awe of this totem pole, it’s beautiful but it made me feel very sad. I feel sad now, even though I know these things took place a long time ago, and I can’t change them I just feel sorry. Perhaps thing were done with the best of intentions at the time although I often doubt that….

It might help you to read the 1937 British Peel Commission report, especially in light of everything that happened since. Britain, and more accurately white colonialism, is a scapegoat for issues that they either did not create, did not exacerbate, or actually helped with. (I shouldn't need to say, although I undoubtedly do, that they also did cause plenty of real problems). Behind it is an image of non-whites as passive angels who lived in the Garden of Eden before evil whitey arrived, much like the Victorians viewed women, whose innate innocence could be corrupted by bad men.

Text of the Peel Commission Report (jewishvirtuallibrary.org)

Text of the Peel Commission Report

Encyclopedia of Jewish and Israeli history, politics and culture, with biographies, statistics, articles and documents on topics from anti-Semitism to Zionism.

https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/text-of-the-peel-commission-report

Grassy82 · 12/10/2023 10:08

@Pollyputhekettleon yes they had. And didn’t the romans drive them out? However instead of any country working to secure the safety of Jews who had settled in Europe, they ended up with no choice but to leave and find somewhere else to go to be safe. The modern movement of Zionism was borne out of fear and the need for protection. Yet they still aren’t safe.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:03

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 09:59

The land of the Palestine Mandate was not the Arabs' land or the Jews' land. You understand that, right?

Not really. You could argue it belonged to the people who lived there not whoever the empire decided to give it to. I’m not saying Jewish people should have been prevented from settling there but the whole partitioning thing was a mistake.

You've been around these threads for quite a while. Are you still genuinely unaware that there had been Jews also living there all along? Or what exactly is going on here?

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:01

@Iwasafool

The belief that war is caused by economic factors is simply, again, left wing dogma. Historically, most human conflict seems to have been about access to women actually. Interestingly, I rarely hear people argue that, say, the Crusaders were in no way motivated by religion. Or that if they had been happy and prosperous at home they'd never have gone.

Maybe most western people just don't meet many men who absolutely love war, who live for it. You'll find them on Telegram posting videos about blowing up tanks. They also don't meet many people who genuinely believe in their religion and believe their duty to their God is to go to war, that they'll go to hell if they don't and heaven if they do. There's an odd assumption that all humans are motivated by standard 20th century materialistic western values - happiness, material wealth, optimism.

I do think you're being optimistic, yes. At one point, around 1939, the British proposed that the Jews should just get 500 square miles I think it was. The Arabs still rejected it. Former dhimmis don't get sovereignty on Islamic lands. Lands conquered by Islam cannot be voluntarily handed over to former dhimmis at the request of other non-muslims.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 09:59

The land of the Palestine Mandate was not the Arabs' land or the Jews' land. You understand that, right?

Not really. You could argue it belonged to the people who lived there not whoever the empire decided to give it to. I’m not saying Jewish people should have been prevented from settling there but the whole partitioning thing was a mistake.

Grassy82 · 12/10/2023 09:59

@Defiantjazz As I get older I find it very hard to reconcile how I feel to be British, when I am so acutely aware of how much of the issues in the world have been caused and created by the empire and colonialism. I once went to a museum in Cambridge and there they had a huge totem pole in the middle of the room and from what I could see, someone decided it would be great for everyone else to see in the U.K. so took down a huge religious artefact and popped it onto a boat and sailed away with it. Everyone was in awe of this totem pole, it’s beautiful but it made me feel very sad. I feel sad now, even though I know these things took place a long time ago, and I can’t change them I just feel sorry. Perhaps thing were done with the best of intentions at the time although I often doubt that….

Teder · 12/10/2023 09:54

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 22:30

I do actually have a detailed understanding of Jewish history. I've spent a lot of time learning over the past several years because I strive to be anti racist, and part of anti racism is understanding Anti-Semitism. Which means becoming educated about Jewish Culture, Heritage and History.

Just above this post There's an excerpt of a previous comment of mine, detailing some of the history I'm familiar with. There's more detail in a much longer comment. I think it's on page 4 of this thread.

Fair enough. I appreciate people who do genuinely take the time to learn. However, this does include listening to people with lived experience though. There appears to be no space for people like me who desperately want to be balanced. We are constantly shut down when we do see anti semitism. It’s on this thread! Not by you, I must add, but by others.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 09:52

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 09:46

Actually in the 1937 Peel Commission Report the British suggested that the Arabs living in the 20% of the Mandate that was to be the Jewish territory should be transferred to the intended Arab state, and they/the new Arab state, was to be financially compensated for that. Their reasoning was that similar population swaps had resolved ethnic conflicts in several other places. Their main example was the population swap of Greeks and Turks after WW1. There was absolutely no suggestion they would be refugees anywhere

Thats not much better is it? Say the Israeli's were ordered to hand over 20% of the country over to another population and if they live in that area they can shift. Oh but financial compensation. I don’t think they would agree. I don’t think ANYONE would agree to that.
Israel is loath to give back the land they acquired by force never mind that which is considered theirs.

I mean…population swaps? Asking for trouble. But that’s the British Empire for you.

Not much better than what?

The land of the Palestine Mandate was not the Arabs' land or the Jews' land. You understand that, right?

Lots of populations did agree to population swaps, obviously enough. Did you miss that? Are Greeks and Turks 'ANYONE'?! Or were you by any small chance unaware until approximately 5 minutes ago that that had ever happened?

Teder · 12/10/2023 09:51

quiteoldad · 11/10/2023 22:28

Teder wrote
"Please don’t pretend there hasn’t been a plethora of anti Jewish propaganda on here."

I've seen a lot of vehement anti-Israel propaganda on here.

I cannot be sure whether or not it comes from antisemites, .... neither I think, can you.

I didn’t call anyone an anti semite. I have seen anti Jewish statements and stereotypes. It doesn’t paint people in a great light to shut down discussion and tell people what is and is not anti Jewish judgement. What qualifies you to say this?

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 09:46

Actually in the 1937 Peel Commission Report the British suggested that the Arabs living in the 20% of the Mandate that was to be the Jewish territory should be transferred to the intended Arab state, and they/the new Arab state, was to be financially compensated for that. Their reasoning was that similar population swaps had resolved ethnic conflicts in several other places. Their main example was the population swap of Greeks and Turks after WW1. There was absolutely no suggestion they would be refugees anywhere

Thats not much better is it? Say the Israeli's were ordered to hand over 20% of the country over to another population and if they live in that area they can shift. Oh but financial compensation. I don’t think they would agree. I don’t think ANYONE would agree to that.
Israel is loath to give back the land they acquired by force never mind that which is considered theirs.

I mean…population swaps? Asking for trouble. But that’s the British Empire for you.

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 09:45

ForFriends · 12/10/2023 09:37

Also please visit a Holocaust museum OP, or one of the Nazi concentration camps, it's eye opening.

I have and it is but the Palestinians weren't responsible for any of it.

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 09:43

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 09:20

Actually in the 1937 Peel Commission Report the British suggested that the Arabs living in the 20% of the Mandate that was to be the Jewish territory should be transferred to the intended Arab state, and they/the new Arab state, was to be financially compensated for that. Their reasoning was that similar population swaps had resolved ethnic conflicts in several other places. Their main example was the population swap of Greeks and Turks after WW1. There was absolutely no suggestion they would be refugees anywhere.

You can agree or disagree with the rights or wrongs of that, but you should read it first. They set out the advantages they saw for the Arabs also in the plan. In light of what's happened since, while it may have been a grim proposal, so were many other postcolonial partitions. Some worked out ok, some much less so. In this case I think it would clearly have been less grim than what's actually happened.

Text of the Peel Commission Report (jewishvirtuallibrary.org)

I think that is interesting. My own feeling is that people who are happy, prosperous and see a good future for their children don't generally want to go to war. If I was in charge in 47/48 I'd have proposed to the Palestinians that we are here we are staying but we will split the land 50/50, we will ensure that every Palestinian child will go to a school that is as good as the schools Jewish children will go to, that hospitals will be as good and as well resourced in the Palestinian areas as in the Jewish areas, that the laws will be imposed equally regardless of ethnicity or faith, that displaced people will be supported to set up a new life, that investment and development will be equal in both areas, that we will work together to run Israel/Palestine for the benefit of all.

I reckon most Palestinians would be too busy leading their productive comfortable lives to want to have war now. There are always a few extremists so I imagine there would be some Palestinians who want their land back and some Israelis who want to land grab to expand Israel but I reckon the majority would be living together happily now and although it would have been a huge financial commitment for the Israelis in the long run it would have been cheaper than constantly being on war preparations, lives would have been saved and everyone would be happier.

Maybe I am naive but I think it would have been worth a try.

Swipe left for the next trending thread