Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think grocery substitutions should weigh the same as the original item you ordered?

92 replies

Ivylea · 11/10/2023 08:38

I’m sure there is one supermarket who does substitute for the weight ordered, or, at least, they used to - maybe Waitrose?

But today Asda have substituted a 180g bag of own brand salad with a branded 120g bag of salad. Yes, I pay the ‘original’ cost of £1 (even though the branded salad is more expensive), but I didn’t want to spend £1 for just 120g.

And they’ve also substituted a 240g pack of roast chicken with a 160g one. Both cost £2.95.

Last week, they substituted a 250g pack of butter with a 200g one.

AIBU to think the substitutions should give you the same amount of product, and/or charge you proportionately?

They say they will never charge you more for substitutions, which is true. But you do actually end up paying a lot more per gram or per item.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 11/10/2023 11:52

Just reject the substitutions you don't want. That way you don't pay anything.

Pickers can't pick something that it's there so they have to pick the next nearest thing to what you want.

The stores are always happy enough to take it back and refund. Never had any problems. Sometimes the drivers let you keep the item and still issue the refund anyway!

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/10/2023 11:51

Depends on the quality. I would expect a smaller corn fed, free range chicken for example to cost more than an indoor reared. Same for organic/no -organic, etc.

Plasmodesmata · 11/10/2023 11:49

Asda used to send all but one from a promotion so you lost out. Eg if it was 3 bottles of wine for £15 they'd sub one so I wouldn't get the deal. They would refund if I could be bothered to check receipt and contact them but it started happening every shop which was annoying.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 11/10/2023 11:28

I just opted out of all substitutions. It did mean I had to go out and buy something myself at times, but saved getting stuff I didn't want or having to go through everything with the driver and waste his or her time.

AuntieStella · 11/10/2023 11:01

Coffeerum · 11/10/2023 09:37

@Ivylea This reminds me of when I worked in a newsagents a very long time ago - if we were out of 20 packs of cigarettes we were told to sell 2x 10 packs for the same price!

I don't understand why any business would willingly do this.

To keep the customer happy by providing good service.

They are not running a loss doing that, just foregoing a few pennies from the profit.

Cheeesus · 11/10/2023 11:00

I always presume they’ve tried their best to offer a fair substitute and if you don’t like it, just reject it. With Sainsbury’s we usually get a bigger or same weight but branded item as the sub, but a couple of times if our ordered item was on offer then then the sub works out as much less good.

I think it’s coded, rather than down to the picker, as an aside.

Warum · 11/10/2023 10:56

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 10:33

They used to do that all the time. The idea is that the store absorbs the downside of it not having the original item in stock, rather than the customer being punished by having to pay more to get what they need.

Maybe they can no longer continue doing it?
Customers aren't being punished, just choose no substitutes if you don't want a different item.
Customers shopping instore cannot always get the exact item they want either.

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 10:33

Warum · 11/10/2023 10:25

Right, but then that will put the cost up, meaning you pay for even more units at a higher unit price. You cannot expect them to substitute more of a higher value item surely, if that's what you mean?

They used to do that all the time. The idea is that the store absorbs the downside of it not having the original item in stock, rather than the customer being punished by having to pay more to get what they need.

Soubriquet · 11/10/2023 10:26

Yup. I always did when I was an online shopper. We were encouraged to do so, even if it cost the shop money

Warum · 11/10/2023 10:25

Kaill · 11/10/2023 09:14

2x 120g bags. So you have more salad than you originally ordered.

Right, but then that will put the cost up, meaning you pay for even more units at a higher unit price. You cannot expect them to substitute more of a higher value item surely, if that's what you mean?

humpty74 · 11/10/2023 10:21

And the ASDA order summary makes it impossible to tell what you've actually paid.
They put a substitute and a note saying 'don't worry you still get your descount' or something but without getting a calculator out and adding up the whole order it's often impossible to tell what they've actually done.

eg I ordered 3 packs of 6 beers. They sent one pack and then 12 loose beers which were the same but as they were single bottles they were more expensive, even before the multibuy discount. The note said I still get my discount but as far as I could tell from adding things up, they meant that the one 6 pack I got was charged at the 3 for £20 rate, the single beers were still charged at £2 a bottle which is their standard price.

Offcom · 11/10/2023 10:20

AuntieStella · 11/10/2023 09:07

Ocado used to match the product pretty closely and you paid no more than the price of the item you ordered.

Now it doesn't. And I nearly always reject substitutions now as they have almost invariably been more expensive (outright, or price per weight/volume)

It pisses me off as their range of products seems to have narrowed recently - I know they say they have thousands of lines, but stuff I buy frequently seems to be vanishing so I'm noticing it a lot

Hard agree - so many things have disappeared. I know they're focusing on profitability but it used to be fun shopping on Ocado and now it's just boring and there are fewer and fewer reasons to shop there instead of another supermarket.

Most recent favourite of mine I've seen go: Tunnocks! Their teacakes are clearly an essential item. . .

nanodyne · 11/10/2023 10:18

Sainsburys tend to try and match the weight, although their substitution choices are sometimes questionable. We just send back anything that doesn't work.

FreestyleInTrance · 11/10/2023 10:15

I found this with Tesco. They used to substitute fairly well, but it must have cost them too much, because they started doing things like substituting two packs of courgettes (£3 total) for one organic pack (£2.50 and a 50p refund) where once it would have been two organic packs.

I could have rejected it, but I wanted 6 courgettes, had 2, and rejecting it would mean none at all!

Also substituting vegan items with non-vegan items. If the vegan ready made mash is sold out the only suitable substitution is a potato, not dairy based mash!

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 09:57

That said, the stealth giving you less for your money by making a substitution that is higher priced per gram is probably technically against consumer law and relies on the customer being observant enough to notice, it’s the kind of thing that the likes of Which? or MSE would love to call out. You could email one of their journalists and see if interested in taking it up.

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 09:54

It’s not great. Pickers under time pressure and probably a lot are teenagers who don’t actually do their own shopping and/or don’t apply common sense.
But that’s why you can always reject. Online shopping isn’t perfect, just like sometimes you go to the store and they don’t have what you wanted on the shelf, so you end up spending more than you wanted to, or having to change your dinner plans to a different recipe. It’s annoying but it is still pretty convenient to get your shopping delivered.

Enko · 11/10/2023 09:46

I've just.lookes through my last 4 deliveries. Once I got 250 g beans when I ordered 300 and once I got 300 g when I ordered 200 peppers

It's not a issue I've been aware of happening we shop with Waitrose and usually their substitutions are ok. We had 1 issue recently where a vegetarian pie was substituted.for a meat one. I did complain about this and got a nice email.back. refunding me the money and saying they are updating the subs for that pie so not would not occur again.

They never quibble if I return substitutions I don't want. Like recent chamomile soap subbed for aloe Vera soap.

VisaWoes · 11/10/2023 09:39

@Kaill yes, this happens to me too. No gluten free pasta so they put normal pasta instead 🙈

Coffeerum · 11/10/2023 09:37

@Ivylea This reminds me of when I worked in a newsagents a very long time ago - if we were out of 20 packs of cigarettes we were told to sell 2x 10 packs for the same price!

I don't understand why any business would willingly do this.

TheFlis · 11/10/2023 09:37

Tesco always go the other way, if you ordered an own brand item and they only have a more expensive branded one, you get it at the cheaper prices. Our requested own brand organic milk is often replaced by Yeo Valley.

They also match quantities or go higher than you order. I recently ordered 2x 500g packs of mince and they didn’t have 500g packs so sent me 2 x 750g packs at the 500g pack price.

thebellagio · 11/10/2023 09:33

We had this last week. Ordered a 500g bag of peanuts - it was swapped for 2 x 200g bags of peanuts. Yet I was charged the same price, despite being down 20% on the weight

Also the piss poor sell by dates are annoying. I ordered a roast chicken, the use by date was the same day that it arrived. Luckily I'd planned to put it in the freezer so its OK, but if I'd gone to the shop to buy it, within a few hours it would have had a whoops sticker on it

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 11/10/2023 09:31

MidnightOnceMore · 11/10/2023 09:27

I think this is part and parcel of getting your shopping delivered. Some want the same price, some want the same weight.

You get free choice if you shop yourself. If you get it delivered, these small annoyances are to be expected.

I get a veg box, substitutions happen, I don't mind.

I expect substitutions but what I don't expect is to pay extra. I remember ordering 5 boxes of Twinings peppermint tea and it being substituted for 5 boxes of a really posh peppermint tea at £10 a tin! What sort of idiot thinks that's a suitable substitution?!

I used to have a veg box and you had the option to say if there was anything you really didn't want. I said cabbage and mushrooms so what did I get as a substitution? Cabbage!

Ivylea · 11/10/2023 09:29

It also annoys me when the veg is short dated - those alphanumeric codes aren’t fooling anyone!

OP posts:
Ivylea · 11/10/2023 09:28

Coffeerum · 11/10/2023 09:11

The thing is that just isn't always going to be possible.

What do you want them to do if there isn't another 180g bag of that type of salad?

You sub 2x100g bags.

This reminds me of when I worked in a newsagents a very long time ago - if we were out of 20 packs of cigarettes we were told to sell 2x 10 packs for the same price!

OP posts:
MidnightOnceMore · 11/10/2023 09:27

I think this is part and parcel of getting your shopping delivered. Some want the same price, some want the same weight.

You get free choice if you shop yourself. If you get it delivered, these small annoyances are to be expected.

I get a veg box, substitutions happen, I don't mind.