Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a "gift" back?

109 replies

OrangeEggsAndHam · 10/10/2023 13:42

I'm currently decluttering. I have an iPad Pro 2021 that has just been sitting there gathering dust. It was used as my primary note-taking device for a 3-4 month stint while I was doing some courses, but now that that's over, I've been trying to sell it on.

An old acquaintances of mine saw my post on Facebook and sent a sob story about how her DS could really use it for school, how they are really struggling with the CoL crisis etc. She asked if I could loan them the iPad for 2-3 years till things get better for them. In 2-3 years it'd depreciate even more and selling it then would take more effort than what it was worth so I said I'd give it to her.

That was 2 weeks ago. Fast forward to yesterday I messaged her asking how DS was getting along with his iPad and she told me that she was planning to sell it on, get a cheaper iPad, and then use the extra money to get the kids some presents for Christmas! If I'd known her DS wasn't going to use the iPad I'd have just sold it on instead of giving it to her!! My plan was never to subsidise her Christmas...

I've since asked for the iPad back which she is very reluctant about. She's been saying something about how they've already factory reset the device, have arranged for a buyer to collect it next week, have looked into getting a base model device etc. Asked her to pay my original asking price (which is £50 more than what she's posted it for) and she said she can't afford that.

WIBU to ask her to give it back or pay the asking price minus £50? I know it was a gift but the only reason I offered to give it to her is because she said her DS REALLY needed it and was going to use it!

OP posts:
olderbutwiser · 10/10/2023 14:39

What a moral dilemma. I think she is an outrageous cheeky f£; suspect you have to chalk it up to experience (I also suspect she’s sold it on already) but yet another case of No Good Deed Goes Unpunished.

Allwelcone · 10/10/2023 14:33

She sounds horrible.

NotObligedToArgueWithStrangers · 10/10/2023 14:32

Yes, technically you gave it and so she can technically do what she likes with it. Still a cheeky shitty trick to play on a friend though. Call her out, tell her she knows damn well it was meant for her child to use and not to be sold on by her. She can either return it immediately or your friendship is over. She probably won't, so you'll have lost out but at least you'll be rid of this cheeky bitch.

MichelleScarn · 10/10/2023 14:26

Wheredideveryonego · 10/10/2023 14:12

I disagree that as it was given to her she can sell it. You only gifted it to her because she asked for it with false presences. As far as I'm concerned she scammed you, you wouldn't write others scams off saying "oh well, you handed the money over now so it's theirs"

This, friendship would be over for me anyway so I'd rather get it back.
Are you still registered apple owner?

PrincessHoneysuckle · 10/10/2023 14:22

There's an unwritten rule that if someone gives you something for free then you don't sell it on you just don't its cheeky af.

londonguild · 10/10/2023 14:22

This happened to me at university. I have my friend a dress and then saw her two weeks later selling it at a car boot sale 🙈

YoureALizardHarry11 · 10/10/2023 14:20

What a cheeky cow!!! This has pissed me off and it’s not even me 🤣😱

Janieforever · 10/10/2023 14:13

I’m shocked at this and don’t give a shit about the technicalities, you’ve basically been scammed. She lied to you to con it out of you and promptly then is selling it on.

id demand it back. Total scam. And I’d break all contact with this person. Appalling behaviour.

Wheredideveryonego · 10/10/2023 14:12

I disagree that as it was given to her she can sell it. You only gifted it to her because she asked for it with false presences. As far as I'm concerned she scammed you, you wouldn't write others scams off saying "oh well, you handed the money over now so it's theirs"

RandomMess · 10/10/2023 14:09

Tell her you'll swap it for the more basic model he needs and get one from CEX or not at all.

I'd be livid because she asked full intention of making money out of it.

Basilton · 10/10/2023 14:06

OrangeEggsAndHam · 10/10/2023 14:04

Technically I know it's hers as I've given it to her. Still doesn't help that I feel like I've been cheated. It's not too different from when someone asks you to give them money under false pretences when their goal has always been to profit off you. Guess I've been naive and gullible then.

Oh yes you have definitely been cheated. And she is not your friend. But you need to write this off and just take the lesson.

NoWinterYear · 10/10/2023 14:06

I don't know. I think you gave it to her as a gift if I understood correctly. After seeing the iPad she has realised that her son can do with a cheaper one and she can use the extra money for Christmas gifts. She didn't lie or get the ipad under a false pretext. Her son needs an iPad and by selling your iPad she can now afford to buy him an iPad plus some Christmas gifts. Also she told you that she is doing this so she probably doesn't think it's dishonest or that you'd mind.

Sorry,.I'm just rehashing what you said but I don't think it's so Terrible. The worst is probably asking you to give her an ipad that you wanted to sell but once you've given it to her I don't think the rest is so bad. Her son still gets an iPad but also.some Christmas presents. (I mean if that story is true of course)

I can understand that it grates though. I remember my dad selling his car to a relative for very cheap as a favour and then that relative sold it after a few weeks for much more than that..my dad was quite annoyed..

OrangeEggsAndHam · 10/10/2023 14:04

Technically I know it's hers as I've given it to her. Still doesn't help that I feel like I've been cheated. It's not too different from when someone asks you to give them money under false pretences when their goal has always been to profit off you. Guess I've been naive and gullible then.

OP posts:
dimsumfatsum · 10/10/2023 13:59

Oh OP, she was never a friend and you've been played. Insist she gives you back the iPad. No ifs/buts. I'd have happily bought it from you as I've been looking for something for the same reasons you'd originally bought your iPad for!

Warum · 10/10/2023 13:58

What a horrible 'friend' she is - you might have to write this one off, learn from it and maybe consider if she really is a friend.

burnoutbabe · 10/10/2023 13:57

Legally you have it to her so now hers

But I'd do everything possible to make them give iit beck until they refused "as it's now theirs"

At present they are not refusing it appears so play on that.

itsmeagainagain · 10/10/2023 13:56

@OrangeEggsAndHam I would just be very direct and tell her you were going to sell it but gifted it to be used per what she said. Just outright ask for it back - don't be embarrassed about it - CF's depend on you feeling too awkward to be bold

Neekoh · 10/10/2023 13:56

You can't ask for it back now, but you've learnt a valuable lesson about what kind of person your friend is.

Distance yourself.

Tinkerbyebye · 10/10/2023 13:56

I would tell her it was given for her son to use not get to sell which you are going to do until her sob story do she either gives it back or gives you the money and you won’t be giving her anything thing else

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/10/2023 13:56

OrangeEggsAndHam · 10/10/2023 13:42

I'm currently decluttering. I have an iPad Pro 2021 that has just been sitting there gathering dust. It was used as my primary note-taking device for a 3-4 month stint while I was doing some courses, but now that that's over, I've been trying to sell it on.

An old acquaintances of mine saw my post on Facebook and sent a sob story about how her DS could really use it for school, how they are really struggling with the CoL crisis etc. She asked if I could loan them the iPad for 2-3 years till things get better for them. In 2-3 years it'd depreciate even more and selling it then would take more effort than what it was worth so I said I'd give it to her.

That was 2 weeks ago. Fast forward to yesterday I messaged her asking how DS was getting along with his iPad and she told me that she was planning to sell it on, get a cheaper iPad, and then use the extra money to get the kids some presents for Christmas! If I'd known her DS wasn't going to use the iPad I'd have just sold it on instead of giving it to her!! My plan was never to subsidise her Christmas...

I've since asked for the iPad back which she is very reluctant about. She's been saying something about how they've already factory reset the device, have arranged for a buyer to collect it next week, have looked into getting a base model device etc. Asked her to pay my original asking price (which is £50 more than what she's posted it for) and she said she can't afford that.

WIBU to ask her to give it back or pay the asking price minus £50? I know it was a gift but the only reason I offered to give it to her is because she said her DS REALLY needed it and was going to use it!

If you've given it to her as a gift then she can sell it on.

If you've lent it to her for 2-3 years as she asked then she has no right to sell it on it's your property and she needs to give it back

Thedm · 10/10/2023 13:56

You gave it to her. Legally, it’s hers. It no longer belongs to you and you can’t tell her what to do.
The sob story doesn’t matter. I mean, at what point would you have been happy with her selling it? A year? Six months? When would you have allowed it without complaint?

You gave it to her for her son, she has decided to sell it and get something cheaper. Which she can do because she owns it now.

She is scheming madam, and very rude. But you can’t stop her.

MrsMiagi · 10/10/2023 13:55

She offered the loan option, it was you who refused and gifted the ipad (if i read this correctly). Its not yours so they can do what they like with it if that means make money then so be it.
It would annoyed me too if I were you but a part of me thinks it's a smart move, albeit very cheeky.

VineRipened · 10/10/2023 13:54

More fool you… but her behaviour has been horrible and she is a CF.

What bare faced grabby cheek..

Basilton · 10/10/2023 13:53

She is cheeky. But you gave it to her and you can’t ask for it back.

MissPettigrewIsWFH · 10/10/2023 13:53

CF - get it back

Swipe left for the next trending thread