Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've upset my mum but AIBU?

584 replies

CRivers · 10/10/2023 08:30

I was chatting with my mum about Christmas and she was mentioning things she wants and I said "I hope you don't mind, will do some handmade bits from the kids but as I'm on my unpaid part of maternity leave now I won't be doing presents this year apart from for the kids, I've got to make it a good Christmas for them and I don't want to use credit cards to buy people things for the sake of it"

She read it and didn't reply for 3 days then said "I've got to say that is hurtful. I don't have much money either but would always get you a gift. I do a lot to help with you and the children and feel I should of been a priority, this year especially. You may be on unpaid maternity but my DH name earns and as said I do a lot for you and your family including him."

Yes dh earns but he is solely covering our mortgage, bills, car, fuel, general life, and all of the kids Christmas presents this year not to mention all the food etc. Things are very tight and we both agreed this year just do presents for the kids not each other and other people. Will get the kids to make bits as always but nothing purchased.

AIBU? I feel bad now but I would never want my kids to use credit cards to get me a Christmas present....

OP posts:
VineRipened · 10/10/2023 16:06

"I don't want to use credit cards to buy people things for the sake of it"

I think it is fine to declare a 'no presents' Christmas, but you were tactless, and did make it all about you.

Your explanation should have started with the fact that you don't expect anyone to give YOU a present. And an acknowledgement that 'no presents' is not a reflection on your feelings - that you are aware that she does so much etc. Saying giving her a gift would be 'for the sake of it' rather than because you love her and appreciate her, was tactless and hurtful.

I would never want my Dc to feel the pinch buying me gifts, I would be telling them not to buy presents - but I can see that your message was not reflective of the fact that you appreciate her.

TeamSleep · 10/10/2023 16:01

It’s hard to comment without knowing what expectations your mum has for her Christmas presents. Spending £20 on her plus some thoughtful handmade items won’t break the bank and would be nice but if she’s expecting expensive gifts can’t you just say “don’t buy anything for me and DH mum, you do enough to help us and we really appreciate it and we would prefer you to spend the money you would have spent on our gift on something you really want this year” might be a better way to phrase it, if it’s not too late.

MG1971 · 10/10/2023 15:59

YANBU Your Mother is being very selfish. Your children are your priority and not your mum. I can't believe what she said to you tbh it such a selfish thing to say and very hurtful. I'm a mother and grandmother and would go without for my children and grandchild. My mother was the same as I am she would help to buy presents for my children at Christmas so they didn't go short because money was tight for myself and dh. Honestly do what you've said times are difficult for everyone and especially with little ones it's her problem not yours. Most mothers/ grandmothers would love something made by their grandchildren.

Yetanothernewname101 · 10/10/2023 15:55

When I was a full-time student and we were living off one wage, I made Christmas cakes for family rather than buying presents. One year I made pretty soaps, another year fudge or similar, that could be wrapped cheaply but prettily so they had something to open on the day.
Could you do similar for immediate family like your parents?

Anniegetyourgun · 10/10/2023 15:49

I'm not really able to decide whether OP IBU or not, as she has not yet come back to explain how much help her mum really gives and what sort of gifts we're talking about. Some people's idea of things being really tight would mean they genuinely would struggle to buy an extra bottle of booze, others that they may have to take a holiday worth less than £12,000 next year or won't be able to put as much into savings as usual (savings, hah, remember those?). I'm guessing mum's gift list went way beyond the bottle and plant stage but at this point we don't know, so I'll butt out of that discussion.

However, I will say that on one occasion I was that mother. When DS2 was still living with me, he came home shortly before Christmas with a great pile of bags and boxes. I asked which one was mine? He explained cheerfully that he wasn't thinking of getting me anything as he couldn't afford to, after spending so much on his friends. I pointed out it was kind of hurtful to see him display so much care for anyone except me, but it didn't register; he just didn't get that presents for parents was even a thing.

Later on one of said friends took him aside and told him how heinous it was to spend loads on presents but not a brass farthing on the woman who gave birth to you and did all that nurturing and supportive stuff for 20+ years. (Friend had very strong views on this, mainly a cultural thing, apparently.) He then saw the light and got me a (very acceptable, though by no means expensive) gift, under friend's stern guidance. Honestly, if he had been genuinely skint I wouldn't have expected anything, but bringing home shiny things for everybody except me was quite miffing. To be fair, I'd rather miss out than to have put the fear of God into him to buy Mother a present or else, but fortunately his friend did it for me Wink

These days he's pretty good on the observances.

User0000009 · 10/10/2023 15:48

She needs to grow up and put the kids first like you are x

Lynz32 · 10/10/2023 15:46

YANBU

My dad's side of the family are very weird like this when it comes to Xmas presents. I'm talking about extended family like aunties, uncles and cousins who I'm not close to and hardly ever see. There is drama with them every year because they expect me and my brother (we are both in our thirties) to get EACH of them an expensive present. I fall out with my dad pretty much every time this happens as well as he just goes along with what they say. I used to go along with this and spend a lot of money buying them all presents each year but for the past few years I've stopped doing this and it has caused no end of problems. I've now gone NC with them all now as I had major surgery last year and during my recovery they didn't even send me a card or even a text to say get well soon, and as soon as Xmas came around they started demanding presents again. Also during my graduation a couple of years ago I could only have a handful of people there and they all kicked off because they weren't invited. I'm 35 haha.

mcmooberry · 10/10/2023 15:42

Think you are being unreasonable here. You mother would never agree to a present amnesty with you, she would always buy you and the children something, so it's pointless suggesting it. With a bit of effort and thought you could have come up with some lovely gifts for her (eg people reselling new makeup/beauty items on Vinted) without getting up to your eyeballs in debt.

However, your opening line of your mum talking about things she wants for Christmas makes me wonder what her expectations might be.

GoingDownLikeBHS · 10/10/2023 15:40

shiningstar2 · 10/10/2023 15:30

If she is doing unpaid childcare, that is a big commitment. However much grandparents love their grandchildren, it is tiring looking after them, picking up/collecting from nursery ext that if . It is a massive generous commitment if she does any of this even once a week. I agree it isn't great to use a credit card for Christmas gifting but to use for one Christmas gift to get something for a helpful mother? I would guess that if the ops mother withdrew whatever help she gives the op would need to use her credit card a lot more if she is fully stretched now. I would pass it off as a misunderstanding, take flowers around and hopefully you can all move on. 😀

Surely the OP can't afford the flowers?!

GoingDownLikeBHS · 10/10/2023 15:39

So many messages yet we know next to nothing here. Is OP comfortably off and just being tight? Is her mum very wealthy? its all relative. If OP is really struggling (not just unable to afford a second holiday) then the Mum should be sympathetic, but if the OP is merely doing a bit of performance budgeting then if I were her mum I'd be pretty hurt, as many have said, to not even get a box of chocolates. However, I agree handmade things from the kids is nice (if they are young, not if they are 15 and 16 ...!!)

HelenTherese2 · 10/10/2023 15:33

I genuinely am surprised at how many people think that in order to show appreciation you have to spend money on someone. My mother would be horrified if I spent money on her and didn’t spend it on the kids instead.

shiningstar2 · 10/10/2023 15:30

If she is doing unpaid childcare, that is a big commitment. However much grandparents love their grandchildren, it is tiring looking after them, picking up/collecting from nursery ext that if . It is a massive generous commitment if she does any of this even once a week. I agree it isn't great to use a credit card for Christmas gifting but to use for one Christmas gift to get something for a helpful mother? I would guess that if the ops mother withdrew whatever help she gives the op would need to use her credit card a lot more if she is fully stretched now. I would pass it off as a misunderstanding, take flowers around and hopefully you can all move on. 😀

HelenTherese2 · 10/10/2023 15:25

She was going to do some handmade gifts as a token of appreciation. That should have been enough. I would never expect my children to get into debt to buy me a gift. I also don’t do favours for people and expect to get anything in return.

miral · 10/10/2023 15:23

Not being unreasonable. Personally I never buy Christmas gifts for adults.

Butchyrestingface · 10/10/2023 15:23

I see OP hasn't returned? I'd be interested to know just how much her mum does for OP and her fam. If the woman runs herself ragged for her daughter and grandkids, then yes, I don't think she'd be unreasonable to expect some small token for Xmas, even if it's a potted plant or a box of Cadbury's Roses.

Tontostitis · 10/10/2023 15:01

I'd be a bit upset if I'm honest. I do so much all year and a nice hand ream wrapped in handmade paper would cost less than a fiver. I wouldn't however say anything so kudos for your mum for being honest about her hurt. Don't be surprised if she helps out less next year though.

Fatcat00 · 10/10/2023 14:47

DilemmaDelilah · 10/10/2023 08:42

I am not surprised you found it hurtful. HOWEVER - it does depend on what you mean by making it a good Christmas for your children. If that means buying them one good reasonably priced present and a stocking of small presents and providing a delicious Christmas meal, fair enough. If it means visits to Santa, Christmas shows, elf on the shelf, Christmas Eve boxes (and/or 1st December boxes, God forbid!), huge piles of presents and hundreds of pounds spent on them then it would be extremely unreasonable not to get her anything at all. In fact, if she does a lot to help you then I think you should be able to get her a tiny present anyway, and make it 'from the children' if you aren't doing any adult presents this year.

Just my opinion - I am very aware that there is now a culture of overspending on Christmas that there wasn't when my children were small in the very distant past.

This. And I probably would use a credit card tbh. You can pay it back when you return to work

Verbena17 · 10/10/2023 14:35

@CRivers I think you’re both being unreasonable.
Your mum for being generally ungrateful when you said you’d be making gifts (defo not always a cheaper option) and you for not just paying £5/6 for a box of nice chocolates for her.

Brefugee · 10/10/2023 14:29

how much does she do for you, OP?

surely you can afford a box of chocolates and a book or something for her? your kids are small they don't need that much.

noctu · 10/10/2023 14:28

I guess there's a distinction to be made between types of presents. The financially cheap yet thoughtful ones, and the more expensive purchases. If your mum helps you/your family then as PPs have said I think she deserves something at least.

saraclara · 10/10/2023 14:28

These conversations are better in person. You may have intended the getting gifts "for the sake of it" to be just an expression, but if she dwelt on it for three days she may have understood it to mean that you would have no other reason to get her a gift than obligation or appearances, which would be very hurtful.

That. I suspect that her hurt is not really about the lack of a gift, but the language you used.

PhantomUnicorn · 10/10/2023 14:24

even when ExH and i were on the bones of our asses, robbing peter to pay paul to scrape by, i found something to buy mum a present to thank her for everything she was doing for me and my kids.

Her generosity got us out of so many holes over the years.. i can't imagine never getting her a present to say thank you and that i appreciate her.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/10/2023 14:08

It sounds like gift giving is her love language and I've been brought up to get people thank you gifts if they help me out with lots of favours - at my own budget but nothing at all seems like a bit of a fuck you so I'm not surprised your mum is hurt.

girlfriend44 · 10/10/2023 13:59

Fgs tell your mum to grow up. She's a grown woman, she dosent need Christmas Presents.
Very grabby and immature.
Another reason why Xmas should be consigned to the dustbin.
All this constant brainwashing that every Xmas people need gifts.
Stick to your guns.

Hot Shots Idiot GIF
Lastchancechica · 10/10/2023 13:58

I don’t think many people have realised that a token gift is not the problem!