Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of being fat and hungry

168 replies

ruthonfire · 10/10/2023 22:02

I am overweight. I eat too much of the wrong stuff. I binge on snacks. But I'm hungry always. Everyday I swear I'll try and improve my diet and eat more healthily but then I feel hungry and can't control my behaviours around food. I crave stodge and I just binge on it.

I need to seriously change my habits but how?

OP posts:
Luckydog7 · 11/10/2023 07:29

I'm very similar op. Hungry all the time compared to other people, big appetite, happily have 2 helpings then pudding. Big sweet tooth. The answer for me is fasting.

Fasting was a revelation. Just removing the choice of what to eat was such a relief, I used to do it 2 full days a week for 24 hours. Surprised by how easy I found it and wasn't hungry constantly either.

You would need to look at what technique is best for you lifestyle but I've done 2 full days a week of water fasting, 16:8, skipping breakfast. One meal per day. All effective. It pair particularily well with keto/reduced carb diets as they ace as a sugar fast all on their own.

You find the first week tough but then it gets easier abd easier.

Worriedmum159 · 11/10/2023 07:24

I have a counselling appointment next week to try to get a handle on my eating. Seriously considering a gastric sleeve when I can afford it.

timetochangethering · 11/10/2023 07:24

The answer is Ozempic (or Wegovy which is about to be approved)...

bonzaitree · 11/10/2023 07:21

OP, you sound very hard on yourself. You’re size 14, not Rik Waller.

Saxenda and WeGovy are intended to reduce hunger. I can say personally that this is working for me! I think you’d have to pay as you’re not big enough to get the drugs on the NHS. Can you afford this?

Motomum23 · 11/10/2023 07:19

I haven't read all the messages but I highly recommend fasting. I couldn't go more than an hour without eating, my sugers would drop if I didn't and I would start shaking and pass out.... the less you raise yoru sugar levels in the morning the less insulin you produce... the less you need sugar to combat the insulin.
I now have just black coffee until lunch time and if I eat breakfast I spiral back to needing a snack by 10am.
It works - it takes discipline to start it but it works well and you loose the hungry feeling all the time. On Saturday I was so busy with my broken motorbike it got to 4pm and I thought oops not actually eaten anything yet today!

Lovelyweatheragain · 11/10/2023 07:13

Read ultra processed people and once you’re about 3/4 way through it cut out the UPFs and processed sugar. Just don’t have it in the house. No sugary yogurts, only plain etc. No UPF bread products. You’ll get there

Ansjovis · 11/10/2023 07:10

You have a disordered relationship with food and that generally needs professional help to change. Otherwise all you are going to do is get in a cycle of restrict food -> fail to stick to it -> punish self -> feel worse about self. Lather, rinse, repeat. The last part gets worse with every round, giving you a bigger hill to climb when you start again.

I would consult a dietician and a therapist specialising in weight loss. Also, we know that weight loss is in the kitchen and not in the gym but what exercise are you doing at the moment? I find that it is much easier to make those good food choices when I am full of endorphins post exercise.

Candleabra · 11/10/2023 07:06

Do you have a slow cooker? You can make nice stews and soups with lots of veg and lean meat that are very comforting (especially in the winter) but also healthy. They’re great too, as you can switch them on the morning before going to work and you have a lovely meal waiting so you don’t start snacking when you get in and you’re hungry.

soupweather · 11/10/2023 07:02

I was the same as you OP but I had my moment between Christmas and New Year a few years ago. At that time, I went low carb. The weight fell off. I lost 4 stone in an under year and felt amazing.

The pandemic, like a lot of people increased my weight again. I put 2 stone back on. I couldn’t get into low carb again. I joined Slimming World but I honestly don’t recommend that to anyone now. I stuck with it though and lost a stone and a half. I then switched to another platform called Team RH. Quite content with that. It’s taken a while but I am happy with my calories, what I eat and what I weigh. I fluctuate between 10 stone and 10 stone 5. I’m 5’7.

It’s been quite a journey for me. I do need some sort of group to keep me focussed and food and my weight is thought about every day. I did need that proper light bulb moment to get properly started though. All the best to you. Good luck!

YellowRoses100 · 11/10/2023 07:00

This is head hunger. I've recently started the Cambridge diet. It's really helped me understand that I was not hungry
I drink loads of water now too. Good luck.

stayathomer · 11/10/2023 06:42

Op are you crafty? My mil and sil have started doing online art classes two nights a week- would stop from the having nothing to do- or knitting, crochet- suggesting something to do with your hands as that’s when I start grabbing for stuff. Could you join something start swimming or dancing or something else that’s fun?

I started making myself not eat after 8 at night as I would literally eat the kitchen while watching tv. It’s insanely difficult for about two weeks (think trying not to go to bed early, pacing, the lot!) Then I fell into it but ate frozen grapes or frozen yoghurts (just stick a yoghurt and a sandwich bag with some grapes in it in the freezer!) as they took soo long to eat!!!!

dh lost four stone last year through serious healthy eating etc but I lost enough to make me feel better about myself from

  1. halfing everything unhealthy I ate (he substituted or cut fully)
  2. allowed myself only three slices of white bread a day, instead ate crackers, rice cakes or apples (I know I sound strange!)
  3. making myself drink water (I didn’t before it so was just dehydrated)
  4. instead of crisps I’d go for the ones I saw had less calories or popcorn
  5. halfed my fizzy drinks (they are my vice- incidentally I cut them out for a month once along with cutting white bread and it was the trimmest I ever was but I can’t live without
  6. a day where you ease up on yourself is very important
Best of luck op and remember it’s really all about making you feel happy with yourself, any small change is huge and a bad day doesn’t have to be a bad week(or even a bad day as you can make up for it later!!) x
bakewellbride · 11/10/2023 06:09

Look up Morgan green on YouTube. She focuses on a healthy lifestyle for life rather than 'losing weight' or 'going on a diet' which is a game changer imo. Whatever you do has to be sustainable otherwise what's the point.

merrymelodies · 11/10/2023 02:08

Cut out refined carbs and fats for a week as an experiment. You'll feel like hell for 2-3 days but then you'll feel fantastic. Full of energy and pride in your achievement, which will fuel you on to continue to eat more healthily.
It's a reset and it's always worked well for me.

Aria999 · 11/10/2023 01:25

Try the book 'why we eat too much' by Andrew jenkinson

It's about reducing sugar and increasing fat and protein

Some of the science is a little speculative but the basic idea is sound, that your body is dictating your balance of calories in to calories out and you can't really fight it, you have to convince it to stop stockpiling.

It's working well for a bunch of us on this thread (though it doesn't seem to work for everyone)

Why We Eat (Too Much) thread 6 http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/weightlosss_chat/4590255-why-we-eat-too-much-thread-6

PaminaMozart · 11/10/2023 00:53

Can you try exercise when the cravings threaten to overwhelm you? Just a few push-ups and 50 jumping jacks... or whatever seems feasible to you.

PaminaMozart · 11/10/2023 00:52

Working out one's TDEE and subtracting around 500 calories, with a view to losing around a pound a week is a good idea.

What I did was to work out a series of daily mealplans within that total, so I wouldn't have to count calories all the time.

GFgd · 11/10/2023 00:51

Im fully addicted to carbs/sugar too. The volume of sugar i must have consumed the last few weeks is frightening. It’s just out of sheer boredom when wfh, im breaking my day up with it. It needs to stop and I know I can stop it if I want but each day I make a new target for when I’m starting instead of just doing it!

BellaAndDave · 11/10/2023 00:46

Calorie counting works for me although it’s not everyone’s cup of tea. Count everything you put in in your mouth and work out your TDEE.

HereIAmThereYouAre · 11/10/2023 00:43

This is what worked for me: get the Nutracheck App (you can do a weeks' free trial) its great, very easy to use and it has a helpful and supportive forum/community. Start by just calorie counting your food and drink intake for a few days - it's an eye opener seeing where your calories are going. Aim to GRADUALLY reduce your calories to within the target cals to enable weight loss, whilst eating plenty of healthy filling protein, less carbs and a good balance of foods - veg is your friend, and served in the right ways can be delicious. Do not cut out any food groups! Just use the app to educate yourself as to how much you can really have of any food/treat without gaining weight. Try and see it as an adventure to discover new foods/recipes. Try to move a bit more, but concentrate on your overall diet as the priority.

PaminaMozart · 11/10/2023 00:38

Have you tried intermittent fasting, @toadasoda ? If you eat during an 8-hour window, you won't get the insulin spikes that make you crave food.

The Glucose Goddess, Dr Becky Gillaspy, Dr Mark Hyman explain this really well. Look them up 9n YouTube. For me personally Harman's The Sugar Solution was a turning point. It's quite long and detailed but makes total sense.

It's important to eat lots of vegetables and a fair bit of lean protein, as well as small amounts of healthy fats, complex carbs and dairy.

PriOn1 · 11/10/2023 00:12

I’m currently considering whether to go to Overeaters Anonymous. I’m not sure it’s for me, but I do think certain foods can be addictive and that I am addicted to some of them..

toadasoda · 11/10/2023 00:07

Great ideas for what else to eat but how do you not eat the things you crave. I mean in that moment when your body and mind desperately want a biscuit and a part of your brain says no you shouldn't but the other part of you wins because your urge for the biscuit trumps your logic thoughts. And this isn't once a day, or at certain times. This mental dance goes on and on for most waking hours maybe at 20 min intervals. That's a lot of 'just say no' moments. Even if you are strong enough to say no the first 20 times and give in on 21st then you are no better than just giving in on the first urge. It's absolutely mentally exhausting. I think a lot of people don't get the extent of it. Pls if anyone has mental techniques to help will power do share.

beachdays27 · 11/10/2023 00:06

Since cutting out ultra processed food I'm amazed how much less hungry I am and how quickly weight has dropped off. There are some v interesting studies about ultra processed foods being designed to make people overeat in order to make more money.

Pokinganose · 11/10/2023 00:04

Cut out the crisps and biscuits replace with hummus and carrot or celery sticks. Stop the takeaway and have roast once a month. Everytime you feel hungry have a drink first squash or tea or coffee. By the time you've had it you'll know whether it was hunger or thirst.
Look up healthy snacks and don't buy the biscuits or crisps etc. Just don't let them be in your house. Eat Lillie and often and plan what you eat so you don't have tomrely on quick fattening things to eat.

QS90 · 11/10/2023 00:03

Keto. Weight drops off crazy fast, which is a real boost to keep going. And you almost never get hungry, which is great. When I did it, I went from being hungry often, as you describe, to literally forgetting to eat. People will say it's not a healthy diet, but like anything it depends how you do it really. You can have loads of organic chicken salad, with toasted almonds and a small portion of berries afterwards if you're fussed. Or just eat pork crackling for every meal lol. And being overweight isn't healthy either. Personally I don't have the patience for Slimming World type stuff, and hate being hungry all the time!! Hungry all day thinking about food... but not being allowed food...