Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Letting" my baby only sleep on me

26 replies

EarthRabbit · 10/10/2023 16:23

FTM to a 6 week old baby here. To preface, I feel bad even "complaining" about this aspect because we are so lucky in everything else. She is so placid and happy. She already sleeps for 3 or 4 hours at a time, in the night and the day... but she will only sleep on me. We have a next to me crib, she will lay there happily for ages but she won't go to sleep in it. I've tried waiting it out, but after a while she gets overtired and starts screaming. She won't stay asleep in her swing, her bouncer, her Moses basket downstairs, or even in our bed. She can fall asleep anywhere, but wakes up 3 mins later and won't settle until she's plastered on me. And it does seem to have to be me. Normally I would be jokingly smug, but I am finding the resulting lack of sleep quite hard, and it does also seem to actually hurt DP's feelings that she won't stay asleep on him.

I actually don't mind that she wants to be cuddled to sleep. I love holding her and cuddling her, and if I was that tiny I'd want the reassurance and security of being held too. But it becomes difficult because obviously I need to at least try to sleep as well. I worry to death about accidentally falling asleep while holding her. Sometimes I can successfully "transfer" her into her crib after she falls asleep on me, but mostly she will wake again after a few minutes and cry until I pick her up. Dummies seem to frustrate her as she will spits them out quite angrily. Rocking the crib soothes her if she's crying, but as soon as I stop she will start again. And she won't nod off. I've tried putting my hand on her chest to soothe her, but it just agitates her. She just seems to need to be held while she sleeps.

DP says I am making the problem worse by "allowing" her to only fall asleep on me, that it's a rod for my own back and I'm reinforcing the behaviour. I responded that she's only 6 weeks old, she wants to be comforted, and I don't feel comfortable leaving her to cry regardless. She isn't doing it on purpose and she needs me.

I don't know if he's right or I am, but I don't know what he wants me to do. He does admit that he feels rejected by her not staying asleep on him, so I think that may be confounding the issue as well. I honestly don't think it's a rejection - she's a tiny baby and he is out of the house from 5pm to 7am 5 days a week. He then gets in and sleeps til half 2ish so he only really gets 2 hours with her max before he has to leave again. I therefore have her by myself all night and almost all day. My mum comes round for 2-3 hours on Monday and Wednesday afternoons so I can try to catch up on sleep, but other than that I am the only one taking care of her. Of course she is going to want me, and not be the same with anyone else yet. I'm hoping it comes with time.

I don't want to make things worse down the line, and I do desperately crave some sleep or time for myself, but I also just can't stomach the idea of leaving her to cry at this age. Or any age to be honest. I don't know what the answer is and it is starting to frustrate me a little that DP keeps lecturing me about it. But not sure if he's right and I'm being sensitive due to the stress.

Am I being unreasonable to keep "letting" her sleep only on me at this age? Any advice appreciated... I feel like I'm getting everything wrong already.

OP posts:
nanodyne · 10/10/2023 16:48

Both of my sons were like this, I don't think there's any "letting", you do what you need to to get some rest right? At 6 weeks old she just wants to be close to you and cuddled, which is totally ok! I get that dad is feeling a bit rejected but you grew her and are the one person she "knows" instinctively (if you're breastfeeding you're also her food!). She'll get used to him eventually!

We found that accepting co-sleeping really helped us. It meant baby was used to sleeping next to me (in my arms) which made it easier for him to switch to dad. They both eventually took to the next to me - brushed cotton sheets really helped to make it a bit snugglier. They're now in their own rooms around 6-9 months. One is an excellent sleeper (3yo), the other (1yo) wakes a lot but is learning to get himself back to sleep and he'll get there I'm sure.

I personally don't believe in sleep training, and think that the profusion of sleep coaches online is really predatory, exploiting a primal need at a time when you're really vulnerable. My anecdotal experience is that they'll sleep on their own when they're ready to do so and they all vary on when that is.