Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips

118 replies

HiggleDyPigGeldy · 10/10/2023 09:06

In The Times today, Melanie Phillips page 26 article: “a small Jewish child, alone and bewildered, being tormented on a Gaza street by Palestinian children who are all taught to hate and murder Jews”

The thought of this poor child being tormented is beyond heartbreaking to me as a mother, and as a Jew.

BUT, how can it he acceptable for a major newspaper to print that Palestinian children are all taught to hate and murder Jews?
It’s not true for one (my son’s closest friend is a little Palestinian boy who is lovely, and his family, who are from Gaza and still have relatives there, are horrified by the violence that unfolded this week. We regularly spend time together and actually have a lot in common.)

By blanket painting all Palestinians, even children, as evil terrorists, the writer is inciting hatred. Which is exactly the opposite of what is needed now to stop the bloodshed on both sides!

AIBU to think that the media are inciting hatr

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
HiggleDyPigGeldy · 10/10/2023 23:38

As for those asking why I never mentioned being Jewish in previous posts:

  1. it has never been relevant in any previous post.
  2. I live in the UK. Don’t think I’ve ever posted about the middle east or politics in the past

There are Jews out there (I’m not the only one!) who are really concerned about the escalation of violence and who don’t see “all” Palestinians as a problem.

Like other posters have said about Ukraine, you can have people sharing one characteristic who hold different views.

OP posts:
HiggleDyPigGeldy · 10/10/2023 23:32

Thank you to those who have educated me on Melanie Phillips - it all makes more sense now.
I must admit that I don’t usually read the times but today picked it up along with several other papers because I wanted to read a broad range of perspectives on the weekend news.

I’m a bit disheartened by all the people coming on here taking pains to say how unreasonable it is to expect mainstream media not to be racist, and generally (a) lump all Palestinians together, (b) equate all Palestinians with Gazans and then (c) all Gazans with Hamas supporters and Jew hating murderers.

I can’t see the conditions for peace ever emerging out of this.
People in Israel are reeling from their losses and wondering where their family members and loved ones are - and now their government is preparing to create the conditions for this cycle of violence to continue despite this type of action being a powerful enabler for Hamas gaining support in the past.

OP posts:
Cincills · 10/10/2023 22:10

Purplefriends · 10/10/2023 17:03

Thing is, most humans love, or at least instinctively want to protect, other human children. It takes a special type of vileness to have so dehumanized another group of people that you would terrify, harm or kill their children.

It does, and children are paying the heaviest price in this conflict for something they have no control over. They should all be evacuated immediately from the zones of conflict and allowed safe passage to a place where they can access food, water and medical treatment and are protected from the violence.

I imagine if your child is killed by what you see as an “other group” of people it would be the hardest thing to forgive. But the vast majority of human beings abhor such violence, no matter what colour their skin is or what their religion happens to be. You cannot overcome evil with evil. Every child that is killed or injured in this conflict creates more traumatised and desperate people.

It is a profound and dangerous mistake to convince yourself that any group of people loves or grieves their children less you do.

BlurredEdges · 10/10/2023 20:40

thinkfast · 10/10/2023 20:05

100% agree

Thank you. I notice this poster has no other posts referencing being Jewish. I would suggest approaching with caution

Coffeerum · 10/10/2023 20:17

@DownNative Staying quiet is how my family were able to visit relatives in a PIRA area in Ardoyne. People there never knew we were Catholics who disagreed with and hated PIRA. The world didn't know such Catholic voices really existed in Northern Ireland until well after the Troubles.

Surely that’s literally the point though, you are comparing post conflict with active conflict. In a previous comment you claim so many catholics and Protestants quietly didn’t support paramilitary actions, which was more true as time went on but at the same time seem unable to accept that the support for hamas among ordinary Palestinians might not be so easy to quantify mid conflict.

“The reality is Hamas control Gaza and most Palestinians support them.”

thinkfast · 10/10/2023 20:05

BlurredEdges · 10/10/2023 15:07

This is a very odd thread for a Jewish poster to post. All Jews know what MP is like. And in the hundreds of online and real life conversations we've all been having, no one is giving a moments notice to this.

People are terrified for their loved ones, grieving, dreading what the next few days and weeks will bring for both Israeli and Palestinian civilians. No one is talking about this.

100% agree

FrippEnos · 10/10/2023 17:32

Just as a counter point to some on here, Yitzhak Rabin, The 5th Prime minister of Israel was murdered by Jewish extremists for his views on the Oslo accords and the PLO.

The hatred isn't all one way.

Purplefriends · 10/10/2023 17:03

Cincills · 10/10/2023 13:00

That is a horrifically racist quote. Palestinians love their children as much as any other humans do.

Thing is, most humans love, or at least instinctively want to protect, other human children. It takes a special type of vileness to have so dehumanized another group of people that you would terrify, harm or kill their children.

Circularargument · 10/10/2023 16:51

Coughingdodger · 10/10/2023 09:08

Didn’t read it but sounds a highly biased, inflammatory and irresponsible thing to print in a major national newspaper. Ffs.

Melanie Phillips, 'Nuff said.

DownNative · 10/10/2023 16:36

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 10/10/2023 15:58

all Palestinian children (obviously) are not taught to hate and murder Jews.

There has however been a lot of international concern about the school curriculum in Gaza.

Replace all with "many"...?

The term "many" is most accurate, yes. As always though, a dissenting minority voice is drowned out in the world.

The major problem for any Hamas dissenting Palestinian is Hamas will find them and murder their family. So, they can't really get their voices out to the world. Staying incognito is how you survive.

Staying quiet is how my family were able to visit relatives in a PIRA area in Ardoyne. People there never knew we were Catholics who disagreed with and hated PIRA. The world didn't know such Catholic voices really existed in Northern Ireland until well after the Troubles.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 10/10/2023 15:58

all Palestinian children (obviously) are not taught to hate and murder Jews.

There has however been a lot of international concern about the school curriculum in Gaza.

Replace all with "many"...?

DownNative · 10/10/2023 15:38

Precipice · 10/10/2023 14:07

Were they restrained when they shot civilians in Derry in 1972 or in Ballymurphy in 1971? I suppose they might have shot dead more civilians, and gracefully restrained from that. Being not as bad as paramilitaries is not a high threshold to clear.

I am not sure, however, why the Troubles are being raised as a point of comparison to the Arab-Israeli conflict.

The reality is that Bloody Sunday 1972 never happened again and the British Army trained for urban scenarios like that afterwards. Attachments show they had practically no riot control training.

After Bloody Sunday, the British Army were able to develop riot control equipment and strategies that's now used all over the world because its effective.

There was never a repeat of Bloody Sunday.

Similar to these:

www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/1060018046

The record over nearly 40 years does, indeed, demonstrate the security forces were restrained. Compare and contrast that with the number of people shot dead by United States police forces in the same period, for example.

As for your last paragraph, people are bringing Northern Ireland up because I guess it's the nearest they have to hand. But also because PIRA and Hamas are themselves linked in an international terrorist network. They trained at the same camps in Libya under Gaddafi. See mural attached.

But Northern Ireland is NOT anywhere close to being similar to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The PSF/PIRA link to Hamas is where any similarities between the two conflicts begins and ends.

Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
DownNative · 10/10/2023 15:10

RobynRB · 10/10/2023 14:09

Theoretical modern day IRA.... but never mind, let's not derail the thread.

There is one which the media call New IRA, but they call themselves IRA. Oh, and they're infiltrated as well which is why they can't really get going. 🤷‍♂️

Other than that, not sure where you're looking to go with your train of thought.

BlurredEdges · 10/10/2023 15:07

This is a very odd thread for a Jewish poster to post. All Jews know what MP is like. And in the hundreds of online and real life conversations we've all been having, no one is giving a moments notice to this.

People are terrified for their loved ones, grieving, dreading what the next few days and weeks will bring for both Israeli and Palestinian civilians. No one is talking about this.

TravelatorStopping · 10/10/2023 14:16

She is a horrific ‘journalist’ at the best of times. I would expect nothing less from her.

Saschka · 10/10/2023 14:14

Melanie Philips has always been a racist piece of shit, so YABU to expect anything more from her. She’s a posh Katie Hopkins. She must be loving every minute of this, the perfect opportunity to vent her spleen without being censured.

RobynRB · 10/10/2023 14:09

DownNative · 10/10/2023 13:18

Which particular terrorists are you referring to in your 'negotiated with' bit?

Theoretical modern day IRA.... but never mind, let's not derail the thread.

Precipice · 10/10/2023 14:07

DownNative · 10/10/2023 12:40

I wasn't actually referring to YOU, @Coughingdodger. But speaking generally.

You are, of course, correct that the British Army was pretty restrained, especially in comparison to the Republican and Loyalist terrorists. 👍

Were they restrained when they shot civilians in Derry in 1972 or in Ballymurphy in 1971? I suppose they might have shot dead more civilians, and gracefully restrained from that. Being not as bad as paramilitaries is not a high threshold to clear.

I am not sure, however, why the Troubles are being raised as a point of comparison to the Arab-Israeli conflict.

Green777 · 10/10/2023 14:02

@DownNative

Do you think Israelis are brought up to hate Palestinians? And defend Israel no matter what, as you do?

The loss of life is far far greater to Palestinians and always has been.

Teentaxidriver · 10/10/2023 13:59

Amazing posts DownNative. Thank you.

thinkfast · 10/10/2023 13:59

HiggleDyPigGeldy · 10/10/2023 09:06

In The Times today, Melanie Phillips page 26 article: “a small Jewish child, alone and bewildered, being tormented on a Gaza street by Palestinian children who are all taught to hate and murder Jews”

The thought of this poor child being tormented is beyond heartbreaking to me as a mother, and as a Jew.

BUT, how can it he acceptable for a major newspaper to print that Palestinian children are all taught to hate and murder Jews?
It’s not true for one (my son’s closest friend is a little Palestinian boy who is lovely, and his family, who are from Gaza and still have relatives there, are horrified by the violence that unfolded this week. We regularly spend time together and actually have a lot in common.)

By blanket painting all Palestinians, even children, as evil terrorists, the writer is inciting hatred. Which is exactly the opposite of what is needed now to stop the bloodshed on both sides!

AIBU to think that the media are inciting hatr

YABU OP. You can't generalise that the entire media is inciting hatred on the basis of one opinion piece from Melanie Phillips.

Congratulations on your son having a Palestinian friend, but you can't make generalisations about all Palestinians based on one family either.

EnoughIsay · 10/10/2023 13:55

DownNative · 10/10/2023 10:08

When Hamas were formed in 1987, they had minimal support from Palestinians. But in 2021, support for Hamas dramatically increased as AP News reported:

https://apnews.com/article/hamas-middle-east-science-32095d8e1323fc1cad819c34da08fd87

In 2022, respected Palestinian pollster Khalil Shikaki and his Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research (PCPSR) carried out a survey looking at Palestinian support for armed groups. Main takeaways below:

  • 72% of Palestinians support forming more armed groups in West Bank
  • in Gaza, 84% of respondents supported concept of armed groups taking NO orders from the Palestinian Authority. This is HIGHER than in the West Bank where 65% supported the idea.

www.pcpsr.org/en/node/924

So, the support for Hamas, Lion's Den and other Palestinian armed groups is there from the Palestinian population. A minority do not support them.

At the same time, Palestinian support for the Fatah party led by President Abbas in the West Bank has collapsed to as low as 14%. Abbas is struggling to keep control of the Palestinian Authority territory in the face of support for armed groups such as Hamas.

So, not all Palestinians support Hamas. But it is NOT wrong to say Gazan social climate is geared around hating Israelis. That's what happens when a terrorist group controls a territory effectively and support from locals increases.

It's reality.

But in 2021, support for Hamas dramatically increased as AP News reported:

By '21 the Palestinians in Gaza had been living under embargo for more than 10 years. We can imagine the impact on the ground of that.

So Hamas do what the narc gangs do in Latin America or what mafia did/do - "help" people on the ground, get supplies in, get jobs, lend money and so on.. Bit by horrible bit they start to own the people.

Civilians are always between a rock and a hard place. There is nowhere to turn. If your child needs meds, and the hated Hamas guy has them, you ask. You don't want to but you do.

It means you do not have to wait for a full day to cross the border, be strip searched and so on.

DownNative · 10/10/2023 13:18

RobynRB · 10/10/2023 12:47

What I meant was, given that we've had years of politicians telling us over and over that terrorists must be 'dealt with' and not 'negotiated with' it would be difficult to explain why these particular 'terrorists' should be 'negotiated with'.

Which particular terrorists are you referring to in your 'negotiated with' bit?

Cincills · 10/10/2023 13:00

MariePaperRoses · 10/10/2023 10:14

Muslim extremists so teach their children this because they hate the Jews. Note that I said EXTREMISTS.

As Golda Meir said "If Palestinians laid down their weapons there would be no war. If Israel laid down their weapons there would be a massacre."
And "There would be peace if when Palestinians love their children as much as they hate the Jews."

That is a horrifically racist quote. Palestinians love their children as much as any other humans do.

SerendipityJane · 10/10/2023 12:52

When you remember she's called Mad Mel, things make sense.

Swipe left for the next trending thread