Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nieces teenage coffee habit is costing ME money!

313 replies

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 12:41

AIBU... we live with my MIL and whenever my SIL and her husband come to visit, they bring their nightmare of a 13 year old daughter. My SIL and BIL are TIGHT, but stinking RICH. BUT, when they come to ours the daughter always wants to go Starbucks, Costa, fancy coffee shops etc etccc. And the parents sit there while she asks me if we can go.

Sometimes I've said yes (if i want a coffee too) but when I try to make an excuse she doesnt stop. She is never told no. But the thing that IRKS me is when i do agree to take her they never offer to give me money to pay for her coffee habit. Not being funny but in a cost of living crisis, im not happy to pay £5 for her snapchat coffee.

On the flip side, whenever it his her birthday my BIL always puts on a huge birthday, everything paid for (he is generous when it comes to pleasing her and showing off), but AIBU to not want to pay for her coffee habit? I don't mind to take her in the car to Starbucks (obv she doesnt drive) but a little gratitude would be nice! And also the fact that they can defintely afford it, while me and DH are not in the best place financially. We do not have kids yet either.

How do I say no or ask them to give me the money to take THEIR daughter without sounding like a Scrooge or complete B*tch.

OP posts:
crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 15:08

piccola15 · 10/10/2023 14:33

You are not being unreasonable. I have kids of 11 and 8 and I have never heard them ask my siblings & their partners to get them things. They do like to play with them a lot which I think probably does get annoying! So I am very conscious of that and step in when I sense my siblings need some time alone! If they did ask for a treat like that then I would give my siblings the money to take them. They may say no but I would definitely offer, especially as one of them doesn't have much spare cash. So yeah all round, I think the other family are taking advantage or just being thoughtless x

Thank you!!

OP posts:
crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 15:07

Bimbimmer · 10/10/2023 15:00

I get it, OP. It’s not the coffee, it’s the constant demands. I get similar, and it’s very wearing to be constantly viewed as a piggybank, especially with little gratitude.
Sometimes, it’s nice to be able to offer instead of having things demanded of you.

Thank you. Exactly this. I know i am having a moan but also wanted other peoples opinion. The votes are split on whether i AIBU and vice versa currently

OP posts:
Iknowthis1 · 10/10/2023 15:03

She's just a kid. If she's spoilt, blame the people who are spoiling her, not the child.

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 15:03

EachandEveryone · 10/10/2023 14:44

Im more curious to know what is happening to grannys house when she pops her clogs, if you have paid her mortgage and looked after her all this time! That fall out will be spectacular I imagine.

I imagine SIL has already dug her claws in and DH cant stand up for himself. Im hoping by then we emigrate.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 15:01

Iknowthis1 · 10/10/2023 14:59

YABU for

A. Speaking about a child the way you do. It's appalling and it does not reflect well on you.

B. Complaining that she's never told no while never telling her no. You don't need to come up with an excuse. Just say no.

Oh come on, she does sound like an appalling brat.

The OP says that she has said "no" repeatedly but the girl doesn't accept no for an answer and throws a tantrum until she gets what she wants.

Obviously the OP needs to say "no" harder and not give in to blackmail, but the kid's behaviour is disgraceful.

Bimbimmer · 10/10/2023 15:00

I get it, OP. It’s not the coffee, it’s the constant demands. I get similar, and it’s very wearing to be constantly viewed as a piggybank, especially with little gratitude.
Sometimes, it’s nice to be able to offer instead of having things demanded of you.

RosesAndHellebores · 10/10/2023 15:00

I haven't read all of this but are you sure that neither she nor her parents actually understand just how skint you are? I'd be flattered dn wanted to spend time with me as well as the coffee. A Starbucks for a well off child isn't a big treat.

Explain to her dad that you just don't always have sub a tenner for a couple of coffees. There would have been nobody on my children's radar who wouldn't have been able to run to a couple of coffees.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 10/10/2023 14:59

Say “Today it’s a cappucciNO. Maybe latter… just mochaing fun, it’s still a FrappucciNO”. Keep punning until she can’t stand the sight of you and asks someone less annoying.

I thought teenagers weren’t supposed to drink coffee as it stunts their growth. Possibly this is what my parents told me as a teen so they didn’t have to make me any.

Iknowthis1 · 10/10/2023 14:59

YABU for

A. Speaking about a child the way you do. It's appalling and it does not reflect well on you.

B. Complaining that she's never told no while never telling her no. You don't need to come up with an excuse. Just say no.

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 14:59

@crossroads1 I really think I would err on the side of just getting her gift cards for Christmas and birthday from now on.

Say to your BIL and SIL: "DNiece always wants us to pay for coffee when we see her and buy her expensive Christmas and birthday presents such as Chanel makeup, which is just out of our budget unfortunately. From now on we will just get her gift cards which will allow her to put whatever money we can afford to give her towards something she really wants. Do you think she would prefer a Starbucks gift card or a Sephora gift card for Christmas?"

Aubree17 · 10/10/2023 14:58

If there in a good position financially I think they are probably quite oblivious of the cost to you.

Firmly say no if you don't want to treat her. Maybe even say your cutting back your budget and can't go this time. That might get the message across,

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 14:56

fearfuloffluff · 10/10/2023 14:55

There's something really depressing about driving somewhere just for a coffee from a multinational chain.

Anyway. Just say no to anything she asks for that you think is unreasonable.

Yeah, think of the money she must be wasting.

It would be a really valuable life lesson for her to start paying for her own coffee even if her parents give her a whacking great allowance for it. Because if she's got any brains she'll soon figure out how many lattes equal a Chanel lipstick.

Sparkleshine21 · 10/10/2023 14:55

“Sure, why don’t you ask your mum/dad for your pocket money and I’ll take you :)”

fearfuloffluff · 10/10/2023 14:55

There's something really depressing about driving somewhere just for a coffee from a multinational chain.

Anyway. Just say no to anything she asks for that you think is unreasonable.

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 14:54

Grimchmas · 10/10/2023 14:50

Worked through for Chanel make up:

Straightforward: No.

Deflect: "I'm not buying you Chanel make up. Get your dad to buy it for your for Christmas." or "I'm happy to buy you make up if you want it for your Xmas present but I'm not buying you Chanel level of make up. "

Give a reason that it's not easy to argue about: "No I'm not buying you Chanel. I don’t even buy it for myself usually, this was bought for the most special occasion of my life, my wedding day. If I don't buy it for myself I'm certainly not buying it for anybody else!"

Softner: "No I'm not buying you Chanel but I can give you a gift voucher to go towards some make up for your Christmas present if that's what you'd like."

Broken record: "No." (Repeat each time she asks. If necessarily add: "because I don't want to buy anybody Chanel make up." before going back to: "No." Be as dull and repetitive as it takes, ignore any scowls, strops, begging, pleading or looks.

End the conversation: "No and stop asking now." Paddington stare and allow awkward silence/ just stare at her while she kicks off or strops with no visible change in emotion from you.

Ignore: "No and stop asking now." Physically turn away from her and immediately start a conversation with somebody else. Speak softly. If she talks over you, carry on as if she isn't. If she calls out to you, asks a question, anything, ignore and pretend she's not even there.

Change the subject: "I've said no. Now, tell me about that thing you did recently [insert topic here]..."

Leave the room: "No, I'm not buying you Chanel make up." Leave the room.

Simpler solution.

Ignore, ignore, ignore, nod and smile.

Christmas Day/birthday rolls around.

"Here is some money which you can put towards Chanel makeup, or add to your Starbucks kitty if you prefer. Happy shopping!"

Grimchmas · 10/10/2023 14:50

Grimchmas · 10/10/2023 14:39

Here are some options for being more assertive:

Straightforward: No.

Deflect: "Not today. Get your dad to take you," or "they're expensive, so only if you're paying!" (If you don't mind taking her and it's mainly the money that is the issue). "We went last week, I'll take you again next month but I'm not doing it more often."

Give a reason that it's not easy to argue about: "No I don't want to drive anywhere today." "No I don't have money for that today."

Softner: "No but we've got coffee and caramel syrup in the kitchen if you want one here."

Broken record: "No." (Repeat each time she asks. If necessarily add: "because I don't want to. " before going back to: "No." Be as dull and repetitive as it takes, ignore any scowls, strops, begging, pleading or looks.

End the conversation: "No and stop asking now." Paddington stare and allow awkward silence/ just stare at her while she kicks off or strops with no visible change in emotion from you.

Ignore: "No and stop asking now." Physically turn away from her and immediately start a conversation with somebody else. Speak softly. If she talks over you, carry on as if she isn't. If she calls out to you, asks a question, anything, ignore and pretend she's not even there.

Change the subject: "I've said no not today. Now, tell me about that thing you did recently [insert topic here]..."

Leave the room: "No, I'm not buying you coffee today/Chanel make up for Christmas/ the moon on a stick." Leave the room and ignore any follow up from her, and either go out of the property entirely, or go for a long bath or even just for a long sit in the loo whilst reading mumsnet.

Edited

Worked through for Chanel make up:

Straightforward: No.

Deflect: "I'm not buying you Chanel make up. Get your dad to buy it for your for Christmas." or "I'm happy to buy you make up if you want it for your Xmas present but I'm not buying you Chanel level of make up. "

Give a reason that it's not easy to argue about: "No I'm not buying you Chanel. I don’t even buy it for myself usually, this was bought for the most special occasion of my life, my wedding day. If I don't buy it for myself I'm certainly not buying it for anybody else!"

Softner: "No I'm not buying you Chanel but I can give you a gift voucher to go towards some make up for your Christmas present if that's what you'd like."

Broken record: "No." (Repeat each time she asks. If necessarily add: "because I don't want to buy anybody Chanel make up." before going back to: "No." Be as dull and repetitive as it takes, ignore any scowls, strops, begging, pleading or looks.

End the conversation: "No and stop asking now." Paddington stare and allow awkward silence/ just stare at her while she kicks off or strops with no visible change in emotion from you.

Ignore: "No and stop asking now." Physically turn away from her and immediately start a conversation with somebody else. Speak softly. If she talks over you, carry on as if she isn't. If she calls out to you, asks a question, anything, ignore and pretend she's not even there.

Change the subject: "I've said no. Now, tell me about that thing you did recently [insert topic here]..."

Leave the room: "No, I'm not buying you Chanel make up." Leave the room.

LlynTegid · 10/10/2023 14:48

I refuse to go to Starbucks because of their tax avoidance. Which would be the reason I would use in the OPs shoes.

WitcheryDivine · 10/10/2023 14:47

I hate to say it but you need to learn to say no before you have your own kids.

If it were my niece I'd probably take her with me next time, and over our drinks I'd say something like "it's a shame but I won't be able to go out for expensive coffees like this as much from now on, money is really tight. What could we do instead next time you come round?" If she says "urgh nothing I just want to go for coffee" you can suggest that you take turns in paying - but you're happy to drive.

That can then mellow in her and next time she asks you remind her that unfortunately you can't afford it at the moment, like you said. Unless it's her round this time?

I am constantly saying no to my niece and she LOVES me, it's weird.

Scirocco · 10/10/2023 14:46

You say "No". If she pushes, you clearly state to her and her parents that £5+ coffee shop drinks are not something you can justify in your budget. It's not a negotiation, you just say it's not happening with your money.

If her parents want to fund it, they can.

M4J4 · 10/10/2023 14:46

5128gap · 10/10/2023 13:44

You need to try to be a little more authentic OP. You are clearly presenting in one way to this child (nice, fun, generous auntie) while inwardly disliking, resenting her and calling her names.
Thats actually no fairer on her than on you. It's two faced and hypocritical.
There is no rational reason for you being obliged to take this girl anywhere. She has parents, grandparents and your husband who come higher in the hierarchy of obligation towards her than you, so why not just back away and let them get on with it?
She asks you to take her out? You say, "Not today niece, perhaps dad/uncle/grandad will take you"

Oh give over. I have teenage nieces. I love them to bits but they have no concept of earning money and would expect me to take them out every week for meals out and coffess and Creams dessert if they had their own way.

Stop talking of what you don't understand.

Luckydog7 · 10/10/2023 14:45

@Est1990

THANK YOU! I've been reading through the thread in disbelief that no one has mentioned this! Coffee is a stimulant and isn't particularly good for adults let alone a 13 year old. It mucks up my sleep for days! Its too late to tell her you think she is too young for it so I guess that isn't an option.

1month · 10/10/2023 14:45

Your DH needs to talk to his sibling and explain that you love taking her out but you just can’t afford it but you don’t know how to say it without upsetting her.

So either they give her money when she asks you to take her out or they step in when she asks and you say no and she keeps on.

ThisIsCharlotteYorkGoldenblatt · 10/10/2023 14:45

@crossroads1 listen darling , I would love to take you out for coffee but I cannot afford it right now .
Problem solved.

EachandEveryone · 10/10/2023 14:44

Im more curious to know what is happening to grannys house when she pops her clogs, if you have paid her mortgage and looked after her all this time! That fall out will be spectacular I imagine.

oksothisisusnow · 10/10/2023 14:44

I'll tell you to tell your niece what I tell my teenager. "£10 for two coffees! Not today, unless you're paying!"
The requests have slowed down...but she does also offer to pay sometimes (win win for everyone except starbucks really!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread