Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why the Palestinians did not put up solar panel farms

207 replies

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 08:18

This may be naive in the extreme, but I was reading the reports this morning that Gaza will run out of power today, which is horrific. I dread to think what is going to happen now to those poor people.

This caused me to think: We happen to be in the process of making ourselves completely self-sufficient (off-grid) using solar panels (and some wind), and this is in Ireland, so not a sunny place like Palestine.

My question is, given the Gaza Strip was always dependent on power from Israel, which they regard (rightly) as a hostile country, why have they not in all the years sought to become self-sufficient (or at least more self-sufficient) with regard to power, to prevent the kind of blockade they are experiencing now?

Actually an allied question for those who know would be: travelling in eastern Europe recently, especially Bulgaria, there are huge solar farms everywhere. I have not been to the Middle East (well not since I was a baby), but do they use solar at all? It would seem to be an obvious choice given the climate.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 17:12

Bearcub101 · 11/10/2023 17:01

Because Hamas is a terrorist group, all they are concerned about is arms. They have zero concern for the civilian population. Plus have you seen the size of Gaza and how densely populated it is??

I'm not sure if it's been said on this thread or not, but this isn't true. NGOs, whilst obviously not condoning the group, acknowledge the humanitarian work that they do. Delivering food, medicine, education etc. The 'arms' wing of Hamas is a very small part.

Bearcub101 · 11/10/2023 17:01

Because Hamas is a terrorist group, all they are concerned about is arms. They have zero concern for the civilian population. Plus have you seen the size of Gaza and how densely populated it is??

SinnerBoy · 11/10/2023 17:00

EnoughIsay · Today 16:18

"When Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005 they left lots of infrastructure including a water treatment plant etc. the first thing Hamas did when they got into power was blow it up.' This is up for debate.

Well, not really, as the Israelis blew it up in an airstrike.

BlueYonder57 · 11/10/2023 16:52

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 16:51

Ps my solar panels in a non sunny country aren't in any danger from rockets, not sure what you mean by that!

I thought it was fairly obvious....

BlueYonder57 · 11/10/2023 16:51

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 15:36

Exactly. This is what this is about. I'm so bloody sick of people saying "this isn't about land, they just want to kill Jewish people!". The Jews, Christians and Muslims lived together peacefully before the occupation. It's the OCCUPATION and the human rights violations that are the problem.

Cobblers. In the first place there was no "before the occupation" - it was just different people doing the occupying. Immediately before - oh yes, the British. During the 3 decades of the British Mandate there were continual protests, riots and and revolts. THere was no golden age of communities living together peacefully - that is British tripe that is not borne out by the historical record. We weren't even very "nice" occupiers -

I do not support Zionist policies, but nor do I support terrorists, and Hamas are terrorists. But the roots of this are neither Israel or Palestine - they lie much closer to home You could argue that both sides learned a lot from us, and it wasn't about peaceful co-existence. Britain left Palestine simmering on the brink of a war between the Arabs and Jews, and didn't look back, because it was too hot to handle.

Be clear - whatever else may or may not be possible in achieving a peace in the longer term, it will never happen whilst terrorists backed by Iran and Russia control the agenda, and they do just want to kill Jewish people (and actually anyone else, including Palestinians who get in their way). And if they ever succeeded with the Jews, they would move on to Christians and then Muslims who don't share their views. Hammas are not Muslims, they are terrorists, and there is no room in the Quran for their actions. As any decent Imman would tell you.

The forgotten atrocities: Britain’s history of abuse in Palestine - BBC Newsnight

The UK government is being urged to make a formal apology for alleged war crimes by British troops in historical Palestine nearly a century ago. The petition...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKPayr11kFI

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 16:51

@CinnamonJellyBeans that is unnecessary, please read some of the thread

OP posts:
emilysquest · 11/10/2023 16:51

Ps my solar panels in a non sunny country aren't in any danger from rockets, not sure what you mean by that!

OP posts:
CinnamonJellyBeans · 11/10/2023 16:50

They could use the solar power to provide energy for ovens, so they can eat cake.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 16:48

@BlueYonder57 by that logic no-one would have built any infrastructure in Gaza at all, as it is all going to blown up by rockets now. Why bother with any facilities since they can all be destroyed. (A hospital or blood bank is no more immune to being blown to pieces than a solar panel, but they did build those).

And have you seen the earlier posts about the solar panels that were in Gaza (of which I was not aware when I write my original post), the (thwarted) plans there had been for more, and the still extant solar panels in other areas of Palestine?

I too sometimes despair of people.

OP posts:
BlueYonder57 · 11/10/2023 16:31

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 08:38

I am not trying to be goady at all. I was just wondering, in light of the news today, how the impending humanitarian catastrophe might have been prevented if one went back a few years. Because I am in the middle of building a solar system in a very non-sunny countey, my mind went to "would this not be a consideration in the Middle East?". That's all.

Ermm, have you ever played "rock, paper, scissors"? How about "rockets & solar panels"? In case you aren't aware, your solar system in a very non-sunny country will definitely be blown to pieces if hit by a rocket. Like, you know, most of the Gaza Strip is being hit by rockets???

Sometimes I despair of people...

EnoughIsay · 11/10/2023 16:18

Bells3032 · 11/10/2023 08:36

This.
Gaza gets more humanitarian aid per capita than any other nation or refugee group on earth. Sadly for the people there Hamas siphon it off for weapons, to pay suicide attackers or prisoners or just to line their own pockets.

When Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005 they left lots of infrastructure including a water treatment plant etc. the first thing Hamas did when they got into power was blow it up. Now they get their electricity, water and medical supplies from Israel. whilst i think it's awful for Israel to cut innocent people off I have to ask what other country is expected to supply humanitarian aid, water and electricity to their enemy state?

While this is almost certainly true, it is also true that Gaza is razed to the ground frequently.

That is one of the reasons the aid amount is so high - they have to rebuild from the ground up fairly often.

"When Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005 they left lots of infrastructure including a water treatment plant etc. the first thing Hamas did when they got into power was blow it up.' This is up for debate.

Hamas are evil bastards.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 15:36

NotTerfNorCis · 11/10/2023 15:07

Under occupation, 90% of Gaza's water went to 7,000 Israelis.

It's this kind of statistic I wish defenders of Israel were aware of.

Exactly. This is what this is about. I'm so bloody sick of people saying "this isn't about land, they just want to kill Jewish people!". The Jews, Christians and Muslims lived together peacefully before the occupation. It's the OCCUPATION and the human rights violations that are the problem.

feralunderclass · 11/10/2023 15:33

YesterdaysGirl · 11/10/2023 12:35

WHAT!!!

it's the where and when of the flag waving!

You're being disingenuous linking the 2 together!

So you think it's just coincidence that the day after Hamas committed those atrocities, thousands of Palestinians descended on some of our cities and waved their flag? You don't think that's celebrating what Hamas did?

Come on!!

And I've not seen anyone on this thread say they have zero sympathy for the people in Gaza. It's just hell all round.

I was at a march last weekend organized by a socialist party. I do not support Hamas in any way. I was there to show solidarity to the Palestinians and call for an end to the occupation. I would hazard a guess at least 90% of the other people were white British. Everyone and their dog knows that the events will have severe repercussions on the civilian population. I unapologetically stand with the people of Gaza, there wasn't a single mention of Hamas.

Bonkersworknonsense · 11/10/2023 15:16

This may have been mentioned already, but Gaza has around 45,000 acres of farmland and 200 acres of forests. It is not all densely populated cityscape.

NotTerfNorCis · 11/10/2023 15:07

Under occupation, 90% of Gaza's water went to 7,000 Israelis.

It's this kind of statistic I wish defenders of Israel were aware of.

Emmalin · 11/10/2023 15:04

To answer your original question OP they keep getting bombed, so ... 🤷‍♀️

Bloomingmagnolia · 11/10/2023 14:25

Mistakes on such a huge scale? Naaah.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 14:14

@Bloomingmagnolia wouldn't you say that mistakes/too broad a bandwidth are more likely that a false flag?

OP posts:
itstoopeopleyoutthere · 11/10/2023 14:13

I asked a few family members about solar panels when I was back in Australia, as I was surprised there weren't a lot more of them. They said that it can actually get too hot and then the energy output isn't as efficient. And if it gets too hot they can stop working.

SinnerBoy · 11/10/2023 14:07

Bells3032 · Today 08:36

When Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005 they left lots of infrastructure including a water treatment plant etc. the first thing Hamas did when they got into power was blow it up.

That's not actually the case, Israel blew it up later. The Gazans smashed up settler's homes and flower growing greenhouses - bizarrely, when they could have used them. Under occupation, 90% of Gaza's water went to 7,000 Israelis. The Israelis blew up unofficial wells and sometimes, the house whose property it was on.

GrumpyPanda · 11/10/2023 14:06

CyberCritical · 11/10/2023 08:22

Suspect it's to do with lack of resources like solar panels, batteries, the material to set up the infrastructure.

People in Gaza strip rely heavily on humanitarian aid, they don't have access to enough clean water let alone supplies to put in place enough solar panels to provide electric to a couple of million people.

Some aid actually does go directly to solar panels - read in the papers this morning that Germany ran some West Bank projects in this area.

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 14:04

@Insommmmnia no I know you didn't! Some people did though. I have learned a lot from this thread.

OP posts:
Bloomingmagnolia · 11/10/2023 14:03

Milarky · 11/10/2023 13:50

Are you suggesting they ignored the warnings on purpose, so they could watch their friends and loved ones being massacred?

Or more likely the Intelligence Services get so much intel from various sources that some concerns can not be validated? It happens in the UK, god knows how many terrorists attacks that we don't know about about in this country have been stopped but sadly a few have succeeded.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

The Israeli lives are collateral damage for their longer-term goal of wiping Gaza and its people off the map. There is no way on God’s earth that the IDS didn’t know about Hamas stockpiling military weapons. I just can’t fathom such a massive failure of intelligence. This wasn’t a one-off suicide bomb but a well-orchestrated slaughter. There will be reverberations across the world as more ME countries get sucked in.

London feels unsafer.

Skodacool · 11/10/2023 14:02

Hermittrismegistus · 11/10/2023 08:31

Do you have any idea how small Gaza is and how densely populated? How on earth would you find the space?

Exactly. Also, the Israeli government exercises total control over utilities and supplies in Gaza.

Insommmmnia · 11/10/2023 14:01

emilysquest · 11/10/2023 13:59

@Insommmmnia yes I see. That is a horrible horrible picture. Is it from today? It really brings home the point many have made about the futility of putting up panels because they would always be a military target. So, a misguided plan and I see that. I suspected so from the off. That's why I was asking a question, not posing a solution.

But was I "stupid"? Others, some in Gaza, some in foreign governments, did have the same idea (as has been shown by some of the links on this thread), so although clearly naive, I had some company at least (have been educated now though).

It's from yesterday and fact checked by snopes and linked back to a specific jounalist so I think authentic

I never called you stupid