Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My sister's a cow and mum's sad- what do I do?!

82 replies

WhatToDoAboutTheNosys · 11/10/2023 07:39

The basic gist is that my mum's really mentally struggling, is chatting to some support on the phone and waiting for a proper referral for depression.

My DS1 is the unreasonable one. She doesn't seem to care in the slightest, won't ask my mum how she is or have any sort of nice chat you'd expect a daughter to have with her mum in this position.

I'm going to give a little family round up to explain the situation. My mum and dad split up when I was 2, DS2 was 6, DS1 was 8. He's never made much effort, my mum used to try push him to see us but I basically don't feel like I have a dad and don't have a bond with him. DS2 likes to think that she does, DS1 actually does despite him acting being her step dad, but from a very young age.

DS2 wants everything to be happy, fine and normal so just pretends that it is. My mum reminded the both of us that she split from my dad because he got violent with her, but she literally doesn't want to acknowledge that.

My mum's councilling and mental state means she's remembering all of the abusive stuff my dad did to her (I don't know the details but although she's sensitive I believe her). She's decided she's done and will never see my dad again. We've all accepted it, however I'm the one one who doesn't care at all because it doesn't effect my relationship with him.

The problem is DS1 is renovating her house and my dad basically lives with her to do it and will for a long time. We all have kids, DS1 has the most and my mum used to go round and see them loads. DM has an isolated life, tonnes of acquaintances, but she pushes friends away (I think my dad screwed her up good) and only really has us. DS1 claims to be too busy and isn't making any effort at all for my mum to see them now that she's avoiding my dad.

The bigger problem as I said at the start is she just will not be kind and supportive with my mum's depression. I asked her to ask my mum how she was when she was seeing her briefly last week and her response was that she's helped her so much in the past with paperwork and ordering things online for her- which I feel is irrelevant to the issue!!

We used to all pretend that things are ok like DS2 does but in the past couple of years I've got sick of DS1 and call her out because she's often removed and unfriendly (I basically began when she wasn't happy for me being pregnant- enough is enough). The other day I sent her the following message

"I am struggling to grasp what's going on/what you're thinking. Why are you not making any effort to see if mum is ok- that emotional support that doesn't require actions just chatting to her? You haven't acknowledged anything about it that I've seen? Or if you are could you tell us so we're aware of what support she's having?".

There was no reply and there won't be. My mum says she feels my dad is chosen over her, DS1 doesn't care about her, it makes her sad and she misses the kids.

What do I do? Is there anything I CAN do? I would cut contact with DS1 if it wasn't for my DC missing out on seeing cousins and my mum and DS2 would be so gutted with a broken up family.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhatToDoAboutTheNosys · 11/10/2023 17:18

@OrderOfTheKookaburra thank you for picking up on those points that I made!! You're pretty much the only person to have noticed 😅

@jammyhand you'd be absolutely correct if it was all stemming from my mum. The truth is I've had a problem with my sister's behavior for long before my mum's been upset with her and depressed.

I've mentioned previously but the main points are she wasn't happy for me when I was pregnant (very hard to overcome this because he's my world. It was at the same time DS2 was pregnant too and DS1 was absolutely super over the moon for her. We are both married, own houses, stable jobs etc so it wasn't that she was worried for my situation or jealous etc).
She ruined the wedding prep of DS2 because we felt we couldn't talk about it in front of her.
I'm often not comfortable at all at how she speaks to and treats kids that are in her care.

With me living away, yes I'm not there all the time but I'm not abroad or anything and do visit pretty frequently. I see them together it's not all just told to me.

DS1 obviously remembers lots from our parents marriage. The only memory she's told me is finding my dad having sex with the cleaner on the sofa

OP posts:
EmmaPaella · 11/10/2023 16:23

This is such a complex issue. I have a similar situation in my family. It’s really upsetting at times. It’s so easy to see things in black and white though, and less easy to live it. The pps are right though, your sister has a different experience of her parents so you will be happier if you leave her to it and concentrate on your own relationship with your DM. Also while it is admirable and lovely that you care, don’t become your DM’s sole support blanket as it will wear you down.

phoenixrosehere · 11/10/2023 16:11

sparklefresh · 11/10/2023 14:40

@MyGooseisTotallyLoose if it's so easy, why can't the OP's DS1 chip in and do it too?

From what OP said herself, her DS1 chipped in quite a bit in the past, but it’s irrelevant now in OP’s eyes.

OP is not local yet she knows everything (including her sister’s finances and how she treats their father who OP says herself, she doesn’t have a relationship with) seemingly going on despite also not talking to her oldest sister. She has used her sister’s relationship with her dad as an issue, her sister’s work as an issue, how her sister spends her money as an issue. Everything seems to be her oldest sister’s responsibility to sort out their mother while OP who constantly keeps reminding us she’s not local, doesn’t seem to have done near as much and/or doing anything but chatting with their mum.

Her oldest sister probably has a good reason for not doing more than she already has right now. It likely took a toll on her and she is doing what her own mother is doing, prioritising her own mental health and that includes taking a step back from her mother.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 11/10/2023 16:09

You sister sounds like she's selfish, upset that she didn't get married first, upset at you having DC, etc. using your DF for the building work matches with that.

I bet that when the building work is done, and it becomes more useful to her to see your DM rather than your DF then she will happily go back to seeing her more frequently. But right now she gets more value out of seeing your DF so that's what she is doing.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 11/10/2023 15:44

@sparklefresh @jammyhand has given far, far better reasoning as to I ever could as to examples why the ds1 has stepped away!

jammyhand · 11/10/2023 15:15

WhatToDoAboutTheNosys · 11/10/2023 10:52

@IkeaMeatballGravy is it not human nature to speak to somebody close to you and say things like "I'm so upset I saw x today and she didn't talk to me" or "I'm really struggling I wonder why x never asks if I'm ok".

If that wasn't normal would half of this forum even exist and how would people give support to each other- a problem shared is a problem halved

Honestly, no. I mean this 100%: you need to learn about healthy or even normal relationships.

Venting anonymously is fine, and even venting a few times IRL is OK.

But:

  1. If you keep venting to someone you know about the same person/thing, it becomes bitching and moaning. The listener is well within their rights to draw boundaries.

Eg If I moan to you about my neighbour every. single. day. non stop, at some point you will tap out of it emotionally.

  1. (And more importantly in my view) In front of you, your mother shouldn't consistently denigrate someone you are both meant to have an equal family relationship with.

It is really vicious for a daughter to call her sibling a cow just based on the strength of her mother's words.

That is NOT a healthy family dynamic. In fact, what your mother is doing is called triangulation: "A form of manipulation, triangulation involves the use of indirect communication, often behind someone's back." Its goal, or at least consequence, is to divide and conquer.

Imo, a real mother wants her children to get along. In that sense, your mother is a selfish manipulator and a Child, setting out to (or at least not caring that she will) ruin your sibling relationship because she hasn't got the attention she wants. I don't mean this as a moral judgment, but as a descriptor of her current motives and behaviour.

There's no way your mum is giving you the full picture of what's happening locally as well. Plus, make no mistake, if one day your behaviour displeases your mum, she'll turn to your other siblings to slander you as well.

Finally, it seems like you have idolised your mother as being able to do no wrong. Yes, when you were a child you viewed her as sparkly and perfect.

But firstly, as an older child, your sister might not have viewed her that way. Moreover, she might have a fuller view of your mum's behaviour both as an 8 year old, and in the many years preceding your birth.
(As a sidenote, the Harry-William-Diana dynamic is a lot like this because William was older when Diana passed away. William has a more realistic (but still loving) appraisal of Diana's toxic behaviour and adultification of him, while Harry is still visibly stuck in perpetual mummy-as-victim-worship-mode.)

Secondly, even if your mum used to be perfect, it's been decades. She would have changed a lot since then and you can't blame your sister for viewing reality instead of being trapped in the past.

You need to let your mother and adult sister handle their own relationship. And your mother needs to stop poisoning the relationship between you 2 siblings; you can form your own judgments on DS without your mum continually sowing seeds of discord. A bit of venting and moral support is OK but not if it's to the point of character assassination.

sparklefresh · 11/10/2023 14:40

@MyGooseisTotallyLoose if it's so easy, why can't the OP's DS1 chip in and do it too?

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 11/10/2023 14:34

sparklefresh · 11/10/2023 13:57

YANBU. Your mum is struggling and you shouldn't be expected to support her alone just because your sister can't be arsed.

What exactly is the op doing that's so hard? She chats on the phone as they don't live close, most of the chat seems to be moaning about ds1 and why she just won't do what the dm and op want her to do?

Coughingdodger · 11/10/2023 14:33

hellohelp · 11/10/2023 14:10

That was really interesting to watch every single poster be unanimous and point out the same things to op

Hopefully she’ll get the message and her life will be the more peaceful for it.

hellohelp · 11/10/2023 14:10

That was really interesting to watch every single poster be unanimous and point out the same things to op

Brefugee · 11/10/2023 13:59

WhatToDoAboutTheNosys · 11/10/2023 07:45

@MyGooseisTotallyLoose my mum has 3 adults she's close to in her life and I should let one of them not give a crap about her? How can a kid not show any care about their struggling mum?!

much as you want to, it is not up to you to tell other adults how to live their lives.

Concentrate on what you can do for your mum and let the others do the same. Or not. However they feel about it is not up to you

sparklefresh · 11/10/2023 13:57

YANBU. Your mum is struggling and you shouldn't be expected to support her alone just because your sister can't be arsed.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 11/10/2023 13:55

Also agree with @Enko re the b&w thinking.
Op you come across as 'mum says this happened, x did/didn't do this therefore it's absolutely true'.

Enko · 11/10/2023 13:43

Goldfish41 · 11/10/2023 12:33

Maybe, maybe not, we don’t know who she has spoken to and whether they are her friends or people in the family who might have broader perspectives on things. All I’m saying is that some posters on here have clearly decided exactly who these people are and what the dynamic is on very little information.

I agree that she can’t control this, but I think some of the conclusions people have leapt to - sister obviously deeply damaged by things mother has done, mother never taking responsibility for anything in her life (??), OP a flying monkey - go a little bit far when we don’t know very much about this situation.

I think when we have a post like " my sister is a cow" it is all one-sided towards the mother. What is seen is a sister/daughter who has sided very much to one side. Even after she was told rather bluntly by others she has gone wrong she stands by calling her sister a cow. This gives judgements from people.

Sometimes hearing a blunter perspective can make us sit up and take notice and consider our own involvement in this. OP to me comes across as if she feels she knows the truth "Mum is x dad is y". In life, people are rarely black and white. It may do the op some good to consider this and draw her own involvement back a few notches.

Op can remain within her truth without forcing her sister or mother to be in her truth with her. The truth can be multifaceted.

MackenCheese · 11/10/2023 13:19

Another person here who wouldn't pick up the phone. I'm well aware that my dad is ill, frail and struggling. But every time I think about him, I think of the physical abuse and verbal abuse. The latter up to quite recently . Sorry , sometimes it's about setting boundaries and allowing oneself to be protected.

PatchouliOilandRoses · 11/10/2023 13:00

Your mum sounds manipulative with her woe is me routine.
You sound like her flying monkey as others have pointed out.
This is one thread that I would absolutely love to hear from DS1's point of view!!!

LadyBird1973 · 11/10/2023 12:54

OP, you might be better to post in Relationships

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 11/10/2023 12:41

I'm very shocked that so many people think it's fine for a daughter to not show their mum they give a toss about them. I'm sure we'd all be devastated if our own kids did this to us.
Has your mum shown to your dsis that she 'gives a toss' about her?
Or is it all about centering your mum and her needs and if you don't you're a cow?

Beangrove · 11/10/2023 12:40

OP for whatever reason, your sister has decided she won't/can't support your mother at this particular point in time. Maybe for some deep seated psychological reason rooted in her childhood (which as so many have said will she will have experienced in a totally different way to you), maybe just because she has a lot on her plate at the moment and can't be arsed with it all. Only she knows. The key thing is there is absolutely nothing you can do about it and haranguing her is only likely to make her want to distance herself further. Leave her be, and focus on supporting your mother if you want and feel able to.

Goldfish41 · 11/10/2023 12:33

Enko · 11/10/2023 11:54

@Goldfish41. In part when we speak with people we know they care about us and due to this are involved.

If op is saying to friends. Something like "I dont get why my sister is being so mean to my mum all mum wants is a to see her grandchildren" the response is likely to be more in style of "oh that sounds so hard you would think your sister would want to Foster a good relationship" "you can only do so much" "don't beat yourself up over it"

If you care about someone you are less likely to say "wow you were out of order" more likely to say " while I get why you did that do you think that will work?" And op will take from that "my friend understands me and is on my side aka I am right" where as friend may have a different view but their focus is on supporting their friend whom they care about.

@WhatToDoAboutTheNosys your sister was much older when your parents parted and she will have her own experiences and trauma from this. What you describe as a mother who made fun of hard things a sister 4 years older than you may habe felt a responsibility for. As then older sister she may have felt forced to be distant with her father as mother wouldn't approve (doesn't matter if mother did or not we are looking at how this may have felt for a 6 year old) and sister may now have come to a part where she have decided she wants to pull away from your mother's issues and focus on her own.

That she takes on more meetings than she has to at work has nothing to do with this. She may enjoy her work. She may be working towards a promotion, want to be considered for some further education paid for by work. I take on extra meetings at work because I want to understand our processes and it supports my work

Your experiences as a child will have been very different to your sisters as you are 2 different people. You need to respect your sister makes different choices to you. If you love her then let her know the door is open and you are there. Just stop deciding how she should behave and whom she should see. Allow her to make her choices just like your mum made hers.

I get its hard. My brother cut contact with our sister for 18 years. To begin with he was adamant the rest of us had to do so too or "we were taking her side" I told him I care about tou both and I am here but you do not get to chose whom is in my life. I will respect you are not wanting contact and I wont mention our sister around you or invite you both to mine at the same thing. But in return you respect it is my choice if I keep her in my life.

He coped and oddly 8 years ago when our mother died they made up and these days are actually closer than he and I are.

We need to allow each person autonomy to make their adult choices. You are putting conditions on your sisters choices.

Maybe, maybe not, we don’t know who she has spoken to and whether they are her friends or people in the family who might have broader perspectives on things. All I’m saying is that some posters on here have clearly decided exactly who these people are and what the dynamic is on very little information.

I agree that she can’t control this, but I think some of the conclusions people have leapt to - sister obviously deeply damaged by things mother has done, mother never taking responsibility for anything in her life (??), OP a flying monkey - go a little bit far when we don’t know very much about this situation.

Enko · 11/10/2023 11:54

@Goldfish41. In part when we speak with people we know they care about us and due to this are involved.

If op is saying to friends. Something like "I dont get why my sister is being so mean to my mum all mum wants is a to see her grandchildren" the response is likely to be more in style of "oh that sounds so hard you would think your sister would want to Foster a good relationship" "you can only do so much" "don't beat yourself up over it"

If you care about someone you are less likely to say "wow you were out of order" more likely to say " while I get why you did that do you think that will work?" And op will take from that "my friend understands me and is on my side aka I am right" where as friend may have a different view but their focus is on supporting their friend whom they care about.

@WhatToDoAboutTheNosys your sister was much older when your parents parted and she will have her own experiences and trauma from this. What you describe as a mother who made fun of hard things a sister 4 years older than you may habe felt a responsibility for. As then older sister she may have felt forced to be distant with her father as mother wouldn't approve (doesn't matter if mother did or not we are looking at how this may have felt for a 6 year old) and sister may now have come to a part where she have decided she wants to pull away from your mother's issues and focus on her own.

That she takes on more meetings than she has to at work has nothing to do with this. She may enjoy her work. She may be working towards a promotion, want to be considered for some further education paid for by work. I take on extra meetings at work because I want to understand our processes and it supports my work

Your experiences as a child will have been very different to your sisters as you are 2 different people. You need to respect your sister makes different choices to you. If you love her then let her know the door is open and you are there. Just stop deciding how she should behave and whom she should see. Allow her to make her choices just like your mum made hers.

I get its hard. My brother cut contact with our sister for 18 years. To begin with he was adamant the rest of us had to do so too or "we were taking her side" I told him I care about tou both and I am here but you do not get to chose whom is in my life. I will respect you are not wanting contact and I wont mention our sister around you or invite you both to mine at the same thing. But in return you respect it is my choice if I keep her in my life.

He coped and oddly 8 years ago when our mother died they made up and these days are actually closer than he and I are.

We need to allow each person autonomy to make their adult choices. You are putting conditions on your sisters choices.

WhatToDoAboutTheNosys · 11/10/2023 11:49

@Godzillaisjusthangry if you have seen all of my posts you'll see some other examples of why I've unfortunately lost faith in my sister. I've tried speaking to her to see if anything's wrong a few times. She says there isn't, so from the evidence I have I stand by the cow comment

OP posts:
WhatToDoAboutTheNosys · 11/10/2023 11:45

I'd never heard of being a flying monkey until I was diagnosed as one so many times today 😂

Just fyi the text I sent was in response to not saying anything for ages, then gently trying a few times before I sent that message to try and get more to the bottom of things and actually get a response.

I'm very shocked that so many people think it's fine for a daughter to not show their mum they give a toss about them. I'm sure we'd all be devastated if our own kids did this to us.

However I'm taking it on board that I need to step back from trying to change anything. I'll tell mum to stop taking about it so much. I've already tried to say she needs to stop dwelling on it but will draw a clearer line so hopefully she can move past it a bit.

OP posts:
Godzillaisjusthangry · 11/10/2023 11:41

@Goldfish41 given that the op titled her thread ' my sister's a cow' doesn't suggest she's objective on the situation or is considering how her sister might actually feel. Think the OP has been harsh in her judgement of her sister.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 11/10/2023 11:25

@Goldfish41 but if all the other people op and her dm have talked to (about how dreadful ds1 is...) are only hearing one side of the story of course they'll side with the teller of it.
Are you/dm just pissed off ds1 wont do as you're telling her? That for 20 years is it, her having a relationship with dad was OK, but now you and she have decided its not well that's it she needs to stop?