Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips

118 replies

HiggleDyPigGeldy · 10/10/2023 09:06

In The Times today, Melanie Phillips page 26 article: “a small Jewish child, alone and bewildered, being tormented on a Gaza street by Palestinian children who are all taught to hate and murder Jews”

The thought of this poor child being tormented is beyond heartbreaking to me as a mother, and as a Jew.

BUT, how can it he acceptable for a major newspaper to print that Palestinian children are all taught to hate and murder Jews?
It’s not true for one (my son’s closest friend is a little Palestinian boy who is lovely, and his family, who are from Gaza and still have relatives there, are horrified by the violence that unfolded this week. We regularly spend time together and actually have a lot in common.)

By blanket painting all Palestinians, even children, as evil terrorists, the writer is inciting hatred. Which is exactly the opposite of what is needed now to stop the bloodshed on both sides!

AIBU to think that the media are inciting hatr

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
tabulaisrasa · 12/10/2023 10:25

CrunchyCarrot · 10/10/2023 09:15

as a mother

Sorry you lost me there. Even childfree people like myself have the same feelings you know!

This is not about you, get off your high horse.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/10/2023 10:21

Bigbrotherpropoganda · Yesterday 14:05
**
“The news is incredibly biased”

Not news, an opinion piece and most sensible/decent people realise that her opinions are bollocks.

Cincills · 12/10/2023 10:20

DownNative · 12/10/2023 09:28

Good point @Goodornot!

@HiggleDyPigGeldy's Palestinian neighbours did the right thing by their family by getting out of Gaza and as far away as possible from the clutches of Hamas.

It's not possible to get everyone out of Gaza away from Hamas, so it's in the interests of all Palestinians and Israelis that Hamas is defeated. Remember, they use Palestinian civilians as human so Hamas absolutely do NOT want a fair fight!

It’s not possible for anyone to get out of Gaza right now given that the Israeli army blew up the only airport 20 years ago, has built a wall along the border, blockaded the sea to prevent anyone leaving by boat, closed the crossing into Israel and currently is repeatedly bombing the only other exit to Egypt. So everyone inside Gaza is completely trapped. With food, water and electricity cut off. And constant bombing of residential areas.

It is absolutely possible for Israel to stop bombing the Egyptian border crossing and allow children and civilians to escape. They could even assist in the evacuation if they chose to do so.

Cincills · 12/10/2023 10:11

DownNative · 12/10/2023 09:17

If you'd bothered to read my previous post properly, you'd have discovered that Hamas has been propagandising Gazan schooling for YEARS.

Well before this new round of conflict.

Note the valid comparison between Gaza and West Bank schooling. The international community has been concerned about this for a decade at least. That wasn't the situation before Hamas took power in the manner PIRA wished they could do - "will anyone here object if we take power....with the Armalite in one hand and the ballot box I the other?".

You cannot negotiate peace with a fundamentalist terrorist group that is in the ascendancy and believes it can win. If the Northern Ireland peace process teaches us anything, it's that you have to defeat terrorists before you can get a peace agreement. And PIRA was defeated. Spain also defeated ETA.

That's the true, sad reality.

Edited

The power of the IRA in Northern Ireland was diminished by political negotiation, not by bombing and starving the whole population of Northern Ireland.

And of course you know that paramilitary groups still operate there, and still recruit and kill on occasion.

Terrorists were not extinguished by bloody war. When the IRA bombed Manchester, the army did not drop bombs on residential tower blocks across Belfast. They did not cut off the power and water to the whole of Northern Ireland, blow up the airport, blockade the Irish Sea, bomb the only exit and so prevent anyone from leaving Northern Ireland.

If they had done that - what do you think the effect would have been on the power and persuasiveness of the IRA?

I don’t know what the answer to Hamas is, but surely you cannot believe that trapping and starving 1 million children is going to be effective… not to mention just, humane or ethical?

HeatherMoores · 12/10/2023 09:41

Children are raised to revile the enemy, i.e. Israel

You can present this in different ways. Melanie Phillips does it in a way that is perhaps more emotive or inflammatory. But it is what it is.

Abhannmor · 12/10/2023 09:40

It is horrible for that poor child. As for Mad Mel Phillips - par for the course. There's nothing so bad she couldn't make it worse.

Goodornot · 12/10/2023 09:34

DownNative · 12/10/2023 09:28

Good point @Goodornot!

@HiggleDyPigGeldy's Palestinian neighbours did the right thing by their family by getting out of Gaza and as far away as possible from the clutches of Hamas.

It's not possible to get everyone out of Gaza away from Hamas, so it's in the interests of all Palestinians and Israelis that Hamas is defeated. Remember, they use Palestinian civilians as human so Hamas absolutely do NOT want a fair fight!

They're probably happy to be out of Gaza and have embraced their new life and put the past behind them

If the Palestinian boy the OP uses as an example refused to play with Jewish children at school the parents would be spoken to. It would be unacceptable here to ostracise anyone for their race or religion and they know this.

"I know a Palestinian boy who lives in western comfort and safety who doesn't hate Jews, therefore I don't believe Palestinian children are taught to have Jews," is so flawed an argument I can't believe OP actually said that.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/10/2023 09:33

@Cincills

'You'd have thought we’d have understood by now that there are no winners in war. Everyone loses.'

Unless I'm losing it and you're actually speaking German, I'm pretty sure that's not true. Someone should also go back in time and inform the Normans of this.

DownNative · 12/10/2023 09:28

Goodornot · 12/10/2023 09:18

I mentioned in my original post, I need look no further than my Palestinian neighbours, from Gaza, to find an example of a boy who happily plays befriends Jewish children.

So you know one boy who's family are from Gaza. They don't live there anymore and you're using that as an example of how all Gazan children don't hate Jews.

And you think the author of the piece doesn't think logically?

Good point @Goodornot!

@HiggleDyPigGeldy's Palestinian neighbours did the right thing by their family by getting out of Gaza and as far away as possible from the clutches of Hamas.

It's not possible to get everyone out of Gaza away from Hamas, so it's in the interests of all Palestinians and Israelis that Hamas is defeated. Remember, they use Palestinian civilians as human so Hamas absolutely do NOT want a fair fight!

Goodornot · 12/10/2023 09:18

I mentioned in my original post, I need look no further than my Palestinian neighbours, from Gaza, to find an example of a boy who happily plays befriends Jewish children.

So you know one boy who's family are from Gaza. They don't live there anymore and you're using that as an example of how all Gazan children don't hate Jews.

And you think the author of the piece doesn't think logically?

DownNative · 12/10/2023 09:17

Cincills · 12/10/2023 09:09

Textbooks?? What kind of education can these children be receiving whilst trapped in a war zone, with no food, water or electricity? If they are not allowed to leave the Gaza Strip, how can they possibly access any alternative perspectives?

If the 1 million children of Gaza are not permitted to evacuate this war zone, do you think the starving, injured, traumatised children who manage to survive will be more or less likely to fall into the clutches of Hamas?

You cannot extinguish violence with more violence. Everyone is brutalised and traumatised by it, including the victims and those who commit it on both sides of this particular horrific, nightmarish conflict, and in every war on this planet throughout this planet.

You'd have thought we’d have understood by now that there are no winners in war. Everyone loses.

If you'd bothered to read my previous post properly, you'd have discovered that Hamas has been propagandising Gazan schooling for YEARS.

Well before this new round of conflict.

Note the valid comparison between Gaza and West Bank schooling. The international community has been concerned about this for a decade at least. That wasn't the situation before Hamas took power in the manner PIRA wished they could do - "will anyone here object if we take power....with the Armalite in one hand and the ballot box I the other?".

You cannot negotiate peace with a fundamentalist terrorist group that is in the ascendancy and believes it can win. If the Northern Ireland peace process teaches us anything, it's that you have to defeat terrorists before you can get a peace agreement. And PIRA was defeated. Spain also defeated ETA.

That's the true, sad reality.

Cincills · 12/10/2023 09:09

Textbooks?? What kind of education can these children be receiving whilst trapped in a war zone, with no food, water or electricity? If they are not allowed to leave the Gaza Strip, how can they possibly access any alternative perspectives?

If the 1 million children of Gaza are not permitted to evacuate this war zone, do you think the starving, injured, traumatised children who manage to survive will be more or less likely to fall into the clutches of Hamas?

You cannot extinguish violence with more violence. Everyone is brutalised and traumatised by it, including the victims and those who commit it on both sides of this particular horrific, nightmarish conflict, and in every war on this planet throughout this planet.

You'd have thought we’d have understood by now that there are no winners in war. Everyone loses.

DownNative · 11/10/2023 21:51

Cincills · 11/10/2023 20:20

Children can grow up to support Hamas Well they might, and they might not. And it is in everyone’s interests to do everything in their power to ensure that doesn’t happen.

Education is one thing. Experiences may also be relevant in shaping their perspectives. Are there things that could be done right now to decrease that risk?

I’d say evacuating all the children from that war zone, allowing them safe passage to a place where there is no fighting and where food, water and medical care is available would be an immediate action which would decrease Hamas’ power to influence these children.

You're obviously not taking into account the following from NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence 2019 report on issue:

"The Gazan defensive worldview is deeply engrained into the social fabric of the population. Children are raised to revile the enemy, i.e. Israel. There is limited critical thinking and access to information or to independent analysis. This significantly limits Israel’s ability to influence the Gazan population in such a way that it recognises the actual benefits of not being aligned with Hamas."

It goes on to discuss what could potentially be done to counteract that, but concedes deep penetration is unlikely.

"The likelihood of a narrative or strategic communications plan to have this penetration is unlikely."

Note the underlined parts especially.

Western States also are unlikely be able to penetrate through the Gazan social fabric to undermine Hamas with PsyOps as well.

So....just how likely do YOU think it is that Gazan children WON'T grow up to be ideologically linked with Hamas?

I'll give you a hint....its NOT a 50%-50% chance.

Understanding the reality of living with the threat of a terrorist group daily is very important here.

As for education, the international community has been concerned for years that Hamas has made their own textbooks for Gazan children to learn in schools. Gazan children are NOT learning the same things as Palestinian children in the West Bank!

This is dangerous and will continue Hamas ideology onto another generation.

See attachments as an example.

Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Worddance · 11/10/2023 21:36

Purplefriends · 10/10/2023 17:03

Thing is, most humans love, or at least instinctively want to protect, other human children. It takes a special type of vileness to have so dehumanized another group of people that you would terrify, harm or kill their children.

Sadly, this is where both sides with arms seem to be at.

Cincills · 11/10/2023 20:20

Children can grow up to support Hamas Well they might, and they might not. And it is in everyone’s interests to do everything in their power to ensure that doesn’t happen.

Education is one thing. Experiences may also be relevant in shaping their perspectives. Are there things that could be done right now to decrease that risk?

I’d say evacuating all the children from that war zone, allowing them safe passage to a place where there is no fighting and where food, water and medical care is available would be an immediate action which would decrease Hamas’ power to influence these children.

Bigbrotherpropoganda · 11/10/2023 14:05

The news is incredibly biased.
I have read several articles this morning and, for example

When noting those Israelis who have lost their lives the papers say they have been, killed, murdered etc
When noting those Palestinians who have lost their lives the papers say they have died.

Subtle propaganda.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/10/2023 11:24

The problem with our newspapers is that the proportion of columnists to actual journalists has increased massively over the last decade or so, and that opinions masquerade as news

You couldn't be more correct - ditto interviews and even so called documentaries, where it's getting almost impossible to find anything without a pre-decided angle

For me, where Melanie got it wrong was in saying they're all taught to hate jews. It's an awful fact that far too many are, but hardly wise to claim it's all of them, any more than it would be to suggest all Israeli children are taught to loathe Palestinians

Candlelight34 · 11/10/2023 11:10

Melanie Phillips is crap and not a serious journalist.

DownNative · 11/10/2023 10:33

Cincills · 11/10/2023 00:45

47% of Gazans are children, who can’t be said to support Hamas or otherwise.

That brings in this specific part from NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence's 2019 report:

"The Gazan defensive worldview is deeply engrained into the social fabric of the population. Children are raised to revile the enemy, i.e. Israel. There is limited critical thinking and access to information or to independent analysis. This significantly limits Israel’s ability to influence the Gazan population in such a way that it recognises the actual benefits of not being aligned with Hamas."

It goes on to discuss what could potentially be done to counteract that, but concedes deep penetration is unlikely.

"The likelihood of a narrative or strategic communications plan to have this penetration is unlikely."

Children can grow up to support Hamas. That's enabled Hamas to go from having fringe support in 1987 to having majority support from 2021 onwards.

Terrorist groups are highly effective at limiting information to their communities since critical thinking can hurt support levels for them.

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/10/2023 10:25

BlippiIsAnnoying · Today 01:08
**
Melanie Phillips was quoted approvingly by Anders Brevik in his manifesto.
**
How she and India Knight still have gigs at the Times I will never know

£ makes the world go round and thousands salivate over their bile.

Coughingdodger · 11/10/2023 09:53

Cincills · 11/10/2023 00:45

47% of Gazans are children, who can’t be said to support Hamas or otherwise.

Exactiy.

BlippiIsAnnoying · 11/10/2023 01:08

Melanie Phillips was quoted approvingly by Anders Brevik in his manifesto.

How she and India Knight still have gigs at the Times I will never know.

Cincills · 11/10/2023 00:45

47% of Gazans are children, who can’t be said to support Hamas or otherwise.

DownNative · 10/10/2023 23:58

HiggleDyPigGeldy · 10/10/2023 23:32

Thank you to those who have educated me on Melanie Phillips - it all makes more sense now.
I must admit that I don’t usually read the times but today picked it up along with several other papers because I wanted to read a broad range of perspectives on the weekend news.

I’m a bit disheartened by all the people coming on here taking pains to say how unreasonable it is to expect mainstream media not to be racist, and generally (a) lump all Palestinians together, (b) equate all Palestinians with Gazans and then (c) all Gazans with Hamas supporters and Jew hating murderers.

I can’t see the conditions for peace ever emerging out of this.
People in Israel are reeling from their losses and wondering where their family members and loved ones are - and now their government is preparing to create the conditions for this cycle of violence to continue despite this type of action being a powerful enabler for Hamas gaining support in the past.

Your second paragraph isn't really reflective of what's been said in the thread. The evidence demonstrates that a clear majority of Gazan Palestinians support Hamas with a minority rejecting them. Evidence from the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research led by Khalil Shikaki has been given in support.

You, on the other hand, offer no such evidence to show otherwise. Anecdotes is not evidence. Indeed, you didn't really read what NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence report said about it and completely missed the part where it says "Gazans are not necessarily ideologically linked with Hamas" too. 🤦‍♂️

DownNative · 10/10/2023 23:53

Coffeerum · 10/10/2023 20:17

@DownNative Staying quiet is how my family were able to visit relatives in a PIRA area in Ardoyne. People there never knew we were Catholics who disagreed with and hated PIRA. The world didn't know such Catholic voices really existed in Northern Ireland until well after the Troubles.

Surely that’s literally the point though, you are comparing post conflict with active conflict. In a previous comment you claim so many catholics and Protestants quietly didn’t support paramilitary actions, which was more true as time went on but at the same time seem unable to accept that the support for hamas among ordinary Palestinians might not be so easy to quantify mid conflict.

“The reality is Hamas control Gaza and most Palestinians support them.”

@Coffeerum thank you for bringing to my attention the sloppy, rushed wording of my last line you quoted which is this "The world didn't know such Catholic voices really existed in Northern Ireland until well after the Troubles."

What I really meant is that the average Joe Bloggs on the street for who Northern Ireland was a vague concept. My apologies for that sloppiness.

There is no question that the world DID know throughout that a clear majority of Catholics opposed Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA. Governments knew, especially the British, Irish and Americans. Many journalists were aware of it too.

Indeed, American political scientist Richard Rose's 1967 survey confirms a clear majority of Catholics didn't support the use of violence to end partition. See attached.

We can also point to the fact Catholics in Northern Ireland overwhelmingly votedfor the Irish Nationalist party known as the Social And Democratic Labour Party (SDLP) led by Gerry Fitt then John Hume. In fact Hume rammed this point home very publicly when he travelled extensively to internationalise the Troubles around the world.

Hume strongly argued in 1973, for example, that PIRA had no mandate from the people and that the community rejected them:

"We are under no illusions about that (PSF/PIRA) campaign. We are under no illusions that it had no mandate from anybody to get into that campaign. Neither are we under any illusions that if it has victory it will seek no mandate for anything else and that it will impose a dictatorship on the people. So, do not let anybody think that we do not oppose the work of the Provisional I.R.A."

And:

"...the reaction of that community (Catholic), having suffered so much, was to reject every single (PSF/PIRA) candidate who stood before it in the Assembly election without the slightest trace of sympathy for any organisation which supported violence in any shape or form."

The SDLP was the biggest Nationalist party from 1970 until John Hume's retirement in 2001 due to dementia. Spoke volumes to the world!

John Hume is very well known for his total opposition to PIRA and he publicly called them fascists. Catholics voted for him in such numbers that PIRA considered killing him. They didn't, but did firebomb his house using their youth wing and they did the same to Gerry Fitt's house.

The Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association was also well known which mainly had Catholics in it. Again, this group were strongly opposed to PIRA. NICRA achieved a load of reforms very early on too.

So, now it's been established that a clear majority of Catholics had always rejected PSF/PIRA throughout the Troubles and that this was known by the world. Only people who weren't paying much attention thought otherwise.

BTW, when I said we kept it quiet in Ardoyne, I meant from the Republicans on that street. The whole street was very pro-IRA and would have murdered us straightaway had they known we were Catholics who were pro-union. Republicans also attacked Nationalists, so you were fine if you were a Republican.

The same kind of evidence demonstrates that a majority of Palestinians support Hamas and a majority support more armed groups in West Bank too. Shown on page 1.

This is the exact reverse of Catholic support for PIRA during the then active Troubles.

Unlike NI Catholics with SDLP, Palestinians have overwhelmingly rejected the Palestinian Authority led by Abbas' Fatah party. Unlike PA Fatah, the SDLP proved to Catholics they were strong AND achieved things, e.g. Sunningdale 1973, Anglo-Irish Agreement 1985 and Belfast Agreement 1998. Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA were blamed by the SDLP led by John Hume for being the principle reason why Nationalists had various restrictions on daily life. People were obviously in agreement with Hume. Fatah has failed to convince Palestinians as a majority of the same thing.

It's clearly possible to quantify overall support for any terrorist organisation during active conflicts be they PIRA, Hamas, FARC, etc.

All the available authoritative sources tell us a minority of Gazans are opposed to Hamas - including NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence and the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research led by Khalil Shikaki. The majority are not opposed to Hamas. Like PIRA, Hamas intimidate, murder and exile dissenting Palestinian voices until a pro-Hamas majority in Gaza is left. Attached is an example of PIRA turning Riverdale into a pro-IRA estate.

Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Hate speech in The Times today - Melanie Phillips
Swipe left for the next trending thread