Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A thread for lower earners to discuss!

196 replies

AlexBalex · 10/10/2023 19:16

AIBU to make a thread for lower earners?

I feel like every thread I read on MN is full of middle to high earners or just posters where it's commonplace for a household to be earning really high amounts like £80k, £100k, £150k.

Now I fully understand the national average is approx. £30k. But does nobody on here and their partner take home minimum wage each resulting in a household income of about £45k?!

In real life I'm surrounded by plenty of 'low earners' but the representation on here seems to be massively skewed the other way.

Where are all the retail staff, hospitality staff, nurses, school teachers etc? Apologies, I don't know the salaries of these roles but they're understood to be below the national average right?

Just wondering if anyone with a not insanely high, lower than average household income (i.e. less than £60k) exists out there?!

Thoughts welcome, was just looking for a discussion really as fed up of reading about 'high earners' all the time Smile.

OP posts:
ChamaChamaChamaChameleon · 14/10/2023 13:45

midlifemelancholy · 14/10/2023 13:36

What benefits? I get £200 child benefit a months for 4dc

I put in a single mother earning 32K with 2 DC into a benefits calculator and came out with the below.

Whether it's 'enough' is one thing but it's certainly a large enough top-up that you're better off than someone earning more but with less benefit entitlement.

Total benefits entitlement
£404.96 / weekly
Our estimate is based on the information you have entered and does not guarantee entitlement. It uses 2023/24 benefit and tax rates.
This amount is made up of the following benefits:
Universal Credit£354.15 / weekly
We estimate your monthly Universal Credit award will be £1,534.66.
Council Tax Support£10.91 / weekly
Your full Council Tax bill of £26.60 per week will be reduced to £15.70 per week because of your entitlement to Council Tax Support.
This estimate is based on your local authority's Council Tax Support scheme but there are some rules for how earnings are treated that we are unable to include at this time.?
Child Benefit£39.90 / weekly

midlifemelancholy · 14/10/2023 13:36

What benefits? I get £200 child benefit a months for 4dc

ChamaChamaChamaChameleon · 14/10/2023 12:52

midlifemelancholy · 14/10/2023 12:04

"The average full time UK salary is £32K."
^But isn't it that this the average, and those who are earning more are earning much much much more

I am depressed by it all tbh
^

With children you can get up to a grand a month in benefits on 32K though - you take home more than someone who earns 40K because they get taxed more.

midlifemelancholy · 14/10/2023 12:04

"The average full time UK salary is £32K."
^But isn't it that this the average, and those who are earning more are earning much much much more

I am depressed by it all tbh
^

HeadCreature · 14/10/2023 10:55

Movinghouseatlast · 10/10/2023 19:34

I never understand why people don't believe others earn a lot.

Most people I know have a household income of at least £100k. My friend is a Social Worker and earns £70k for example, her husbands salary is £45k. Head teachers earn more than £100k My friends daughter is on a graduate scheme and her starting salary was £50k at age 21.

I always feel like the poor relation. Our household income is £70k. But I don't think.other people are lying about what they earn.

I can promise you HTs don't all earn that kind of money.

Startingagainandagain · 14/10/2023 10:52

''@Maverickess · Yesterday 07:45

I dont think salary is remotely reflective of hardwork, effort, energy and lifestyle.

This.

One of the most galling things about being in low paid jobs is the attitude some have towards them, that you can't be bothered to do better, telling you how you don't contribute, how you're uninspired, how you don't or didn't work hard enough.

Yet society wants demands and in some cases relies upon many of these types of jobs, and also insist prices for them are kept as low as possible - which is a large factor in what people get paid for them - what people are willing to pay for them in the first place.
No one seems to have a problem using the services provided by low paid workers, only with the people providing the service in the first place because the wage they command is low.

Ignoring the fact there aren't enough 'better' jobs for everyone, without those low paid jobs there'd be no social care, no shops, no pubs, no restaurants, no hotels or holiday parks, very few leisure facilities.''

This!

The last thing we need as a society is more lawyers, accountants or edge funds managers...yet those are the people commending high salaries.

Society can't function with people working in schools, social care, hospitality, healthcare, transport and so on. But these essential jobs are undervalued and underpaid.

Maverickess · 13/10/2023 07:45

I dont think salary is remotely reflective of hardwork, effort, energy and lifestyle.

This.

One of the most galling things about being in low paid jobs is the attitude some have towards them, that you can't be bothered to do better, telling you how you don't contribute, how you're uninspired, how you don't or didn't work hard enough.

Yet society wants demands and in some cases relies upon many of these types of jobs, and also insist prices for them are kept as low as possible - which is a large factor in what people get paid for them - what people are willing to pay for them in the first place.
No one seems to have a problem using the services provided by low paid workers, only with the people providing the service in the first place because the wage they command is low.

Ignoring the fact there aren't enough 'better' jobs for everyone, without those low paid jobs there'd be no social care, no shops, no pubs, no restaurants, no hotels or holiday parks, very few leisure facilities.

Mopbucketmoo · 13/10/2023 00:29

I clean part time and my husband earns about £30,000. Get a bit of UC monthly top up

Our rent is sky high (1250pm) but the cheapest we could find in our area, we live in a town where the rent is ridiculous.
We pay the bills and buy food and have sweet f.a all left over but we have a roof over our heads and a meal every night, it is tough but we get by.

Ahjaysus23 · 12/10/2023 23:02

But people on MN say 'oh, I get by on 12 grand a year' but what they actually mean is after benefits have paid their rent etc... it's 12000. So that's at least another 12 grand in the mix. People who say they earn 40 - they mean covering everything including housing. In that way, sometimes the difference between households isn't always as different as some people like to make out.

PestilencialCrisis · 12/10/2023 22:50

So, slight tangent, but there is a thread where loads of people are saying how much they paid for cakes (posts ranging between £65-£200!)

One step closer to understanding how all these people bringing home £4k a month have no money left at the end of the month 😂

Pinkglobelamp · 11/10/2023 23:11

Member589500 · 11/10/2023 12:57

Great thread. I always see those comments about not being able to survive in London on less than £100k and wonder how we Civil Servants survive. Most people are at EO grade so about £30k.
I feel pretty comfortable on my average salary but only because I have been trading upwards in property since the early 90s so mortgage is tiny.

Lots of Londoners live in social housing or council housing, so have relatively low housing costs (£800-1500 a month rather than thousands).

SomewhereInTheMIdlands · 11/10/2023 21:53

Leveling up where we live is all about our Tory MP in conjunction with our Tory County Council spaffing it on a dozen useless projects. eg £2 million on a pointless IT project for local museum that gets about 10 visitors per month. 5 new buildings with no specific purpose have gone to one crony contractor. Meantime the local swimming pool has been bulldozed down to save a relatively small amount of money on repairs. I could go on. Apart from the perennial housing problem, transport is a massive cost where we live. Obscene train fares on a decrepit line where passenger trains wait for goods trains as a priority. £20 return to the nearest big town 20 miles away if you meed to work as everything nearby has shut down in the last few years. There is zero Leveling up in the UK.

Optimistic66 · 11/10/2023 13:49

Member589500 · 11/10/2023 12:57

Great thread. I always see those comments about not being able to survive in London on less than £100k and wonder how we Civil Servants survive. Most people are at EO grade so about £30k.
I feel pretty comfortable on my average salary but only because I have been trading upwards in property since the early 90s so mortgage is tiny.

I definitely think many factors come into play:

Job Industry - Working rewarding jobs may not necessarily pay well, whereas working jobs such as business/banking pay much more. Do i think it right? no. But that unfortunately the sad truth.

Location - if you are in SE/London- alot of salaries are upwaited to account for london living. Many grad roles start at 32k - 40k. (Google most companies grad schemes)

Age - often you earn more as you get older through experience

Family/Responsibilities - having children can make it difficult to progress career wise espc if you have in your 20s for example, but also if you have kids - you may not want to work full time etc or may not be able to justify certain jobs to only end up putting your children in childcare. Alot of the females I see earning 80k+ have chosen to have careers, many dont have children or have children at 40+ where they already earn more than average person.

Education: If you start working at 18 (not necessarily as true now with apprenticeships) - you often rely on experience and working very hard to get where you want to and often enter into lower paid industries. Whereas if you had further education - many start on higher paid jobs.

I dont think salary is remotely reflective of hardwork, effort, energy and lifestyle.

I think the quality of life (Health/Happiness) is WAY more important.

I'd rather earn minimum wage and be happy - than earn 100k and be miserable.

Member589500 · 11/10/2023 12:57

Great thread. I always see those comments about not being able to survive in London on less than £100k and wonder how we Civil Servants survive. Most people are at EO grade so about £30k.
I feel pretty comfortable on my average salary but only because I have been trading upwards in property since the early 90s so mortgage is tiny.

MotherOfRatios · 11/10/2023 12:37

SarahAndQuack · 10/10/2023 21:28

But this is not a thread about people like you. So please - go away. We're all familiar with having high rents. We don't all earn what you do.

There's plenty of people who earn the same amount of me who have commented, and you've not called them out interesting...,..

PestilencialCrisis · 11/10/2023 11:57

Yes! Glad you started the thread. I'm on £20k, part time to work around school hours. Single parent, 2 kids, mortgage, car. Kids are fed and have hobbies and toys and clothes. Car has petrol, insurance, tax. Bills are expensive and I'm definitely feeling the squeeze, but don't understand how people are "poor relations" "struggling to get by" or "not sure where their money goes" when their household income is 2x, 3x, 4x...10x more than mine is!

AlexBalex · 11/10/2023 11:29

Glitterybee · 10/10/2023 22:42

I’m a single parent.

My income was £26K in 2020 and I now earn £48K.

I will never stop being grateful 🙏

It scares me to think how mortgages & rents have doubled since 2020 - even ‘up north’ and in cheaper areas. How do low income earners afford this?

Where I live a nice 3 bed house in a new build with a garden was £500/£600 per month in 2019 - you’re now talking £1100 at least!

Do benefits make up the difference?

Edited

Congrats! Please may I ask how you almost doubled your salary in 3 years? What sectors where the roles?

OP posts:
Startingagainandagain · 11/10/2023 09:57

Interesting thread.

I always though that Mumsnet seemed to be a parallel universe where the majority of people live in detached houses, have husbands who make 100K a year and themselves have 'careers' and are 'professionals' on more than 50K...

So either people are lying through the teeth or this just shows that Mumsnet has an audience that is not representative of the general population.

If you look at salaries for the vacancies currently advertised for the civil service, the charitable sector, local authorities, retail, hospitality, schools and NHS admin, care work, people who work as airport security or ground staff, art and museum jobs...most of the vacancies available have salaries that go from 25- 35K.

The average full time UK salary is £32K.

CerealUnderachiever · 11/10/2023 08:17

spirit20 · 10/10/2023 23:19

"I have friends and relatives who are teachers. Whilst I appreciate that they work hard for their pay, during all half term holidays they work full time in alternate jobs and get paid from their usual full time job also.'

Where exactly are they getting these full time jobs that is willing to hire them for a period of a week during a half-term?

And even if this were true, the fact that they feel the need to spend their holidays working in another job shows they clearly aren't well paid. Rich people don't tend to work during holidays.

But, with a starting salary at the national average, and only up from there, teaching IS a well paid job. No, it doesn't reach the heights of some private sector and that definitely doesn't mean for certain households, life isn't difficult (as we've seen here, plenty of families only have one FT earner so it pushes what that salary can cover). But it is a decently paid, good stable job with unbelievable pension and huge job security.

I definitely don't know people who do 'full time half term jobs' but t's extremely well known a good chunk of teachers take on GCSE/A level marking in the summer holidays, and others run tutoring etc etc. It's a nice little bonus earner. They do it because it's easy, flexible, they have time and most people welcome the opportunity to boost their income if it comes along.

DilemmaDelilah · 11/10/2023 08:08

Before my husband retired our take home pay was about £45k between us, and we felt relatively comfortable financially, but we have no dependent children. Comfortable, for us, means being able to pay the bills, not panic if we need to replace the washing machine, and we can save for inexpensive holidays etc.

We have been really poor in the past, so we feel really lucky to be in our current financial position. It would be nice to have a new car instead of a second hand one, and to be able to go on more, more expensive holidays, but we are very happy with what we have. If we had children at home it would be more difficult though.

whatkatydid2013 · 11/10/2023 07:30

Age is a factor in skewing towards higher wages being discussed here. Lots of parents will be in their 30s/40s and two full time incomes in that bracket are going to be comfortably over the £60k you mention in the OP. Also someone mentioned 15% earning over £50k but it will be more than 15% of those in late 30s/early 40s & that age bracket will be well represented on a parenting site.
Being single vs in a couple makes a huge difference not only due to gross earnings but also down to tax.
You possibly see a lot of posts talking about £100k salaries because of the instant loss of tax free childcare and the phased loss of your personal allowance over that salary. It’s quite contentious because say you had 3 children in full time childcare if you went from £95-105k then of that £10k you’d pay &4k in tax, £200 in NI & then you’d lose £6k of help toward your childcare and pay 40% on an additional £2.5k as you’d lose some personal allowance. Net your £10k payrise could cost you money on your net pay. This is (I think understandably) something high earners feel very unhappy with & you see it posted about a lot.
You’ll similarly see loads of posts about earning over £60k with one income earner and unfairness of no child benefit when 2 earners on 50k each can claim.
For me it’s those plus questions about pensions & private schools where you see lots of comments about earnings. I’m guilty myself of often thinking we are not well off because so many of our peers/family members are super high earners. It’s easy to have a skewed view of normal earnings because of comparison with neighbours/colleagues etc who will typically be in a similar income bracket.

A thread for lower earners to discuss!
Tbry · 11/10/2023 00:20

This is a very interesting thread to read thank you very much OP.

Joint income here under £50k in the SE. We are not entitled to any benefits or help and never have been.

Very high mortgage (fixed rate low interest rate for now) but much cheaper than when we used to rent. This is for a small home where we WFH and Mortgaged until we are over 70. Had to go without for 5 years to save for a deposit so no clothes, literally no anything apart from basic food.

House prices are eye watering in this part of the country and our wages do not match even though My DP works in a professional role and we are degree educated.

We are fortunate to have a home of our own but each month is a struggle. We have enough for bills, mortgage, food so in that way we are lucky. We bought a doer upper which we do the DIY for and in between projects we have to just live in it as it is. We drive an old car. We try not to go out as we can’t afford it and we don’t socialise, just a trip to the seaside once a month free parking with a picnic. We usually cannot afford any sort of holiday. We have had one caravan break in the last 2 years cost £100 and to cover that I went without for 5 months.

Now also faced with potential redundancy. Apart from the redundancy woes and ongoing health problems I am not complaining about my life as in the past I have faced a lot of adversity. I have been homeless and a single parent on a council estate, no support network and a victim of DV. I studied and worked really hard to get myself a different future.

When I look around the family housing estate where we live and contemplate we are the ‘poor’ ones. Most of our neighbours have 2-3 kids, all have continuous upgrades to their houses on repeat, change cars every couple of years and have 2-3 vehicles minimum. Many have luxury hobby related items plus 2-3holidays per year. All have very materialistic lifestyles and I have no idea how they can afford it.

I feel grateful and humble for my life, home and garden.

EmpressSoleil · 10/10/2023 23:25

I'm on 40k so if I had a partner also on 40k I'd be golden, but I don't. My plusses are that I live in an HA home so rent is affordable (although I am in London so it's on the higher end of SH rents) and my DC are adults and financially self sufficient. I do have enough to cover my expenses. But I have to choose between holidays and having a social life. As I'm an introvert I forgo the social life and have a really good holiday every 12-18 months. I also do spend a bit on my various craft hobbies, the odd takeaway etc.

If I compare myself to the MN high earners then my life is shit! 😂 but honestly I've been a lot poorer in the past so I am thankful for what I have and know that people are struggling on a lot less. Do I have as much as I'd like? No. Do I have "enough"? Yes.

Tunisbaby · 10/10/2023 23:20

I'm on less than minimum wage for full time hours as a student in the NHS. In some ways, I feel like if I can make it with so little then the only way is up. At least I know there is progress and in a years time all will be completely different (if I pass!)
There are some anxious moments. At present I am getting a train to a destination four hours away tomorrow for training for two nights and I have zero funds in my bank. No money for a coffee, breakfast or if I lose my bus ticket. I'm taking a tin of beans which I can eat cold if costa or similar won't me use their microwave. But I have survived before and I will survive this.
I'm so used to getting my card declined it doesn't even embarrass me anymore.