Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my husband to change Christmas traditions with DSC

489 replies

spookymooky1 · 10/10/2023 09:41

My husband has two children from his previous relationship, both boys one aged 8 and one 12. We have been married three years and together for 5, I was not the other woman.
He basically gets his kids 45% of the time. He does all the pick ups and drop offs and their mum lives around 40 minutes drive away.
Christmas (yes I know it's early but in a step family you do start thinking of plans well in advance) he normally picks the DSC up at 1ish on Christmas Day and keeps them until Boxing Day 6ish.
This has never been ideal for me and now we have a 2 1/5 year old toddler I'm wondering if it's time for a change.
him picking up his kids at 1pm means it splits our day right down the middle, we can't go to my families for Christmas lunch and they've often eaten lunch at their mums so won't touch my Christmas tea.
They always had their Christmas Day on Boxing Day morning (Santa came to dads on Christmas night) I don't think the boys believe in Santa anymore.
AIBU to ask every second year we do Christmas the three of us and collect them on Boxing Day morning? I don't mind things staying the same this year but any suggestions moving forward would be appreciated

OP posts:
Mumto6ac · 11/10/2023 10:16

I used to alternate Christmas Day/Boxing day with my older kids dad when they were small. As they got older they decided that they wanted to stay home on Christmas Day & go to their dads on Boxing Day instead. It was their choice so was accepted by all

senior30 · 11/10/2023 10:07

I feel so much for children who have separated parents and then have step-parents like this. It’s all about what you want, your parents don’t know your step children? You’ve been in a relationship 5 years that’s just not acceptable. My brother’s step son is involved in everything we do and he wouldn’t allow it to be any other way. Why did you marry and have children with him, or did you expect that once you had your own you’d be able to force his out?

Backagain23 · 11/10/2023 10:06

And putting them first is part of that deal. I don't blame anyone who doesn't want to put other people's children first, but they shouldn't get into relationships with existing parents
Nope. None of the children get to come first every time. Anyone who wants to always put their first child at the top of the priority list has no business making a second or third child.

Coffeepot72 · 11/10/2023 10:03

I locked horns with DH many times over the arrangements with DSS. Not necessarily over Christmas plans, but just stupid things that didn't work for anyone, but had to continue 'just because.'

Example - at one time, DSS was with us Wed, Fri , Sat. It would have saved DH a lot of driving, and DSS a lot of to-ing and fro-ing if the arrangement had been Thu, Fri, Sat. But no, it had to be Wednesday. Why? No reason, its just what we've always done.

gannett · 11/10/2023 09:49

spookymooky1 · 10/10/2023 14:21

My DH is not adverse to change, when we moved in together he said just because Christmas plans are like that now doesn't mean they can't change, I didn't push the matter as in all honesty I didn't have the confidence, I think the deal isn't great for him and he'd be open to discussions but im just wondering what's reasonable to ask of him and his ex.

You can make whatever suggestions you want then, if everyone else involved is amenable to change. There's no single "reasonable" plan - only what's reasonable for the people involved. As you can see on this thread, plenty of blended families wouldn't want to split Xmas Day, but plenty others would be happy to do so. You find a solution that works for you (primarily the kids though).

What is unreasonable is to use the phrase "just the three of us" and give any indication that you want to exclude yoru husband's kids from your "little family". No, they're part of his family of five, and you signed up to joining that wen you married him. And putting them first is part of that deal. I don't blame anyone who doesn't want to put other people's children first, but they shouldn't get into relationships with existing parents.

What would be more reasonable is to present your suggestions from a purely logical and logistical point of view. Frame it as making life easier for everyone involved. And accept that if a split Xmas Day is what makes the kids happy, then that is what will have to happen.

FWIW I don't think the inconveniences to you are anywhere near as bothersome as keeping those kids from seeing their dad on Xmas Day would be. Your husband is gone for 90 minutes? That's barely anything. Your stepkids aren't hungry? Make them a plate of nibbles rather than a full dinner then. Your parents might have to eat lunch a couple of hours later? That's barely an inconvenience. Your parents don't know your stepkids very well? Well, a good time to remedy that then.

Mitchlou84 · 11/10/2023 09:48

i haven’t read the whole thing but as long as you are suggesting that you have the step children for all of Christmas Day one year at yours, then one year at his mum’s then you aren’t in the wrong
if you are suggesting the split day one year then nothing the next then that’s pretty mean
Never word things ‘the 3 of us’ there are 5 of you

BookishBabe · 11/10/2023 09:38

I preferred splitting the day as a child.
But my Dad collected me at 3ish.
I wouldn't have wanted to be collected at 6 or 7 as the day is basically over then.
But you could go to your parents and have dinner if they eat at 12/1ish and collect DSC at 3ish.

Coffeepot72 · 11/10/2023 09:23

I don't think anybody is saying her husband should stop seeing his kids on Christmas Day. Just that this specific arrangement is a bit crap and can be improved upon in a way that will benefit everyone.

Absolutely!

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 08:56

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 08:18

Why is it rubbish for the child/children of the 2nd relationship? Just because it isn't what you like it doesn't mean they will feel the same. I have 4 kids, 2 from first marriage and 2 from 2nd.

My older two had Christmas Eve/Christmas morning with their dad and his family, lots of fun with grandparents and aunts and uncles and cousins, then came to us sometimes having lunch with their dad sometimes coming to us in time for lunch. They loved having two Christmas Days in one day, one in each house.

In my house my younger kids had Christmas morning, opened what Father Christmas had brought them, grandparents would arrive. Lots of fun and then big siblings arrived and more presents, bigger kids to play with them, bigger kids loving the excuse to be like little kids again (obviously just to amuse the little ones but they did a very convincing job of enjoying it unless of course it actually is fun.)

I would never have agreed to miss seeing them on Christmas Day and fortunately my husband would never even have suggested it.

All the fuss about having to do Christmas tea alone for 6 pm as partner is absent for less than 2 hrs and is presumably back by 2 pm is just silly and just sounds like desperately trying to justify what she wants.

It's rubbish because they and their mum will be twiddling their thumbs at lunchtime while their dad is absent, they aren't allowed to go and have Christmas lunch with their grandparents, and they have to wait until the evening to have their Christmas meal which is a muted affair because their siblings have already had their main celebration and aren't eating.

It also no doubt condemns the OP to preparing the meal every year because once her husband gets home with his older children he'll want to hang out with them, not help with the cooking.

I don't think anybody is saying her husband should stop seeing his kids on Christmas Day. Just that this specific arrangement is a bit crap and can be improved upon in a way that will benefit everyone.

Roselilly36 · 11/10/2023 08:38

Coughingdodger · 10/10/2023 10:15

Ask the children.

This.

Goldencup · 11/10/2023 08:33

MeMySonAnd1 · 11/10/2023 08:19

I think that is a terrible arrangement for both families and the kids. A judge tried to impose that on us and both exH and I refused as we had already seen that it didn’t allow for anyone to have a nice uninterrupted Christmas Day or see the extended family.

You may ask, they may say no, but who knows, probably they would be more than happy to change it, some options could be:

  1. Christmas Day with mum, Boxing Day with dad one year, Christmas Day with dad, Boxing Day with mum the next

  2. What we did, as we needed to travel to see our respective families was that the first week of the holiday was spent with one parent, the second with the other and we rotated each year so both of us could have the kids on Christmas Day on alternate years

  3. My boyfriend’s exW would not, ever allow the children to see their dad on Christmas Day as Christmas is big for her and she doesn’t give a shit about her exH, but we have learned that is not worth it to make a big fuss about it, they have their big party with mum at Christmas, we have the big party on New Year’s Eve (mind you, no toddlers involved here, it might be different with toddlers)

It really doesn't matter what you or I or anyone else thinks. The only thing that matters is if this works for the children of the divorce, not OP, not their Dad or their Mother. What the children want should be the only guiding principle and most family court judges would agree with me.

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 11/10/2023 08:32

As a step parent. I came into my DH life knowing that his son and X would always be a part of his life and they would always be a family though not together any longer. I have always treated it, for SS because he is a child and didn’t choose this situation for himself, like we are one extended family as much as I possibly can regardless of the ups and downs of working the emotions in the situation between his mum and dad at times.

DH and I don’t have children together, but his mum and stepdad have 2 further children. As heartbreaking as it is for my DH Christmas Day for us is a very quiet day with just my mum and grandad having spent Xmas Eve with his mum and dad. So SS has Xmas Eve and Xmas Day with his mum and family as there are other siblings he wants to be with and play with.

We pick him up Boxing Day (he lives 30 mins away) at 9.00am, go to my DH parents for the morning to do gifts and have some fun (DH is an only child and his mums not big on Xmas as it’s been traumatic for her in the past), then head to ours briefly to see what gifts Santa left at our house and then head on to my mums where my brothers and their children all come and have the best time! So Boxing Day is more like our Christmas! Then we have his for a couple of days and drop him back thereafter until our rotation comes round again.

You have children in your home too that your SC are going to want to see as they are their half siblings too. I don’t think alternating Xmas Eve/Xmas Day hurts so long as the children are happy with this. It allows everyone a far more relaxed and less stressful day to enjoy TBH, so I understand your point.

But, what I will say is this isn’t your decision, they were here before you and you need to accept and respect that and, whilst you can have a quiet chat with your DH about what you think, none of it is your decision I am afraid IMHO that is then up to him if he’s happy to work that out with consideration of the fact that it might even work better for his children in discussions with their mother.

we also do all pick ups and drop offs, but we don’t care, if that’s what we need to do to see SS that’s what we do, simple as that.

cassy16 · 11/10/2023 08:32

To be honest it just sounds like all you care about is yourself! Maybe you shouldn’t of started a relationship with someone with kids not everyone is cut out to be step mum, if it works well for them leave it you get to be with your child wake up with your child that’s what matters, like you said in a previous comment it would be disingenuous to say your doing it for the kids! You sound like a right pain in the arse they won’t be children for ever then you can have as many Christmas’s your way as you like don’t rock the boat and create problems where there aren’t any

Goldencup · 11/10/2023 08:29

aSofaNearYou · 10/10/2023 22:33

Or you could say that for 5 years it's been all about them and his family, at the expense of OP, and isn't that selfish of him. It's not selfish to stop putting up with something that's been problematic for you for years.

Again who are the adults here ? SDCs are only 10 &12, I think it's easy for the parents of toddlers to think this is " nearly grown up" and attribute maturiy and resilence to these children that they just don't posess. Once DCs are in the picture it's not about adults ' desires or preferences. The toddler doesn't know any better as I said once they are 15 & 17 and the toddler is 7 things will be different.

MeMySonAnd1 · 11/10/2023 08:19

I think that is a terrible arrangement for both families and the kids. A judge tried to impose that on us and both exH and I refused as we had already seen that it didn’t allow for anyone to have a nice uninterrupted Christmas Day or see the extended family.

You may ask, they may say no, but who knows, probably they would be more than happy to change it, some options could be:

  1. Christmas Day with mum, Boxing Day with dad one year, Christmas Day with dad, Boxing Day with mum the next

  2. What we did, as we needed to travel to see our respective families was that the first week of the holiday was spent with one parent, the second with the other and we rotated each year so both of us could have the kids on Christmas Day on alternate years

  3. My boyfriend’s exW would not, ever allow the children to see their dad on Christmas Day as Christmas is big for her and she doesn’t give a shit about her exH, but we have learned that is not worth it to make a big fuss about it, they have their big party with mum at Christmas, we have the big party on New Year’s Eve (mind you, no toddlers involved here, it might be different with toddlers)

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 08:18

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 07:08

I'm not talking about the stepchildren, I'm talking about the OP's children. If the OP's young children are having rubbish Christmases because of this bonkers arrangement, that's not going to change at the request of teenage stepsiblings, is it?

The problem here is obvious. Lunchtime is a completely antisocial time to do the handover. If they insist on splitting Christmas Day, either the OP's husband needs to pick his kids up slightly earlier so they come over for lunch (and don't eat Christmas lunch beforehand) or he needs to pick them up later in the afternoon so the OP and her husband and children can have their Christmas lunch first.

And her husband's ex wife should be doing her fair share of the driving.

It's utterly shit for the OP and her children to be abandoned over lunchtime every year (on strict instructions not to go to the OP's family for lunch either) and for the OP to then spend her afternoon slaving away making an evening meal that her stepchildren don't want to eat because they had their big meal at lunchtime. That would be shit any particular year but making them all do that every year until the stepchildren have grown up is ludicrous.

The stepchildren might not have chosen for their parents to separate. The OP and her husband might have chosen to form a relationship knowing that he had children from his first marriage. But that doesn't mean that this arrangement needs to be preserved for all eternity just because his children from his first marriage are innocent in all this. Other people are innocent in all this too, namely the OP's children and her parents.

As for all the people criticising the OP's parents for not eating their Christmas lunch in the middle of the afternoon so the OP's stepchildren can attend, what on earth makes anyone think her stepchildren want to attend?

Imagine you are one of the OP's stepchildren and your Christmas Day looks like this. You wake up in your mum's house, open your presents while your mum is cooking, gobble down your Christmas lunch at 12 o'clock when you're probably not even that hungry but you have to be ready to get picked up by your dad at 1 o'clock, then instead of being able to relax around the table or get back to your presents, you have to get in the car and drive to your stepmum's parents' house, i.e. two old people who aren't even your own grandparents, where you're expected to sit politely at the table for a second Christmas lunch about two hours after your first one, which obviously you're too full to touch. And you don't really get to spend any quality time with your dad or look at your presents until much later. How on earth is that a good Christmas Day for the stepchildren?

It makes so much more sense for them to stay with their mum for a few more hours. I expect she would prefer that too.

So who is the current arrangement actually benefiting?

No one.

Why is it rubbish for the child/children of the 2nd relationship? Just because it isn't what you like it doesn't mean they will feel the same. I have 4 kids, 2 from first marriage and 2 from 2nd.

My older two had Christmas Eve/Christmas morning with their dad and his family, lots of fun with grandparents and aunts and uncles and cousins, then came to us sometimes having lunch with their dad sometimes coming to us in time for lunch. They loved having two Christmas Days in one day, one in each house.

In my house my younger kids had Christmas morning, opened what Father Christmas had brought them, grandparents would arrive. Lots of fun and then big siblings arrived and more presents, bigger kids to play with them, bigger kids loving the excuse to be like little kids again (obviously just to amuse the little ones but they did a very convincing job of enjoying it unless of course it actually is fun.)

I would never have agreed to miss seeing them on Christmas Day and fortunately my husband would never even have suggested it.

All the fuss about having to do Christmas tea alone for 6 pm as partner is absent for less than 2 hrs and is presumably back by 2 pm is just silly and just sounds like desperately trying to justify what she wants.

user1492757084 · 11/10/2023 08:17

You can only discuss. I like the idea of the Mum dropping the kids off later on Christmas afternoon, in preparation for the kids to spend a quality Boxing Day with you.

Sunshineandflipflops · 11/10/2023 08:12

I haven't rtft but we have a similar arrangement to you - separated 6 years this xmas and I have always had Xmas eve/Xmas day with the dc until about 4/5pm when their dad picks them up, takes them to his and they do Xmas eve/Day all over again at his. He had an affair and broke the marriage/family up so he felt it was right I still got to spend this time with them (he was right). It has worked well for us all but now ex has met someone who doesn't live that close to us, so has changed arrangements this year to picking them up Boxing Day morning and having them for a day or two.

The dc are 16 and 18 now so it's fine but I wouldn't have been thrilled with him changing the arrangements like this when they were younger just because he met someone else and it was inconvenient/he couldn't have a drink.

It's tough to please everyone but you have to work together really to find a solution that everyone is happy enough with (you, your dh, his other dc and their mum).

Coffeepot72 · 11/10/2023 07:28

So who is the current arrangement actually benefiting?

No one.

@MargotBamborough excellent point. These arrangements take place simply because “that’s what we’ve always done” with no thought to whether they serve any benefit. This is all too common in step families

Backagain23 · 11/10/2023 07:22

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 07:08

I'm not talking about the stepchildren, I'm talking about the OP's children. If the OP's young children are having rubbish Christmases because of this bonkers arrangement, that's not going to change at the request of teenage stepsiblings, is it?

The problem here is obvious. Lunchtime is a completely antisocial time to do the handover. If they insist on splitting Christmas Day, either the OP's husband needs to pick his kids up slightly earlier so they come over for lunch (and don't eat Christmas lunch beforehand) or he needs to pick them up later in the afternoon so the OP and her husband and children can have their Christmas lunch first.

And her husband's ex wife should be doing her fair share of the driving.

It's utterly shit for the OP and her children to be abandoned over lunchtime every year (on strict instructions not to go to the OP's family for lunch either) and for the OP to then spend her afternoon slaving away making an evening meal that her stepchildren don't want to eat because they had their big meal at lunchtime. That would be shit any particular year but making them all do that every year until the stepchildren have grown up is ludicrous.

The stepchildren might not have chosen for their parents to separate. The OP and her husband might have chosen to form a relationship knowing that he had children from his first marriage. But that doesn't mean that this arrangement needs to be preserved for all eternity just because his children from his first marriage are innocent in all this. Other people are innocent in all this too, namely the OP's children and her parents.

As for all the people criticising the OP's parents for not eating their Christmas lunch in the middle of the afternoon so the OP's stepchildren can attend, what on earth makes anyone think her stepchildren want to attend?

Imagine you are one of the OP's stepchildren and your Christmas Day looks like this. You wake up in your mum's house, open your presents while your mum is cooking, gobble down your Christmas lunch at 12 o'clock when you're probably not even that hungry but you have to be ready to get picked up by your dad at 1 o'clock, then instead of being able to relax around the table or get back to your presents, you have to get in the car and drive to your stepmum's parents' house, i.e. two old people who aren't even your own grandparents, where you're expected to sit politely at the table for a second Christmas lunch about two hours after your first one, which obviously you're too full to touch. And you don't really get to spend any quality time with your dad or look at your presents until much later. How on earth is that a good Christmas Day for the stepchildren?

It makes so much more sense for them to stay with their mum for a few more hours. I expect she would prefer that too.

So who is the current arrangement actually benefiting?

No one.

Great summary.
The current King Solomon set up is making Christmas Day a bit shit for everyone and OP is getting pelters for wanting everyone to enjoy a proper Christmas Day and all it involves.
There's nowt queer as folk, as they say.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 07:20

Do you have a second car/means to get to your parents house, OP? The more I think about it the more of a no brainer it seems that if the arrangement isn't going to change, you should go to your parents house for lunch and the afternoon while he does this, and come back together for the evening. It's incredibly selfish of him to object to this.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 07:12

Goldencup · 11/10/2023 06:36

But the children of the second marriage get all day every Xmas with both their parents, so yes they can have lunch at 3pm.

For whose benefit? Their stepsiblings who have already eaten lunch at 12pm?

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 07:11

Goldencup · 11/10/2023 06:36

But the children of the second marriage get all day every Xmas with both their parents, so yes they can have lunch at 3pm.

No they don't, they get abandoned every single year over lunchtime.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 07:08

Goldencup · 11/10/2023 06:25

This is a straw man things will change as the DC get older but it will be at their request as teenagers not at the whim of their step mother. Most teenagers I know would happily eat an Xmas lunch @ 12 and another at 3 or 4pm. This is a non problem.

I'm not talking about the stepchildren, I'm talking about the OP's children. If the OP's young children are having rubbish Christmases because of this bonkers arrangement, that's not going to change at the request of teenage stepsiblings, is it?

The problem here is obvious. Lunchtime is a completely antisocial time to do the handover. If they insist on splitting Christmas Day, either the OP's husband needs to pick his kids up slightly earlier so they come over for lunch (and don't eat Christmas lunch beforehand) or he needs to pick them up later in the afternoon so the OP and her husband and children can have their Christmas lunch first.

And her husband's ex wife should be doing her fair share of the driving.

It's utterly shit for the OP and her children to be abandoned over lunchtime every year (on strict instructions not to go to the OP's family for lunch either) and for the OP to then spend her afternoon slaving away making an evening meal that her stepchildren don't want to eat because they had their big meal at lunchtime. That would be shit any particular year but making them all do that every year until the stepchildren have grown up is ludicrous.

The stepchildren might not have chosen for their parents to separate. The OP and her husband might have chosen to form a relationship knowing that he had children from his first marriage. But that doesn't mean that this arrangement needs to be preserved for all eternity just because his children from his first marriage are innocent in all this. Other people are innocent in all this too, namely the OP's children and her parents.

As for all the people criticising the OP's parents for not eating their Christmas lunch in the middle of the afternoon so the OP's stepchildren can attend, what on earth makes anyone think her stepchildren want to attend?

Imagine you are one of the OP's stepchildren and your Christmas Day looks like this. You wake up in your mum's house, open your presents while your mum is cooking, gobble down your Christmas lunch at 12 o'clock when you're probably not even that hungry but you have to be ready to get picked up by your dad at 1 o'clock, then instead of being able to relax around the table or get back to your presents, you have to get in the car and drive to your stepmum's parents' house, i.e. two old people who aren't even your own grandparents, where you're expected to sit politely at the table for a second Christmas lunch about two hours after your first one, which obviously you're too full to touch. And you don't really get to spend any quality time with your dad or look at your presents until much later. How on earth is that a good Christmas Day for the stepchildren?

It makes so much more sense for them to stay with their mum for a few more hours. I expect she would prefer that too.

So who is the current arrangement actually benefiting?

No one.

Bearcub101 · 11/10/2023 06:44

Me and ds’s dad used to split our Christmas Day. He always stayed with me Christmas Eve, as I was the big kid at Christmas, then dad would pick him up at lunchtime and he would have lunch and presents at dads.

Then ex met a women, who was amazing at first. She was brilliant with ds, painted his bedroom as she was an amazing artist, picked him up from school, took him out etc. She was lovely! Then she had her own children.

She refused to go on holidays as a family if ds was there, would not look after him, and wanted Christmas to be changed so ds spent it with me and her dc had their dad to themselves.

Unfortunately fortunately they got divorced….