Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 12:26

@Defiantjazz As I get older I find it very hard to reconcile how I feel to be British, when I am so acutely aware of how much of the issues in the world have been caused and created by the empire and colonialism. I once went to a museum in Cambridge and there they had a huge totem pole in the middle of the room and from what I could see, someone decided it would be great for everyone else to see in the U.K. so took down a huge religious artefact and popped it onto a boat and sailed away with it. Everyone was in awe of this totem pole, it’s beautiful but it made me feel very sad. I feel sad now, even though I know these things took place a long time ago, and I can’t change them I just feel sorry. Perhaps thing were done with the best of intentions at the time although I often doubt that

Yes, and you have things like the Benin Bronzes, which 100% belong to a culture that still exists, but the various museums won’t give them back because that would set and precedent. Maybe they’d have to start giving everything back. We can’t have that can we?

medianewbie · 12/10/2023 12:26

@Pollyputhekettleon 'banning widow burning & building some railway lines' hardly balances the scales of what the British did in India, in my opinion, No. Inevitability any minority will seek to improve its lot if it is not being treated equitably. Of course access to women is a massive historical advantage - it's how any particular population increases. I may be 'a modern Westerner' (we're all viewing via a modern prism) but don't assume I'm insensible re Religion (or indeed what my ethnic background may be).

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:26

It is hate anger and revenge

That's normal reaction but it's still wrong and short sighted

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:19

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:12

All the killing is bad. One lot of killing does not justify more murder .

No.

We bomb the rockets they fire at us from their homes, and the people who fire them because we refuse on moral grounds to give up and die. That is lawful under the rules of law provided it is proportionate.

Sadly that leads to tragic consequences for their families.

We do not act out of hate or anger or revenge.

That is not the same thing as intentionally dismembering children in front of their parents. The full horror of what happened is unspeakable.

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:12

All the killing is bad. One lot of killing does not justify more murder .

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:06

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 11:57

@AUserNameIsNot

Palestinian or Israeli or both ?

Israeli Jew, dual citizen, long term resident in London.

Pro Palestinian state and pro Palestinian rights, against the occupation, but being woke wouldn't have saved me if I fell into their hands.

They tortured and violated a peace loving conscientious objector to Israeli military service, paraded her unconscious on Al Jazeera, and now she's allegedly in intensive care in captivity, possibly still alive.

At times like this you realise however hard you try, to anti Semites a Jew is always a Jew.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 12:04

medianewbie · 12/10/2023 11:55

'Have you studied every instance of partition in history?' No, of course not. Have you ? (But I respectfully disagree that anything the British Empire did in India or Burma or Pakistan helped those regions in the long term)
'You'd need a crystal ball to know how the alternatives would have turned out'. Indeed! Okay, I'll rephrase: ' Partition (by outsiders, even if some insiders wanted to gain advantages from it) is almost ALWAYS a mistake'. Better ?

I do agree with posters who have commented that ethnic groups who have access to the same advantages as other local ethnic groups rarely make war. They just get on with life.

Not a single thing the British did helped those regions in the long term? Didn't they ban widow burning? Built some railway lines?

Your characterization of the motives of minorities in seeking partition as 'wanting to gain advantages from it' is interesting. I mean, sure, wanting to not be persecuted by the majority ever again is an advantage. But that's not usually how you'd describe such a motivation.

If you study anthropology, you'll find that groups made war on each other constantly, usually about access to women. It had nothing to do with 'advantages'. They were literally just having beefs about who raped whose property last. Another common motive was when one group showed disrespect to the other's sacred places. People get genuinely furious about that kind of thing, something atheist/materialist modern westerners seem to find almost impossible to accept. These are not groups where one was richer than another, those concepts weren't even applicable.

Whalestoe · 12/10/2023 11:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

OneTC · 12/10/2023 11:57

There is a lot of surreptitious manipulation of low information observers in any discussion on Israel or in a wider sense, Jews.

A good example of that is the number of people willing to call themselves anti Zionist without giving much consideration to what it actually means.

The same thing can be seen through conspiracy theories and the infiltration of right wing conspiracies in that. There's loads of people that are so stupid they probably couldn't find their own arses repeating anti Jewish conspiracies without even realising that's what they're doing. They don't hate "Jews" they just hate a load of people that happen to be Jewish or represent something that is seen as being inherently Jewish.

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 11:57

@AUserNameIsNot

Palestinian or Israeli or both ?

medianewbie · 12/10/2023 11:55

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 11:42

This particular partition, like many, was done by outsiders but at the request of some of the insiders. Insiders who had been persecuted by the majority population for religious reasons for centuries.

Have you studied every instance of partition in history and were the outcomes all worse than the alternatives? I doubt it. Apart from which, you'd need a crystal ball to know how the alternatives would have turned out. The separation of Burma from India - by those evil outsider Brits at the request of many Burmese - apparently was peaceful and successful in the end. Actually the Peel Commission Report refers to it as an example of partitions.

'Have you studied every instance of partition in history?' No, of course not. Have you ? (But I respectfully disagree that anything the British Empire did in India or Burma or Pakistan helped those regions in the long term)
'You'd need a crystal ball to know how the alternatives would have turned out'. Indeed! Okay, I'll rephrase: ' Partition (by outsiders, even if some insiders wanted to gain advantages from it) is almost ALWAYS a mistake'. Better ?

I do agree with posters who have commented that ethnic groups who have access to the same advantages as other local ethnic groups rarely make war. They just get on with life.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 11:54

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 11:42

"Death has come to our kitchens "

Are you speaking as an Israeli or Palestinian ?

Death with a capital D. The twisted faces of pure Evil. The delight in savage butchery. Death came alive, riding around on motorbikes and livestreaming on Telegram.

If they were animals it would be easier. We cannot expect humanity from animals. But they were humans with dark blasted hearts filled with hate.

We have no words and no negotiations with such evil. We understand innocent people die (lower case d) as we fight for our existence, but we are not targeting innocent people, and that is why we are who we are. Even when we die, we live. But these terrorists were dead before they even died.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 11:42

medianewbie · 12/10/2023 11:21

Partition (by outsiders) is ALWAYS a mistake. But both Jewish people & Palestinian people have a moral & historical right to live in the same area of land so that's the crux of the problem. Both sets of people are represented by Govts who have power for themselves as their aim rather than the best long term interests of their people. Outrages are committed by both sides, usually in the name of Religion (rather than the land/power grabs they are) which heightens the issue. I have only travelled to the Holy Land once, in 1990 as a tourist, but I found it genuinely oppressive & scary.
I don't pretend to have any answers but I am sorry for ALL those in fear today (largely as a result of historical political screw ups). Perhaps it needs a Reset /
Reconciliation process which was largely successful in South Africa & Northern Ireland? How one would get the Israeli & Palestinian leaders around a table is anyone's guess however.

This particular partition, like many, was done by outsiders but at the request of some of the insiders. Insiders who had been persecuted by the majority population for religious reasons for centuries.

Have you studied every instance of partition in history and were the outcomes all worse than the alternatives? I doubt it. Apart from which, you'd need a crystal ball to know how the alternatives would have turned out. The separation of Burma from India - by those evil outsider Brits at the request of many Burmese - apparently was peaceful and successful in the end. Actually the Peel Commission Report refers to it as an example of partitions.

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 11:42

"Death has come to our kitchens "

Are you speaking as an Israeli or Palestinian ?

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 11:37

No, your posts are just extremely difficult to follow

Yeah, that’s it I’m sure

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 11:36

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 11:08

That's so strange. This is the exchange

Are you trying to gaslight me now?

I know that there were Jews living in Palestine. I know they started to go there long before WW2 and that there were Jews living there all along anyway.

I’m arguing that the partitioning is what has ultimately caused the current situation. Well that and the six day war. Preemptive defence? Great! Nabing large chunks of land that were not theirs under the agreement while they’re at it? Hmmm.

Edited

This is apologetics for war crimes.

I don't defend the occupation. I couldn't object in moral grounds if they simply attacked military targets.

The bedroom of a 4 year old is not a military target.

There are no excuses. There is no forgiveness.

Death has come to our kitchens and now we have lost our fear of death.

We are united. We are not so much angry as implacable. We will defend our continued existence as the nation of Israel, the nation of the Jews, whatever the cost.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 11:36

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 11:08

That's so strange. This is the exchange

Are you trying to gaslight me now?

I know that there were Jews living in Palestine. I know they started to go there long before WW2 and that there were Jews living there all along anyway.

I’m arguing that the partitioning is what has ultimately caused the current situation. Well that and the six day war. Preemptive defence? Great! Nabing large chunks of land that were not theirs under the agreement while they’re at it? Hmmm.

Edited

No, your posts are just extremely difficult to follow. Ok, so you disagree with partition. So do you think that the entire area of the Mandate should have been turned into one state, in which the Jews would have continued to be a minority?

Why do you think the Jews living in Israel in the 1920s and 1930s didn't want to be governed by an Arab majority state?

medianewbie · 12/10/2023 11:21

Partition (by outsiders) is ALWAYS a mistake. But both Jewish people & Palestinian people have a moral & historical right to live in the same area of land so that's the crux of the problem. Both sets of people are represented by Govts who have power for themselves as their aim rather than the best long term interests of their people. Outrages are committed by both sides, usually in the name of Religion (rather than the land/power grabs they are) which heightens the issue. I have only travelled to the Holy Land once, in 1990 as a tourist, but I found it genuinely oppressive & scary.
I don't pretend to have any answers but I am sorry for ALL those in fear today (largely as a result of historical political screw ups). Perhaps it needs a Reset /
Reconciliation process which was largely successful in South Africa & Northern Ireland? How one would get the Israeli & Palestinian leaders around a table is anyone's guess however.

Whalestoe · 12/10/2023 11:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 11:13

Most of the victims were the most humane, open minded people in all of Israel.

They were the secularists, they voted for the left, they campaigned against the occupation, and they burned in their own homes with their children.

The founding charter of Hamas includes this Hadith:

“The Day of Judgment will not come about until Muslims fight Jews and kill them. Then, the Jews will hide behind rocks and trees, and the rocks and trees will cry out: 'O Moslem, there is a Jew hiding behind me, come and kill him.'"

Hamas does not understand the difference between anti Zionism and anti Semitism. Huw should we?

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 11:08

That's so strange. This is the exchange

Are you trying to gaslight me now?

I know that there were Jews living in Palestine. I know they started to go there long before WW2 and that there were Jews living there all along anyway.

I’m arguing that the partitioning is what has ultimately caused the current situation. Well that and the six day war. Preemptive defence? Great! Nabing large chunks of land that were not theirs under the agreement while they’re at it? Hmmm.

etmoietmoietmoi · 12/10/2023 11:06

Syndulla · 12/10/2023 10:32

I agree OP. It has been frustrating to see many posters on here claiming that posters who are criticizing the Israeli actions in Palestine are antisemitic.

It has been used to shut down debate. We don't claim that individuals criticizing HAMAS are Islamophobic so why are people accused of antisemitism when they criticize Israel's actions?

Of course there are those who are antisemitic, and this should be called out and dealt with appropriately. But just saying that Israel should not be bulldozing Palestinian homes for settling in the West Bank, or should not be cutting off water supplies, flattening whole neighborhoods, or are potentially going to commit genocide through their actions in Gaza, is not antisemitic.

Have you read the full thread - including the posts by OP who has engaged in good faith to understand what is and isn't antisemitism, because if you do you'll find out that the majority of Jews don't make accusations of antisemitism for simply being critical of the Israeli govt.

It has been used to shut down debate. But that is exactly what happens to us when we try to highlight antisemitic language and behaviour! "It's not antisemitic to criticise Israel" is hollered at us all the time to shut us down even though we're not saying it's antisemitic to criticise Israel! Most of us despise BN and current Israeli policy. Antisemitism is actually more nuanced, pernicious and widespread than perhaps you realise. So I don't see how you can say it's "frustrating" for you because we are claiming that we are not actually claiming! Have you considered that we're probably better at recognising antisemitism than you are?

Many of us are genuinely really scared at the moment! Here's one reason why

"Hamas founding member Khalid Mashal calls for global Jihad, invasion of Israel, and to attack Jews worldwide on Oct. 13"

https://twitter.com/HenMazzig/status/1712145022630387718

https://twitter.com/HenMazzig/status/1712145022630387718

25milesfromhome · 12/10/2023 10:57

Gravityisreal · 12/10/2023 09:03

@CoughingMajoress

“Plus, Jews only have one single miniscule country to call our own where we can be safe (after centuries of non-stop persecution and multiple genocides). There are nearly FIFTY Muslim countries, and many of those countries are extremely wealthy and could protect and home the entire population of Palestine if they wanted to. “

This is abhorrent. Can you imagine living in your house for decades and then one day someone knocks on your door (rather violently may I add!!) and says you have to leave because that house is the only place THEY feel safe? But it’s ok you can go to someone else’s house who shares the same religion/skin colour! It would not even be remotely acceptable in ANY other part of the world. That is their rightful HOME. I can’t quite believe people actually think like this.

@Gravityisreal you say this would not be acceptable in any other part of the world, but this is exactly what did happen. Post 1948, hundreds of thousands of Mizrahi Jews were expelled from the Arab countries they had lived in for generations (having always been denied citizenship in those countries). Some were murdered, some were imprisoned, billions of pounds worth of land and property was confiscated/stolen from them. The majority fled to Israel because there was no other place for them to go. I’m sure many of them would have preferred to stay in their rightful homes too.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:53

@Teder

Calling out antisemitism is not the same thing at all as reporting posts and threads to Big Brother demanding they be deleted and/or the poster banned. The former is debate, the latter is shutting down debate.