Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why the Palestinians did not put up solar panel farms

207 replies

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 08:18

This may be naive in the extreme, but I was reading the reports this morning that Gaza will run out of power today, which is horrific. I dread to think what is going to happen now to those poor people.

This caused me to think: We happen to be in the process of making ourselves completely self-sufficient (off-grid) using solar panels (and some wind), and this is in Ireland, so not a sunny place like Palestine.

My question is, given the Gaza Strip was always dependent on power from Israel, which they regard (rightly) as a hostile country, why have they not in all the years sought to become self-sufficient (or at least more self-sufficient) with regard to power, to prevent the kind of blockade they are experiencing now?

Actually an allied question for those who know would be: travelling in eastern Europe recently, especially Bulgaria, there are huge solar farms everywhere. I have not been to the Middle East (well not since I was a baby), but do they use solar at all? It would seem to be an obvious choice given the climate.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Flamedmoth · 11/10/2023 10:17

Using republic of Ireland as a comparison, the population density

Gaza=6500 people per square km
Ireland =73 to 82 depending

You could put irelands entire population in Kildare and still have half the population density of gaza

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 10:16

Maybe because Israel has restricted numerous things from being allowed into the place - anything that could be deemed to be used by terrorists. Which includes a long list of building and construction materials.

I would be more surprised if solar panels weren't on a restricted list tbh!!

Your OP really highlights the lack of understanding of how the Israeli state has oppressed the Palestinians for years and why it's lead to radicalised Palestinians.

Neither party is free from responsibility.

I saw a comment about how we are forgetting our humanity over the situation - we are told to cry for one party over the other because 'terrorism'. We are told about how Israeli have died whilst Israel use phosphorus bombs on one of the most densely populated places on earth (phosphorus bombs are 'banned' under international treaties for their violations against humanity - treaties that Israel has refused to sign up to. Why because you can't control who you hit, they burn through structures and if they don't kill you they leave you with horrific injuries). A densely populated area where 50% of the inhabitants are children.

It's all fucked in the head.

I saw this comment on twitter which is one of the most balanced, I've seen. It's from an opinion piece in an Israeli newspaper from someone who is Jewish.

Glenn Diesen AT glen_diesen
Gideon Levy writing about our common humanity in Haaretz: "We now have to cry bitterly for the Israeli victims, but we should also cry for Gaza":

"Behind all this lies Israeli arrogance; the idea that we can do whatever we like, that we’ll never pay the price and be punished for it. We’ll carry on undisturbed. We’ll arrest, kill, harass, dispossess and protect the settlers busy with their pogroms. We'll visit Joseph’s Tomb, Othniel’s Tomb and Joshua’s Altar in the Palestinian territories, and of course the Temple Mount – over 5,000 Jews on Sukkot alone.

We’ll fire at innocent people, take out people’s eyes and smash their faces, expel, confiscate, rob, grab people from their beds, carry out ethnic cleansing and of course continue with the unbelievable siege of the Gaza Strip, and everything will be all right.
We’ll transfer half an army from the Gaza border to the Hawara border in the West Bank, only to protect far-right lawmaker Zvi Sukkot and the settlers. And everything will be all right, both in Hawara and at the Erez crossing into Gaza.

It turns out that even the world's most sophisticated and expensive obstacle can be breached with a smoky old bulldozer when the motivation is great. This arrogant barrier can be crossed by bicycle and moped despite the billions poured into it and all the famous experts and fat-cat contractors.

We thought we’d continue to go down to Gaza, scatter a few crumbs in the form of tens of thousands of Israeli work permits – always contingent on good behavior – and still keep them in prison. We’ll make peace with Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates and the Palestinians will be forgotten until they’re erased, as quite a few Israelis would like.

We’ll keep holding thousands of Palestinian prisoners, sometimes without trial, most of them political prisoners. And we won’t agree to discuss their release even after they've been in prison for decades.

We’ll tell them that only by force will their prisoners see freedom. We thought we would arrogantly keep rejecting any attempt at a diplomatic solution, only because we don’t want to deal with all that, and everything would continue that way forever.

Once again it was proved that this isn’t how it is. A few hundred armed Palestinians breached the barrier and invaded Israel in a way no Israeli imagined was possible. A few hundred people proved that it’s impossible to imprison 2 million people forever without paying a cruel price.
Just as the smoky old Palestinian bulldozer tore through the world’s smartest barrier Saturday, it tore away at Israel’s arrogance and complacency. And that’s also how it tore away at the idea that it’s enough to occasionally attack Gaza with suicide drones – and sell them to half the world – to maintain security.

On Saturday, Israel saw pictures it has never seen before. Palestinian vehicles patrolling its cities, bike riders entering through the Gaza gates. These pictures tear away at that arrogance. The Gaza Palestinians have decided they’re willing to pay any price for a moment of freedom. Is there any hope in that? No. Will Israel learn its lesson? No.
On Saturday they were already talking about wiping out entire neighborhoods in Gaza, about occupying the Strip and punishing Gaza “as it has never been punished before.” But Israel hasn’t stopped punishing Gaza since 1948, not for a moment.

After 75 years of abuse, the worse possible scenario awaits it once again. The threats of “flattening Gaza” prove only one thing: We haven’t learned a thing. The arrogance is here to stay, even though Israel is paying a high price once again.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu bears very great responsibility for what happened, and he must pay the price, but it didn’t start with him and it won’t end after he goes. We now have to cry bitterly for the Israeli victims, but we should also cry for Gaza.

Apparently this guy is hated in Israel for saying this. But he speaks the truth - the unsayable.

Wars are the product of failed policy. They are what happens when politicians have failed.

Terrorism is usually the product of desperation. Where we get large numbers of people working together and taking it to the extreme it's because of a total loss of hope and lack of self determination through politics. Because of policy which has deliberately sort to exclude.

The West has a problem here with how we view ourselves and talk about democracy.

Democracy has failed the Palestinian people. Even with the voting in of Hamas' control of Gaza. Hamas were voted in, in 2007. There haven't been elections since. And Palestinian have no democratic influence in Israel which controls their border (and so much more of what happens to Palestinians).

I have no time for western politicians who are now cheerleading Israel 'because terrorism'. But equally I have no time for those who cheer on Hamas and condone what's it's done and doing because it is barbaric. Rape, beheadings, burning people to death, executions all barbaric.

The Israeli and Gaza leadership are rotten. I understand why they've done things but it's so fundamentally wrong in application. The Rest of the world has done fuck all to challenge the situation because it suits their own interests to do fuck all.

It's all so desparately appalling. It's children who bare the brunt of this. It doesn't matter how you die once you are dead. There is no 'humane' way to kill children.

Today's rhetoric from Israel: soon Gaza will be a tent city and they've released all restraints from troops.

What does that actually mean? Cos that doesn't really sound a lot like it's considering human rights or civilians does it?

They are all monsters.

BurrosTail · 11/10/2023 10:14

Because Israel has a long tradition of blocking Gaza from importing A LOT of stuff, ranging from weapons to building materials, tomato paste and coriander! Don’t think renewable energy components are anyhow in their plans, as it’s very convenient for Israel to have full control of Gaza’s energy.

Justgivemeasec · 11/10/2023 10:12

IncomingTraffic · 11/10/2023 09:52

It’s how you ask the question though.

Positing a solution and saying that it seems obvious (and will also
solve climate change, as a bonus) doesn’t feel like genuine curiosity.

Especially in relation to a topic that is clearly extremely divisive.

I didn’t get the feeling the op was being disingenuous or goady in the op, just that she really didn’t have any idea of the situation/practicality- so what might be blatantly obvious to some people really wasn’t to her, thus she asked what a lot of people think is a ludicrous question.

Im always seeing questions on here that I can’t believe people don’t know, and then people giving the wrong answer with confidence (usually related to my field of work). A lot of people really really don’t know things… especially about the Middle East because it wasn’t a part of the curriculum when a lot of early middle aged people were at school- I’m nearing 40, have history and and politics a levels and a degree and masters in connected areas- I have learned EVERYTHING I know about the Middle East from my own reading etc.

YesterdaysGirl · 11/10/2023 10:01

Why do you think we are not attacking Russia? Because what they can fire at us is as heavy as what we can fire at them.

OP thanks for this thread I found it very interesting. Ignore PPs the baiting you, the ignorance on this thread is nuts. Particularly loving the quote above, shows you the level of understanding (I'm being kind) of some mumsnetters!!

I enjoy these kind of threads because you can hear and learn from both side. The water treatment plant info took me down a huge rabbit hole. I was trying to confirm that the Water treatment plant was indeed destroyed by the Hamas, but all I could find was an article from 2014 in The Economist saying that Israel had bombed vital water and sewerage infrastructure.

It would be helpful if posters could give references for some of the info, as there is so much shit out there!

On another note, it looks like UNICEF were installing a new desalination plant in Gaza back in 2017, I can't see if it was finished.

If someone could answer me a question please. I was going to start thread but thought I'd get hounded like you are OP.

The water and electricity that Israel are "cutting off" from Gaza. Is it Israels? Do they sell it to Gaza. Or are the literally cutting it off coming in from another country?

If it is Israel's, I don't understand why it's a war crime. Why would you give it to your enemy?

Absolutely it's horrible innocents will suffer but if your next door neighbour came round to your house kicked the shit out of you, murdered your dog and raped your daughter would you continue to give them water?

Of course you wouldn't! Didn't Russia cut off a lot of gas supplies (except where it wasn't economically viable for them) that's not a war crime?

If someone could explain I'd be grateful.

Flamedmoth · 11/10/2023 09:58

The scale issue is a big one

Gaza for example is roughly the size of the Isle of Wight with 15 times the population, and 1/10 of the size of Cornwall but 4 times the population

IncomingTraffic · 11/10/2023 09:52

Justgivemeasec · 11/10/2023 09:48

If people don’t ‘have enough understanding’ but are discouraged to ask questions- how are they supposed to learn?

Not everyone has the ability to go and read academic books on a topic, or journals or political thesis etc (I’m not meaning you @emilysquest, you might have 3 phds for all I know!)-

it’s a Good Thing for people to ask questions and try and educate themselves, that’s how society improves. People should not engage in knowledge gate keeping by essentially laughing at people who don’t know as much.

It’s how you ask the question though.

Positing a solution and saying that it seems obvious (and will also
solve climate change, as a bonus) doesn’t feel like genuine curiosity.

Especially in relation to a topic that is clearly extremely divisive.

Justgivemeasec · 11/10/2023 09:48

IncomingTraffic · 11/10/2023 09:32

Do you know, OP: when you’re sitting there looking at a long running geopolitical problem and think you’ve, just off the top of your head, figured out and easy and obvious solution to it… it means that you really, really haven’t grasped the problem at all.

If it were easy at all, the absolute mess of a situation wouldn’t have been going on for decades.

Sometimes that ‘why can’t they…?’ question can be a useful way in to trying to understand a large systemic problem. But you need to start from the recognition that you have too limited understanding - not from confidence that your just thought of this now solution really should be the answer.

Edited

If people don’t ‘have enough understanding’ but are discouraged to ask questions- how are they supposed to learn?

Not everyone has the ability to go and read academic books on a topic, or journals or political thesis etc (I’m not meaning you @emilysquest, you might have 3 phds for all I know!)-

it’s a Good Thing for people to ask questions and try and educate themselves, that’s how society improves. People should not engage in knowledge gate keeping by essentially laughing at people who don’t know as much.

Safarisling · 11/10/2023 09:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 09:41

@IncomingTraffic I did not say I have the solution. I was pondering why this did not/could not happen, and asking people for views, very different.

OP posts:
Mistressanne · 11/10/2023 09:40

Surely Iran is just using Hamas to do their dirty work.
It’s in Iran’s interest for Palestinian civilians to have electricity and water cut off because the more Palestinians suffer the more they can garner sympathy for their ‘cause.’

@emilysquest there’s never a wrong question op. I admire people who are prepared to ask out loud what other just think about.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 09:40

@Palmasailor I am not here talking about the savings (although my solar and wind power is saving me a lot right now, I appreciate there could be other long-term problems). That is a first world way of looking at it, really, I was talking about a country under siege trying to make itself self-sufficient in some resources. The concept is worth discussing, even if the practicalities in the end make it impossible (...or do they?).

I may be naive and have never been to Gaza, but I am not ignorant or stupid.

OP posts:
emilysquest · 11/10/2023 09:35

@birgittestyle Thanks for that too!

OP posts:
JoanOgden · 11/10/2023 09:32

I've learnt something from this thread too! Thanks for starting it, OP, and ignore posters who just want to put you down.

IncomingTraffic · 11/10/2023 09:32

Do you know, OP: when you’re sitting there looking at a long running geopolitical problem and think you’ve, just off the top of your head, figured out and easy and obvious solution to it… it means that you really, really haven’t grasped the problem at all.

If it were easy at all, the absolute mess of a situation wouldn’t have been going on for decades.

Sometimes that ‘why can’t they…?’ question can be a useful way in to trying to understand a large systemic problem. But you need to start from the recognition that you have too limited understanding - not from confidence that your just thought of this now solution really should be the answer.

PleaseGiveMeBackMySummer · 11/10/2023 09:30

Good grief @emilysquest REALLY?! Hmm I have no words to describe this thread!

Reality25 · 11/10/2023 09:27

Solar panels don't just drop from the sky lol. It's complex manufacturing. Expensive product.

BeetleDeuce · 11/10/2023 09:26

I think you are confusing Gaza with Gloucester

Palmasailor · 11/10/2023 09:24

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 08:18

This may be naive in the extreme, but I was reading the reports this morning that Gaza will run out of power today, which is horrific. I dread to think what is going to happen now to those poor people.

This caused me to think: We happen to be in the process of making ourselves completely self-sufficient (off-grid) using solar panels (and some wind), and this is in Ireland, so not a sunny place like Palestine.

My question is, given the Gaza Strip was always dependent on power from Israel, which they regard (rightly) as a hostile country, why have they not in all the years sought to become self-sufficient (or at least more self-sufficient) with regard to power, to prevent the kind of blockade they are experiencing now?

Actually an allied question for those who know would be: travelling in eastern Europe recently, especially Bulgaria, there are huge solar farms everywhere. I have not been to the Middle East (well not since I was a baby), but do they use solar at all? It would seem to be an obvious choice given the climate.

The point is that despite the propaganda they’re bullshit. The lifetime carbon saving is not offset. IE in terms of manufacture and transport etc, they have more of a carbon impact than they save.

This is concealed behind lies, damn lies and statistics and will only really become obvious when all this crap ends up landfill and the people who bought them never see an ROI.

Thats some way off.

EasternStandard · 11/10/2023 09:24

Bubblesqueak88 · 11/10/2023 09:14

Why can’t Gaza, a densely populated hell hole without enough money to feed its citizens, install vast solar panel farms? Emily from Ireland did. 😂🙈😂🙈😂

Look at @Rosebud21 links

The op is as far off as some are laughing about

DRS1970 · 11/10/2023 09:22

It is the most densely populated area on land in the world - think of it as a landlocked city. They don't have the space to produce enough food, let alone for solar power. Plus most of the population rely on charitable handouts and aid to survive, and there are few job prospects, so little money to make such a large upfront investment either. Hope that helps. 🙃

Catza · 11/10/2023 09:22

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 08:41

I am not suggesting civilians build solar farms in their vast leafy gardens with their abundant disposable income. I am asking why their leaders did not over the last 20 years build some sustainable infrastructure. Its a completely different question.

For the same reason our own government didn’t manage to ensure any kind of reasonable education, healthcare and standard of living for the electorate. It is not government’s priority.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 11/10/2023 09:21

littleblackcat27 · 11/10/2023 08:33

I think this is a stupid and goady post from the OP.

Yeah - they should have got solar panel farms sorted Confused

Really??

The OP said that she thought it might be naive. She is only asking a question. That is how people learn.

I knew the answer like you, but she didn't.

ticketstickets · 11/10/2023 09:19

NotTerfNorCis · 11/10/2023 08:27

Israel would probably bomb them. If Israel wants to put the Palestinians under maximum pressure, including cutting off electricity, they'd be targeting solar panel farms right now, should they exist.

If Gaza would spend its resources on solar panels or other useful infrastructure instead of rockets, guns and tunnels, Israel would have no reason to bomb them. So double benefit!

(or are you suggesting Israel is bombing Gaza because they like killing innocent people?)