Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:20

usernamealreadytaken · 12/10/2023 13:14

Lots of racists are comfortable with their own views, and don't listen when others tell them they are racist.

Yes I agree. But I genuinely don't believe I am antisemitic, as in against someone on the grounds that they are Jewish. I've interned/lived in Israel and I've had this conversation many a time with people (who I'm good friends with). There are many Jews who are anti Zionist, so by default they are antisemitic too. What about ultra orthodox groups such as Satmar, who are very observant Jews, but anti Zionist. How would one argue that they are antisemites?

roarrfeckingroar · 12/10/2023 13:19

Disagreeing with the existence of the state of Israel is inherently antisemitic.

Poudretteite · 12/10/2023 13:18

the fact that you can't see that your children were targeted because Palestinian children have been killed by Israelis soldiers for decades ... is so utterly sad and distressing because until you lose the eye for an eye attitude children on both sides will continue to die

....this is contradictory

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 13:15

Many Germans who shopped Jews and Roma were defending their lives

It's pretty pathetic if you think killing children is the way to defend your children

And the fact that you can't see that your children were targeted because Palestinian children have been killed by Israelis soldiers for decades ( recurse this for however long back you want ) is so utterly sad and distressing because until you lose the eye for an eye attitude children on both sides will continue to die

Your children are no more important than anyone else's

usernamealreadytaken · 12/10/2023 13:14

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:12

No, not at all. I'm perfectly OK with people disagreeing with me, or making accusations against me. I'm very comfortable with my own views.

Lots of racists are comfortable with their own views, and don't listen when others tell them they are racist.

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:12

usernamealreadytaken · 12/10/2023 13:07

And if that Jewish person still considered your words or actions to be anti-Semitic, would you still tell them they were wrong?

No, not at all. I'm perfectly OK with people disagreeing with me, or making accusations against me. I'm very comfortable with my own views.

DevonDelight · 12/10/2023 13:11

my

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 13:10

Similarly, oppression. I don't object to the use of the word (whilst genocide felt like serious hyperbole). They do oppress Palestinians. But my question is why do you feel this is unique to them? Hamas oppress their own citizens with worse human rights abuses by a considerable measure. Jews are again, oppressed similarly by almost every Arab state. Historically, Jews lived for 600 years as Dhimmi to Muslims, which is my definition - "oppression" and "Apartheid" in it's worst forms
Oppression happens in all aspect of life at higher and lower levels. If a man oppresses his wife, can she says that she can oppress his children from a first marriage because her husband does it to her? Or that their own mother dies it to them at their residence home so why is the finger pointed at the SM? Pointing that other generations have done harm so it justifies doing the same to the next to next generation isn't ok.

I agree to so many things you say but the above comes across as shifting responsibility. It might not be the most important matter, it might not be the worse, but it remains something that has a negative impact.

DevonDelight · 12/10/2023 13:10

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:39

It's not love - and it helps to keep the hatred and fear going for generations- is that the future you want for your children?

Was it love that motivated the Germans during the nazi years ? No it was fear and self preservation and it led to great evil

And there you have it: deliberately conflating the legal and moral right of Jewish citizens to defend themselves from Hamas butchers with the actions of Nazi Germans.
My uncle died fighting the Nazis, and my father and his surviving brothers fought in World War 2.
The "great evil" to which you allude is alive and kicking-not just in the atrocities of Hamas, but in the foul comments made by you, Last Train East and others.
I am a Roman Catholic and will be putting up the Israeli flag as a public sign of solidarity with y Jewish brothers and sisters.

ForFriends · 12/10/2023 13:08

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 09:45

I have and it is but the Palestinians weren't responsible for any of it.

Whats' that got to do with anything? In order to understand the current situation, OP wants to educate themselves. A great place to do this are Holocaust museum and concentration camps. My post was not in reference to Palestinians. Perhaps all you are able to see is the Muslim Palestinian cause, with no regard to The Bigger Picture or relevant details, that's not on me.

usernamealreadytaken · 12/10/2023 13:07

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 16:01

I would absolutely tell (not lecture) a Jewish person why I believe me being anti Zionist is not antisemitic. I really don't see the problem. Racism is so widespread and can be so nuanced that not everyone from the same race will always agree about what is racist.

And if that Jewish person still considered your words or actions to be anti-Semitic, would you still tell them they were wrong?

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:59

Israel's position is Palestine doesn't exist ?

Poudretteite · 12/10/2023 12:58

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:19

No.

We bomb the rockets they fire at us from their homes, and the people who fire them because we refuse on moral grounds to give up and die. That is lawful under the rules of law provided it is proportionate.

Sadly that leads to tragic consequences for their families.

We do not act out of hate or anger or revenge.

That is not the same thing as intentionally dismembering children in front of their parents. The full horror of what happened is unspeakable.

Edited

Exactly this.

Israel's position is 'we deserve to exist.' Hamas' position is 'no, you don't.'

We have not seen Pro-Israeli celebrations spreading graffiti in Muslim areas, chanting genocidal slogans, setting off fireworks, shouting 'gas the Muslims,' or cheering the death toll.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:57

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:48

There were evil people in Germany but most of the atrocities were only possible because ordinary Germans joined in because they were scared - they wouldn't shelter people they once had dinner with out of fear

Don't paint all Germans as evil - paint them as human too

So ordinary Germans committed atrocities but were nevertheless not evil because we Jews scared them? And we should have been nicer to them so they didn't exterminate us.

And you presume to lecture me about love.

As I keep learning, to an anti Semite, a Jew is always a Jew.

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:48

There were evil people in Germany but most of the atrocities were only possible because ordinary Germans joined in because they were scared - they wouldn't shelter people they once had dinner with out of fear

Don't paint all Germans as evil - paint them as human too

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:46

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:39

It's not love - and it helps to keep the hatred and fear going for generations- is that the future you want for your children?

Was it love that motivated the Germans during the nazi years ? No it was fear and self preservation and it led to great evil

You probably didn't mean to imply that the ovens of Auschwitz were just the Germans self preservation.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:44

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:39

It's not love - and it helps to keep the hatred and fear going for generations- is that the future you want for your children?

Was it love that motivated the Germans during the nazi years ? No it was fear and self preservation and it led to great evil

You keep assuming there is a logical motivation for Hamas' atrocities and if we're nice enough to the Gentiles they will stop killing us.

We've been there, in Auschwitz. We've done that already. We're not sheep to be slaughtered all over again.

Teder · 12/10/2023 12:40

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:53

@Teder

Calling out antisemitism is not the same thing at all as reporting posts and threads to Big Brother demanding they be deleted and/or the poster banned. The former is debate, the latter is shutting down debate.

Fortunately, I’ve seen mostly healthy debate on this thread.

That said, people have a right to report racist or sexist or ableist or otherwise offensive posts. MN has a right to protect itself. Freedom of speech does not mean there are not consequences.

Personally, I prefer posts are not deleted as it gives racists an excuse to carry on because their opinions have been wiped.

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:39

It's not love - and it helps to keep the hatred and fear going for generations- is that the future you want for your children?

Was it love that motivated the Germans during the nazi years ? No it was fear and self preservation and it led to great evil

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:39

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 12:35

Hamas will fall.

And something will replace them. The combative mentality (from both sides) will just perpetuate the conflict endlessly.

Yes, like the German Federal government replaced the anti Semitic government of Adolf Hitler. Or the government of Iraq replaced Isis in Mosul.

Maybe the Palestinian Authority will reassert control over Gaza. Who knows? All I know is this: we will not tolerate the continued existence of a state of pure evil on our Southern border.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 12:35

Hamas will fall.

And something will replace them. The combative mentality (from both sides) will just perpetuate the conflict endlessly.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 12:34

Not when a lot of artifacts would be returning to cultures that actively destroy art and UNESCO world heritage sites

I don’t think Nigeria is planning to get the bronzes back to trash them

FeelingVeryUnwell · 12/10/2023 12:32

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 12:26

@Defiantjazz As I get older I find it very hard to reconcile how I feel to be British, when I am so acutely aware of how much of the issues in the world have been caused and created by the empire and colonialism. I once went to a museum in Cambridge and there they had a huge totem pole in the middle of the room and from what I could see, someone decided it would be great for everyone else to see in the U.K. so took down a huge religious artefact and popped it onto a boat and sailed away with it. Everyone was in awe of this totem pole, it’s beautiful but it made me feel very sad. I feel sad now, even though I know these things took place a long time ago, and I can’t change them I just feel sorry. Perhaps thing were done with the best of intentions at the time although I often doubt that

Yes, and you have things like the Benin Bronzes, which 100% belong to a culture that still exists, but the various museums won’t give them back because that would set and precedent. Maybe they’d have to start giving everything back. We can’t have that can we?

Edited

Not when a lot of artifacts would be returning to cultures that actively destroy art and UNESCO world heritage sites.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 12:31

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 12:26

It is hate anger and revenge

That's normal reaction but it's still wrong and short sighted

I promise you it's not. It's love. For our children and their future. We refuse to bequeath this evil to our children.

They may not teach you this in your woke studies class, but the history of mankind is full of decisive battles which changed the course of history. Sometimes, war is the answer.

Daesh was dragged down and is no more.

Hamas will fall.

Swipe left for the next trending thread