Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think grocery substitutions should weigh the same as the original item you ordered?

92 replies

Ivylea · 11/10/2023 08:38

I’m sure there is one supermarket who does substitute for the weight ordered, or, at least, they used to - maybe Waitrose?

But today Asda have substituted a 180g bag of own brand salad with a branded 120g bag of salad. Yes, I pay the ‘original’ cost of £1 (even though the branded salad is more expensive), but I didn’t want to spend £1 for just 120g.

And they’ve also substituted a 240g pack of roast chicken with a 160g one. Both cost £2.95.

Last week, they substituted a 250g pack of butter with a 200g one.

AIBU to think the substitutions should give you the same amount of product, and/or charge you proportionately?

They say they will never charge you more for substitutions, which is true. But you do actually end up paying a lot more per gram or per item.

OP posts:
CharlieBigPotatoes1 · 11/10/2023 16:32

AfterWeights · 11/10/2023 13:00

I turn off all substitutions for this reason.

I suspect they have algorithms that prompt the store picking staff to select substitutions that are favourable to the store in terms of profitability, stock management etc, rather than the individual making a logical choice based on what the customer needs.

You’re very wrong.

CharlieBigPotatoes1 · 11/10/2023 16:10

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 09:57

That said, the stealth giving you less for your money by making a substitution that is higher priced per gram is probably technically against consumer law and relies on the customer being observant enough to notice, it’s the kind of thing that the likes of Which? or MSE would love to call out. You could email one of their journalists and see if interested in taking it up.

Nobody forces subs on the customer.

longtompot · 11/10/2023 16:10

Yanbu. This is one reason why I say no subs, unless I know the sub will be acceptable (this week I said they could sub kidney beans as I needed them).
The other reason is I check everything is dairy free so don't want a sub that might not be.

Apologies if already mentioned, but I do wonder if the butter is more a brand fault and not the store as I know a lot of them have gone from 250g to 200g and not reduced the price.

Newestname002 · 11/10/2023 15:58

Ivylea · 11/10/2023 08:38

I’m sure there is one supermarket who does substitute for the weight ordered, or, at least, they used to - maybe Waitrose?

But today Asda have substituted a 180g bag of own brand salad with a branded 120g bag of salad. Yes, I pay the ‘original’ cost of £1 (even though the branded salad is more expensive), but I didn’t want to spend £1 for just 120g.

And they’ve also substituted a 240g pack of roast chicken with a 160g one. Both cost £2.95.

Last week, they substituted a 250g pack of butter with a 200g one.

AIBU to think the substitutions should give you the same amount of product, and/or charge you proportionately?

They say they will never charge you more for substitutions, which is true. But you do actually end up paying a lot more per gram or per item.

That's the type of thing I write to the supermarket's customer service about in the rare circumstances something like this happens. I usually get refunded to my credit card or get sent a gift card to the same amount. 🌹

VeronicaSawyer89 · 11/10/2023 15:57

The ridiculous substitutions are the reason I stopped shopping online with Asda.

Glittertwins · 11/10/2023 15:57

Tesco are supposed to give you the quantity you asked for or slightly more. I've had a couple of problems lately though and have had to call to get the refund. If I've ordered a kilo of chicken , I want a kilo of chicken, not 800g priced at the same as a kilo!

TheFlis · 11/10/2023 15:52

@CatMattress They definitely still do at mine, we had the milk upgrade I mentioned last week and a small tub of blueberries was replaced with a larger tub for the same price.

CatMattress · 11/10/2023 15:48

TheFlis · 11/10/2023 09:37

Tesco always go the other way, if you ordered an own brand item and they only have a more expensive branded one, you get it at the cheaper prices. Our requested own brand organic milk is often replaced by Yeo Valley.

They also match quantities or go higher than you order. I recently ordered 2x 500g packs of mince and they didn’t have 500g packs so sent me 2 x 750g packs at the 500g pack price.

They used to. Maybe they still do at yours, but they don't at mine. Same bollocks everyone else is talking about - smaller versions of more expensive items but no refund, or less than what you ordered at the same price as what you ordered etc

riotlady · 11/10/2023 15:40

My favourite one was the other way round-I ordered 5 loose pears (I think it was 5 for the price of 4 or something like that, so about £1) and got given 5 packs of 4 pears instead

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 11/10/2023 15:26

We went back to using Ocado rather than Sainsburys due to the attitude of the driver when we rejected some substitutions. He stood there huffing and puffing while DH found them and acted as though he was doing us a favour by taking them back!

Theprincessisblanketed · 11/10/2023 14:40

I usually find the Tesco substitutions very good - always get the multiple of smaller sizes to make up to the amount you need. I'd complain if they gave me less and expected me to pay full price for it. (I have never had a problem with getting items refunded via a quick phonecall if there's an issue).

BedknobsNoBroomsticks · 11/10/2023 14:29

Asda's substitutions are based on price.
Thats why you very rarely get more than you ordered because you pay no more than the original item ordered. They won't want to do themselves out of money. Everything is controlled by the system. Very rarely the pickers may override the system and give you something more expensive.

If you don't like the way substitutions are some complain to head office because the store can't do anything about it.

ohsuzannah · 11/10/2023 14:00

I got Willow instead of butter 😖

Cosycover · 11/10/2023 13:51

Tesco gave me dog food instead of cat food 😂

VisaWoes · 11/10/2023 13:28

greenjojocat · 11/10/2023 13:03

I ordered 2 x200g bags of cashews, they didn't have any available so I got 2 x500g bags instead.. Best day of my life 😂

Wow, I might have to turn substitutions back on! 😁

greenjojocat · 11/10/2023 13:03

I ordered 2 x200g bags of cashews, they didn't have any available so I got 2 x500g bags instead.. Best day of my life 😂

AfterWeights · 11/10/2023 13:00

I turn off all substitutions for this reason.

I suspect they have algorithms that prompt the store picking staff to select substitutions that are favourable to the store in terms of profitability, stock management etc, rather than the individual making a logical choice based on what the customer needs.

Ap24 · 11/10/2023 12:57

Morrisons have the worst system. They charge you the full price of the substitutions. For example I ordered some cheap lamb for a stew, they substituted with a good quality lamb that was 4 times the price and charged me the extra. I was at work and DH accepted it. On that occasion I requested a refund and they gave me the whole lot for free.

dankfarrik · 11/10/2023 12:56

I didn't used to mind the sainsbury's substitutions vouchers because I saved them for Christmas, but now they've changed the validity of them to only a couple of months it's more annoying. 😂

The customer service ones still last ages, but they seem to add more and more hoops to jump through to get to speak to someone.

VisaWoes · 11/10/2023 12:35

Ok, found my last email about the money off thing. So sainsburys charge you more money if the substitution is more expensive. But you can then claim the difference back. Still not great as I’m sure previously they just didn’t use to charge the difference. It’s why I now tick don’t sub for everything.

As promised, we've checked the difference in price between the substituted item/s delivered in your recent online shop against the item/s you originally ordered and where the substitute/s were more expensive we've given you a money-off voucher for the difference.

You'll be able to find this voucher in your online voucher wallet, which can be used on any future online grocery order within the next 2 months. You simply tick this and it'll appear as money-off from your shop.

Voucher Amount: £2.05
Voucher Expiry Date: Tuesday, 26 September 2023

See you again soon,
Sainsbury's Online Team

VisaWoes · 11/10/2023 12:32

What does actually annoy me is sainsburys don’t refund the difference if something cheaper is substituted. It goes into “your account” and you get emailed a code to use on your next shop to get the money taken off. But it’s only valid for about 3 months.

I didn’t realise for a while so not sure how much money I lost. I’m not even sure if somethings unavailable if they refund you the money straight away or if you have to do the stupid thing of using the code next time.

gotomomo · 11/10/2023 12:26

Years ago now I order pull ups, size 5, what arrived as a sub were newborn sized nappies! Same shop load I ordered chicken breast (raw) and what came were frozen chicken nuggets Confused. To add insult to injury they just didn't deliver the fresh fish I'd ordered at all (but had charged) that was the last time I ordered from that store

dankfarrik · 11/10/2023 12:24

I think Tesco must do it by weight as I had some cheese substituted with a similar one that weighed slightly less so they sent two.

Sainsbury's are really stingy with subs because you have to pay the price for the subs and they give you a voucher if they cost more. Swapped two grapefruits for one because it was 5p more etc.

I've not yet managed to figure out how Asda decide subs, it seems almost random at times. The process for refunds is great though.

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 12:23

Warum · 11/10/2023 10:56

Maybe they can no longer continue doing it?
Customers aren't being punished, just choose no substitutes if you don't want a different item.
Customers shopping instore cannot always get the exact item they want either.

Oh sure, I get that absolutely, and I actually said as much in an earlier post, that you need to think of it like shopping in-store, where it’s your choice to decide to buy another higher priced brand or leave without what you came for.

My point was simply that it’s not right to say you cannot expect the store to make a sub that gives the customer a windfall because, for a long time, lots of stores had a policy of doing exactly that, in order to incentivise people to shop online by making the sub process as favourable to them as possible.

KnottyKnitting · 11/10/2023 12:02

I can't say I have ever had that problem with Tesco. Eg. A 1l bottle of olive oil replaced with 2 500ml bottles. If the item they replace it with is a lower cost then you pay that, if the item they replace it with is more, you pay the price you paid when making the order.