Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of being fat and hungry

168 replies

ruthonfire · 10/10/2023 22:02

I am overweight. I eat too much of the wrong stuff. I binge on snacks. But I'm hungry always. Everyday I swear I'll try and improve my diet and eat more healthily but then I feel hungry and can't control my behaviours around food. I crave stodge and I just binge on it.

I need to seriously change my habits but how?

OP posts:
SecretAgent008 · 11/10/2023 00:02

Apart from chicken and eggs, what else do you eat using the glucose goddess method?

3beesinmybonnet · 10/10/2023 23:55

Agree with pps the problem is addiction to carbs and sugar. DH and I had a wake up call when our annual healthchecks showed we were both prediabetic. We both had several stone to lose as well.

DH does the cooking in our house - he now uses Tesco vegetarian recipes from their website, the Jamie Oliver ones are especially nice. We've replaced bad carbs with complex good carbs which make you feel fuller for longer, also cut back drastically on the quantities of carbs, and eat lots more veg. We have meat occasionally but we really don't miss it now.

We also stopped buying chocolate, cakes and biscuits, which we snacked on most nights after tea. After 4 weeks the sugar cravings were gone.

I've lost 16 lbs/7.4 kg since January 1st and its showing no signs of stopping! I don't often feel hungry but as a pp said your attitude to hunger changes - ATM I'm feeling slightly hungry after reading this thread, so I might have an apple, but TBH I'll probably forget once I stop reading about food. Last year I would've raced into the kitchen long ago for some toast and jam.

The only downside is all these fresh vegetables take longer to prepare, but its well worth it for the benefits.

RogueFemale · 10/10/2023 23:43

I've just dropped from size 16 to 12 in a year. I did it not by calorie counting or any special foods, I just cut out all the crap I used to eat such as cakes, biscuits, chocolate. I also eliminated rice, pasta and cheese and most processed foods such as crisps and ready meals. I still ate as much as I wanted of the other stuff - fresh fruit and veg (including potatoes), plain (no added sugar) yogurt, fish, smaller amount of meat and bit of seriously wholegrain bread and butter. I didn't eliminate wine, though. It's also important to do some moderate exercise, at least 20 mins walking (or gardening or hoovering) daily.

Edit: I honestly haven't felt that hungry on this regime. Although I've lost the weight now, I'm still carrying on avoiding the sugary processed foods and also eat much less pasta and rice than I did before.

And got an airfryer, so I make 'chips' out of celeriac which feel as fun as potato ones but are much healthier.

Jakadaal · 10/10/2023 23:34

Another vote for intermittent fasting. Try and eat within an 8 hour window. More protein and try and switch to a protein risk breakfast.

I am on the verge of being diagnosed diabetic type II and that is what has motivated me. Have a look at Michael Mosley Or the Glucose Goddess x

NotSuchASmugMarried · 10/10/2023 23:34

BibbleandSqwauk · 10/10/2023 23:18

@NotSuchASmugMarried someone was in the news two days ago having died doing exactly what you propose. She was one of I think 30 people that have died abroad as a result of botched bariatric surgery. There are better ways.

More people have died from the side effects of being overweight.

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 10/10/2023 23:31

Read delay dont deny and fast feast repeat. Honestly changed my life. You are undoubtedly insulin resistent and constantly spiking your blood sugar with a carby diet of ultra processed refined carbs. Start intermittant fasting but read those books first as it really explains whats going on in your body and how to fix it. I started pushing breakfast back gradually and now generally only eat within a 5-8 hour window depending on my schedule and I promise I dont get hungry now. I used to be constantly snacking and reaching for sugar to keep my energy up. But now I feel better than I did a decade ago.

AltitudeCheck · 10/10/2023 23:30

Intermittent fasting helped me. Feeling real hunger at the end of an 18 hour fast helped me recognise the difference between hunger and a desire to eat / emotional eating. Now I do 18:6 or 16:8 most days.

Having a timer on an app that says well done and gives you badges etc motivates me. Starting my fast just after dinner helps stop me snacking later in the day as I've already switched the timer into fasting mode straight after dinner and I don't like to 'fail'!

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 10/10/2023 23:19

It's awful to say it like this, but you just need to decide. Nothing ever worked well for me until one day I woke up and was ready.

Agree. Happened for me about 3 weeks ago. And unfortunately you have to just be "hungry" for a couple of weeks as you adjust (you're not, really).

All I am doing is eating approx 1400 calories and exercising enough that my fitbit says I'm burning about 2200 to 2500. It's slow but effective.

Don't do keto. Ketosis can be really dangerous for your organs, particularly kidneys, and blood pressure.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/10/2023 23:18

I started slimming world back around May and for the first couple of weeks on that I felt hungry all the time and constantly wanting to find "free" snacks. After a couple of weeks of pushing through that barrier things improved massively and now I follow the plan easily, have a couple of snacks on fruit between meals and rarely feel hungry.
Its really helped me stop eating crap all the time and think more about what I'm eating and when.

I think it's about finding the help out there that works for you.

BibbleandSqwauk · 10/10/2023 23:18

@NotSuchASmugMarried someone was in the news two days ago having died doing exactly what you propose. She was one of I think 30 people that have died abroad as a result of botched bariatric surgery. There are better ways.

Gowlett · 10/10/2023 23:11

So, I do agree with others that it’s the addictive nature of precesssed foods, sugar, bread, salt. I got totally hooked again…

Gowlett · 10/10/2023 23:08

You eat too much. Another poster said it didn’t seem like that much. But it is. I’m the exact same weight & size as you. It doesn’t take that much extra food, in reality. I didn’t think I ate too much, until I ate a lot less. I slimmed down quite a lot. And it wasn’t that hard to maintain, TBH. Then I started snacking again, not keeping an eye on portions. Giving in to sweet things. And I got fat again really quickly.

R37sraY · 10/10/2023 23:02

Eat more. If you eat more healthy stuff you won’t need the unhealthy stuff so much.

Also walk. At least an hour per day. Does your job/ family life allow for that much time to yourself?

Are you getting enough sleep?

PenelopePitstop22 · 10/10/2023 23:01

Oh me too OP. I feel so shit in myself after having my lovely baby and having a C-section. But I’m absolutely ravenous breastfeeding.

Calorie counting has been, in the past, the only thing that works for me.

Exercising too made me realise that, actually, calories take a lot of work to burn off. And I bloody hate cardio. But I had to strike the balance with exercise as too much cardio and swimming especially also makes me so hungry! Walking and Pilates are more my thing.

I also identified my problem area which was the evening and having a sweet tooth after dinner. So I’d keep most of my Cals for a nice dinner - something like a creamy pasta even - and go light for breakfast and lunch with cereal, fruit and soup or something like that. A salad in warmer weather instead of soup for lunch. I’d also brush my teeth shortly after dinner and perhaps a light sweet snack like a little chocolate bar. That’d stop the evening munchies. I’d distract myself with a good book too and that became my new thing to do in the evening rather than grazing.

Good luck!

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 10/10/2023 22:59

Sugar/ UPF makes you hungry, quit sugar and food keeps you feeling full for longer.

Dixiechickonhols · 10/10/2023 22:58

More protein. I also try and do 3 meals and limited snacks. Bulk out with lots of veg.
Eggs or Greek yoghurt and berries breakfast.
Lunch - soup, stew or omelettes with veg.
Dinner protein and veg. Some carbs but sensible portions.
Lots of water.
Eating enough protein was revolutionary for me I kept thinking I’m not hungry.

Nicole1111 · 10/10/2023 22:57

Studying the intuitive eating book and
practising the principles (I did 1 a week) cured me of binge eating disorder

TheOccupier · 10/10/2023 22:54

One of the big revelations for me when I successfully dieted and lost weight was that rather than trying to avoid feeling hunger, I could just accept that I would be hungry sometimes and that this was OK. It was mentally difficult at first but I did manage to shift my mindset.

Treeinthesky · 10/10/2023 22:50

Join slimming world

Bedbouncer · 10/10/2023 22:49

I third pp's recommendations of Fast 800 and the knitting in the evenings. I've lost 9.5 stone and kept it off for about 9 months so far in the maintenance phase of Fast 800, which is basically low-ish carb Mediterranean style diet & no snacking. I spent DECADES seriously overweight. If I can do it, anyone can. I haven't spent a fortune, I just bought 3 books (original Fast 800 and two recipe books) and followed them- oh and joined the Facebook support group.

Pipps80 · 10/10/2023 22:49

ruthonfire · 10/10/2023 22:02

I am overweight. I eat too much of the wrong stuff. I binge on snacks. But I'm hungry always. Everyday I swear I'll try and improve my diet and eat more healthily but then I feel hungry and can't control my behaviours around food. I crave stodge and I just binge on it.

I need to seriously change my habits but how?

Get yourself a "glucose revolution" by jessie inchauspe. It is life changing.

Karmaisagod · 10/10/2023 22:48

I second the previous poster who mentioned Glucose Goddess. It's not a diet, but a way of eating supported by science that consists of making easy changes (things like always starting your day with a savoury breakfast, or exercising for 10 minutes after eating) designed to help you minimise glucose spikes in your body. I think it might help you reduce your constant hunger and carb cravings.

Elzibells · 10/10/2023 22:46

I feel your pain. I'm having my own battle with it.

It's addiction to ultra processed foods. I have the same problem. They are designed to be addictive, more addictive than hard drugs. Poor diet is a leading cause of death. Really recommend watching the BBC iplayer doc about it by Dr Chris Van Tulleken.

Things that are helping me change.... prioritise exercise and sleep if you can as it helps control your hunger hormone levels (leptin/ghrelin), drinking 2.5l water a day and signing up to the Body Coach Plan. The recipes are amazing, I don't feel deprived at all, there is a FB support group and the workouts are great for all levels of ability.

PaminaMozart · 10/10/2023 22:44

You are probably eating to much UPF - sugar and refined carbs. If you can wean yourself off sugar, the rest will follow and the weight will drop off.

Fill up on lots of vegetables and moderate amounts of lean protein. Plus some healthy fats, especially EVOO, nuts and avocados, and small amounts of complex carbs and dairy.

Many find intermittent fasting a manageable way of dieting: brunch, healthy snack, dinner.

I like Dr Becky Gillaspy's short talks on YouTube - very succinct and I formative, with lots of practical advice on eating a healthy low carb diet.

FannyBawz · 10/10/2023 22:42

K E T O