Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nieces teenage coffee habit is costing ME money!

313 replies

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 12:41

AIBU... we live with my MIL and whenever my SIL and her husband come to visit, they bring their nightmare of a 13 year old daughter. My SIL and BIL are TIGHT, but stinking RICH. BUT, when they come to ours the daughter always wants to go Starbucks, Costa, fancy coffee shops etc etccc. And the parents sit there while she asks me if we can go.

Sometimes I've said yes (if i want a coffee too) but when I try to make an excuse she doesnt stop. She is never told no. But the thing that IRKS me is when i do agree to take her they never offer to give me money to pay for her coffee habit. Not being funny but in a cost of living crisis, im not happy to pay £5 for her snapchat coffee.

On the flip side, whenever it his her birthday my BIL always puts on a huge birthday, everything paid for (he is generous when it comes to pleasing her and showing off), but AIBU to not want to pay for her coffee habit? I don't mind to take her in the car to Starbucks (obv she doesnt drive) but a little gratitude would be nice! And also the fact that they can defintely afford it, while me and DH are not in the best place financially. We do not have kids yet either.

How do I say no or ask them to give me the money to take THEIR daughter without sounding like a Scrooge or complete B*tch.

OP posts:
millymog11 · 10/10/2023 18:09

Eddyraisins · Today 17:58

Its ok. When you post on Mumsnet you full well know there will be some posters who, a few hours before, woke up on the wrong side of the bed and want nothing more than just to come on MN and slag off anyone and everyone on any thread they can get their hands on. I guess because it makes them feel better. Its the way this place works I guess Confused

JustMarriedBecca · 10/10/2023 18:07

Sounds to me like she wants some attention. Maybe Mummy and Daddy are stinking rich but time poor.
My DD loves spending time with her aunt and uncle. It's absolutely not about treats out. How about "sorry, not buying treats this week. Let's have one here and I'll paint your nails"

Startyabastard · 10/10/2023 18:05

Say “Today it’s a cappucciNO. Maybe latter… just mochaing fun, it’s still a FrappucciNO”. Keep punning until she can’t stand the sight of you and asks someone less annoying.
haha yes that's a good one.
Your niece can definitely ask her dad, end of conversation.

olivechuu · 10/10/2023 18:03

Stop being entirely spineless and just say no. She’s thirteen for christs sake.

Startyabastard · 10/10/2023 18:03

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 13:09

Not rent free. We pay more than the MIL, she is retired and elderly, we look after her. The chanel make up is years old which i brought for my wedding where i did my own makeup - i dont frivously spend and the dinners are far and few between.

There's always one, OP!!
@arethereanyleftatall just because someone owns something a little bit expensive, it doesn't mean that they have major assets.
A Chanel eyeshadow makeup palette isn't an indicator of someone's wealth especially if it was bought long ago for something special.

Eddyraisins · 10/10/2023 17:58

millymog11 · 10/10/2023 13:42

If you are 10 years younger than her own parents then this feels like a combination of:

  • your neice feels "in competition" with you as a lot of teenagers tend to do
  • you yourself feel threatened by your neice as some kind of competition to yourself - maybe because you feel she as a 13 year old (via her parents) has more economic power available to her than you do (as an adult with bills to pay etc)
  • maybe you feel disrespected by your neices parents who you feel view you as some kind of "playmate" for their daughter

Whatever the case and irrespective of whether any of the above are true, am I right in thinking there is at least ten years age gap between your neice and yourself (i.e. you are at least 23 years old)?

Assuming that is the case, it is double important you switch your approach and start distancing yourself from your neice, I would even struggle not to laugh at her and make remarks like "don't your parents know that caffeine is bad for growing teenagers" and "it will be great when you get your first Saturday job and you have your own money - how about a Saturday job in a Starbucks?"

The more you let her see you as some kind of peer on her level who she can boss around, the more she will do it. I know this for certain as I have a 14 year old teenage daughter. You need to turn it around and prompto.

I love how one poster said you were unhinged and childlike and another asked if you were a psychologist.

Got to love mumsnet.

Inthebitterend · 10/10/2023 17:56

Am I the only one who finds it weird that a 13 year old drinks coffee regularly or am I just old haha

(not read every page so someone might have mentioned it!)

PosterBoy · 10/10/2023 17:44

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 17:27

I know that wasn't the point of the thread but paying the mortgage on a house your SIL may well inherit is going to cost you a hell of a lot more than your niece's coffee habit.

Yup. I would focus on other stuff if you want to save more than £5 here and there ... like buying your own place and letting mil pay her own mortgage

PuzzledObserver · 10/10/2023 17:34

I tell DH that she keeps asking me to take her out and its expensive. He tells his niece firmly and she listens. With me she just keeps going and I dnt feel i can discipline her because im not blood related

You don’t have to discipline her. What you have to do is say No. Sorry, DN, I’d love to go for a coffee and spend time with you, but money’s a bit tight, so I can’t afford to take you to Starbucks this time. But we can <insert free activity> if you like.

At 13, she’s old enough to understand (or to learn) that things cost money, that money usually has to be earned, and different people have different amounts of it. And also it’s about time she learned that she can’t have everything she wants, no matter how much she strops.

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 17:27

I know that wasn't the point of the thread but paying the mortgage on a house your SIL may well inherit is going to cost you a hell of a lot more than your niece's coffee habit.

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 17:26

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 17:23

Mortgage is paid by DH but ofc i pay half which is fair. My view is SIL will get it because she is money hungry, i cant say for sure but DH seems to think that wont happen. I have a shared property through my own family so homeless wont be an issue.

I still wouldn't be happy with this situation at all.

You could be building up equity in a home that you will own.

Instead you're paying the mortgage on a property that you don't own.

I think I would want to have a family discussion about getting the property put into joint names now to reflect who is actually paying for it, or move out and stop paying for it.

Ormally · 10/10/2023 17:25

The other thing I will say is that 13 year olds are acquisitive and some can be manipulative: they want a lot of things and they want them right now! They are a bit like toddlers but with fancier vocabulary.

I wanted to say this too - there's a big change from 11-12 years, as far as I can see (when they seem quite easy to hang out with, chatty, and reasonable). Enter 13 and in comes a lot more of majorly stroppy, or more socially mortified to be seen interacting in public with anyone related to you, into the mix.

Although it very much varies on the branch and the queue and the teen, Costa in particular will sometimes refuse to serve their drinks with a caffeine content to the under-16s, so possibly this is something that means the OP is seen as quite useful, as well as going for the high end of the drinks menu. I'd also think that either the parents don't often go to coffee shops with the niece, or that when they do, they would assume that the choices will be the more everyday drinks so it doesn't get so expensive.

Making equivalents at home might be a good activity? Or keep saying things like 'Cafes have got so expensive now, we'll have to have coffee here and think of other things to do.'

Incidentally, the Costa app does give some good offers - I hate apps but older teen daughter got it (!) and it seems to be quite generous so far.

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 17:23

MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 17:20

Do you own any other property?

If not, and you're paying the mortgage on a house you expect your SIL to inherit, aren't you at risk of being made homeless one day?

Mortgage is paid by DH but ofc i pay half which is fair. My view is SIL will get it because she is money hungry, i cant say for sure but DH seems to think that wont happen. I have a shared property through my own family so homeless wont be an issue.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 10/10/2023 17:20

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 17:17

I am not banking on DH getting the house. The SIL and BIL are probably the front runners. SIL is the eldest sibling and MIL cannot go a day without talking to her. DH thinks house will be divided but I have my own money so am not expecting anything from them

Do you own any other property?

If not, and you're paying the mortgage on a house you expect your SIL to inherit, aren't you at risk of being made homeless one day?

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 17:18

Zooeyzo · 10/10/2023 17:10

@crossroads1 i don't think you'll change anything to be honest. The cultural expectation is there plus your DH is getting the parents house I assume? that will also be in your SILs and BILs mind. your DH saying anything will just cause a lot of issues with SIL and I bet her husband probably also tells neice to ask for stuff. It's annoying for you- Yes- but can you actually stop it? I don't think so. I doubt very much your DH will say anything.

Agreed. I do think BIL also tells niece to ask for things because he knows she is more likely to get it and he doesnt want to spend the money

OP posts:
crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 17:17

Zooeyzo · 10/10/2023 17:10

@crossroads1 i don't think you'll change anything to be honest. The cultural expectation is there plus your DH is getting the parents house I assume? that will also be in your SILs and BILs mind. your DH saying anything will just cause a lot of issues with SIL and I bet her husband probably also tells neice to ask for stuff. It's annoying for you- Yes- but can you actually stop it? I don't think so. I doubt very much your DH will say anything.

I am not banking on DH getting the house. The SIL and BIL are probably the front runners. SIL is the eldest sibling and MIL cannot go a day without talking to her. DH thinks house will be divided but I have my own money so am not expecting anything from them

OP posts:
Tumbler2121 · 10/10/2023 17:15

Are you in the UK? You are making it sound as though your MIL is penniless and you're helping her. However, as a very ill elderly pensioner she should be having a minimum of around £900 per month (pension credit if not full pension) plus Assistance Allowance £400 per month ... are the household expenses so much more than this?

Pigeon31 · 10/10/2023 17:12

If you liked spending time with her, then you could swivel to being the poor but fun aunt who thinks of lots of cool things to do that don't cost much (which she won't be used to at all). Go to museums, make biscuits, go birdwatching, take a flask with you etc.

Zooeyzo · 10/10/2023 17:10

@crossroads1 i don't think you'll change anything to be honest. The cultural expectation is there plus your DH is getting the parents house I assume? that will also be in your SILs and BILs mind. your DH saying anything will just cause a lot of issues with SIL and I bet her husband probably also tells neice to ask for stuff. It's annoying for you- Yes- but can you actually stop it? I don't think so. I doubt very much your DH will say anything.

LusaBatoosa · 10/10/2023 17:00

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 16:26

Gosh, why are you so angry at my situation? Its a discussion.

She doesn’t sound angry at all. She’s pointing out that there’s an extremely straightforward solution. This isn’t a ‘situation’. Why are you making it one?

AdoraBell · 10/10/2023 16:58

Next time she asks just say - not today, sorry.
If she gets stroppy / demanding tell her if she nags you it will never happen again.

VickyEadieofThigh · 10/10/2023 16:56

Firebug007 · 10/10/2023 16:44

I'm really not sure what the problem is, if you don't want to take her say no 🤷‍♀️

Absolutely. No is a complete sentence.

You could add "I don't want to" if one word isn't enough.

Or if you MUST have an excuse, "I've decided I'm not giving any more money to Costa and Starbucks when I can have better coffee at home".

BenjaminDisraeli · 10/10/2023 16:54

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 14:11

Thanks for your kind response! Yes she does show signs of enjoying y company - we go for a drive, i put her fave music on (ariana grande or whatever theyre listening to) and we get coffee and i buy her some other snacks. I get she is happy to be out of her grandamas house with all the adults (As am I!) but its the constant asking for 'stuff'. she would never go on a walk or a picnic, it has to be something where she is 'getting' something. Maybe im being harsh but from what i know of SIL/BIL, i think its her upbringing. She even bargains at a coffee shop to taste all the flavours! Her dad is in sales - she is certainly his daughter.

Lol, love the idea of her haggling to try all the coffee flavours😆sounds like you've got a right little character on your hands there! You know, it may just be her character, she can't help being a hustler, it's who she is. Remembering my friends' kids, their personalities were there from the start - including the little boy who 'sold' juice to visitors from the age of about 4, and is now a very successful digital entrepreneur! His siblings are entirely different, so it's not necessarily just following in your parents' footsteps.

It's sweet how you describe these episodes of freedom you have together, and it sounds like the mithering is the only thing spoiling it. Would that be an approach? Next time she goes into her routine, could you say, "Look X, I really enjoy spending time together, but can you imagine what it's like to have someone constantly pestering for you to buy them things? What would you do in that situation?" ie, try and involve her in the solution, rather than impose a ban, or make it all about the money.

Passepartoute · 10/10/2023 16:49

Seems to me it's a relatively simple issue. She needs to learn that you are no longer the soft touch aunt, so from now on you have to say no and, if she whinges, direct her to her parents. If she has a tantrum, walk away. Never, never give in.

TerfTalking · 10/10/2023 16:45

“Oh, we don’t need to go niece, I’ll stick a (Lidl) pod in the Nespresso machine and make you a coffee”

Swipe left for the next trending thread