Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nieces teenage coffee habit is costing ME money!

313 replies

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 12:41

AIBU... we live with my MIL and whenever my SIL and her husband come to visit, they bring their nightmare of a 13 year old daughter. My SIL and BIL are TIGHT, but stinking RICH. BUT, when they come to ours the daughter always wants to go Starbucks, Costa, fancy coffee shops etc etccc. And the parents sit there while she asks me if we can go.

Sometimes I've said yes (if i want a coffee too) but when I try to make an excuse she doesnt stop. She is never told no. But the thing that IRKS me is when i do agree to take her they never offer to give me money to pay for her coffee habit. Not being funny but in a cost of living crisis, im not happy to pay £5 for her snapchat coffee.

On the flip side, whenever it his her birthday my BIL always puts on a huge birthday, everything paid for (he is generous when it comes to pleasing her and showing off), but AIBU to not want to pay for her coffee habit? I don't mind to take her in the car to Starbucks (obv she doesnt drive) but a little gratitude would be nice! And also the fact that they can defintely afford it, while me and DH are not in the best place financially. We do not have kids yet either.

How do I say no or ask them to give me the money to take THEIR daughter without sounding like a Scrooge or complete B*tch.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pollymere · 12/10/2023 12:07

I remember telling some students how much a TA earnt. They were horrified. They were doing a project and a night in their hotel was more than a TA earned in a month...

Explain to your niece that unfortunately you're not made of money and that she should be old enough now to know that not everyone has lots of money.

I stopped my own from acting this way by comparing them to Veruca Salt. If they started demanding things I'd ask them if they'd turned into her and say "Daddy, I want an Oompa Loompa NOW". Stopped them in their tracks. If it were my niece, I'd be doing that every time she started whining for Starbucks trips.

kerryelaine100 · 12/10/2023 11:48

You simply say “of course babe but your dad will need to give you money for it or I can’t take you” while her parents are there and hearing what you say !! In fact say it TO the parents not to her .. it’s not her that’s doing this ❤️

Lollingabout · 12/10/2023 09:50

Anele22 · 12/10/2023 00:22

So what if she wants it? She’s a teenager . Wanting nice things doesn’t mean she’s entitled. You sound really unpleasant. You obviously don’t like her. Are you scared of her? Resentful? You’ve been given so many good suggestions of how to deal pleasantly with her but you just keep adding more and more examples of how dreadful you think she is.

Yep. 13 year old is a child. What’s OP’s excuse? Spending so much time and energy slagging off a child says it all to me.

Lollingabout · 12/10/2023 09:45

Autumnleaves89 · 10/10/2023 15:24

You’re absolutely ridiculous. The way you write you sound like a teenager yourself. Bitching about a child and slagging her off online-really?!
Just say no it’s really that straightforward. Don’t agree to it then come on line calling your niece names!

This.

Harls1969 · 12/10/2023 08:43

She asks to go for coffee, you say no and stick to it.
She asks for expensive gifts, you just laugh it off (and say no and stick to it).
She'll soon learn

GettingStuffed · 12/10/2023 08:20

I can't understand why she wants to go to Costa or Starbucks, their coffee is awful, so weak. I second you get the branded sachets and make them at home. You could also get some nice biscuits for less than you'd pay out.

Anele22 · 12/10/2023 00:22

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 13:06

Monthly for sure. But it isnt restricted to coffee. Its make up, clothes, eating out, jewelery - you name it she wants it.

So what if she wants it? She’s a teenager . Wanting nice things doesn’t mean she’s entitled. You sound really unpleasant. You obviously don’t like her. Are you scared of her? Resentful? You’ve been given so many good suggestions of how to deal pleasantly with her but you just keep adding more and more examples of how dreadful you think she is.

PestilencialCrisis · 11/10/2023 23:26

The niece is a child. The OP is an adult. All of the other adults have said no, but the op says yes - why would BIL/SIL say no if they think OP is ok with taking her?

@crossroads1 nobody knows you don't want to take her, including the niece, BIL and SIL. If you don't want to take her, don't! If you do take her, stop complaining (nobody else is going to say no for you - if you aren't happy with the situation, change it).

Nanny0gg · 11/10/2023 23:11

crossroads1 · 10/10/2023 12:50

I wont bore you with the details, but she is the most spoiled, entitled brat. Anything she says she gets. and loves a freebie, just like her parents. I also think she knows i am the only one who will take her and may see me as soft. Ive never had a teenage niece before marrying my DH. Any tips on how to set boundaries is appreciated as I cant stomach another latte!

Don't be available when they come round for a start.

Then learn to say No!

Toomuchtrouble4me · 11/10/2023 22:45

Why don’t you just say no?

Tbry · 11/10/2023 21:10

You just say no and that you can’t afford it. That’s it.

Birch101 · 11/10/2023 20:43

I have a nephew who always wants things

I'd resort to

Have you got your pocket money to pay for it. Don't forget to bring your pocket money. If she asks why you can't buy it for her say fact of life kid people earn different amounts of money and I can't afford too.

If she asks for something like jewelery/ perfume then say something like put it on your Christmas/ birthday list and then just give her something you can afford either cash towards the item(s) or one of the actual items on the list.

She's gotta learn that not everyone has the same amount of flexible money. She will have friends eventually that spend money in different ways to her

As an aunt/uncle it is nice to treat if you can outside of special occassions but I would do this through experiences e.g. crazy golf, cinema trip etc but you said she is a bit brattish so can understand not wanting to do that!

CKL987 · 11/10/2023 20:26

Just ask your sibling for the money. If I think mine owes me something I ask and he gives.

Icantrememberit · 11/10/2023 19:22

You are fully entitled to say no. However, does she just want to ‘spend’ time with you? Or maybe her parents are so tight that she sees it as a little treat you do for her.
I suggest the next time you both go maybe mention next time you can treat me? And see what her reply is.
Being a teenager is hard even for little rich kids, she may just want some time with someone/ an adult without the pressure.

Barney60 · 11/10/2023 19:05

Just say sorry theres no petrol in the car, but i love the idea someone further up added buy her costa vouchers for Christmas.

Owl55 · 11/10/2023 19:04

I think you can buy costa coffee in the supermarket now maybe that’s a cheaper option x

Bellyblueboy · 11/10/2023 18:28

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 17:54

Yes but the point is that most people who rent are doing it either out of choice or because they don't have the financial means to buy.

The OP and her husband appear to be doing it out of obligation, in which case I think it would be incredibly unjust if SIL were to inherit it. The OP and her husband should be protecting their own interests now by either having part of the house put in their name or buying their own property instead of paying the MIL's mortgage for her.

I wouldn't be happy bringing children into this setup.

Again I am not arguing with you😂.

I am simply clarifying to op that she isn’t paying a mortgage - she is paying rent.

I will leave it there as I think we are having an odd argument which is at cross purposes!

echinaceadreams · 11/10/2023 17:57

Say "yes if your parents are paying!"

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 17:54

Bellyblueboy · 11/10/2023 17:39

I think we have been caught in a strange meaningless argument!

my point was simply that they are paying the mortgage for a house they never expect to own. They aren’t paying to get the house - so they should think of it as dead money - money to put a roof over their head.

I am not arguing they are doing the right thing. If they would rather pay for their own home and get their own mortgage then they should.

but getting bitter about paying someone else’s mortgage is pointless- millions of renters are doing just that

Yes but the point is that most people who rent are doing it either out of choice or because they don't have the financial means to buy.

The OP and her husband appear to be doing it out of obligation, in which case I think it would be incredibly unjust if SIL were to inherit it. The OP and her husband should be protecting their own interests now by either having part of the house put in their name or buying their own property instead of paying the MIL's mortgage for her.

I wouldn't be happy bringing children into this setup.

Tempone · 11/10/2023 17:42

Op, people.who have money, I.e your in laws often don't understand that other people don't have access to money as easily. They may think the 3 pound per month or whatever it is doesn't bother you.

Anyway, it sounds like you don't like the girl though so that's moot. Stop facilitating a relationship with her because you don't like her.

Bellyblueboy · 11/10/2023 17:39

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 10:30

Most people don't want to rent if they have the option of buying their own home.

And it doesn't actually sound like the OP has much choice in the matter. The MIL can't afford to pay her own mortgage and it sounds like she needs significant practical help.

What would happen if the OP and her husband decided to move out, buy their own house and leave the MIL behind? Would the family be fine with that? Would SIL and her husband step up, start paying her mortgage and providing the practical assistance that the OP and her husband are currently providing?

The same SIL and her husband who can't be arsed to drive their own child to Starbucks and too mean to give her money to buy her own coffee but expect the OP to do these things instead?

I do not think so.

I think we have been caught in a strange meaningless argument!

my point was simply that they are paying the mortgage for a house they never expect to own. They aren’t paying to get the house - so they should think of it as dead money - money to put a roof over their head.

I am not arguing they are doing the right thing. If they would rather pay for their own home and get their own mortgage then they should.

but getting bitter about paying someone else’s mortgage is pointless- millions of renters are doing just that

Daisybuttercup12345 · 11/10/2023 17:32

AvocadotoastORahouse · 10/10/2023 12:45

"We have no money for treats this week as things are tight, but if Mum or Dad want to give you the money, I'd happily take you in the car"

Then a firm stare at BIL/SIL.

This.

ToniTTtopaz · 11/10/2023 17:00

@MargotBamborough Snapchat is not the bee all and end all.

I have a teen, I get it.

But if she's only going for Snapchat and not because she actually likes coffee, id be inclined to stop it even more!

WomanHereHear · 11/10/2023 14:55

Exactly

If you read properly, there is massive entitlement from the in laws here, they think it is OP’s husband’s duty to be the family caretaker as I assume fil is not around. So this extends to op, as always the woman is expected to do the free childcare and other shit work that she doesn’t really want to. She won’t get thanks because it is expected of her.

The op has said the niece is a “spoilt brat“ and I wonder if the niece would act like this around her other grandparents from her father’s side or is it reserved for op because they expect her to be the pushover because op has mentioned that sil does not bother her own husband and in laws in the way she bothers her brother (op’s dh). This is what happens in some joint family type communities anyway, the wives are not allowed to ask for much from their husband and in laws but are expected to go back to their own family, it’s a patriarchy/gender bias thing but with that obligation on the op’s Dh (and her), there should be a lot of privilege ie the Dh should be the one to solely inherit the house because of all the caretaking and financial contributions he’s making, but here op thinks it will be split or even worse the sil will take it all. The Dh seems very passive in all of this, so they’re majorly taking advantage of him when they know if they stuck to the ‘rules’ it should be her Dh inheriting it all.

I know op has her own savings etc but if you are contributing bills or giving general care to mil, saving on care bills, or limiting your working hours so you are more available for the in laws and their kids, I would want that legally recognised and have a share in the house as because all the help op is providing to her dh’s mother, it is allowing her Dh to pay the mortgage so it’s really wrong she does not have any share in the property. But I guess it’s not something op can change unless she makes a noise about it and I doubt her Dh will listen if he’s not even bothered about the stuff that concerns him

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 13:22

@PestilencialCrisis But the niece refuses to take no for an answer when the OP doesn't want to go.

I assume that these conversations are happening within her parents' earshot.

What kind of person, when hearing their 13 year old child repeatedly haranguing her aunt to take her to Starbucks and having a tantrum when the aunt said no, would not say, "DD, stop that right now! No means no."

Swipe left for the next trending thread