Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't actually understand the difference between Anti Zionism and Anti-Semetism in the context of the current conflict?

540 replies

Fruitandclottedcream · 11/10/2023 09:40

Every time someone criticises the Israeli State or Zionism ideology, there is always someone who comments shouting about Anti-Semitism and how anyone who questions, criticises or condemns Israel's behaviour is Anti-Semitic. And it's really annoying because it's not true.

The definition of Anti-Semitism is "Prejudice or Hostility towards Jewish people".

Anti-Zionism in the context of the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine is being opposed to Israel's decades long oppression, genocide and apartheid of Palestinians. Including but not limited to leaving people stateless, giving Palestinians less rights than Israelis and creating the open air prison that is Gaza, depriving the people there of water, electricity and food, and bombing relentlessly while not giving anyone a way to escape.

Plenty of Jewish people practice their faith, but are anti Zionist and condemn what the Israeli government are doing.

And plenty of Zionists are Anti-Semites, but support the behaviour of the Israeli government (including a decent chunk of British MPs according to Google)

Disclaimer before anyone jumps on me: I absolutely condemn and despise Hamas and their actions. I've not mentioned them as they're not relevant to my point.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CoughingMajoress · 12/10/2023 14:13

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 10:53

@Teder

Calling out antisemitism is not the same thing at all as reporting posts and threads to Big Brother demanding they be deleted and/or the poster banned. The former is debate, the latter is shutting down debate.

MNHQ is not "Big Brother."

This kind of hyperbole does not contribute towards debate; pretending that you're being censored and oppressed just because minorities give an opinion that you dislike, or word their opinions in ways you consider abrasive, is not a good faith argument.

This is a webforum. It has rules, which we are all bound by equally. No one forced you to sign up to a privately owned webforum which has openly stated rules.

The comparison with 1984 is ludicrous because the entire point of 1984 is a) the public had no choice, the oppression was forced on them without consent and b) they aren't told what the rules are, only punished when they accidentally break one.

To compare that to making a completely voluntary choice to sign up to a message board, then claim you're being censored by the fact that message board has rules, does not strengthen whatever argument you're trying to make. (I'm not sure what argument you are trying to make, other than that pesky Jews are trying to silence and oppress you, using what you apparently perceive as the fascist dictatorship that is Mumsnet moderators as a weapon.)

And actually in practice I don't think we are all bound equally by MN Talk Guidelines, because MN is pretty white, and this forum has a pretty poor history of things like dog whistle racism (especially against black posters) going unchallenged because not everyone is educated enough on issues around unconscious bias and racial stereotypes to be able to recognise anti-black dog whistles. In my experience minorities who complain about racism are more likely to be deleted and banned than posters posting racist stuff that's subtle/coded enough that the mods don't recognise it as such.

So if anything, minorities are more likely to have a hard time on this forum. So to claim that minorities are the oppressive censors and you're being uniquely censored and oppressed is just... a bad take.

The only reason posts are deleted is because the mods found that they broke talk guidelines. And for that to happen the posts have to be really pretty bad, since the mods are hardly experts on race relations. There aren't loads of Jews "demanding" that MNHQ censor non-Jews, that feels perilously close to pushing the stereotype that Jews secretly control the media.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 12/10/2023 14:10

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:33

I have no issue whatsoever with the Jewish people having a homeland. I have a problem when that 'homeland' results in the occupation, massacre, displacement of an entire nation. It is very clear cut. No one on this thread who is insisting that the Jewish people should be entitled to emigrate and live in Israel have responded to the question of what should be done for the displaced Palestinians?
This isn't a Jewish issue for me, it's about any occupation. I feel equally as strong about the British occupation of Ireland.

They could live in Israel, 1.6m already do as full Israeli citizens.

If they're serious about have a complete separate country of their own they could get back round the table and negotiate a two-state solution, but they've been very vocal about it being all or nothing.

Out of interest can you name this entire nation that has been displaced and define it's boundaries?

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 14:08

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 14:04

There's also a big difference between disagreeing with the creation of Israel, and thinking it should be destroyed now.

Yes, it’s done now and Israel exists. Due to the way it came about and the conditions in the Palestinian Territories is also inflicted with terrorism. Obviously they are going to fight the terrorists.
What irks me is attitudes like that of a pp who seem to feel their enemies are “evil” and they are, and always will be, the victims. It’s not a very nuanced view is it?

Edited

No, but then burning people to death in the streets and cutting their heads off live on telegram with a spade wasn't very nuanced either. I don't think it's a situation which demands much nuance.

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 14:06

ForFriends · 12/10/2023 13:37

Isn't it interesting how pro Hamas posters are now positively likening ordinary Palestinians with ordinary Nazi Germans? @AUserNameIsNot
They really are not helping their cause. I suppose I don't expect better from someone who aligns themselves with a death cult.

There are a lot of obvious similarities between palestians now and Germany after ww1. Are you saying that Germans in the nazi era were uniquely evil? That is not true (although Hitler himself was an extreme case). The conditions that created Nazi Germany could happen in any country.

One major similarity is feeling oppressed and hard done by, giving the opportunity for leaders who promise nationalist glory.

Of course, since its creation Israel has been under threat from its neighbours on all sides which has also led to a strongly nationalist government there too.

Interference from the US and Iran is a complicating feature that didn't apply to Germany.

But humans are humans, underneath our skin we are all the same and given the same conditions will behave very similarly.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 14:06

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 12/10/2023 14:01

How do you break a cycle of violence when one side has explicitly and repeatedly declared (and shown) they are fully committed to the obliteration of the other and, under no circumstances, will they entertain peace with that side?

Genuinely what's your solution here?

I don't accept this cycle of violence rhetoric as it seems to deprive human beings of the choice not to respond to provocation with murder, rape, kidnap, execution by immolation, and torture.

The occupation of the West Bank is not justified by our caused by these atrocities.

These atrocities are not justified by or caused by the occupation.

Defiantjazz · 12/10/2023 14:04

There's also a big difference between disagreeing with the creation of Israel, and thinking it should be destroyed now.

Yes, it’s done now and Israel exists. Due to the way it came about and the conditions in the Palestinian Territories is also inflicted with terrorism. Obviously they are going to fight the terrorists.
What irks me is attitudes like that of a pp who seem to feel their enemies are “evil” and they are, and always will be, the victims. It’s not a very nuanced view is it?

Whalestoe · 12/10/2023 14:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 12/10/2023 14:01

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 13:21

It's not contradictory

It's trying to say there is a long running cycle of violence between the communities and until that can be broken it will continue

But what is so sad is that people think that continuing the cycle is somehow protecting themselves and their families

But I think perhaps emotions are currently too high for this conversation

How do you break a cycle of violence when one side has explicitly and repeatedly declared (and shown) they are fully committed to the obliteration of the other and, under no circumstances, will they entertain peace with that side?

Genuinely what's your solution here?

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 14:00

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:20

Yes I agree. But I genuinely don't believe I am antisemitic, as in against someone on the grounds that they are Jewish. I've interned/lived in Israel and I've had this conversation many a time with people (who I'm good friends with). There are many Jews who are anti Zionist, so by default they are antisemitic too. What about ultra orthodox groups such as Satmar, who are very observant Jews, but anti Zionist. How would one argue that they are antisemites?

Satmar / Neturei Karta went to the Holocaust denial conference in Tehran. To be fair, their position was that the Holocaust did happen but it was the fault if the Zionists. What makes this do unconscionable is that Joel Teitelbaum, the prior head honcho of Satmar, used his privilege to take the 'Zionist' Kastner train to escape the Holocaust, just a few days after he publicly urged his followers not to do so. Some leader.

They are welcome to their views on Zionism, perhaps slightly less welcome to their views on women (they should shave their heads AND wear a wig AND wear a hat; they should not drive), secular education (they don't believe in it), and sexual abuse (the Satmar Rebbe's chauffeur is a convicted child rapist, who enjoyed the Rebbe's public and full throated support; the victim was threatened and ostracised).

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 13:51

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:20

Yes I agree. But I genuinely don't believe I am antisemitic, as in against someone on the grounds that they are Jewish. I've interned/lived in Israel and I've had this conversation many a time with people (who I'm good friends with). There are many Jews who are anti Zionist, so by default they are antisemitic too. What about ultra orthodox groups such as Satmar, who are very observant Jews, but anti Zionist. How would one argue that they are antisemites?

Ultra orthodox Jews are against the existence of Israel because they believe that Israel will only be recreated when the Messiah comes. It's nothing to do with the rights of Palestinians.

The antisemitism is because for most non Jews who are anti-israel, they "care about Palestinians" without bothering to find out any of the reasons for the current situation or caring about other people around the world in similar situations. It's literally an excuse to have a pop at the only Jewish country in the world

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:48

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 13:10

Similarly, oppression. I don't object to the use of the word (whilst genocide felt like serious hyperbole). They do oppress Palestinians. But my question is why do you feel this is unique to them? Hamas oppress their own citizens with worse human rights abuses by a considerable measure. Jews are again, oppressed similarly by almost every Arab state. Historically, Jews lived for 600 years as Dhimmi to Muslims, which is my definition - "oppression" and "Apartheid" in it's worst forms
Oppression happens in all aspect of life at higher and lower levels. If a man oppresses his wife, can she says that she can oppress his children from a first marriage because her husband does it to her? Or that their own mother dies it to them at their residence home so why is the finger pointed at the SM? Pointing that other generations have done harm so it justifies doing the same to the next to next generation isn't ok.

I agree to so many things you say but the above comes across as shifting responsibility. It might not be the most important matter, it might not be the worse, but it remains something that has a negative impact.

In reality, the only way you can attempt to justify removing someone else's rights for your own benefit is to shift responsibility. No decent human feels comfortable in their own self knowing that their advantage is to another's irreparable loss. It's much easier to remain in a state of cognitive dissonance than to accept partial blame or compliance at the very least.

Totalblindnessofthesoul · 12/10/2023 13:42

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:33

I have no issue whatsoever with the Jewish people having a homeland. I have a problem when that 'homeland' results in the occupation, massacre, displacement of an entire nation. It is very clear cut. No one on this thread who is insisting that the Jewish people should be entitled to emigrate and live in Israel have responded to the question of what should be done for the displaced Palestinians?
This isn't a Jewish issue for me, it's about any occupation. I feel equally as strong about the British occupation of Ireland.

Absolutely!

There's also a big difference between disagreeing with the creation of Israel, and thinking it should be destroyed now.

I don't think it was the right thing to create the State in the first place, but the passage of time since it's creation means I don't think it's right or fair for that to be "undone". I don't give a monkeys whose land it was in the bronze age, but for the children born in Israel it's their home now too. It's a right old mess.

WillowCraft · 12/10/2023 13:41

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 16:34

As an occupation, no. The Jewish people when deciding on a homeland country had other options that did not involve displacing people and violating their human rights.

No they didn't. They were being systematically slaughtered in most of Europe. The UK, the US, south American countries closed their borders to fleeing Jews. Most middle Eastern countries were with Hitler in wanting to exterminate Jews. The British didn't actually want them in Palestine either but turned a blind eye. There certainly weren't loads of options at that time, or ever really.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 13:39

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:35

Please read up the statistics. Israel ARE killing children. The figures should chill anyone to the bone.

If someone plots to shoot at us from his family home, we will rise up to defend ourselves. And that is the right and moral thing to do. It's sad that these children have such shocking parents, and we will not apologise for not going like sheep to the slaughter. We are proud to live.

ForFriends · 12/10/2023 13:37

Isn't it interesting how pro Hamas posters are now positively likening ordinary Palestinians with ordinary Nazi Germans? @AUserNameIsNot
They really are not helping their cause. I suppose I don't expect better from someone who aligns themselves with a death cult.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 13:36

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:33

I have no issue whatsoever with the Jewish people having a homeland. I have a problem when that 'homeland' results in the occupation, massacre, displacement of an entire nation. It is very clear cut. No one on this thread who is insisting that the Jewish people should be entitled to emigrate and live in Israel have responded to the question of what should be done for the displaced Palestinians?
This isn't a Jewish issue for me, it's about any occupation. I feel equally as strong about the British occupation of Ireland.

They should have their own state and I support Palestinian statehood.

The struggle for Palestinian rights has got nothing to do with butchering 40 children in one village, 900 civilians killed, 150 taken hostage. Hamas is destroying the Palestinian people.

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:35

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 13:31

We aren't killing children, we are killing anti Semitic terrorists and destroying their weapons, for which we do not apologise.

Of course my children are my everything, and you don't really care as much about my children as you do about your own.

Insofar as our resolve to continue existence offends you, I am delighted to provide offence, and I hope I and my Jewish children continue to offend you for many, many more years.

Please read up the statistics. Israel ARE killing children. The figures should chill anyone to the bone.

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:33

roarrfeckingroar · 12/10/2023 13:25

@feralunderclass not denying the Jewish people a homeland? Erm most people? To my knowledge, international institutions. What would you do to all the Jews in Israel?

I have no issue whatsoever with the Jewish people having a homeland. I have a problem when that 'homeland' results in the occupation, massacre, displacement of an entire nation. It is very clear cut. No one on this thread who is insisting that the Jewish people should be entitled to emigrate and live in Israel have responded to the question of what should be done for the displaced Palestinians?
This isn't a Jewish issue for me, it's about any occupation. I feel equally as strong about the British occupation of Ireland.

ForFriends · 12/10/2023 13:33

Iwasafool · 12/10/2023 09:45

I have and it is but the Palestinians weren't responsible for any of it.

I said visit a Holocaust museum OP to the OP who wants to educate themselves, which is commendable. Are you the OP or why did you reply 'I have and it is but the Palestinians weren't responsible for any of it.' ?? I have reported your post.

AUserNameIsNot · 12/10/2023 13:31

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 13:15

Many Germans who shopped Jews and Roma were defending their lives

It's pretty pathetic if you think killing children is the way to defend your children

And the fact that you can't see that your children were targeted because Palestinian children have been killed by Israelis soldiers for decades ( recurse this for however long back you want ) is so utterly sad and distressing because until you lose the eye for an eye attitude children on both sides will continue to die

Your children are no more important than anyone else's

We aren't killing children, we are killing anti Semitic terrorists and destroying their weapons, for which we do not apologise.

Of course my children are my everything, and you don't really care as much about my children as you do about your own.

Insofar as our resolve to continue existence offends you, I am delighted to provide offence, and I hope I and my Jewish children continue to offend you for many, many more years.

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2023 13:27

Lots of racists are comfortable with their own views, and don't listen when others tell them they are racist
I really struggle with this concept.

It so reminds me when I took the decision to move to sleep in another room. My husband kept going on about how it meant I didn't love him anymore (analogy for being told I'm racist). I explained that I did love him but his snoring really affected my sleep so I had to move. He insisted that loving people sleep in the same bed, so moving meant I stopped loving him. The more I tried to explain, theore I was told I was showing all the signs I'd stopped loving him.

Should I have just accepted that if he felt unloved, it meant that it was and it was all down to me?

Whalestoe · 12/10/2023 13:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

roarrfeckingroar · 12/10/2023 13:25

@feralunderclass not denying the Jewish people a homeland? Erm most people? To my knowledge, international institutions. What would you do to all the Jews in Israel?

feralunderclass · 12/10/2023 13:23

roarrfeckingroar · 12/10/2023 13:19

Disagreeing with the existence of the state of Israel is inherently antisemitic.

Says who?

andtheworldrollson · 12/10/2023 13:21

It's not contradictory

It's trying to say there is a long running cycle of violence between the communities and until that can be broken it will continue

But what is so sad is that people think that continuing the cycle is somehow protecting themselves and their families

But I think perhaps emotions are currently too high for this conversation

Swipe left for the next trending thread