Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think grocery substitutions should weigh the same as the original item you ordered?

92 replies

Ivylea · 11/10/2023 08:38

I’m sure there is one supermarket who does substitute for the weight ordered, or, at least, they used to - maybe Waitrose?

But today Asda have substituted a 180g bag of own brand salad with a branded 120g bag of salad. Yes, I pay the ‘original’ cost of £1 (even though the branded salad is more expensive), but I didn’t want to spend £1 for just 120g.

And they’ve also substituted a 240g pack of roast chicken with a 160g one. Both cost £2.95.

Last week, they substituted a 250g pack of butter with a 200g one.

AIBU to think the substitutions should give you the same amount of product, and/or charge you proportionately?

They say they will never charge you more for substitutions, which is true. But you do actually end up paying a lot more per gram or per item.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
noodlebugz · 15/10/2023 12:35

And yes - annoying!

noodlebugz · 15/10/2023 12:34

abandoned sainsburys for fish dates the same day - 6pm delivery and them
refusing to refund as I’d accepted it. I did feel like making one last large order and pedantically checking every date on the doorstep. And waitrose for out of date bacon (3 days!) and bread constantly arriving with that days best before. Ocado are good as we rarely get substitutions.

Desiredeffect · 14/10/2023 23:52

Awful Asda as I call them now. They have really gone down hill and now I'm with sainsburys who are much better

Ivylea · 14/10/2023 23:48

Infuriating!

OP posts:
Grumblebees · 14/10/2023 22:00

Had this with Sainsbury's this week - my normal 12 pack of own brand fromage frais at 80p substituted with a 6 pack of paw patrol ones for £1.50. Yes I'll get the difference back but I now only have 3 days' worth of yoghurt for my two children rather than 6. And they argued over who got which one 🙄. They used to do the same with milk but lately if Ive order a 6 pint bottle they have managed to use their brain and send a 4 + 2, or once I had 3 x 2 pints.

BookishBabe · 12/10/2023 11:00

I shop at asda and had to stop doing click and collect.
I ordered 3 boxes of asda own 1kg cat food priced at £1.
They send 1 box of 900g whiskers at £3.

I ordered 2 boxes of just essentials wheat biscuits 24pack. 75p.
They send one branded pack of 12 weetabix. Not sure on the price.
But I need 48 wheat biscuits, 12 doesn't help me!

And I would never buy branded weetabix, because the price isn't justifying for me.

I just go in store and scan as you shop now.

Strictlymad · 12/10/2023 10:13

Ah it drives me mad! The only shop that subs correctly is Waitrose! The others will sub 3 loaves of bread for one fancy loaf, I have a family to feed I need more bread arrgghhhhh! I know they charge you for what you paid, but sometime the sub is cheaper and they charge you the top price, I ordered 1l extra virgin olive oil at £6, they sent normal oil and charged £6!!

Luckyduc · 12/10/2023 09:57

The way ASDA see it tho is you don't need to agree to the substitute. You hand it back at the door. Or you can untick substitutes on your payment page

MrsPepperpotspickles · 12/10/2023 00:33

I ordered 12 basic fromage frais for my toddlers lunchboxes, and they were subbed for 6 peppa pig yoghurts. Why not send two packs? I handed them back.

KittenKins · 11/10/2023 23:29

I've found Tesco follow my instructions so I always write in the substitution box that I need X weight & they've always done so. I acknowledge this may have been luck, & for a large order it would be frustrating.

Maybe try it?

Shry · 11/10/2023 22:05

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 20:58

I never said they did? In fact in the post I wrote directly above the one you quoted (hence this post beginning with “that said”) I specifically made the point that everyone is free to refuse them.

However, my point is that the customer has to be very observant to calculate quickly whether the sub is good value for money and, therefore, whether or not to accept it. This disadvantages vulnerable people and that is the sort of thing that the consumer organisations like to challenge.

If youre not happy with the sub, even after you've signed and the drivers left you can still contact the customer service and ask for them to refund it. At least with Tesco.

Once I bought a 1kg lamb shoulder and was given a 600g one but I didnt notice until after the driver had left. I didnt mind 100g or so, but 600g is such a large gap!! I contacted Tesco on Whatsapp and they refunded it. I think they would rather lose a small amount of money than a reliably regular customer.

KingsleyBorder · 11/10/2023 20:58

CharlieBigPotatoes1 · 11/10/2023 16:10

Nobody forces subs on the customer.

I never said they did? In fact in the post I wrote directly above the one you quoted (hence this post beginning with “that said”) I specifically made the point that everyone is free to refuse them.

However, my point is that the customer has to be very observant to calculate quickly whether the sub is good value for money and, therefore, whether or not to accept it. This disadvantages vulnerable people and that is the sort of thing that the consumer organisations like to challenge.

Redwinestillfine · 11/10/2023 20:20

I stopped shopping at ASDA because of the ridiculous substitutions. Try another supermarket op.

Phil39 · 11/10/2023 20:12

Substitutions are why I switched from Asda! We use Morrisons and there are hardly ever substitutions.

SadlyACupOfTeaDoesNotSolveEverything · 11/10/2023 18:01

Bearcub101 · 11/10/2023 16:54

My Best two subs:

  1. cabbage substituted with ONE sprout
  2. cheese substituted with orange juice
🤣

@Bearcub101 I raise you…

2 x 200g bag of sprouts - in stock so fine

2 x Savoy cabbage substituted with
2 x 200g bag of sprouts

2 x Braised red cabbage substituted with
2 x prepared sprouts with chestnut butter

and my personal favourite…
Walkers chicken and thyme crisps with a bunch of fresh thyme!

I honestly asked the driver if someone was taking the piss 🙄

SilverSpringss · 11/10/2023 17:54

This is why I shop with Tesco, I never have any issues with substitutions.

For example, last week I ordered 2x 100g cheap 40p bars of chocolate for baking, and they gave me 500g of Cadbury dairy milk.

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 11/10/2023 17:52

Asda's subs and the fact they don't do loose veg made me go elsewhere. They used to be alright but since the pandemic it went downhill. Even if I do click and collect I still end up in the shop, picking up the things that were unavailable (when they are available) or that were substituted with something covered in plastic instead of loose.

Badleg89 · 11/10/2023 17:48

TheFlis · 11/10/2023 09:37

Tesco always go the other way, if you ordered an own brand item and they only have a more expensive branded one, you get it at the cheaper prices. Our requested own brand organic milk is often replaced by Yeo Valley.

They also match quantities or go higher than you order. I recently ordered 2x 500g packs of mince and they didn’t have 500g packs so sent me 2 x 750g packs at the 500g pack price.

This is my experience, tesco are pretty good

Baconisdelicious · 11/10/2023 17:40

Ivylea · 11/10/2023 09:28

You sub 2x100g bags.

This reminds me of when I worked in a newsagents a very long time ago - if we were out of 20 packs of cigarettes we were told to sell 2x 10 packs for the same price!

You’re being a bit disingenuous there - how do you know that there were 2x100g bags available? If they didn’t have what you want, you would make a substitution yourself based on what’s available. . You are under no obligation to accept the substitution chosen for you. You can tick boxes to accept substitutions on some items and not on others and even then, you don’t have to accept what they send. They’re not mind readers who know you would have preferred a slightly different option. They’re people making a choice in a given moment. If you don’t like it, you can always do your shopping yourself?

tothelefttotheleft · 11/10/2023 17:36

@Kaill

Don't they get thrown away if you reject them?

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 11/10/2023 17:06

I usually get a refund if the item was less

margotrose · 11/10/2023 17:00

We shop with Tesco and 99% of the time, substitutions work in our favour.

Bearcub101 · 11/10/2023 16:54

My Best two subs:

  1. cabbage substituted with ONE sprout
  2. cheese substituted with orange juice
🤣
Pleaseme · 11/10/2023 16:48

TheFlis · 11/10/2023 09:37

Tesco always go the other way, if you ordered an own brand item and they only have a more expensive branded one, you get it at the cheaper prices. Our requested own brand organic milk is often replaced by Yeo Valley.

They also match quantities or go higher than you order. I recently ordered 2x 500g packs of mince and they didn’t have 500g packs so sent me 2 x 750g packs at the 500g pack price.

I get that a lot too. I think it depends what you are buying, I I buy a lot of tesco value or equivalent, creamfields etc. You do tend to get more bargains in the substitutions as the only way is up!

PennywisePoundFoolish · 11/10/2023 16:36

The supermarket policy I work for is substitutions must be equal to or greater than what was ordered. And the customer only pays what they were expecting to for their original choice.

Mistakes do happen though, particularly with pick rate pressure. Bur if you rang and complained you'd get some goodwill comp.