Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my husband to change Christmas traditions with DSC

489 replies

spookymooky1 · 10/10/2023 09:41

My husband has two children from his previous relationship, both boys one aged 8 and one 12. We have been married three years and together for 5, I was not the other woman.
He basically gets his kids 45% of the time. He does all the pick ups and drop offs and their mum lives around 40 minutes drive away.
Christmas (yes I know it's early but in a step family you do start thinking of plans well in advance) he normally picks the DSC up at 1ish on Christmas Day and keeps them until Boxing Day 6ish.
This has never been ideal for me and now we have a 2 1/5 year old toddler I'm wondering if it's time for a change.
him picking up his kids at 1pm means it splits our day right down the middle, we can't go to my families for Christmas lunch and they've often eaten lunch at their mums so won't touch my Christmas tea.
They always had their Christmas Day on Boxing Day morning (Santa came to dads on Christmas night) I don't think the boys believe in Santa anymore.
AIBU to ask every second year we do Christmas the three of us and collect them on Boxing Day morning? I don't mind things staying the same this year but any suggestions moving forward would be appreciated

OP posts:
HeadAgainstWall0923 · 11/10/2023 11:10

ZebraD · 10/10/2023 09:52

I would say collect them on Christmas Day but more like 6-7pm so that they have had a full day with their mum. Then it’s a bit of supper together and chat about their day and then ‘Christmas Eve’ again ready for Boxing Day. It must be an unsettling day for their mum having to rush to be ready for 1pm as well. It just doesn’t make sense to me. But I would definitely ask as I think it would be beneficial for both sides and of course the kids.

I think this is a really good solution.

Would your husband be happy not drinking all day on Christmas though due to needing to go out in the evening?

I think your current situation is unworkable for the reasons you’ve mentioned and it can’t be nice for his children to have such a disjointed Christmas Day, spending half of it in one place and the second half in another.

My parents are divorced, have been since I was five, and I used to sleep at my dad’s house on Christmas Eve and spend Christmas Day with him and his side of the family and then he’d take me over to my mum’s house at about 4pm, where all her side of the family would be there too.

It never felt rushed and it felt like we got a good portion of Christmas Day being relaxed with my dad’s side of the family and we had our Christmas lunch there, followed by a lovey relaxing evening with my mum’s side of the family, having more presents to open and munching on naughty Christmas food until we finally fell asleep.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 11:09

It can be right for everyone, that is what you seem to be misunderstanding. It might not work for everyone but it works for many families.

But not this one, since OPs DH chose to make her and their child part of the family and it doesn't work for them.

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 11:08

Whataretheodds · 11/10/2023 11:00

The suggestion of alternating Xmases would entail him not seeing his kids on Xmas Day.

Millions of families do this, precisely so that each parent gets a turn at an interrupted Christmas day rather than every year being a mishmash/not quite right for anyone.

It can be right for everyone, that is what you seem to be misunderstanding. It might not work for everyone but it works for many families.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 11:04

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 11:02

The problem is the step mother walked into a relationship that already existed and wants to change the rules.

The OP wasn't suggesting the children come a little later, she wants Christmas with "just the three of us."

No, she suggested alternating years as a solution to the problem.

It is one of several possible solutions to the problem.

You seem to think she should just accept the problem because she was stupid enough to marry a man who already had kids.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 11:03

The problem is the step mother walked into a relationship that already existed and wants to change the rules.

So just petty principle because you morally object to a step mum changing anything even if it's not really causing a problem and a solution could be found that suits everybody, then. As suspected.

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 11:02

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 10:54

I don't understand what part of this you are struggling with.

It's Christmas Day. The OP wants it to be a special day for herself and her children.

Making chicken nuggets for lunch with her children whilst her husband is absent is not special. It's like any other day.

And going to a lot of effort to make a big Christmas dinner for the evening, when her stepchildren aren't going to eat it and her own children are going to be tired and nearly ready for bed, is a waste of time.

The OP would like to be able to go to her own parents for Christmas lunch, or have a nice Christmas lunch with her husband and children, without having lunchtime completely obliterated every single year because her husband for some reason HAS to be in the car during that specific 90 minute window.

What, actually, is the problem with having the stepchildren come a little bit later so the OP can also enjoy Christmas lunch with her family?

Talk us through what the problem is.

The problem is the step mother walked into a relationship that already existed and wants to change the rules.

The OP wasn't suggesting the children come a little later, she wants Christmas with "just the three of us."

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 11:02

gannett · 11/10/2023 10:52

The suggestion of alternating Xmases would entail him not seeing his kids on Xmas Day.

I think the stepkids staying a bit longer at their mum's is a reasonable suggestion for the OP to make. But we don't have the info as to why the 1pm handover was agreed on (there may well be good reasons for it). And if she makes that suggestion, like I said, she should frame it as a logistical suggestion that makes Xmas work better for everyone, rather than the vibe of wanting to exclude the stepkids that most people in this thread have picked up on.

I don't get any vibe that she wants to exclude her stepkids at all.

She is objecting to these things specifically:

  1. Their Christmas Day being split down the middle.
  2. Her husband doing all the driving.
  3. Her not being able to go to her parents for Christmas lunch but having to always stay home AND make a Christmas dinner that her stepkids don't eat.

There's literally no reason why the arrangements can't be tweaked so those things don't happen.

OK she suggested alternating years, but other compromises are possible.

It's not unreasonable for the OP to object to these specific parts of the arrangements and also for her to want to give her own children nice Christmas memories and not have the day's events dictated by this particular arrangement being set in stone.

She's put up with it for five years, it's never really worked for her, and now she has her own children to consider as well she wants to see if it can be tweaked.

That's not the same as wanting to exclude her stepkids and I think it's really unfair to accuse her of that based on what she has actually said, which is perfectly reasonable.

Whataretheodds · 11/10/2023 11:00

The suggestion of alternating Xmases would entail him not seeing his kids on Xmas Day.

Millions of families do this, precisely so that each parent gets a turn at an interrupted Christmas day rather than every year being a mishmash/not quite right for anyone.

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 10:56

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 10:38

Nobody is saying that he shouldn't see his kids on Christmas Day.

Why do people keep claiming that other people are saying this?

The point is that him being absent for 90 minutes SPECIFICALLY OVER LUNCHTIME doesn't work.

If the stepchildren are going to have Christmas lunch with their mother before they come to the OP's house then they should stay there for a little bit longer so that everyone else can also enjoy their Christmas lunch beforehand.

The OP is saying that. She is saying every other year they would pick them up Boxing Day instead of Christmas Day. So that year Dad doesn't see them Christmas Day and presumably the other year Mum doesn't see them Christmas Day.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 10:54

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 10:49

Well if an adult with a child can't think of anything better to do than twiddle their thumbs for an hour and a half on Christmas Day they have bigger problems than accommodating step children.

Fancy being condemned to making a meal, for goodness sake prep in advance and shove it in the oven.

Talk about making a drama out of nothing.

Whether people on here make a judgement about how splitting Christmas day can't work the fact remains that it works for many families and it has positives.

I don't understand what part of this you are struggling with.

It's Christmas Day. The OP wants it to be a special day for herself and her children.

Making chicken nuggets for lunch with her children whilst her husband is absent is not special. It's like any other day.

And going to a lot of effort to make a big Christmas dinner for the evening, when her stepchildren aren't going to eat it and her own children are going to be tired and nearly ready for bed, is a waste of time.

The OP would like to be able to go to her own parents for Christmas lunch, or have a nice Christmas lunch with her husband and children, without having lunchtime completely obliterated every single year because her husband for some reason HAS to be in the car during that specific 90 minute window.

What, actually, is the problem with having the stepchildren come a little bit later so the OP can also enjoy Christmas lunch with her family?

Talk us through what the problem is.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 10:52

@Iwasafool Cooking Christmas dinner is a big deal, I would be fucked off if I had to do every year, especially given i was being prevented from ever going to my family and being a guest rather than the host. If it were me, DP would be cooking when he got back at least every other year.

And yes, splitting Christmas might work for lots of families but it isn't working for part of this one. The considerate thing to do would be to at least consider whether perfectly valid other solutions might work better for everyone.

gannett · 11/10/2023 10:52

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 10:38

Nobody is saying that he shouldn't see his kids on Christmas Day.

Why do people keep claiming that other people are saying this?

The point is that him being absent for 90 minutes SPECIFICALLY OVER LUNCHTIME doesn't work.

If the stepchildren are going to have Christmas lunch with their mother before they come to the OP's house then they should stay there for a little bit longer so that everyone else can also enjoy their Christmas lunch beforehand.

The suggestion of alternating Xmases would entail him not seeing his kids on Xmas Day.

I think the stepkids staying a bit longer at their mum's is a reasonable suggestion for the OP to make. But we don't have the info as to why the 1pm handover was agreed on (there may well be good reasons for it). And if she makes that suggestion, like I said, she should frame it as a logistical suggestion that makes Xmas work better for everyone, rather than the vibe of wanting to exclude the stepkids that most people in this thread have picked up on.

Flopsythebunny · 11/10/2023 10:51

5128gap · 10/10/2023 20:39

Thats not strictly true, is it? For starters we don't know he 'left' his first wife. She may have instigated the split. Secondly, he hasn't had to make the sacrifice as a result of the separation because both parents came to an arrangement that meant is wasn't necessary.
Its entering his new relationship that's caused the conflict, and so really both he and OP should have known what they were getting into if anyone should.

The op has already said that he left and moved away

Iwasafool · 11/10/2023 10:49

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 08:56

It's rubbish because they and their mum will be twiddling their thumbs at lunchtime while their dad is absent, they aren't allowed to go and have Christmas lunch with their grandparents, and they have to wait until the evening to have their Christmas meal which is a muted affair because their siblings have already had their main celebration and aren't eating.

It also no doubt condemns the OP to preparing the meal every year because once her husband gets home with his older children he'll want to hang out with them, not help with the cooking.

I don't think anybody is saying her husband should stop seeing his kids on Christmas Day. Just that this specific arrangement is a bit crap and can be improved upon in a way that will benefit everyone.

Well if an adult with a child can't think of anything better to do than twiddle their thumbs for an hour and a half on Christmas Day they have bigger problems than accommodating step children.

Fancy being condemned to making a meal, for goodness sake prep in advance and shove it in the oven.

Talk about making a drama out of nothing.

Whether people on here make a judgement about how splitting Christmas day can't work the fact remains that it works for many families and it has positives.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 10:45

senior30 · 11/10/2023 10:38

Where did I say that we don’t see the other children/DB without his step son. It just wouldn’t have been acceptable to not involve him at Christmas or special occasions. He’s not with a resident parent the split is 50/50, so there are plenty of times he’s not around.

It just takes very little effort to get to know a child and I don’t know how anybody can excuse that after 5 years. There are very, very few ‘perfectly good reasons’ and it amazes me that any adult can excuse this.

You literally said he was involved in everything you do. If he's not there 50% of the time, it's really not hard to understand how if he was there say 15% of the time/you lived a large distance from your family so only ever saw them for full overnight stays/the limited time they come over is not spent visiting family, and if it is, there's only really time to visit one family which is naturally going to be their paternal family they can only see at that time, the amount you'd have met him would be much lower.

SemperIdem · 11/10/2023 10:43

senior30 · 11/10/2023 10:07

I feel so much for children who have separated parents and then have step-parents like this. It’s all about what you want, your parents don’t know your step children? You’ve been in a relationship 5 years that’s just not acceptable. My brother’s step son is involved in everything we do and he wouldn’t allow it to be any other way. Why did you marry and have children with him, or did you expect that once you had your own you’d be able to force his out?

My parents and my partners parents don’t have much to do with their respective step grandchildren.

There isn’t really any need to be, they send gifts for birthdays, Christmas, Easter and so on but that’s it. The children aren’t exactly desperate to spend time with their “step grandparents” but they do enjoy seeing their grandparents.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 10:38

gannett · 11/10/2023 09:49

You can make whatever suggestions you want then, if everyone else involved is amenable to change. There's no single "reasonable" plan - only what's reasonable for the people involved. As you can see on this thread, plenty of blended families wouldn't want to split Xmas Day, but plenty others would be happy to do so. You find a solution that works for you (primarily the kids though).

What is unreasonable is to use the phrase "just the three of us" and give any indication that you want to exclude yoru husband's kids from your "little family". No, they're part of his family of five, and you signed up to joining that wen you married him. And putting them first is part of that deal. I don't blame anyone who doesn't want to put other people's children first, but they shouldn't get into relationships with existing parents.

What would be more reasonable is to present your suggestions from a purely logical and logistical point of view. Frame it as making life easier for everyone involved. And accept that if a split Xmas Day is what makes the kids happy, then that is what will have to happen.

FWIW I don't think the inconveniences to you are anywhere near as bothersome as keeping those kids from seeing their dad on Xmas Day would be. Your husband is gone for 90 minutes? That's barely anything. Your stepkids aren't hungry? Make them a plate of nibbles rather than a full dinner then. Your parents might have to eat lunch a couple of hours later? That's barely an inconvenience. Your parents don't know your stepkids very well? Well, a good time to remedy that then.

Nobody is saying that he shouldn't see his kids on Christmas Day.

Why do people keep claiming that other people are saying this?

The point is that him being absent for 90 minutes SPECIFICALLY OVER LUNCHTIME doesn't work.

If the stepchildren are going to have Christmas lunch with their mother before they come to the OP's house then they should stay there for a little bit longer so that everyone else can also enjoy their Christmas lunch beforehand.

senior30 · 11/10/2023 10:38

Where did I say that we don’t see the other children/DB without his step son. It just wouldn’t have been acceptable to not involve him at Christmas or special occasions. He’s not with a resident parent the split is 50/50, so there are plenty of times he’s not around.

It just takes very little effort to get to know a child and I don’t know how anybody can excuse that after 5 years. There are very, very few ‘perfectly good reasons’ and it amazes me that any adult can excuse this.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 10:34

Coughingdodger · 11/10/2023 10:17

Anyone who DOESN’T prioritise the interests of their child has no business having any more.

Yes, well the OP's child already exists.

Backagain23 · 11/10/2023 10:31

Coughingdodger · 11/10/2023 10:17

Anyone who DOESN’T prioritise the interests of their child has no business having any more.

You can prioritise to your heart's content when you only have one.
After that, all the children you have are "existing" children, all of them are important, none of them got to choose to be born or into what family circumstances so none of them win the arguement to be automatically top priority every single time.
OPs child isn't more important than her DSC,but he's not less important either. The mutual father is going to have to strive for balance.

aSofaNearYou · 11/10/2023 10:28

senior30 · 11/10/2023 10:07

I feel so much for children who have separated parents and then have step-parents like this. It’s all about what you want, your parents don’t know your step children? You’ve been in a relationship 5 years that’s just not acceptable. My brother’s step son is involved in everything we do and he wouldn’t allow it to be any other way. Why did you marry and have children with him, or did you expect that once you had your own you’d be able to force his out?

If my family didn't "allow" it to be any other way, historically they'd never get to see us unless they fancied sleeping on the floor because they slept in the same bed he did when they come to stay, so it was never at the same time for obvious reasons.

Plus then there's the fact that he wants to do other things when he comes over, or see his own GP (DPs parents).

So not an awful lot of point in them "not having it any other way" and refusing to engage with us if DSS isn't there. It's not like he's there and they're ignoring him - he is not there when they are.

Honestly I do not think people think comments like this through very carefully. There are plenty of perfectly legitimate reasons for a step parents family to not know their step child. Presumably your DB is with a resident parent. It doesn't take much thought to comprehend why it might be a little bit different when your relative is with the NRP so the child is rarely around.

Nina1013 · 11/10/2023 10:27

Also why not get him to ask his ex wife - instead of saying we won’t take Christmas morning from you, this could be pleasantly reframed as
‘Splitting the day in half with the long pick up drive just isn’t sustainable, but I would like to find a solution you’re happy with - we could alternate Christmas Day and Boxing Day each year, or we could alternate the pick up/drop off at the time it currently is, so that you do it one year and I do it the other. What would be your preference?’

You know she doesn’t want to give up Christmas morning, so the obvious solution would be for her to alternate the pick up/drop off - but this way it’s her feeling as though she has had a say in it.

sianny87 · 11/10/2023 10:24

This is what my DP does with his DC. Whoever has them at their house does the drop offs. I think this is the only fair way to do it.

With Christmas it alternates every year. DSC spend Christmas Eve with one parent and then are dropped to the other at 11am Christmas morning, until Boxing Day 11am. It works for them and us. Mindful that we’re trying for our own DC but this routine would work.

Nina1013 · 11/10/2023 10:23

I think it’s actually your husband who is in the wrong and being unreasonable here.

There’s nothing wrong with him continuing this tradition (and in some respects I think it’s easier as you can then relax, switch off, have some Christmas drinks rather than having to drive later on). There’s nothing wrong with him doing the drop off and pick up (although he can’t be in permanent purgatory whether self inflicted or otherwise for leaving her).

What is wrong is that he is in control of everything, including you and your child. He’s dictating what YOU can do as well and that’s what’s making it unbearable. There’s no reason you couldn’t go and visit your family at 11 (arbitrary time), spend some time with them, and him leave you there at 1pm to relax and enjoy lunch with your family before a Christmas supper with his kids later.

His insistence on you doing what he tells you (sitting at home and waiting for him!) is what’s ruining this day for you and your child.

Coughingdodger · 11/10/2023 10:17

Backagain23 · 11/10/2023 10:06

And putting them first is part of that deal. I don't blame anyone who doesn't want to put other people's children first, but they shouldn't get into relationships with existing parents
Nope. None of the children get to come first every time. Anyone who wants to always put their first child at the top of the priority list has no business making a second or third child.

Anyone who DOESN’T prioritise the interests of their child has no business having any more.