Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why the Palestinians did not put up solar panel farms

207 replies

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 08:18

This may be naive in the extreme, but I was reading the reports this morning that Gaza will run out of power today, which is horrific. I dread to think what is going to happen now to those poor people.

This caused me to think: We happen to be in the process of making ourselves completely self-sufficient (off-grid) using solar panels (and some wind), and this is in Ireland, so not a sunny place like Palestine.

My question is, given the Gaza Strip was always dependent on power from Israel, which they regard (rightly) as a hostile country, why have they not in all the years sought to become self-sufficient (or at least more self-sufficient) with regard to power, to prevent the kind of blockade they are experiencing now?

Actually an allied question for those who know would be: travelling in eastern Europe recently, especially Bulgaria, there are huge solar farms everywhere. I have not been to the Middle East (well not since I was a baby), but do they use solar at all? It would seem to be an obvious choice given the climate.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
pasturesgreen · 11/10/2023 13:04

This may be naive in the extreme

It is. You sound so completely out of touch with reality, I'm not sure it's even worth trying to explain.

Bloomingmagnolia · 11/10/2023 13:04

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:55

@Bloomingmagnolia that is interesting. The "real" replies to my question here (ie not those just calling me stupid or missing my underlying point) seem to have divide in to two different reasons why Palestine does not have a better power infrastructure. One that Hamas just does not care about anything like that (although, as I have said, surely it is in their interests to be able to supply their fighters now aa well as create another generation of fighters? So this puzzles me a bit). The other reason being that Israel would simply not allow the infrastructure to be developed. I guess both can be true.

I appreciate you are genuinely trying to understand. Interesting to see the different opinions. History has shown how the Palestinians have been penned into an ever-decreasing amount of land. As atrocious as the actions of Hamas have been, in the long-run, it worked to Israel’s advantage as they will have control over Gaza in the coming days.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 13:03

@WeWereInParis and yes, energy independence (or an attempt at it) is surely a priority when much of your population is essentially in a landlocked enclave of a hostile power? Or should be? (Note I said nothing whatsoever about "green initiatives. That has nothing to do with my thinking here).

OP posts:
emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:58

@WeWereInParis yes I get that, a lot of people have gone down the "Hamas don't care" line. But read my recent points. Any military needs supplies. And a new generation coming up behind. If you pay no attention to these points you may win a battle but never a war.

OP posts:
WeWereInParis · 11/10/2023 12:56

This may be naive in the extreme

Yes, very.

I am asking why their leaders did not over the last 20 years build some sustainable infrastructure.

The terrorist group? Why didn't the terrorist group put in some infrastructure to support green initiatives and energy independence? Is this your question?

I mean, of all the things to question about a despotic group of terrorists. Of course they don't give a shit. They don't care if Palestinians civilians die. I think I'm also right in saying ISIS hasn't built many wind farms..

begs the question as to how they have been able to build their paramilitary capability while ignoring their civilian population.

Because they don't care about the civilian population.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:56

@headcheffer that is interesting, I did not know that. I know of a lot of solar use in South Africa, because of all the load shedding, but I guess that is not the same level of heat.

OP posts:
emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:55

@Bloomingmagnolia that is interesting. The "real" replies to my question here (ie not those just calling me stupid or missing my underlying point) seem to have divide in to two different reasons why Palestine does not have a better power infrastructure. One that Hamas just does not care about anything like that (although, as I have said, surely it is in their interests to be able to supply their fighters now aa well as create another generation of fighters? So this puzzles me a bit). The other reason being that Israel would simply not allow the infrastructure to be developed. I guess both can be true.

OP posts:
headcheffer · 11/10/2023 12:55

Solar use for electricity isn't actually great in very hot countries. The panels can't cope with the temperature.

Bloomingmagnolia · 11/10/2023 12:50

I think you are overestimating what is possible in an open-air prison. Do you really think Israel would want or even allow them to be self-sufficient? Solar power won’t generate gas, which has now been shut off.

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 12:49

War is horrendous.

I'm not in the military, but going to places like Bosnia even ten years after a war is sobering enough for me.

We have NO idea in this country.

We need to do better. I do feel we are sleep walking into something much bigger.

YesterdaysGirl · 11/10/2023 12:48

People know exactly what's going to happen to innocent Palestians now so they are showing their support.

Ok I genuinely didn't think of this perspective. Thank you.

YesterdaysGirl · 11/10/2023 12:46

@RedToothBrush

Apologies I'm on App and can't reply to a reply. But yes I am very aware how the media machine works hence why I like threads on here so I can get different perspectives and references.

But sadly I was in the military during the Bosnian war and did 2 military tours there. I've seen first hand the horrendous atrocities men (and it's mostly always men) do to their "enemy".

I also saw how it was reported back home (UK) but it's slightly different now as we can see legitimate first hand accounts -
Twitter, Facebook, TikTok

Not of which was available during my military career and to be honest would have made my job much easier!

This conflict was never my area of expertise and lazily never researched too deeply. So I'm learning loads from threads like these.

Anyway said too much so I'm off to change my username AGAIN! I only changed it yesterday!

See ya on the other board ;)

Glitterdavies · 11/10/2023 12:43

YesterdaysGirl · 11/10/2023 12:35

WHAT!!!

it's the where and when of the flag waving!

You're being disingenuous linking the 2 together!

So you think it's just coincidence that the day after Hamas committed those atrocities, thousands of Palestinians descended on some of our cities and waved their flag? You don't think that's celebrating what Hamas did?

Come on!!

And I've not seen anyone on this thread say they have zero sympathy for the people in Gaza. It's just hell all round.

People know exactly what's going to happen to innocent Palestians now so they are showing their support.

It's the same. If you can wave an Israeli flag whilst Israel are commit war crimes without it being in support of those war crimes - then people can do the same for Palestine

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/10/2023 12:43

Because it can’t afford to.

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 12:41

I get the very cynical feeling that increasingly the western attitude is that human rights aren't for everyone. They are only for 'the right people'.

And looking at that through that lens is fucking scary.

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 12:39

Glitterdavies · 11/10/2023 12:22

Supporting Palestine and waving a flag is not supporting Hamas, the same as supporting Israel outside of downing Street and waving a flag is not supporting Israeli war crimes.

If it can mean that for Israeli support then it can mean that for Palestinian support.

My problem is ultimately with the flag - it's an endorsement of the Israeli government if a government is hoisting it in support. It's officialdom. And it's without cavet about the actions of the government. That sends a diplomatic message.

It's different if it's an individual hoisting a flag. There isn't the diplomatic considerations.

Keep in mind that Israel ISN'T a member of NATO but is an official NATO ally.

We have an issue in terms of arms supply and the power of Israel. Israel's relationship with Saudi Arabia is also relevant here. (And Saudis with Iran). Especially since the Ukrainian war has been stretching reserves.

Now would be an ideal time for China to be dicks (just saying)

I have to say, I find all of this terrifying. It's another front in a war of certain alliances and that's what should be scaring the shit out of everyone.

This isn't just about Palestine and Israel.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:38

To be fair, I think some of the Palestinian flag-bearers (by no means all) are trying to show solidarity for the Palestinian people, not celebrate war crimes.

OP posts:
emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:37

Apologies, I guess I did say "farms" in my title. I was not really thinking of huge Bulgarian style acres-wide areas, but I didn't make that clear. I call my own power system a "farm" too, because it's a few panels and batteries not just a single roof panel.

OP posts:
YesterdaysGirl · 11/10/2023 12:35

Glitterdavies · 11/10/2023 12:22

Supporting Palestine and waving a flag is not supporting Hamas, the same as supporting Israel outside of downing Street and waving a flag is not supporting Israeli war crimes.

If it can mean that for Israeli support then it can mean that for Palestinian support.

WHAT!!!

it's the where and when of the flag waving!

You're being disingenuous linking the 2 together!

So you think it's just coincidence that the day after Hamas committed those atrocities, thousands of Palestinians descended on some of our cities and waved their flag? You don't think that's celebrating what Hamas did?

Come on!!

And I've not seen anyone on this thread say they have zero sympathy for the people in Gaza. It's just hell all round.

RedToothBrush · 11/10/2023 12:31

YesterdaysGirl · 11/10/2023 11:57

After seeing the media of scenes in London, Birmingham and Nottingham I would guess they're pretty well supported.

I used to sympathise with Palestinians (although my knowledge wasn't deep).

But now after seeing those scenes in my own country (UK), I feel more for the Israelis.

I think you make a really good point.

You are being influenced by what you are seeing.

I always make the point about the media in terms of getting into the habit of considering what you are not seeing and why are you not seeing it?

It's relevant.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:24

@Glitterdavies I agree.

OP posts:
emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:23

My post about "why would Hamas not want to keep the mothers alive to breed fighters" was not meant to support that aim. I as pointing out that if their aim is. as I presume it must be, to win a long war, they won't do so by having no infrastructure and no fighters. My whole point is that from their point of view (not mine) it doesn't seem to make sense not to have invested in logistics over the past decades. Underuse of sustainable energy systems was an example of that. (Although, as some people have enlightened me, I see there are very good practical reasons which may have made this nigh impossible to do).

OP posts:
Glitterdavies · 11/10/2023 12:22

Supporting Palestine and waving a flag is not supporting Hamas, the same as supporting Israel outside of downing Street and waving a flag is not supporting Israeli war crimes.

If it can mean that for Israeli support then it can mean that for Palestinian support.

Glitterdavies · 11/10/2023 12:19

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 12:16

@Glitterdavies I absolutely support Palestine, where are you getting that I do not? I have taken part in marches against Israeli atrocities (note, not against the Israeli people) in various places in the world and my parents are very pro-Palestinian (as I said my dad was born in Palestine).

But pro the Palestinian people and their right to their land (which was stolen from them first by Britain and then by Israel). Not pro-Hamas* *(although it is precisely because this is all so complex, and I have an incomplete understanding of it that I asked my original question in the first place about how Hamas attends to infrastructure in Gaza).

Before anyone jumps on about my being antisemitic, I'm not.

This was not for you but for someone else upthread you can see it. They said they used to feel sorry but no more sympathy.
Clearly they had none to being with.

Glitterdavies · 11/10/2023 12:18

There's a racist undercurrent running through these threads that all Palestinians are for Hamas and they are breeding and giving up their children to kill Jews.

This is being put out there so that when you see Israeli soliders killing children you will think in the back of your mind that they would have been jihadi's anyways so...

I bet Hamas are thinking the same about the Israeli citizens since they all have to do national service and be reservists, they are all potential soldiers so...

When does it end!

Look back over the last 4 years and see how many Israeli soldiers have gotten away will killing children, not innocent people in general, just look at the numbers of children.

Look at how many children have been set on fire by settlers and see how they are not brought to justice by the Israeli criminal courts.

Where was the fucking outrage then?

Where were these Israelis that felt sorry for the Palestinians?